Still one of my Hamptons favorites. Classy atmosphere and still feels "under the radar"…read moreconsidering this is a historic venue. Food always has a very fresh farm to table vibe.

One of the worst dining experiences I have ever had…read more My partner became ill and was unable to join me for dinner. We called the restaurant to either move our reservation to another day or cancel it, and were told that only the manager could assist us. However, we were told the manager was unavailable because he was busy speaking with regulars at a table. I asked if we could simply be placed on hold until he was available so we could find a solution. We were told no. Instead, the employee said they would "leave a note" and that someone would call us back if they were able to help. Meanwhile, we were told that if the reservation was canceled, we would be charged a $135 cancellation fee -- despite the fact that we were actively trying to work with the restaurant to either reschedule or resolve the situation. The experience became even more unacceptable when the employee eventually hung up on us and then stopped answering our calls. The restaurant only answered after American Express contacted them on our behalf. To be clear, I have no issue with a restaurant having a cancellation policy. What I have an issue with is the way this situation was handled: being told the manager was "too busy" to speak with us, being refused the simple courtesy of being placed on hold, having our calls screened, and ultimately being hung up on. That is an embarrassing level of customer service for an establishment of this caliber. I genuinely hope someone in management -- above the person working the restaurant that evening -- takes this seriously and addresses this behavior. A cancellation policy is one thing; treating a customer with this level of disrespect is another.

This was our initial experience at the Mill House Inn located in East Hampton. We visited for the…read moreHampton Classic, and the location proved to be extremely convenient. Our accommodation was situated on the third floor, which was ideal, featuring a king-sized bed, a television, and a bathroom equipped with a spacious soaking tub. Each morning, we enjoyed a complimentary breakfast that included eggs, yogurt, fruit, pancakes, coffee, tea, and more. This meal was available in a cozy dining area or could be served in our room. Additionally, there is a small snack area accessible throughout the day. The Inn itself exudes the charm of a bygone era and is well-maintained. The staff consistently demonstrated friendliness and attentiveness. The Inn is conveniently positioned within walking distance to downtown and other attractions. Overall, it was a delightful stay.

The place is amazing, very well kept. Very clean and quiet. rooms are beautiful and breakfast is…read moredelicious It is highly recommend and we can't wait to came back during the summer.

Very comfortable hotel with amazing outdoor spaces. The backyard is especially beautiful at sunset,…read morewhere the light is soft and fireflies dance. They offer bikes for exploring, a car service, and complementary snacks throughout the day. I recommend this hotel for all, but especially for families looking for a summer getaway. Boby, the hotel manager, is very kind and accommodating. He went above and beyond to deliver an amazing experience for my family. Be sure to try the desserts from their Balinese chef!

This a great place to stay! We stayed here the later part of June and had a fabulous time there…read more The cottage is situated where you can walk to town, to great restaurants, and bars. The owners Jed and Leslie were super nice, very helpful and gave great recommendation for places to eat. The cottage we had was very spacious as there were six in our party. We had 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms that were decorated really nice. The cottage was also stocked with everything you could possibly need. The grounds were also super beautiful with trees, flowers, and a large spacious grass area with different sitting areas where you could sit, relax and have a glass of wine.

The Maidstone for Thanksgiving dinner was very nice. The service was EXCEPTIONAL. Atmosphere was…read morewarm and welcoming. The soup and pasta were EXCELLENT. Turkey could have been better. Pumpkin cheesecake and carrot cake delicious!

This place has really gone downhill…read more They used to have a nice full menu. Now they have a small tiny menu and take over an hour to bring you your food. Our server made us go on a treasure hunt just to find him. He took our appetizer order and then never returned. Our side plates were never taken away, our server never asked how the food was, and they never brought out all our food. Don't be deceived by their low prices. The portions match the prices... SMALL. The only thing that separates this from a one star review is that the food. The food was decent but definitely not worth coming back for.

Lovely stay at the Journey. Cindy was absolutely wonderful as was everyone else we met throughout…read moreour stay. The little breakfast set up in the lobby is perfect. The lobby itself is warm and inviting. Firepit with all the fixings for s'more's was a wonderful touch. Can't wait to come back.

Stayed at the Journey East Hampton hotel for just one night for business. I found the room lovely…read more Next time, I'll need to take part in some of amenities that they offer. I would definitely stay here again.

Here is an email I sent to "The Hedges Restaurant" after having lunch there about a year ago after…read moreit opened. Unfortunately, I never received an acknowledgment of my email or any response. Lunch left a lot to be desired service wise. I have not been back since based on the experience I had there and, also based on their lack of response. It speaks for itself. Here is my email - Hi Leani - It's John O'Rourke again. Thank you for arranging and changing our lunch reservations for this past Monday. It's was a lovely location and a beautiful restaurant to return to. I have lived here for over twenty-five years now. My guests were so impressed by the respectful, well chosen, and stunning renovation. But, please allow me to mention some problems, as well as the previous compliments, that happened during our lunch. I believe feedback is important and can be productive. So for that purpose I send you these observations. - After we were seated and given menus - we waited at least 5 minutes before a waiter came to the table. - We were a party of four and, when two servers (not our waiter) put down our main courses - only two people in our party were served. We waited - thinking the other two orders would come out soon but, they didn't! Finally, we waved to our waiter who was not aware of the problem and, the entrees came out shortly after. - It's worth noting that none of the entrees served were presented in the 6 o'clock position where the plate is strategically placed in front of the diner. - Also, the wait staff never refilled our water glasses or asked if we would like another drink. Frankly, this is not the level of service I expected. And, if you would please pass my comments on to the proper person in the restaurant- I would appreciate that. I love East Hampton and, I am enthusiastic about the newly renovated Hedges. I wish you all well. Respectfully, John O'Rourke

The Hedges Inn is an absolutely gorgeous place to stay when visiting East Hampton. This quaint bed…read moreand breakfast has a lot of history surrounded by cobblestone and beautiful greenery. I stayed at the Hedges Inn during the early spring for a bachelorette. We loved the accommodating staff members whom checked in with us frequently. The Inn is a brisk walk away from the relaxing beach. Staff provide you with passes. We had access to bikes for an enjoyable ride along the cobblestone and windmills. The room service was excellent and my bed was extra comfortable. My friends and I loved that breakfast was offered as a part of our stay. We couldn't locate many East Hampton locations which included this. The breakfast here was self-serve and delicious! Hands down I will visit The Hedges Inn next time I'm in the area. Thank you for making my stay super relaxing and memorable!

Really underrated hotel in EH. The staff is simply fantastic. The front desk ladies made our stay…read moreso enjoyable. Like we made new friends. The rooms are clean and the AC blows cold. Great deals midweek. A fun bar. The Palm is at your fingertips for a quality steak.

Had a lovely Hamptons overnight here. Location is the key. Seriously right in the middle of town…read moreand an easy drive to the beaches. Dark, small "lobby", so the main area could use a facelift but the room was clean and comfortable. Staff was helpful. Beach chairs, umbrellas and towels provided. Perfect for a girls trip.

The Baker House 1650 in East Hampton is just an amazing bed and breakfast experience. It's an old…read morehouse from 1600's with all the old world charm. If you want to have a massage or the private pool make an appointment and reserve your private time. The rooms are quite beautiful and offer a lot of charm and all the necessities. They offer delicious breakfast each morning, The staff is extremely friendly and helpful.

1. A gentleman with AirPods in his ears checked us in. To explain that we would need to move rooms…read moreafter our first night into a different room for our remaining two nights, he showed us the entire booking screen with all the guests' private contact information. 2. The rooms have iPod docks with 30-pin connectors. I mean at this point just remove them if you aren't going to replace them guys - they haven't worked with any iPhone since 2012. 3. A woman who fell squarely into the "surprised and afraid to find herself in charge of a hotel" category was incredibly rude to my wife when we were working from the room (as we had been told we could) the day we needed to inexplicably vacate it for a different room. "My husband is showering, we need 15 minutes." "You can't have 15 minutes." Like, what are you going to do? Forcibly remove us from the room? You guys were the ones who told us we could use the room. 4. I should also note that the rooms were LITERALLY RIGHT NEXT DOOR TO EACH OTHER and to my eye completely identical. (The one we moved to had a small balcony but otherwise I didn't detect any material difference.) It doesn't seem like an insurmountable puzzle to solve that you could have just put the other people into the vacant room. 5. They decided for some reason to empty the hotel's septic tank during our friends' wedding photos. 6. It's one of those places where a hopeless fussy person has laminated lots of signs with rules and instructions. Do NOT remove the laminated guide to the room from the room itself. Do NOT use any towel other than the blue ones for removing makeup. Do NOT flush anything other than toilet paper because the house has EXTREMELY sensitive plumbing. It all seems like someone very, very angry runs the place. (Is there a significant problem with guests removing the laminated guide from the room?) One star for a good location and another star for a pretty good breakfast (you are entitled to ONE cooked item, per the rules).

Always amazing! Especially Vinny at the bar! Expansive wine list and great food-feels like going…read moreback in time

Went to have dinner there - was put in the back patio which was nice, but did get a little…read moreforgotten about in the back. Dinner was roughly 95 minutes for two. Food, drinks and dessert were great though. Went on a Tuesday night so also had the $2 oysters deal!

We absolutely loved our first time stay at Barons Cove. We can in the off season November but the…read moreplace seemed very busy with guests. We stayed two nights in a dog friendly room, which was spacious and clean - no previous smell of a dog at all! They had a dog bed and treats with bowls waiting for her. It was so cute! We visited the restaurant and our food was great. Service was quick and helpful with the menu as well. They had the fire place on which was so nice. We went to the bar/lounge afterwards and had a few drinks by that fireplace. So nice and relaxing. Staff was always welcoming and all drinks and food were good. Room was clean, spacious and comfortable. That's all you can ask for! My only complaint was when we were checking out I wanted to make sure our bill was correct and wanted to speak with someone. With Sunday brunch going on upstairs there was no one at the front desk for almost 15 minutes. During the time I was waiting two other people came behind me to wait as well. The front desk person who came back was quick and friendly to get us checked out but for the price I would think someone would be there at all times? We can't wait to come back to Barons Cove soon!!

Our two night stay at Baron's Cove was a mixed experience…read more On the plus side: 1) Their staff is friendly and helpful (especially Concierge Eliza). 2) Decor is pretty and homey with flowers all around. 3) We didn't get to use the saltwater pool but it looked inviting. 4) Free live music in the lounge every night was a nice perk. 5) Walkable to town or free bikes provided. 6) Spacious room with cute patio. 7) On-site dining available. Room to Improve: 1) Inflexible 4:00PM check-in. They emailed to ask when we'd arrive beforehand; I said 2:00 and would appreciate an early check-in, they said to wait and will text me when room was ready. Actually we had to wait outside in the heat or in the crowded lounge until 4:30PM, no early check-ins for anyone (there were other guests waiting with us). We would have walked into town for lunch had we known this. 2) Free coffee but no included food for breakfast, which is only served in their upstairs restaurant at extra charge. At BC's price point they could have offered a few complementary pastries, as is done at many cheaper venues. 3) The a/c in our room was old, noisy, had no remote and didn't work well. Musty smell in room. 4) Lunch served outside only in all kinds of weather, insufficient umbrellas to provide shade on hot day. (Pls see separate review for their restaurant). All in all our stay at Barons Cove was pretty good, but felt their oldish amenities didn't warrant high room rates plus puzzling "resort fees."