New York Pizzeria

Absolutely love when we come into town, we have dinner at Abruzzo's Pizza! This time we ordered…read morePepperoni, black olives and 1/2 mushroom. Excellent Pizza!!! Wonderful team in getting the orders filled and served piping hot! Yummy! We are leaving with a half of pizza for a late night snack!!

I was told this was the best pizza in Jacksonville, but I have to disagree. It was mediocre at…read morebest. There was nothing really special about the pizza. I took it to go, so I didn't eat in the restaurant. I cannot comment on service or ambience.

Medium 1/2 green pepper 1/2 mushroom

Large pepperoni

See all

Medium 1/2 grilled chicken 1/2 banana peppers

Havana 58 Cafe

4.8(52 reviews)

4.5 mi

I found another gem amongst the gravel! Havana 58 cafe has an outstanding staff wonder ambiance for…read morejust sitting and enjoying the liquid gold that is the Cafecito Cubano! The cakes on display are to die for. The salsa music playing in the background while enjoying a Cuban sandwich and the gold!

We were in the area and decided to try this place out. It's…read morea cute place with tables inside. If it's your first time they offer a complimentary cafecito cubano. We are familiar with Cuban coffee from having it up north and in Miami. We had Cafe Bombón, tres leches cake, guava pastry and lemon cake. The cafecito cubano was good and the Cafe Bombón was good. The only thing we thought would have been better is to serve the Cafe Bombom in a glass cup/glass. Presentation sometimes is important and serving it in a plastic cup kinda takes away from it. The tres leche cake was good, the guava pastry was not. Lacked the filling and then it was wrapped in plastic so the humidity made it most. These guava pastries are meant to be flaky and with more guava. The service was good and staff were nice. May come back for coffee.

Chocolate tres leches

Scoop of butter pecan Ice cream with a shot of Cuban espresso on the side

See all

Casa Mia Pizzeria

4.6(85 reviews)

5.1 mi

Huge pizza's and made right with fresh toppings and everything was cooked the way it should be, not…read moresoggy or undercooked. We ordered several kinds and they lasted several days because they were bigger than we expected. Like most pizza it was better the second day reheated in the oven or the air fryer. Service was friendly and watching them I guessed the management had a military efficiency but still everyone was friendly.

I'll start this off by saying I am NOT an Italian food fan including pizzas, pastas, etc but my…read morehusband is. We swung by after seeing this restaurant while going to a restaurant next door. To satiate his cravings we got a serving of fried mushrooms, cannoli, and a meatball sub. I didn't expect much as I'm not a usual fan, but I can say with my trial bite for this review that it's very delicious. The sub is NOT overwhelming with the sauce which is what usually puts me off for subs. It's the perfect balance between tangy and savory without locking my jaw. You can never go wrong with fried mushrooms and their cannoli custard was delicious. Service was quick and they were very welcoming when we walked in. Great place, if you love American Italian food you'll love this spot!

Spinning Pizza!

Margarita Pizza with added balsamic drizzle

See all

Meat lovers, ranch (side)

Ducks Grille & Bar

4.1(378 reviews)

4.7 mi

Another truly outstanding experience at Duck's Bar and Grill…read more From one business owner to another, I have a deep appreciation for what you're doing here. Everything--from the atmosphere to the execution--is top tier. But what really sets you apart is your attention to detail and genuine care for your customers. Our waitress tonight, Kaila, was absolutely phenomenal. She picked up on something most people would overlook--I don't use straws--and brought my drink without one, without me even having to ask. That may seem small to some, but to me, that level of awareness and intentional service speaks volumes. It's those little things that create unforgettable experiences and separate good businesses from truly great ones. Kaila absolutely crushed it tonight, and it's clear your team is operating at a very high level. Keep doing what you're doing--you've built something special.

We were in town on a little vacation and stopped in for dinner. We stood at hostess stand for 5…read moreminutes before we were seated. We got seated and waited over 5 minutes while no one acknowledged us. There was one table and 3-4 servers and no "be right there" they were doing their side work at 6pm and we got up and left with not a word from staff. Disappointed

Nice atmosphere

Small house salad

See all

Tomahawk, baked potato, onion rings & asparagus dinner for 2

Lazzara's Pizza & Subs

4.0(136 reviews)

3.8 mi

Clean, fresh, great staff, and worth the money on the great quality you receive. I highly recommend…read morethis one of a kind restaurant for their Pizza or Subs.

I have been here many times. I had a couple sandwiches from here the other day. They were…read moreabsolutely delicious! I watched my sandwiches being made fresh. Employees were really courteous. My highly recommend this place to eat. Lazzaras has a great menu with something for everyone!

The main pizza counter.

The aftermath!

See all

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

3.4(167 reviews)

5.6 mi

I had a great meal at this Olive Garden. I had the house salad and the Tour of Italy dish. I also…read morehad a very nice Margarita! The breadsticks were superb. The Tour of Italy dish was very good. The service was excellent. Rowan was cheerful and attentive throughout! Several higher level staff stopped by to ask about the meal. I felt as if the entire staff were there to make the meal as enjoyable as possible! Job well done!

I'll start by saying that I never planned to step foot in an Olive Garden again. I'm part Italian…read moreand have eaten at many Italian places, and somehow Olive Garden has become a thin veneer of a mockery of Italian cuisine in my eyes. So I also never expected that I'd be giving this one three stars even. In part, because they were able to seat our party of 5 pretty quickly, and the service was really good. They even didn't try to pass off the soft Romano as "Parmesan", but did have those graters always at the ready to offer more cheese. The ambiance - well, it's Olive Garden. There was a gas fireplace in the room we were in, but it wasn't lit at the time (June, in Jacksonville, NC, there would be no reason to). There's some faux stonework, but generally the space is forgettable. The food - I had the Minestrone (which the waitstaff mispronounced, without the final "e"). This soup is arguably an Olive Garden strength. It's pretty authentic in the ingredients, and the soups are made locally fresh. I also had the Chicken Alfredo. This is so far beyond Alfredo di Lelio's original recipe, it probably shouldn't be called that. Just call it "chicken fettuccine in a garlic cream sauce with broccoli as an option". I did get the broccoli also. That was blanched well and still firm but good when in the dish. There was a decent amount of a heavy garlic cream sauce and the pasta was ... OK. In past OG visits the pasta was clearly as if it had been pulled from a microwave. This was better than that, but still not amazing. The chicken was nearly undercooked. It was just enough that I trusted to eat it, but the staff definitely need to pay attention to that. Let's talk about those breadsticks. These of course are a selling point of OG, with bottomless breadsticks and the flavorless, nutrition-less cores of so much iceberg lettuce in the bowl they call "salad". The part that sells the bread is the brushed butter substance and the dusting of cheese, lending salt to the flavor as well. But as far as "bread" it's a spongy soft mess. I went because family wanted to, and I was polite and went with it. But I'd wager you can find even better Italian.

Fettuccine Alfredo: Our signature alfredo made fresh in-house every day, served over fettuccine.

Minestrone: Fresh vegetables, beans and pasta in a light tomato broth.

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant - Five Cheese Ziti al Forno: Oven baked blend of Italian cheeses, pasta and our signature homemade five cheese marinara.

See all

Five Cheese Ziti al Forno: Oven baked blend of Italian cheeses, pasta and our signature homemade five cheese marinara.

Angry Ginger Irish Pub

3.8(229 reviews)

4.8 mi

Went with friends for karaoke and pizza and drinks waitresses friendly helped my friend with her…read moredrink choice. Pizza was amazing and fish and chips as well

Very sad Was one of our "go to" places in Jacksonville…read more Apparently social hour for wait/kitchen/ bar staff. Focus on hanging out than customers. Numerous people VAPInG Do not like smelling raspberry, bubblegum or any scented fumes when eating a meal! No different than smoking in a restaurant/bar!!!

See all

Captain Bob Beck's Marina Cafe

3.5(263 reviews)

2.6 mi

We had a great server, Michael. We sat outside with a view of the river, very tranquil spot to have…read moredinner. We order peel and eat shrimp as an appetizer, highly recommend. Served hot with old bay seasoning and butter. We also order a Reuben and beer batter fries. A minor up-charge but delicious. We met JoJac the Perot. He lives at the restaurant. Friday nights in May are the river cruises and Sunday live music. A cool place to try!!!!

This place is always a vibe! Staff is amazing, dinner by the water can't be beat. Everything on…read morethis menu is so good!

Joe Jack

1/2 Pound Jumbo Peel and Eat Shrimp

See all

Views from our table

Abruzzo's Pizza at Carolina Forest

4.4(109 reviews)

5.9 mi

Huge pizza's with generous toppings. I ordered a medium and they guy making the hand tossed pizzas…read moregave me a look and said are you sure, its big. He wasn't kidding. I like to take leftover pizza home, I think it's often better the next day. I ended up with enough leftover for three meals. I also liked the dipping marinara which did not seem to be the same sauce as the pizza sauce. I also hate it when you order a pizza and the center items are under cooked or not cooked at all. All the toppings were cooked and the crust had a nice chew and a lightly crisp bottom surface. I look forward to coming here again soon.

Best pizza in Jacksonville NC since 2016. Check out the "Abruzzo". XXL 26 inch pizza. Spinning…read morethe dough looks like they are making a bed. It's huge and fun to watch professional pizza makers hand toss the dough to a perfect thin pie. Very accommodating and friendly staff. Amazing prices. We fed a family of 5 adults and 4 kiddos for $76 before the tip You will not be disappointed.

Parmesan cheese

See all

Can you have too much cheese?

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

6 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Kierston H.

8

1

0

11 years ago

When it comes to pizza, there is only one place to go for truly amazing pizza in Jacksonville-New York Pizzeria. The staff are friendly and the food is fantastic. Their menu is full of choices and I've never been let down! Tonight I ordered a large pizza and it was so big, the edges folded over in the box. They aren't stingy with toppings either! Hands down, this is the best pizza place in Jacksonville!! read more

Amanda G.

0

1

0

12 years ago

I usually order the 1/2lb Angus Bacon cheeseburger and it is absolutely to die for! I have ordered pizza and subs as well and they're excellent too. The staff is much friendlier and food is much betterthen the place by Walmart. Oh yeah be sure to try the cannoli, its amazing! read more

Cannon H.

0

2

0

7 years ago

The food is decent but the service is absolute trash. The little brats at the cash registers have the worst attitudes and the greasy cooks just look like they are crap talking everyone while they are eating. read more

Brian B.

0

3

0

8 years ago

This place was horrible. Anyone posting it is like authentic be NY pizza is a friend of the owner. Additionally the staff had no emotion.

Lori K.

78

60

35

12 years ago

LOVE THIS PLACE! Great food, great staff, great specials and prices! Owner is super friendly as are all of his employees. read more

Maureen P.

0

2

0

3 years ago

Closest to a New York, New England Pizza in this area! Very Good!

New York Pizzeria - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed New York Pizzeria also viewed

Casa Mia Pizzeria

4.6

(85 reviews)

Huge pizza's and made right with fresh toppings and everything was cooked the way it should be, not…read moresoggy or undercooked. We ordered several kinds and they lasted several days because they were bigger than we expected. Like most pizza it was better the second day reheated in the oven or the air fryer. Service was friendly and watching them I guessed the management had a military efficiency but still everyone was friendly.

I'll start this off by saying I am NOT an Italian food fan including pizzas, pastas, etc but my…read morehusband is. We swung by after seeing this restaurant while going to a restaurant next door. To satiate his cravings we got a serving of fried mushrooms, cannoli, and a meatball sub. I didn't expect much as I'm not a usual fan, but I can say with my trial bite for this review that it's very delicious. The sub is NOT overwhelming with the sauce which is what usually puts me off for subs. It's the perfect balance between tangy and savory without locking my jaw. You can never go wrong with fried mushrooms and their cannoli custard was delicious. Service was quick and they were very welcoming when we walked in. Great place, if you love American Italian food you'll love this spot!

Lazzara's Pizza & Subs

4.0

(136 reviews)

Clean, fresh, great staff, and worth the money on the great quality you receive. I highly recommend…read morethis one of a kind restaurant for their Pizza or Subs.

I have been here many times. I had a couple sandwiches from here the other day. They were…read moreabsolutely delicious! I watched my sandwiches being made fresh. Employees were really courteous. My highly recommend this place to eat. Lazzaras has a great menu with something for everyone!

Napoli's Pizzeria

3.9

(97 reviews)

My wife and i were going to a kids birthday party around the area, and my pregnant wife was craving…read morepizza and we decided to give it a try... Needless to say its one of the best spots Ive eaten a good pie at, everyone was friendly and attentive. 9.7/10

After running errands, we needed a quick bite. We've been here before, just neglected to write a…read morereview previously. They're located in a small strip mall off the main road. Kind of hidden. Every time we've been here there's always a steady flow of customers. That's a good sign to us. As soon as you enter there's a display of the pizza by the slice pizzas next to the counter where you place your order. There's also a large menu above the counter and case. They offer a wide variety of choices. Pizza, pasta, Stromboli, fried pickles, wings, to name a few. We ordered three slices and spaghetti. After a short wait our food was delivered. We did have to wait a little longer for the spaghetti, but not a big deal. My two slices were large and looked good. I had the supreme and meat trio. Wife had a cheese pizza slice. After a few bites my wife's spaghetti was delivered. If she knew garlic knots came with the pasta she would've skipped the slice. I enjoyed my slices and she said the spaghetti was good. There is ample seating and plenty of parking in front of the building. Overall we have always liked our experience here and will continue to dine here on occasion. If you're in Richlands and have never tried eating here, I recommend giving it a try.

Abruzzo's Pizza

4.6

(190 reviews)

Absolutely love when we come into town, we have dinner at Abruzzo's Pizza! This time we ordered…read morePepperoni, black olives and 1/2 mushroom. Excellent Pizza!!! Wonderful team in getting the orders filled and served piping hot! Yummy! We are leaving with a half of pizza for a late night snack!!

I was told this was the best pizza in Jacksonville, but I have to disagree. It was mediocre at…read morebest. There was nothing really special about the pizza. I took it to go, so I didn't eat in the restaurant. I cannot comment on service or ambience.

Tony's Pizza

3.8

(84 reviews)

Before leaving Jacksonville, we stopped by Tony's Pizza, which is my boyfriend's favorite pizza…read morespot from his home town. Since he'd been going there since he was young, I couldn't wait to stop in and grab a slice. Tony's Pizza is located inside Jacksonville Mall but you can also access it from the outside as well. When we approached the counter, the staff were very nice. We ordered two Pepperoni Pizza slices and a drink and by the time we sat down, the pizza was ready. The Pepperoni Pizza slice was very large, but I loved that it was thin crust. I literally ate it with two hands but it was absolutely delicious!!! It included the perfect amount of cheese and pepperoni and as full as I was, I definitely could've ate another. I can see why this pizza spot has been open for as long as it has! The next time we're in Jacksonville, the first stop will definitely be Tony's Pizza! They have ample seating and an array of different food options like strombolis, calzones and subs. I can't wait to return!

Had a great experience today, stopping for a bite to eat on a Friday afternoon. They did not have…read moreunsweetened tea for my wife, but the girl behind the counter offered a variation of an Arnold Palmer beverage with lemonade and regular, sweet tea. We shared their daily special; a personal pizza with one topping and two medium beverages. Everything was delicious.

Bpw's Pizzeria

4.4

(87 reviews)

I while heartedly have to say- this is the best pizza in the Jacksonville/Richlands area. I will…read morenever ever betray BPW by ordering anywhere else, ever again. The cheese is devine but the Margherita was out of this world. We're roughly 23 minutes from the shop, so just outside of delivery range BUT worth he drive for pick up. AND worth the additional fee if they wanted to extend the delivery range. Permanently our Friday spot.

This place is such a gem. The Thai chicken pizza was so good, and my husband loved the wings so…read moremuch we ordered them again the night after! Between the actual crispiness of the skin and the robust garlic parmesan sauce they were generously tossed in- hands down best wings in Jville! We also ordered the steak and cheese sub and the peppers and onions on it were grilled to perfection with savory melty cheese on a sesame bun. It soaked up all the juices from the sub and was mouthwatering even the next day for lunch. Having trouble picking the next thing we want to try- is it the loaded fries, calzone or one of the salads? The menu and pics made it easy to pick and there is so much to choose from.

Baked Pizza Company

3.6

(213 reviews)

My aunt and uncle got some really good huge pizzas here for our last night on North Topsail Beach!…read moreMargherita and Supreme and Another. A little bigger than they guessed, but we all had leftovers in the car for lunch!

The best pizza in Sneads Ferry by far! My family and I have lived in Sneads Ferry for 5 of the last…read more 8 years and we absolutely love Baked. The location is a very comfy setting with both indoor and outdoor seating. The kitchen is wide open so you can see the great work being done for each pie and the menu is filled other delicious options if you aren't in the mood for pizza. In additional to all this, Baled also has a very well stocked little bar with choice options on tap and TV's broadcasting anything you want. The staff are all friendly and routinely check on you to ensure you are served well. The best aspect of Baked, as it should be, is the delicious taste and quality of the food. All pies are baked with a high level QC and always satisfy. Whether for a casual dinner night with friends or family, or in celebration for a special event, Baked is the place to go in Sneads Ferry!

Pizza Village Of Beulaville

3.2

(26 reviews)