i have never written a review because i am simply not that person, however , this place was divine…read more our wait time was 30 minutes and we got seated in 5. The service was that of a fine dining restaurant with the FOH staff going above and beyond. You can tell they genuinely enjoy their position. The food was extremely delicious and portions were huge. if the price scares you away, then please reconsider as its 100000% worth it . The ingredients in both the pizza & pasta were incredibly fresh and you could taste the quality. BOH really knows how to cook!!!! My only dislike was I live 4 hours away from this place and cant go at least once a week! The restaurant was cute and ambiance was very chill and music wasn't too loud so you could hear your party. I will miss this place! Please come to phoenix!!!!

I am not sure why this place is so busy. We had to wait for about 30 minutes to get a table since…read morethey don't take reservations. While the place is lovely, the servers are clueless and we had a few of them come up during our dinner. I asked if there is any pasta made in house and she said she did not know so I asked if she could check with the kitchen. Turned out they make cannelloni and ravioli in house. They were out of cannelloni so we ordered ravioli and veal Parmesan. Veal Parmesan was too breaded and spaghetti and marina were simply not tasty. Ravioli on the other hand were very good. The Caesar salad was not worth the upgrade since the lettuce were somewhat wilted.

Solid to-go sandwich for lunch…read more Pastrami. And the bread was fresh and delicious First visit and I recommend, next time will be pizza and beers on the patio!

Look, from all the high ratings and positive reviews came I, who unfortunately followed the…read morepopularity of this restaurant and turned up to be a bad dinner. I ordered the Spicy Meatball pizza, and while the dough was fresh, it was extremely salty and hard. The sauce and cheese were no better, being just as salty and very artificial. The "spicy meatballs" were just weird-tasting meatballs with a ton of chili flakes, not spicy meatballs. It was very cheap in quality but expensive in price. I do not recommend anyone who loves pizza to get this one. People always say the service is fast, but I had lazy service. What I mean is that you have to go up and do everything yourself except for the cooking. I almost was charged for an extra cheese pizza that I didn't order. It took about 30 minutes for this ~8 inch pizza, which wasn't that bad. But everything was just slow and there were some times where things were really busy. The restaurant itself was okay. Although it doesn't make up for the 3/10 meal, it was cushy but there were places that were pretty dirty. It's more interesting than actually good, but the booths were a little nice. Overall, I do not recommend this place. Take your business somewhere else, because I will most likely never come back to Pitalian. Sorry.

I can't say enough amazing things about this place. I tell everyone I talk to about their subs and…read morecannolis. With family living in Pinetop and us visiting multiple times a year, I honestly don't know how we didn't discover it sooner, but now it's a must every time we come up, without fail. I split the meatball sub with my husband, and I'm so glad I did because it was huge. Even my half had four HUGE meatballs, and they were hands down the best I've ever had. The sauce, the bread, my goodness, my mouth is watering just writing this review. I bought four cannolis to share, and while I'm glad I did, selfishly I could've eaten them all myself. Best cannolis EVER, don't try to tell me otherwise. The cupcakes were delicious, and the turkey sub was also so, so good. On top of everything, they even give you a bag of chips with each sub. The hours are limited, and you definitely need to get there early for the hot subs. If you go to Pinetop and don't try this place, you're crazy.

This was AMAZING!!!!!! Loved the chips options we got to choose from too! Fully loaded hoagies…read morethat'll leave you extremely satisfied. 12/10 would return again asap!

The service was great, very friendly, helpful. The food was Very good- spaghetti and meatballs,…read morewith a side salad and garlic bread. Dessert was bananas foster and was absolutely delish. this was the 2nd time we ate here--when traveling through town.... we would go again! Great food great place great people! worth the stop!

Great unexpected Italian food (we enjoyed the pasta dishes very much) BUT do NOT trust the gluten…read morefree pasta! (GF kid was truly sick later.) I am vegan and loved the pasta pomodoro. It was fresh and flavorful and satisfying. My partner had the chicken Jerusalem and seemed pretty blissful. Our other kid enjoyed the manicotti and cheese sticks. The restaurant is attached to a sports bar but don't let that stop you from enjoying this. As long as you don't have Celiac!

After a long ski day at Sunrise Ski Resort, we headed back to our cabin and needed to feed 28…read morehungry people -- kids, adults, picky eaters, the whole crew. Red Devil Pizza came THROUGH. We needed something quick and delicious, and they absolutely delivered. The ordering process was easy, the food was ready fast, and everything was hot and fresh. First of all -- shoutout to them for offering a cauliflower crust. That was perfect for our crew members with dietary restrictions, and it was actually GOOD (not cardboard pretending to be pizza). We went with Meal Lovers and all I can say is Chef's kiss for anyone wanting all the flavor without the traditional crust. The kids devoured the classic cheese and pepperoni. Zero leftovers on those. The veggie pizza had great flavor, variety and didn't feel skimpy on toppings. The boneless wings were solid too -- the Mild was kid-friendly, and the Honey Hot had just enough kick to keep the adults happy. When you're feeding 28 people after skiing, you need reliable. You need fast. You need crowd-pleasing. Red Devil checked all the boxes.

This place is our go-to Italian spot in AZ. Have been to the ones in the valley many times but…read morefirst time up here in Pinetop and it did not disappoint. Our server was very friendly and food came out fresh and quickly. I went with something different this time with the chicken cacciatore and it was delicious! They have a great red sauce here. Great job to the team here!

This is a classic cheap pizza spot, is it the greatest pizza? Absolutely not, but did it hit the…read morespot? Yes. We got 4 slices of pizza and two drinks for $18, a great deal.

Great hometown pizza joint. Friendly service on the phone and at the restaurant. The veggies and…read moretoppings at the salad bar could've been a bit fresher looking, but there was a ton of variety which I love

Friendly service and yummy food. Their burgers are quite delicious and a great price point. 10/10…read morewould return.

Very casual place to grab dinner. My lemon basil pasta arrived luke warm but it had great…read morecombination of flavors. The grilled chicken sandwich and the coleslaw we perfect. The service was kinda slow but we were in no hurry.

Have enjoyed this establishment twice. Both times the antipasto salad was fresh and tasty. The…read morevinaigrette dressing is perfect. The pizza was perfect. It had great crust with lots of toppings. YUMMY Service was fine. Nothing to complain about. This has become our favorite pizza place on the mountain. Highly recommend.

Spending all day in town. We didn't want to go out and eat. So, we ordered Pizza Factory.... We had…read morethe large pizza with pepperoni, black olives, and sausage and fresh artichokes.. and a side of wings... We picked it up. Friendly ppl working and the pizza and wings and a Greek ..were really good. If you are ever too tired to roll out after a long day. I would recommend Pizza Factory.. and a reasonable price...

Friendly service! Awesome menu. So many things looked great hard to only choose 1 sandwich…read more 100% I'll go back.

Simply the best! And not just for Lakeside or Pinetop-Lakeside or the mountain! Also fresh…read morecannoli, Italian Cream sodas, soups etc etc. I love this place

Absolutely phenomenal the best spaghetti I've ever had, I will be coming back all the time. Super…read morenice and friendly staff, it's a great place to eat. It's a nice interior that fits the atmosphere of the restaurant. Come here

Keep driving... stale pasta stale bread old meatballs. Two tables inside.. took it home and threw…read moremost of it out. I hope we survive the night...