All the employees were pleasant and helpful. My family and I didn't like the flavor of the pizza. The cheese pizza was the most palatable. It could just be that we are new to NC and where we're from we were used to something different. We ordered some assorted slices as well and 2 of 4 were burnt on the bottom. Edit: I know it's a far stretch here, but have you considered that fact that Yelp asks days later if you'd still like to leave a review so I thought why not..now I have the owner scratching his head and finding it suspicious that someone could possibly have not been thrilled by his pizza. It was a review from a day you were very much open, Friday. I still think that any and everyone should give it a try if they are so inclined. I'm also thrilled that so many people have enjoyed it. As a business owner, your immediate response to a review should not be to attack the reviewer. This interaction has left a much worse taste in my mouth than the burnt pizza. read more

Very good pizza n fast delivery! Family of 12 visiting Carolina Beach....first night in town n wanted something quick n simple for all after a day of travel. Specially asked how long it would take for the delivery of 5 pizzas n 2 orders of garlic knots...we were told 35/40 min....they were spot on! 8 hungry adults n 4 hungry grands taken care of and happy!!! read more

Fentoni's is the perfect pit stop when you're in full beach-and-boardwalk mode. This is their slice shop right in the heart of the action, serving up a variety of pizzas by the slice. No waiting forever, no breaking the bank. You order at the counter, they pop your slice in the oven, and a few minutes later you've got that crispy NY-style crust in hand. The pizza is solid all around.Classic flavors done right, nothing overly fancy, just dependable, tasty slices that hit the spot. Perfect for a quick lunch break before heading back to the sand or catching the next boardwalk event. Not a life-changing pie, but for speed, price, and location, it's a winner. read more

Fentoni’s Pizzeria - White pizza veggie slice - Pizza Near Me - Carolina Beach, North Carolina

See all

We ordered pizza for pick up at Fentoni's location near the Publix Grocery store on Lake Park Boulevard North. They make a really good pizza here... the crust and the sauce are very good, and they give you a generous amount of whatever toppings you select. The place gets busy, so you know that they make a good product! Tasty! read more

Fentoni’s Pizzeria - Pizza with Mushrooms and Green Peppers - Pizza Near Me - Carolina Beach, North Carolina

As a native New Yorker from THE Island this place is spot on!!! Great authentic pizza, REALLY! read more

Interesting response and true to form as other Reviewers have accused you of. You simply should try to just resolve the issue. Period. Since you feel it is better to insult the customer instead... I will give you free advice on how to run a successful business. I get you love your family and friends, but the customers needs should take priority. You sold me an inferior, undercooked product. So, maybe your "lil' buddies" need discipline and proper work training or they should stay home! read more

Five stars all the way. Just picked up a large loaded specialty pizza which gives you a choice of five toppings. I added sliced meatballs, pepperoni, spinach, mushrooms, and black olives. This a legit NY style pizza. The sauce was so flavorful. I called in the pizza and there was an hour lead time, which was not a problem, The pizza was piping hot and delicious. The staff was friendly and efficient. I would definitely go back! This is a small spot where you could dine in, but there were only a couple of tables. This is a fantastic spot for carry out. read more

Fentoni’s Pizzeria - Loaded Pizza with sliced meatballs, pepperoni, spinach, mushrooms, and black olives. - Pizza Near Me - Carolina Beach, North Carolina

This is really like genuine NYC pizza - perfect crispy crust that has a great bite, good flavor on the sauce and toppings. Price is also very affordable, with slices less than $5. Don't hesitate to stop here for a good bite! Only feedback is that they should add margarita to the menu! read more

Fentoni’s Pizzeria - Veggie and pepperoni slice - Pizza Near Me - Carolina Beach, North Carolina

Everything went well! The pizza is fabulous and the people were delightful. I felt like I was home!

Fentoni's is the best in the area--I just wish they'd make a Margarita pizza It's great they deliver read more

Saw the great reviews and said to my wife, let's go have a slice of the best pizza in Carolina Beach. Very sorry it was such a let down. We both ordered 2 slices each, and wife also got a house salad. The pizza came out and was very hit, but was burnt and so hard it hit your mouth to eat. The took some slices from the pizza sitting in the window case and just heated it up. Maybe we should just got a fresh made pizza and it could have been different? Pass read more

Ordered pizza two different nights whole staying at CB! You can't go wrong with anything ordered. Super nice employees!

I stopped at Fentoni's for dinner. I was told my order would be 15 minutes. The staff was friendly and we were discussing sports games. When someone who placed an order after me returned to pick up his order, I knew there was an issue as mine should have been ready before that order. It seems that the attention to the sport's scores caused a lack of attention to my pizza and it burnt. I am still puzzled by why they didn't start a new pizza right away so I was there a very long time. They must have been planning to give me the burnt pizza. The pizza I eventually got was good and I'd rate that 5 stars. But the service was bad and gets 1 star. I won't return again as it was too slow and the staff was inattentive to their jobs. I do understand mishaps can happen but how those are handled is what determine good service from bad. read more

See all

Was once the best pizza at Carolina Beach! But the place is never open! Even though the website said today it was open. It's not open. Used to be our go to pizza place every time we visit Carolina Beach. Try Michelangelo's it's on the other side of the road facing the Main Street. This is my family's new go too!! And you can sit inside if it's too hot! If you're looking for a business opportunity, a great one would be to open up a pizza by the slice pizzeria that actually stays open and is on the boardwalk ! read more

Highly recommend this restaurant, great New York style pizza and the staff is so upbeat and eager to help. Clean space and lots of outdoor seating! read more

I was told this place is, "The best on the island for pizza." I agree. I had to hold myself back from a third slice. Excellent!

From a NYer, this is delicious pizza. We walked the boardwalk and checked out the shops in the evening before we were to go back home from our short vacay and decided to stop here. It was later in the evening but they were still busy. We ordered a large cheese pizza and wings and both were delicious. We didn't have to wait too long for the order. It wasn't sparking clean in there but it wasn't filthy either. I would definitely eat here again m. I crave pizza but usually make it myself because you never know. My only complaint was I could have had a little mor sauce on my pizza. It was spotty and some places were pretty dry because of it, read more

See all

First time ordering from them since they reopened. Worst pizza of my life. What happened? Used to be a fan. Won't be patronizing them again.

We've been here twice now and it may be the best pizza I've ever had. It's a little pricey for a slice but the slices are big. We've had cheese, pepperoni, Buffalo chicken and Hawaiian and they were all good but Buffalo chicken was my favorite. read more

Food was great and the service was 5 Star. The young man that took out order noticed my shirt inquired if I had served then offered us a military discount but that's not the reason for this review it's the good food, the atmosphere and the great attitude of the staff. Thanks and keep being great!!! Davice/25 read more

I am a native New Yorker. Hadn't found any good pizza in Carolina Beach and was hoping Fentoni's would be the answer to finding good New York pizza. We got a pizza takeout. I ordered and asked the pizza to be ready a certain time. I asked if that would be a problem and they said no. I thought that meant they wouldn't cook it so it would be ready that time. My husband got there 10 minutes early and it was ready. It was one of the worst pizzas we have ever eaten. I had to dab the grease off the top with a paper towel. It was a veggie pizza, so no greasy toppings. It was too much unflavored sauce and not enough cheese. The dough was soggy. So very disappointed. We do not normally waste food but we threw out the leftovers. We will not be giving it a second chance. read more

Fenton location at the Publix Shopping Center makes the best cauliflower pizza!! It's perfectly cooked & staff is always friendly.

The way the dough and cheese flow together on your tongue, it's almost as if they're married. It's as if the toppings are one with pizza and not separate. The bread is bomb. All together, beautiful combination. BONUS! It's not greasy!! This is the way! (Pizzas ordered: Hawaiian & Custom veggie with sausage) *review written by college students* read more

Fentoni’s Pizzeria - Empty tray - Pizza Near Me - Carolina Beach, North Carolina

The service was great, but the food very average. There aren't many pizza options here.

Great pizza, like NY pizza not the usual blah Wilmington pies. Wood oven makes all the difference.

Have done many reviews for places in our second home of CB but never for pizza before now. I have been following Mom's guidance that if you can't say anything nice, don't say anything at all. And that honestly the quantity from chain delivery places outweighed the local quality. Until tonight's take out from Fentoni's, Easy call ahead ordering and was ready on time as promised. Quality toppings and seasonings. Had a half sausage/pepperoni NY style and a Sausage Pop (that's comes with a flavorful marinara dipping sauce -- will ask for 2-3 cups next time) Looks like they also sell by the slice (the previous establishment at this location did as well .. though did not need a review). When life returns to normal next year looking forward to grabbing a slice as a night time snack. read more

Fentoni’s Pizzeria - Sausage Pop -- Very Goo but need more dipping sauce -- will ask for next time! - Pizza Near Me - Carolina Beach, North Carolina

See all

We ordered delivery from Fentoni's while on vacation in Carolina Beach. We had high expectations based on the pictures and while we weren't completely disappointed, we weren't blown away. Delivery time was reasonable and we received our order in a timely manner. We ordered the mozzarella sticks and a large pepperoni pizza. The mozzarella sticks were very generic and seemed to be the same that we get in bulk from Costco. Granted this is no fault on the restaurant and more so that mozzarella sticks just do not travel well, but they were rock hard and were inedible once we got them. The pizza is standard to NY style pizzerias and satisfied the craving for pizza. It was greasier than expected and I would give the reheat value of the leftovers a 5 out of 10. read more

Fentoni’s Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Carolina Beach, North Carolina

See all

First time trying Fentoni's and it was delicious We ordered it for delivery and it was delivered quicker than expected and was wonderful! We will order again for sure! The large pizza is quite large! The large + mozzarella sticks + garlic knots fed a family of 4z 5/1 - It was so good before that we ordered again! This time we tried the Cheese Curds and OMG.... I highly suggest them. read more

See all

My wife and I grew up in NY and to say we are biased for NY style pizza would be an understatement. That being said, walking into Fentonis yesterday brought us back to the neighborhood pizza places we remember. Busy, smelling delicious, and plenty of people working behind the counter. We ordered ahead for take out and quickly brought the pie home for consumption. The crust was crunchy on the outside and just the right amount of chew. The cheese and sauce complimented each other allowing us to taste both without one overpowering the other. Definitely a recommend!! read more

Try this new Pizzeria that replaced Frank's Pizza on its grand opening day. With the coronavirus crisis, they only did delivery/pick up orders with special hours, and offered only large size pizzas, not small size. Fentoni's is located on the boardwalk next to Britt's Donuts, so it may be hard to find parking. Ordered garlic knots ($3), fried ravioli ($7.99), pizza pop ($8.50), and a cheese pizza ($15.50). The garlic knots were covered in butter and fresh garlic. It tasted okay, the butter and garlic made it taste better. If you buy more garlic knots, there is a discount. The fried ravioli are not made from scratch. They were deep-fried well, had good flavor, and are filled with a ricotta cheese mixture. Both the garlic knots and fried ravioli were served with marinara sauce, which had small chunks of tomato and diced onions. The pizza pop is like a pizza slice with the sides of the pizza trying to fold into itself. There was a generous amount of mozzarella cheese and you get to choose one topping. The dough didn't have much flavor but it tasted good with the marinara sauce served separately. The pizza is thin crust style. The crust wasn't that crispy, but maybe because it took about 10 minutes for me to finally eat it when I got home. Didn't like the dough-it was bland and lacked flavor, so the outer crust will be a good snack for your pets to eat. On the other hand, the tomato sauce was very flavorful. It tasted like there was a touch of red wine. The amount of tomato sauce and cheese on the pizza was just right and was distributed evenly. Wanted a cannoli but they did not have these available since they did not get the shipment. One of the owners, Jeremy, was friendly and welcoming. I would come back just for the cheese pizza because the sauce is amazing. read more

See all

Nothing better than pizza at the beach. This NY style pizza doesn't disappoint. Crust is thin & crispy, with a great soft top piece of crust. Will be back read more

One of the main reasons we choose Carolina beach! This pizza is perfect! It's cooked to perfection, priced fairly and taste so great! The staff and managers are always nice and very helpful. The restaurant is still the cleanest restaurant I've ever had the pleasure of eating at! Please eat here when you're near there. read more

Fentoni’s Pizzeria - Outside Entrance - Pizza Near Me - Carolina Beach, North Carolina

See all

Excellent actual pizza. Not just good for Carolina Beach, and not just good for Eastern North Carolina, but pizza that would not be out of place in the Northern Land Of Pizza. They've been in their little nook for a few years, but continue to be consistently good. The right ingredients, properly made, and molten and never-undercooked slices. Somebody really knows what they're doing here, and/or has taught others to do it almost as well. If I'm going to be totally honest, on my most recent visit, the slices were a little less flavorful than usual (perhaps some slight error in the dough/rising or just lacking a bit of seasoning in the cheese) -- but, they were absolutely mobbed, it's a wonder they managed to serve everyone so quickly, and it was still better than most any other pizza in Eastern NC. read more

The pizza lived up to its reputation, it is fantastic. And don't skip the garlic knots. They are Devine.

Pizzeria on Carolina Beach Boardwalk, I thought it was very good NY style pizza and reasonable. We had plain cheese and sausage / onion / mushroom and both were tasty. Be aware they get busy, delivery would have been a 2hr wait, so I went and picked it up. Also, the ambiance inside is a little down market, so don't bring a date but go if you're hungry for pizza. read more

Best pizza we have had in a long, long time. Seems to be the pizza we are always looking for but can never find. Edited to add:we are home from vacation and are still thinking about this pizza read more

GREAT pizza! get a slice (or 2)! We ate here twice during a November long weekend - first by the slice and next with a whole pizza to go. When you get a slice, they toss it into the pizza oven and it comes out hot, crispy and greasy - the perfect NY slice - way better than you expect from a boardwalk pizza-by-the-slice place. We raved about it, then went back the next day to get a whole pizza to take home and eat. ( There is inside seating.) While still good, it wasn't as piping hot, so wasn't as good as the slice, but still tasty. Service was great too, again above expectations. Everyone seemed like they were having a good time and went out of their way to be helpful and friendly. Sadly for us, they were closed on Monday and Tuesday (I assume seasonally) so we couldn't go back but will next time. Highly recommend. read more

My favorite pizza on the island Always had good pizza there I have tried all the pizza places. read more

The best NY style pizza ever! It's thin with that crisp on the bottom but still foldable and end crust is a bit chewy. O M G I regret they are closed Tuesdays because I planned to return daily while I'm at Carolina Beach. Ya it's that delicious y'all! Friendly workers, fast service and excellent food. The outside looks a bit rough but that's because it's on the boardwalk, but inside it's cool and clean, with places to dine in if you'd like. Go get you some! read more

Fentoni’s Pizzeria - Pepp slices - Pizza Near Me - Carolina Beach, North Carolina

Stopped to grab a quick slice. Was pleasantly surprised by the size of the slices. Just stuck with a basic cheese slice. They had a few different options to chose from which was great. Both the owner and the young lady working were practicing Covid standard and had their masks in which I always look for in an establishment these days. The pizza was warmed for us, and transferred to a paper bag for us to take to go. The slice was perfectly thin, but with a very good crunch to the crust. The sauce was a nice flavor, not too acidic, and there was just enough cheese. Very reasonably priced, and a good option for a quick bite while swing in the boardwalk. read more

Fentoni’s Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Carolina Beach, North Carolina