Old time feel and baked goods here. Love the vibe, center of town. The gentleman who boxed our goods was so helpful and friendly. We purchased several sweets to try and cut them up to share. The cream puff was not what I was hoping for but still fun to eat. The other doughnuts were okay. Wishing we would have tried the lemon petit 4's. The apple filled elephant ear won our vote. It's just what it sounds like: A folded over elephant ear filled with apple pie filling. As for baked goods, I am always up for trying & happy we did. Try for yourself. read more

See all

Came for donuts two days in a row and they were excellent! Reminds me of the old time bakery in my home town that no longer exists. We will be back often! read more

Been coming here for years. Everytime the selection offerings are less. The portion size are smaller. Large chocolate chip cookies are half the size of the were just 4 years ago. I doubt I'll be back. A great bakery is hard to find. read more

Continuous bad experiences. Came In there for breakfast sandwiches, was turned away TWICE . One of the times There was NOBODY ELSE in the store besides me for customers. She said " Too Busy". I replied " There's no one here and walked out. DONT ADVERTISE BREAKFAST SAND WICHES if you WONT make me A Sandwich lady !!! Other issues besides the breakfast sandwiches read more

Change can be great, but not in this case. Baked goods were dry and dizzy with a very high price point. Sad to say pic save danish were much better at one third of price. Bread was fair, crust not crispy. This place was such a treat but has taken a downward turn. read more

We've been coming to this bakery on occasion for about ten years. It has gone through various owners, and is now a shadow of what it once was. This bakery used to have excellent freshly baked whole grain breads. No longer. Today we purchased a cranberry pecan Kringle that has become smaller with every visit, and it was not as well made. It tasted as if it was not fresh and did not contain as many pecans.The staff and owner are friendly. We may return for lunch sandwiches, but are not likely to return for baked goods. read more

2022 update. I'm unable to say for sure... but locals say business sold over the winter. I'll assume it's true because the great Kringles are no more... we used to purchase 2-3 a week for our cabin crew but this year they're just not the same. One and done for us. Also disappointed you can't buy their products in 3Lakes amd Land O ... I hope they figure it out and will try again next year read more

I'm rooting for this business, but they will need to improve their game. We just had their yellow cake cake with fudge frosting for a birthday. The cake was very over baked and dry, and the decorations were not much more than a home baker could do. We also bought a raspberry and pecan coffee cake which was good, but LOTS of nuts and sadly not as good as the Kringle's of the past. I hope they continue to improve. We'll try them again, just not for a specialty cake. read more

Eagle Baking - Birthday Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Eagle River, Wisconsin

We have enjoyed the baked goods from Eagle Baking for 3 summers. Such yummy donuts, huge selection, great service and prices are very reasonable. read more

Eagle Baking is not the bakery it used to be. All the bread is the same, of fine ground texture, whereas they used to have bread with many different seeds and was more course. AND their prices are outrageous, donuts, cakes, yikes! I don't really go there anymore. read more

What happened!! This place used to have amazing kringles, danishes, breads and other Sweet treats and baked goods. New owners completely destroyed it. Canned fruit fillings are disgusting read more

Not the same quality. Hope things improve. Items purchased were dry and lacking flavor. Will try one more time in a month.

Called on Saturday about a special cake needed for Weds. I was told I could order on Monday. I waited in line outside (90 degrees) for 20 min (covid precautions) only to be told I had not allowed 72 hours. So after many years of going there through more than one owner I will not be back. Wasted my time, gave me incorrect info and spoiled an event. She kept saying "I don't know who told you that!" Ummm someone who works here are there like 4-5 employees? It's not like many other choice/places (grocery decorator quit). AND THEY TOLD ME THEY TAKE THE CAKES TO THE DECORATORS' HOUSE WHICH HMMMMM.... That doesn't seem right pandemic aside. !! Not the end of the world but more annoyed that I was organized enough to call!! read more

Tiny little place right in the downtown area. Delightful desserts and bakery items. Very reasonably priced and fresh. We stopped fairly later in the day and they still have many options. I only got a lemon poppyseed muffin and it was delectable. Moist muffin with a delicious lemon middle. Wow. So very good!!! read more

Eagle Baking - Lemon poppyseed muffin - Bakeries Near Me - Eagle River, Wisconsin

A cute little bakery right in Eagle River. We bought donuts, scones, and elephant ears. A morning breakfast treat doesn't get much better than that. All delicious & so fresh. Busy little place. Lots of people buying their bread...might have to go back to see what I'm missing out on by not getting the bread myself. read more

Outstanding baked goods with a huge variety! Lovely people as well! If you're in the area (or even if you're not) you won't be disappointed. read more

It's a absolutely wonderful place. short staffed like so many places . Just be patient and considerate as a customer. What you get to eat is absolutely delicious and the employees do their best. As a customer, be your best! read more

Baked goods are good. Service is really bad and unfriendly. Unfortunately, there is only one bakery in town.

We love this bakery. So friendly and always well stocked here. Scones, donuts, cookies and sandwiches, too. Best kringle ever!!

Totally disappointing... If you pay a premium price for pastries, you would expect to have something other than day-old bakery. Just paid over $10 for four pastries and the first bite was dry and tasteless. What happened? Maybe over priced so they keep the pastries in the Display case one more day? I don't know, but I'm not gonna go back anymore, I tried to give them a second chance. read more

We ordered 15 cannolis for a birthday party last week an they was amazingly delicious. I also got the chance to have a pizza NY style an it was good as well! Keep up the good work! read more

Fantastic bakery but if you can only try one thing, try the scones!!! They are not the typical ones you get here. They are more authentic to the English and are the best I've had! Lots of yummy desserts! read more

Popped in before a manicure appt for a coffee and something tasty. What a bummer. Coffee was bad, but I sorta expected that bc the place is Old School. However, the scone was sad. Blueberry scone with icing so I figured it would be great! It wasn't even made with real blueberries! It had those creepy blueberry pellets that come in instant pancake mix. I mean c'mon. You're a BAKERY. I'm sure they are using a mix which is embarrassing. read more

Eagle Baking - Sad sad excuse for blueberries. - Bakeries Near Me - Eagle River, Wisconsin

Unfortunately this bakery appears to be permanently closed. Tried calling during business hours with no answer / no voice mail greeting

We have been going to this bakery for two decades on our way up to our lake cabin. Everything bread, pastries, donuts, cakes etc were first rate. A year ago they had problems hiring enough staff to keep the store open but they continued to baked and delivered twice a week to our local grocery in Land O Lakes, WI. The quality was the same. This spring the bakery had a new owner and what a shame. The bread is dry, the rye and multigrain have little rye or whole what flour in them. Even the pastries are dry. The breads need more liquid and shortening and a different baking technique. The pastries need more butter and a better baking technique. I have made bread of all types using the no knead method for many years and have the feeling the new owner is skimping on ingredients and does not know how to bake. We will not go to that bakery again and I will make my own bread at the cabin. We can live without pastries. read more

I so badly want this business to survive because it's great to have a full bakery in town. However, they desperately need to switch it up with a more experiences decorator for cakes, cookies, etc. It floors me that these are being sold for money and not made by children just for fun. I hope that they are looking for and find someone that can help with this. read more

Great sandwiches and delicious bakery Small town feeling with big city taste. This place offers fantastic sandwiches and amazing tasting baked goods. I always like seeing a monster cookie. Cheers- read more

The bakery and sandwiches are amazing! The staff lacks customer service skills. Stopped on the weekend asked to have my bread sliced and was told it was to fresh and I could bring it back Tuesday to have it sliced. No one buys bread to wait to have it sliced 3 days later. Before we had the chance to order a sandwich I was told that there were 11 sandwiches in front of mine and it would be a 30 minute wait. It's sad when you try to support local businesses and you are treated like an inconvenience. read more

Stopped in for sandwiches to go. There was a nice selection of options available. Went for the blue jay. Turkey lettuce tomato pickles and choice of dressing. Really wanted the sourdough bread but they were all out, I did stop after the lunch rush though. Opted for the hoagie roll and it was delicious! Added cheese and was told it would be an extra .50, a steal for the 3 slices they put on. The sandwich includes a pickle, crinkle cut chips and choice of cookie. I will stop here again. read more

Great little bakery. Excellent donuts and pastries at a good price AND everyone wore masks and capacity was limited. THANK YOU for caring about your patrons' and community's health! read more

Your Fat Tuesday packi's are the best in the north woods. Reminded me of the Polish baker's in Chicago. Wish you would do those daily during lent. Although all of your breads and other baked products are great those put the rest of what is available in the area to shame. read more

While the baked goods and sandwiches were good, the customer service was horrible. The staff were beyond rude and tried to push us out the door before we were done ordering. Possibly the owner- was the worst of all. Will never patronize the place again. read more

Still one of my favorite places downtown. Went there yesterday for lunch and today for breakfast before the July 4 parade. Yesterday, we ordered sandwiches for lunch and immediately they got to work and had our food out within 6 minutes. Super friendly and very very efficient. This morning, we went in to grab breakfast and it was absolutely packed. However, the workers were hustling and still got to us in less than 10 minutes and got our order done within minutes. Absolutely love this place. read more

Really good pastry, bread, and sandwiches. Locally owned bakery have been vanishing for decades, but Eagle Baking Co seems to be going strong. I hope it continues. read more

I don't really want to tell people about the lunch sandwiches at Eagle Baking because they will be more busy than they are. That said sandwiches are the worst ever, stay away!!!!!!!!! OK I can't do that. Really really great lunches, very fair prices. I think the best part is the choice of bread and Condiment. My VERY favorite is the " blue jay" on a hoagie with mayo. I also love saying " any cookie" ( you get a fresh cookie with every sandwich) Every cookie is awesome and the surprise is pretty cool! read more

Kringle are fabulous. Many varieties and fresh- we like cherry and berry from what we've tried so far. You know it's good when there is a line out the door. Only two people at a time inside but that doesn't deter folks from coming. read more

It's been a long time since I have been in a bakery. So going into Eagle Bakery put all my senses on not hyper overdrive. There is a fabulous selection of danishes, cookies, breads, pies, & donuts. They also make wonderful deli sandwiches which are served with chips, pickle and a cookie. My snowshoe sandwich was delicious. I will definitely be stopping back several times during my stay at Eagle River. read more

If this is the same place . . my mom and I were addicted to the pecan coffee cake. OMG. She once sent me one in California. I think I might have to call them tomorrow and send myself one or two again! read more

Best bread in town and the only place to get really good fresh sourdough. Pastries and donuts are great as well. As importantly, the people behind the counter are delightful. Love coming in here. read more

Cute little bake shop in Eagle River. Nice selection and friendly staff. We tried an almond cheese danish and found it quite tasty. We'd definitely recommend to others and hope to stop back again ourselves next time we are in Eagle River. read more