We gave them a second chance, because when they first opened, we were not happy with their pizza. We were pleasantly surprised with their pizza, chicken parmigiana hero and the calzone was amazing. We highly recommend and will definitely be making them our go to pizza place. read more

Great New York style pizza pie. Great sauce...not sweet. Great crust. We're from New York and are pleasantly suprised by the quality of their pie. We highly recommend this fine establishment. read more

Well worth a visit. The staff and owner are super friendly and helpful. We have been here on three separate times and haven't dined in yet, just pickup. The pizzas, chicken parm and garlic bread have been tasty. Great pizza crust! Make sure you stop by and give them a try. Enjoy! read more

See all

Did a takeout order. When I think Times Square I think Cheese pizza. Nothing fancy just a huge slice you can fold in half. And Times Square did not disappoint. Atmosphere inside was great and I can totally see myself dining in next time. Don't forget to get their cheese sticks. On point. read more

PSL - Recently tried their pizza for pick up and were not disappointed. Pizza was ready when indicated. Good sauce, fresh ingredients, tasty crust. Toppings are generous but pricey. Casual but nice open dining room. Parking not an issue. Note: This is one of those businesses in this area that unfortunately charge patrons 3% if using a credit card versus cash. read more

I checked out a pizza spot that just recently opened and was pleasantly surprised. The pizza turned out really good. I ordered the Bronx Bomber -- the crust was just right, toppings tasted fresh, and the whole pizza was just really tasty:) The staff were super friendly, and while chatting with them I found out it's a family-owned place. Great experience, definitely recommend read more

See all

I went try but they don't have slices at 5:00pm I would like to try but a whole pie at those prices can't afford to try and it's not good. Try giving a sample first. read more

Wings were definitely a healthy size, the caprese was good. However don't like how they gave me a square slice. It was awkward to ahold and everything fell when I was trying to fold it and eat it. Pizza is on point. read more

New Pizza Place. Food is very good. Hot and Cold subs also. read more

See all

A heads up everyone-tried Time Square Pizza on Crosstown today and HIGHLY RECOMMEND it! Brand new, very clean. Server was awesome. Food is very high quality, big portions and prices are beyond reasonable!! They have unbelievable early bird specials (3-6) and 2 slice and a drink $9 til 3P. Definitely feel this is a find!! It's in the little plaza to the east of the Circle K. Give it a try-think you'll love it! read more

Best pizza in 40-50 years! After watching the reviews on another site, one of which an owner acknowledged an issue which I don't remember and indicated they were looking to improve some process or menu. I respect when people own issues so I decided I need to try this place at least once. Wow, I am glad I did. First, let me say that Pizza choice is very subjective. Not that ethnicity should matter but I am first generation American from an Abruzzeze mother who could cook like nobody's business (including pizza with crispy centers). That trait was not genetically passed on. Raised in northern Ohio, I am a pizza snob. Based upon my experience, I was elated to see a standard menu item of pizza with simple ingredients such as high-quality tomato sauce, oregano and basil and no cheese. Of course it can be customized. So of course this is what I had with a few add-ons. It was served fresh on a vented pizza pan (not sure that is the correct term). Although I have eaten pizza from other establishments, which was served on vented pans, this was the first experience I had where there was absolutely no flopping in the middle of the crust, and the center points of the crust were as crispy as the edges. Of course, I realize some people like that floppy folding pizza. I do not. The service was prompt and friendly. The server placed the array of garlic powder, oregano, grated cheese, and crushed reds on the table without me asking. The interior design was very modernesque and clean. Of course it's new. The music in the background was not too loud and it was sort of a neo-jazz fusion. Nice. All this said, the visuals, sound, and taste senses had the boxes checked. The bottled beer was a little pricey, but that's OK shouldn't drink that much anyhow. it looked like from the people carrying out catering trays that they do a good catering business. I highly recommend at least giving this place a try. Thanks for being here, Times Square. Hoping for your success. read more

Really enjoyed the pizza here. Super crispy crust. Closest we've come to NY pizza since we arrived in PSL read more

Times Square Pizza - Take-out menu - Pizza Near Me - Port St. Lucie, Florida

Fantastic place! Delicious pizza (we've tried classy margarita and also time square) and one of the best cheesesteaks I've ever tried! Very polite staff, clean space - definitely recommend it!!! read more

See all

Food and service was very good and cheerful. I recommend it. The young lady who took our order was polite and professional. The food came I. A timely manner. We ordered pizza which was excellent. read more

After passing by this place for a year waiting for it open, we were able to go in a sit down for a good meal. Great food choices. The pasta sauce is delicious. Will be back to try more options on the menu. read more

Pizza was dry with no taste and over priced $28 dollars for a large pie and the pie was square very disappointed

The moment you step inside, the restaurant wraps you in warmth--soft lighting, rustic wood accents, and the comforting aroma of garlic and simmering tomato sauce. It feels like the kind of place where meals are meant to be savored, not rushed. I started with a classic bruschetta, and it set the tone immediately. The bread was perfectly toasted--crisp on the outside, slightly chewy inside--topped with fresh tomatoes, basil, and just the right drizzle of olive oil. Simple, but done right. For the main course, the pasta was clearly the star. The noodles tasted house-made, with a texture that held onto the sauce beautifully. The marinara was rich and slightly sweet, balanced with a subtle acidity that kept it from feeling heavy. Each bite felt thoughtful, like it had been cooked with patience rather than speed. The standout, though, was the chicken parmesan. The breading was golden and crisp without being greasy, and the chicken inside stayed tender. Melted cheese and sauce layered over the top made it indulgent without crossing into overwhelming. Service matched the food--attentive without hovering. The staff seemed genuinely proud of what they were serving, offering recommendations and checking in at just the right moments. To finish, the tiramisu was a must. Light, creamy, and not overly sweet, with a balanced coffee flavor that lingered just enough to end the meal on a high note. read more

This place has no business charging what they charge! Their prices for pizza are absolutely ridiculous especially considering how mediocre it was! The service is on par with the pizza - you would think charging such an exorbitant amount would mean exceptional ingredients, flavor, and service - but no. read more

This place is absolutely amazing! From the moment we walked in, we were received with some of the friendliest, warmest service I've ever experienced at a Pizza place. The environment is very welcoming and it seems like they put a lot of thought into their presentation, which is nice to see. As far as the food, they went above and beyond to accommodate my dietary needs with a delicious pasta with eggplant, and gave my husband the best chicken wings he's tried in a long time. We're definitely coming back! This is exactly the kind of delicious treat this area needed. Next time we're coming for the pizza. read more

I got a menu but didn't order. I felt the prices were way out of line. 50% to double for a smaller pizza. I love what I've been getting but hoped this place would be good because it's much closer. Very disappointed. read more

Great food and Pizza, Service is also excellent. Owners on site making sure everyone is satisfied. Food has great tastes and it seems everything is home made. read more

I have eaten there at least 15 times and find there pizza and Pasta dishes are great. Service is also top notch, owners are very active and show real pride. I always eat in. read more

Decided to try this place because it is close to the house. They charged me $43 dollars for a pizza that was maybe worth $20. I asked for extra cheese and the cheese did not even cover the entire pizza. Ingredients were extremely chinsey like they were trying to make two tablespoons cover the whole pizza. . Sauce was thin and flavorless and they didn't put enough either. Thumbs down. Won't go back again. Way overpriced for what you get. Pizza was below average. Do yourself a favor and chose something different. read more