Just reviewing the ice cream. Fairly standard case of hard dipped Wilcoxson's brand ice cream with large variety of flavors. Fairly typical pricing about $6 for a scoop. It is part of a gas station/general store so service may not be on point as they are covering multiple areas of the store. Doesn't have anything special like in house made waffle cones or anything. Also doesn't strike me as a good place to get shakes or specialty ice creams but if you just want a quick scoop of ice cream for the kids it'll do the trick. Main deciding factor between here and the stand across the street was having the ice cream case so the kids can see/pick out their ice cream and prevent a buyers remorse kid tantrum. Outside seating is limited, just one picnic table and a few benches in front. read more

See all

This Karen's to have a better selection of ice cream than most of the other places in town. It's set behind an old soda fountain which is pretty cool. The kid that was serving offered up 'try out' spoons if we wanted. We opted for a cone and a cup, both single. They were both a pretty decent sized scoop which hit the spot perfectly. A scoop will run you about $5. This place also has a gas station, gift shop, and mini mart. read more

See all

Got a totally fine Peach ice cream float. Nowhere to sit, didn't realize it was just a knick knack store! Was hoping for a soda fountain experience but oh well. read more

Marketed as a historic soda fountain landmark, when they don't even have a fountain. The shop is simply a glorified gift shop. The best they do is sell ice cream. All the employees were clearly foreign. Not what we expected from a supposed historical landmark. read more

My kiddo had a hot chocolate today. They ran out of the normal hot chocolate mix but our friend gave us a solution and my kiddo loved it! Thank you for going above and beyond to deliver. We appreciate the service, solutions and tasty drinks. read more

You know that phrase to hot to handle? Eagle's was too hot for ME to Handle! It was July. IT WAS SO HOT INSIDE! I had to get out! I placed my daughter's ice cream order and walked out. Dad waited for the ice cream. My Eagle experience was short lived. read more

Eagle's Store - Bubblegum float - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - West Yellowstone, Montana

Over priced!! Service was soooooo slow! It isn't even a soda shop anymore, they just have a self serve soda fountain like they have at any gas station, except it's small and probably from the 90's. Ice cream is nothing special and frankly the building is falling apart! They should definitely restore it and bring it back to its historic soda fountain glory! read more

We are a family of milk shake drinkers. All we have to say is that this spot makes one of the best milk shakes we have had. Thank you!!!

Not a welcoming business. We went for the ice cream, but the person working there treated us like it was a chore to serve us. So we went across the street to Espresso West which was FABULOUS! read more

How sad the virus closed my favorite place to get a milkshake in West Yellowstone I always got the large $6 huckleberry shake and sat at the soda fountain with other tourist but not this year read more

See all

I was so disappointed to go to Eagles curios today. I took my family to go to the old store filled with western wear, cowboy boots, belts, hats, outdoor wear and moccasins along with great gift ware.... We went in to find the nearest store to Yellowstone National park in West Yellowstone, blasting Spanish music, (I like Spanish music) but country' I feels more authentic there . We crossed the threshold to only find tied dyed tee shirts baseball hats, a few Christmas ornaments, puzzles which for us was quite a disappointment.... What happened? Where is the Eagle family? Grateful the old historic soda fountain is still there. I am a Montanan, I have been to Eagles curios for decades, I love Yellowstone National park, but so disappointed in Eagles curios today. read more

If I only rated on the taste of food, value and atmosphere this place would be a 4-star place. But my reviews are heavily based on service. If you go here prepare to wait a beary beary beary long time to have your order taken. For the life of me I can't figure out why they didn't have a "ice cream cone" only line. We watched at least a dozen people walk out because of the service. The ice cream was outstanding and just watching them make the many malts and shakes, I would bet they are nothing less than great. Bottom line... service is horrible! read more

The family liked their ice cream, however, I was fully unimpressed. Definitely over priced and tasted freezer burnt. To be fair, you don't come here for the food, you come because you are seeing Yellowstone, so have low expectations and palates. read more

The Soda Fountain is located inside the Eagle's Store. The best Vanilla Malt I've ever tasted! The malt is creamy and delicious. They also give you the extra malt/shake that didn't fit in the cup. You must try their malt or shake! read more

Eagle's Store - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - West Yellowstone, Montana

There are quite a few ice cream shops around town but I really like the old time soda shop feel of this place. You sit on stools and most of the equipment is from the 50's. Feel free to try other places but don't miss this gem! The teenagers working the counter were polite and answered all of our questions. We ended up ordering three cones with two scoops each along with a sundae and a chocolate malt. I tried a bit of everyone's ice cream and it was good! I highly recommend the huckleberry ice cream with the huckleberry sauce. Very tasty! I ordered the malt and loved it. It's harder and harder to find places that make malts and even harder to find places that do it well. These guys nailed it! As a side note, I recommend having the chocolate malt made with vanilla ice cream and Mom Eagles homemade chocolate sauce (yes, that's really the name). All told I spend about $25 and receive a lot of ice cream! In summary, great ice cream with exceptional service and a fun atmosphere make this place a winner in my book! read more

Awesome place BUT they were out of Chocolate Runs Thru It We really wanted to give it a try. We did get other flavors and they were fantastic and so was the service. Two Polish girls and two Asian girls were working and having a big time. Happiness is contagious; not sure if they caught ours or we caught theirs but it was so nice. When we come back again we'll go again read more

Not very good. My milkshake was spun so much it was like milk. Out of vanilla ice cream. I would not return.

This was about the BEST ice cream I've ever had!!! This is 'chocolate runs through it' and it was delicious!!! It had very thick ribbons of fudge! The gentleman at the counter was very friendly, and the place was set up as an old time soda fountain. We sat at a big, wooden counter and had our ice cream! I'd highly recommend going here. They serve Wilcoxsons Ice Cream! read more

Eagle's Store - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - West Yellowstone, Montana

One of the best malts I have ever had! I believe the flavor I had was called Moose moss and it was Delicious!! The service was friendly and the were very helpful even with my three young children making a big mess! read more

Stopped by for a Sunday and some of the famous chocolate sauce to take home to friends. They were out . BUT proprietor Darleena (also from Oregon like us) took my address to ship later. Before she did that she check a couple places in the back to be sure. read more

Fun, historic shop in West Yellowstone. Really well preserved piece of local history. It was their 140th(?) anniversary when we were there and they were serving cake. We had ice cream at the soda fountain and it was delicious! read more

Wonderful Soda fountain and tackle shop, the store is dope and everyone is super helpful especially in the tackle shop and Soda fountain! Wonderful store with wonderful curios and milkshakes! Kristijan is cool will go back 10/10. And the kid with the rat tail can sling some huckleberry malts like no other, request the Sherkan Special! read more

Eagle's Store - Wonderful staff always full of smiles and they love their job! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - West Yellowstone, Montana

Amazing Ice Cream! We were served at the historic counter while sitting on the old stools. The huckleberry malt was delicious! The others in our group had shakes and they were wonderful, also. The gentleman working the soda counter was friendly and very efficient. I'd love to go back!! read more

This place is unique in that it has its original soda fountain set up... counter and stools. We all had ice cream and it was good. I was disappointed that they didn't have the "true" soda fountain set up with syrups and flavors to add to fountain sodas. It's hard to find a true soda fountain now a days. However, it was neat to see. The staff was awesome and super kind . It's worth seeing if you are in the area. read more

Great Root Beer Float! The best in a long time! Vanilla ice cream tasted very different, a good different, not sure what's in it but very good. And they'll top off your root beer too! Going back before we leave! read more