My needs:
1) A reasonably priced pair of silver, sparkly shoes for an upcoming night of debauchery as a showgirl costumed bridesmaid. This means "dancing all night", so the shoe must be comfy and I cannot break an ankle (which is no small feat for me). The heel cannot be "too high", nor can it be "too low". No pinching anywhere on the shoe.
2) A comfy pair of flats for my feet with fallen arches for the fall.
3) An extremely comfortable, well-made pair of flip-flops to replace the Olu-Kai pair that I must now admit are beyond use.
1) I walked to the Women's Dress section and found about 12 pairs of shoes that could fit the bill. None worked, until I tried that final, glorious pair. Perfect. Price? Check...totally doable. Thank you. Next!
2) Dr. Scholl's cute black flats? I like you. I think you'll do. Thanks! Price? A little high, but you pay for comfort, right? Fine. Thanks. (Unfortunately, I got these home and they rub a bit. Hoping that will get better as the days wear on.)
3) Bear Traps? No workable options in my size. They were all way too big. Olu Kai? Don't carry 'em. Tevas? Ugly. Supremely ugly. Born? They all had closed-in sides that rubbed and will cause blisters. :(... Also, some of the flip flos I liked (even if they had come in my size) were $70, which is approximately what I would pay through the manufacturer, so I'm not sure that's a deal. No options. Really wanted these, too. Instead, I settled for an ugly pair of Easy Spirit clogs that I will use to do things like run out to the mailbox, or go to the garage, etc. Enh...failure.
On to the check out experience. First, I should mention that no one offered to help me during my experience. That's not necessarily a bad thing for me, but it could be for others. The girl next to me had a terrible check out experience. She'd ordered a pair of shoes, received a call that they were in, came out to pick them up, and no one could find them, or had any idea what she was talking about. They didn't even really seem that interested in helping her. That really turned me off. She was very patient about it. I would not have been.
My checkout person did tell me that one of my pairs of shoes was half a size larger than the other two pairs. (I knew this, but it was nice of her to mention it, in case I'd made a mistake.) She also checked each pair to make sure that the shoes inside the box were the same size. I appreciated that. She looked up my DSW membership, using my long, complicated email address. My membership must be a thousand years old by now, so that was also appreciated.
All-told, I walked out of there for around $125, I think? That seems like a fair price for two pairs of comfy, good shoes, and one pair that rubs. Still irritated not to have found a good deal on a well-made pair of flip-flops in my size. With summer coming to a close, I would expect to pay less than $70. read more