Kevin had taken my order. He is awesome. I could tell he usually makes the pizzas but they were busy and he stepped up to the register to take care of me. This is my first time here and he made an amazing first impression! Thanks Kevin! The restaurant is clean and neat! You can tell they take pride in their restaurant. It is a pizzeria! The decor was New York! The pizza is made fresh when you order. These pizzas are AMAZING! Please stop in when you come through Jacksonville, NC! read more

See all

I think that the pizzeria has the potential to be very good, our pizza just wasn't cooked very well. Overcooked, sadly. Especially problematic when it's a plain cheese for the kids. :( read more

New York Pizzeria - Overcooked :( - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, North Carolina

See all

Definitely one of the best pizzerias in Jacksonville. Delicious pizza, sandwiches, and pasta dishes. This is my new go to for pizza.

My husband and I go there all the time!! We recently moved to Jacksonville and have been going here WEEKLY!! The same dude is always in there busting his booty rolling dough, and slinging pizza! Great business! read more

The food is great; I eat here about twice a week. The customer service is awesome as well.

First time eating here with my wife. The pizza was great, easily one of the better spots we've tried in Jacksonville. I got a pepperoni and a cheese slice, both were very good. We ended up grabbing a couple more to go for lunch for the next day. The staff were friendly and checked up on us while we were eating. Great pizza and great people. We definitely be back. read more

Food- weekend craving satisfaction Service- friendly, also welcoming, makes you want to invite them over for every holiday. Ambiance- always has sports playing when ever you walk in. Makes it seem seem like a bro-club. Prices- fair and affordable. read more

We ordered our pies to go...they hit the spot! Staff was courteous and seemed like a bunch of cool dudes. Will be back more often.

Really love the pizza and the service. It's also cool that you can buy pizza dough to make your own pizza at home.

Pizza and pasta were both delicious! And the garlic bread really surprised me with how good it was! I almost didn't try it because of some old reviews but I'm glad I did because they're way better than Domino's! Also all the staff were super friendly and my food was ready at the estimated time. read more

New York Pizzeria - Chicken Alfredo pasta and a Medium choose your own pizza, with chicken bacon and Alfredo sauce. - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, North Carolina

I generally order the Stromboli here. The garlic butter seasoning they put on top at your request is the best. The employees have always been very nice. read more

New York Pizzeria - Had to pull a piece off right when I got in the car! - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, North Carolina

Consistently good food but the elderly lady that is usually at the register is not the friendliest person I have ever met.

I don't know where to begin with this Pizza dive. First of all the pizza is just not good. These reviewers who are saying it's the best they've had are either delusional or not particularly savvy when it comes to Pizza tasting. I ordered two slices of pizza which were dry and bland. I was also overcharged for both slices as the prices listed on their website and even on their menu at the store stated slices were $2.75. When I asked the cashier about the discrepancy she could not explain it and simply said the owner makes decisions about the pricing. I asked for a side of marinara sauce and the cashier told me she could do that for me. Of course I didn't realize she was going to charge a $1.50 for that sauce. The container was so tiny with the sauce I thought I was being pranked. It was about the equivalent of maybe two tablespoons of sauce. When I expressed my disbelief to the cashier and asked for more sauce she said she would have to charge me $1.50 for each of the tiny containers. As if all this weren't enough then I was charged a surcharge for using a credit card instead of cash. They do not inform you of this surcharge, they just simply charge it if you use a credit card. This place is a total ripoff and I would never go there again. Being from out of town I was looking forward to trying local pizzerias and I'm extremely disappointed with this dive. At the very least they should give you extra sauce for free to make their stale pizza more palatable and if they're going to charge you they need to give you a substantial amount of sauce, not one or two bites worth for $1.50. Little Caesars blows this place out of the water. Save yourself money and aggravation and go there instead. read more

Absolutely my go to pizzeria in Jacksonville. Being a Jersey guy, pizza is sought out and cherished when you find what you're looking for. If you like the crust just a little crispy all the way to the center, just tell them. They'll get you hooked up!!! read more

Amazing service amazing food! Love coming here! Every bite I take brings me back to NY. Best NY pizzas in NC right here!

Excellent pizza and customer service This pizza reminds me of NY the 80s the smell and texture is excellent read more

Their steak & cheese sandwiches are killer. The large is enough for 2 people easy they also have small sandwiches to

I've eaten their a couple times at this point. The size of the pizzas available is exceptional but the dough and the quality/ flavor just wasn't there. Not sure if there are other locations but I went near the one near food lion. read more

Well... we just moved to the area and this place already is a disappointment. Called for the pizza and wings special, the girl on the phone said they didn't have it anymore. I asked why it was still on the website... she got rude and hung up. read more

New York Pizzeria - Update your specials or honor them! - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, North Carolina

I wish the food wasn't as decent as it is. But let's talk about the atmosphere - NEVER have I felt so unwelcome or unwanted every single time we come in. The customer service is awful and our bill seems to rise every single time we come in. So, when we asked for a receipt she told us "didn't print." There are two employees that I as a business owner myself would consider liabilities and a danger to a business. These types of people will ruin a business and judging by reviews, we all know who I am speaking of. The workers are miserable, the tables are breaking, dust is literally everywhere, people on their phones... it's wild for a business that I'm assuming wants to continue. We've given hundreds to them, and each time we regret giving people like them our hard earned money & I do not recommend giving these people a penny. We have a strong feeling that our family was over changed and our order was smaller than last time. Y'all lost some good ass customers too. read more

I don't know how NY Pizzeria only has three stars. I suppose the negative reviews are from people not familiar with NY style pizzas. I grew up in the Tri-State area eating NY style slices and pizzas. For the first time, we ordered last night from NYP, and they make an excellent NY style pizza. Is it the best that I ever had? No, but it is by far the best NY style pizza I've had in Jacksonville, or anywhere around here. We ordered a 20" cheese Gotti (only $19.99), and it was what I was hoping for; but one piece of advice, NYP, achieve a little more charring of the crust's undercarriage, for it could have baked another minute. My wife and I drove 25 minutes from outside of Swansboro, and we'll do it again next week. read more

We've been here before some years ago and it hasn't changed much. It's located across the road from the New River Air Station which was awesome for us when we lived in New River especially if you wanted some New York Style Pizza Pie. We walked in and was greeted right away. The menu up was a bit busy , but you could find what you wanted with some navigating around on it haha... There wasn't a line or wait and our food was ready in no time. I wanted the pasta salad , but the lady said they didn't sell it anymore :( so with that being said I'd suggest they take that off the busy menu board up in the front. I was pretty sad about them not having it so I went with a garden salad and a slice of pizza with green peppers and onions. My husband and our son got a large cheese pizza which they devoured expect one piece. There is plenty of seating inside and if you get a medium fountain drink you'll also receive free refills. Id really like to see them update their menu to account for things that don't have sigh such as the pasta salad etc.. read more

New York Pizzeria - Awaiting some delicious Pizza Pie! - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, North Carolina

It's mid , if you're looking forward to an uncut pizza that doesn't even fit in the box , or just and over priced slice that's cold to the bite then this place is right for you. The people aren't here for the quality of the food just for the check read more

This pizza was a huge disappointment. They only thing they have going for them is good, friendly service, and the dough seems decent. But the pizza was undercooked and very under seasoned. Sauce was bland, cheese was caked on and seemed flavorless and cheap. Plus the mushrooms were canned, which is my biggest issue. Canned mushrooms are so gross, and they were just slathered on. Using better ingredients, not so much cheese, and some seasoning would make this pizza much better. Wouldn't recommend nor will I be going back if this is their standard. Couldn't get past two slices....should have just got dominoes or a frozen pie from food lion. read more

My husband and I are out of town on business here in Jacksonville and have ordered from this place a couple different times. The first time we ordered two subs and some fries. The total came out to $29 and they forgot the fries and that was for carry out!! The second time they messed up a simple order of two portions of Chicken tenders some bbq sauce and fries. The delivery driver gave us only one chicken tender dinner without the bbq sauce we asked for and then we had to wait 45 min for the second order only to see that there was only one half of a mangled chicken tender that looked like they grabbed it out of the garbage and re fried it because it was an inconvenience that they messed up OUR ORDER! I WOULDN'T FEED THIS SHIT TO MY DOG!!!!!!!! Then when I called in to complain the girl dismissed me as if I was inconveniencing her very non busy evening! OVERPRICED FROZEN GARBAGE FOOD! If you do eat this food make sure you have a bottle of Pepto bismo on hand!!! read more

New York Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, North Carolina

Been to NYP dozens and dozens of times with nothing but good things to say UNTIL the past few months. I returned a roast beef sandwich a few months ago because the worker admitted they ran out of their normal roast beef and they bought cheap roast beef from the store until their shipment came in. I wasn't pleased with the taste, at ALL. Then, this week I got what's in the meme, one thin layer of beef I really couldn't taste. It's just nothing like the sandwiches they used to make. I called the manager. He didn't ask me to bring it in or offer to remake it or refund my money, in fact he seemed to not really care, which actually got me to leave this review. I understand people have bad days, but being a manager, I thought he handled it terribly. Their pizza is usually above average though, I must say, and that's why it bothered me that their declining quality has been noticed by myself and a few friends, but there's plenty of pizzerias in the area. read more

New York Pizzeria - Just shy of $10 for a large ROAST BEEF sandwich. WHERE'S the BEEF?! Used to be plentiful.... No longer apparently. - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, North Carolina

Phenominal, no way to describe how great this place is. By far the best pizza and sandwiches in the county if not the whole state

Overall, I'm not impressed, nor am I disappointed. For a buffet, it was pretty decent pizza. I still would prefer CiCi's due to variety and flavor offered. Staff wasn't as welcoming as I'd expected. I walked up to the register, and the young lady just looked at me. Didn't say a word, which was a pretty big turn off, but I was already there, so I ordered anyway. One of the gentlemen that removed my food, placed it on the counter and walked off. I wasn't sure if it was for me to pickup, or to be brought to me. This being my first time at this restaurant, there was no acknowledgment of the pizza. So I got the attention of someone and assured that it was mines. Other than the pizza, I don't really see a reason to spend my money here. And again, CiCi's is cheaper, and has more variety. So, I guess it just depends on where I am in Jacksonville. read more

New York Pizzeria - Pizza was okay. Maybe a little greasy, but whatever. It did the job. - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, North Carolina

We've been in Jacksonville for 2 years. This is the ONLY place we eat pizza at. We used to live like 5 minutes away from here, but now live about 20 minutes away and we still make the drive to get their pizza. They already know our name and order. Best pizza in Jacksonville, hands down. I've never had any issues with the pizza or my orders. I would definitely recommend eating here! read more

Have payed for delivery twice from this restaurant. They always say it will take around 45 to 60 min. The first time it took over 90 min and just tonight it took and hour and 45 min. The pizza might be edible if dining in but otherwise you miss well live next door if you want to get it hot when ordering delivery. The first time I thought, "maybe just a bad night." But for the second time, no. Also, bad customer service and never very helpful. As if they are doing me a favor to order from them. Will not be spending any more money there. P.S. it's expensive too! Actual NYPD pizza isn't even this expensive and I am from there! read more

Staff was great. Sandwich's and cheesy bread absolutely smack. One of my new go to places.

We ordered a medium pizza and 32 wings for dinner today and it cost $52... Which might be ok if we weren't so disappointed. I asked for the wings extra extra crispy and fried for at least 22 mins. We are both restaurant people and know how long we like them cooked. The gentlemen told me "I don't know what the time limit is, but I will put crispy down"... They were soggy and not even close to crispy. Not to mention the most expensive wings I have ever purchased. The pizza was gross. It was flimsy and we payed $2.75 for each extra topping which were very sparse and only on half. One of the pieces of pizza only had one pepperoni. The only good thing about my experience was a timely delivery but we won't be ordering from them again.. read more

New York Pizzeria - Scimpy expensive pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, North Carolina

I ordered the spaghetti and paid extra for 2 meatballs. Look at the picture, the meatballs are smaller than the cheap plastic fork they give you to eat it. This place is also a haven for transients. There were several occupying seats although I don't know why. The bathroom was last cleaned when they remodeled in 1972. I would never eat here again. read more

New York Pizzeria - spaghetti and sauce in a bowl - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, North Carolina

Great pizza, I've always had a good experience with the staff and they have always taken care of us.

Food was delicious and the service was awesome! Got a chicken parm sub & my husband got two slices of pizza. Had a small town feel that was really welcoming. Will be coming again! read more

The place has a lot of bugs, lettuce and tomatoes are brown, they have cockroaches running around the floor and they don't clean right. There is mold in the freezer and mold in the cabinets, please do not eat here you will get sick I promise. read more

Just walked in to have a sub and stood for 3 mins with no acknowledgement from 2 of the staff that was standing 5 ft away. This is why local businesses fail read more

This is our go to pizza place. It's the closest to our house and has never disappointed. Prices are competitive--maybe a little high, but the quality of the pizza is quite good. They have two special sizes with 3 toppings--the little New Yorker and the other guy's large. We tend to get either of those, based on how hungry the family is. I haven't checked out the other places in town, but we've been happy with this pizzeria! read more

I got more than I expected when I went here. It's pretty good in my opinion but I've had better. I would definitely go back and recommend to others for a quick meal. read more

This place is the BEES KNEES The bomb.com. Friendly staff and even better pies. 17/10 would recommend!