At $40 for just two tickets, plus a $5 "convenience" fee, and concession prices that border on…read moreabsurd, it's hard not to feel taken advantage of. No matinee options, no consideration!! Just a clear display of profit over people. This isn't about creating a community experience anymore; it's about squeezing every dollar from those of us who simply wanted a night out. We live here year-round. We support this town and its businesses every season, not just when it's convenient. You caught us this time, but know this: there won't be a next. It's disheartening to see this kind of greed, and even more so to be met with dismissive attitudes at the counter. Do better. Our community deserves it.

Didn't much care for this theatre. Staff wasn't friendly at all. Slow service at the snack bar. The…read moreline wasn't so much long as the delivery of snacks to each customer was so slow. I waited in line until way past my movie's start time but fortunately I only missed the first 15 minutes of trailers for other movies. (Seriously! Why are there so many trailers and ads before the movie I've paid to see comes on?) The theatre is icy cold so it's a welcome relief from Key West's heat and humidity in August. But the air carries that faint mildewy aroma that closed up buildings in the tropics can get. Seats were comfy and staggered so you don't have to look at the back of anyone's head, so that's nice. But they don't recline like some more modern theatres' seats do. Parking is hit-or-miss. The theatre shares a lot with Publix (and several other stores) and it must have been free-food day because we ended up having to park a long long way from the theatre.

We found this little gem of a theatre this week while visiting Key West. Not our first time in KW…read moreso we explore new places. What a terrific find. We saw the opening of Scrooge McBeth & enjoyed a night of laugh therapy. Great space, terrific cast & costumes & a wonderful production of a fabulously strange story! LYAO enjoyment. We were a group of six & were all equally happy to have seen the show & meet some of the cast & audience. Very warm & friendly people. We look forward to seeing another performance the next time we get to KW.

Very small theater in a historic building. Saw "Quarantine for Two", a wickedly funny play about a…read moremiddle-aged warring couple cooped up together during COVID. We could all relate to lines about disinfecting grocery bags, "mask-debators", toilet paper shortages and the like. Sometimes it's good to laugh at tragedy. Details: Reserve seats on the theater's website and pick up tickets at the box office up to an hour before curtain time. Very tight leg room and narrow seating with protruding cupholders made us happy it was a short play! As of mid-March the Red Barn was still asking for vaccine cards and masks despite the fact that Florida doesn't require them.