My husband mentioned that this is the same owner as the Benny's next to the brewery in Jensen. We've been there several times, and the pizza has always been fantastic, so once we realized there was another location much closer to us, we were excited to continue supporting them. This time, my husband called in an order for one extra-large pizza, half with everything and half pepperoni. When he went inside to pick it up, he noticed there was a strong odor that smelled like marijuana. Unfortunately, the employee had taken the order incorrectly. Instead of our pizza, she handed him a small pizza that was half meat lovers and half plain cheese. She realized the mistake after my husband mentioned the error and remade our order. We ended up waiting about eight more minutes and left with both the incorrect small pizza and the correct extra-large pizza. The pizza itself was excellent, just like we've come to expect, so no complaints there. However, having our order taken incorrectly--combined with the strong odor inside the restaurant--made for a less-than-ideal pickup experience. We'll definitely be back because the pizza is worth it, but hopefully the ordering process goes much more smoothly next time. read more

See all

As a NYNJ native, I believe I have certain standards for pizza and this spot was a welcome surprise. The pizza is fresh, flavorful well balanced in flavors and the right size, texture. Service is friendly and quick. Overall, this is my go to spot for pizza in the area! read more

Downtown Bennys Pizza - Italian Near Me - Fort Pierce, Florida

I was around town spending time with my parents after an evening event at the local Botanical Garden at Port St. Lucie for a Christmas Event. The service was good while the wait was a little long, but for a Sunday I knew it was Busy that day, which I did understand why. The was good I've enjoy it a lot even dough the pizza was expansive including the Stromboli which came at a total of $46 and change. The best thing was the Pizza itself which I did enjoy but the Stromboli wasn't all that exciting it was just to much onion and less meat inside, what I notice was the onions was still raw and cooked well. If I do come back it'll only be the Pizza but not for the Stromboli again. I've tried many pizzerias which I've had a better experiences than this, this place, as someone that had came from New Jersey I had better. I will come back for the pizza but not for anything else. read more

Consistently great pizza with amazing meatballs and a fair price. Foldable slices. The way they're supposed to be.

Moved from NJ and have been looking for. A good pizza spot. Mannnnn sthis place hit the spot!!! Cheese pizza was floppy with a crispy crust. (Very NY style) which I 100% appreciated. It's a huge pie for $16.95 Also ordered the white pie special $21.95 also a huge pie. Perfect garlic ratio. A little heavy on the ricotta but that's just my preference. Garlic wings and Zeppoles were good too. I place the order for pick up and it was ready in 20 min quick turn around time for the amount of food I ordered. Inside location was mom and pop clean. Absolutely will be ordering again. read more

Downtown Bennys Pizza - Left over Cheese pie and left over white pie. Hand for reference it's 18inxh pie. - Italian Near Me - Fort Pierce, Florida

The Pizza was GREAT at "Downtown Bennys Pizza." The usual place I go to had gotten too pricey, so I went out on a limb and tried Downtown Bennys. I'm so glad I did. The pizza was great and the price was great too. I will definitely go back. Brent Coker. read more

Very good place and I would recommend they're very very nice people and very good pizza!

great ny style pizza crispy crust great toppings. dont let the location scare you away its really good pizza.

I think $30 for a simple vodka pasta that is dry and taste like raos vodka sauce is a bit much... the chicken is extra and there's barely any chicken in it. The best/only thing that they have is the pizza read more

Downtown Bennys Pizza - Penne a la Vodka - Italian Near Me - Fort Pierce, Florida

best pizza in the area! being from the Jersey shore Philadelphia area they were the only pizzeria that perfectly matched the pizza I crave in south Florida! also extremely friendly and reasonably priced! read more

We had the pizza it was excellent. Service was awesome. They went out of their way to make sure we had everything we needed.

We called in the order and it was ready when we got there. Service was prompt and pizza and garlic rolls were delicious! I especially enjoyed the marinara sauce that came with the garlic rolls as it wasn't too sweet, like other marinara sauces! Would definitely go back again when I am in the area! Thank you!! read more

Best sicilian pizza around for my tastes. Order delivery at least once a week. Salads, sides everything has been grrrreat. read more

Cool little pizza spot with amazing pizza and subs! The service was fast and friendly. The food I ordered was served fresh and ready in less than 10 minutes. I had the Philly Cheesesteak with peppers and onions. It was AMAZING!!! read more

Quick delivery and pick up we ate there 4xs so far and everything we ordered was delish We will be regular customers Really good selection reasonable prices read more

Downtown Bennys Pizza - Meatball and sausage - Italian Near Me - Fort Pierce, Florida

Wow is all have to say. Pizza was fantastic, as well as service. Went last night, and had a pie. It was almost as good as any pie I had in NY. Don't miss this gem. read more

Downtown Benny's is a little diamond of a pizza place! The pizza is excellent and the rest of the menu is great as well! The staff is friendly and delivery/pick up is on time and the food is hot! read more

A new addition to South Beach offering pizza and Italian food with a NY flavor. It's recently opened so I've only had pizza so far but will return to try out some other options. Generous toppings on the pizza. Recommend you give them a try! read more

Downtown Benny's serves great food. I love the meatball Parmesan subs the most, as well as all the entrees. And I have tried them all. The pizza's are excellent. Everything is extraordinarily fresh and appeasing. Salads are phenomenal, the freshest, and delicious for salad lovers. I have been to two of their locations and they both are very good. All the staff is friendly and outgoing. Portions are plentiful and filling. A must try for the Italian -Greek authentic cuisine taste palletts. read more

We are staying in Hutchinson Island on vacation and found Benny's on Yelp. This is a walk up pizza place, but they do have some seating. We got our pizza to go. They had it ready very quickly and they were nice to deal with. The pizza was hot and very tasty. The only negative was the $1.00 charge to get a cup of sauce, but that was minor. We'd go back if we are in this area again. read more