Waste of damn $20. The fries were soggy. On arrival 10 minutes after my message said it was done, they said it's only just going in the oven. read more

Ambiance is decent nothing special about this place. Little to no pieces of ham, pepperoni or salami in the calzone. Full of ricotta cheese. Curly fries were soggy not crispy. And expensive. Flavor is not bad just needs more ingredients as advertised for better flavor. Staff is nice though! read more

I found the beer selection not impressive. The menu is a lil confusing because it's supposed to change screens yet it doesn't so you have to ask whats the other options. Its was the young lady's first day so that made for an interesting ordering process. I went with basic hot wings and blue cheese. If your one of them I dont eat spicy foods people, you're in luck. The wings were just tangy bbq sauce. Not cooked enough since they are not fried wings. They tasted good tho. Just not what Im expecting when you say buffalo or hot wings. If Im hungry in the middle of the night Ill choose something else. read more

Calzones came out in a decent amount of time. Mine was watery since the mushrooms and spinach were not precooked. No sauce in the calzone, loads of cheese, but I was hungry so it tasted okay. Someone in our group complained that theirs was not great and very salty. The seats are ripped to hell. For the cost of the food, they can afford to get the seats reupholstered. Even the duct tape holding the ripped vinyl had given up. That was yesterday. I have spent the better portion of today with the most godawful stomach cramps and now someone else in yesterday's group is starting to mention their stomach acting up too. Save your money and a wasted day between the bed and the toilet. Y'all make one product, do better. read more

Terrible! 17 dollars for a burnt piece of bread and cheese when I ordered a chicken bacon ranch calzone. There was one piece of chicken, no bacon and way too much ranch. More ranch than cheese. Waited 25 minutes in their empty restaurant (as it should be) too! Do not go here unless you are drunk out of your mind and there are literally zero other late night food places open. read more

This place has extremely unique calzone options which I thought was so amazing! I ended up going with the Mac n cheese calzone, which was average compared to other Mac n cheese pizza that I have had at other places. I think if I would have tried their other options I would have really enjoyed my meal. The marinara sauce for the pizza tasted great, so I would recommend getting one with red sauce. The staff did warn us that it would be 40 min wait, but I was still shocked by that for one calzone for carryout. Typical fast casual college restaurant environment. I would come back in the future to try the other options!! read more

Eddie's Calzones - Mac n Mac & Cheese Calzone - Food Delivery Services Near Me - Athens, Georgia

Did not respect a valid Buy-One-Get-One-Free coupon. I got the coupon from The Little Coupon Book, which can be found in various Athens establishments. After attempting to use it, Eddies initially charged me $27 for two calzones. I questioned this price, and they rudely told me that the coupon had been applied and that they were not mistaken. I responded, telling them that I was unaware that they sold $27 calzones, pointing at the menu. Eddies then gave me a nonsensical response, in which they essentially claimed the coupon was "misprinted". This business will take every opportunity to take advantage of and rip off their customers. read more

For a non-NY calzone place, it is decent. Definitely not the beat, but decent. Atmosphere: the location is perfectly located on the main Athens area. The inside is very relaxing, inviting, and thr employee always welcoming. The food: while basic, not the best, it is good value for what you get. The people: amazing is an understatement! The two females working were both adventurous, energetic, and welcoming. I look forward to returning. read more

I bought some items and tipped - crooks added the tips again !! It's only a small amount each time but they are likely doing this to everyone who pays by credit card. Crooks !! read more

BEST CALZONES EVER! I recommend the buffalo chicken calzone. The staff is so nice and friendly too! read more

Eddie's Calzones - Buffalo Chicken Calzone - Food Delivery Services Near Me - Athens, Georgia

My boyfriend and I came to athens for the botanical garden lights, but time we got done looking at the lights it was kind of late where everything were closing up. Eddie's was the only thing open nearby, so we went in and they cooked our calzone fresh. I ordered the chicken bacon ranch calzone, and my boyfriend ordered the meat calzone. The meat calzone was incredibly good! I had to order myself a meat calzone to-go because it was that good, but instead they gave it to me for free! I'm not sure why other people got horrible reviews on Eddie's but my experience was amazing. The customer service was incredible also. My boyfriend and I are making it tradition to go to the botanical garden and Eddie's right after every year around Christmas time now. read more

We ordered our calzones on UberEats. It said our food was ready so I went to the pickup area and gave the owner my name and he said it was in the oven. 30 minutes later it still wasn't ready. I asked him about it and he snapped back and said it was busy. I said you told me it was in the oven a half hour ago and he rolled his eyes and walked away. 30 minutes later I was still waiting on my food and he was ignoring me whenever I tried to get his attention. My food didn't come out for another 15 minutes. Other people we were with said this is not an isolated incident, but how he acts on a daily basis. Go to DP Dough instead read more

They got my order wrong so I tried to get it corrected and they got it wrong again. Very disappointing I was really expecting them to get it right the second time. read more

Honestly the worst service I have ever received. The person in front of me in line got their food in 25 minutes. It took an additional 45 minutes for me to get my food, and I'm pretty sure the only reason I ended up getting my food was because I kept asking the worker where my order was. So after waiting 70 minutes to get my food, my order was wrong. I ordered tots with bacon and cheese on them. There was no bacon. I also ordered some ranch. There was no ranch. If I could give negative stars, I would. That is how truly awful this place is. Save yourself the trouble and spend your money somewhere else. P.S. the restaurant is SUPER hot and pretty filthy UPDATE: In response to Edward's comment below, I would like to add that it was NEVER explained that someone took my order. I am not sure if this is an excuse or if someone actually did take my order. Either way, there was zero communication. Also it was not gameday. It was Friday night... read more

Great post Athens nighttime scene downtown snack! Went to a wonderful concert and ate wonderful food after! Delish! - might not be super authentic but i feel like it's more of a "post-game" meal/snack read more

This place turned my friends and I away on a weekend because they were "out of dough" what a measly excuse of a business below 0 starts #scummy. read more

Eric is one of the best business owners I've encountered in my 4 years in Athens. He is working his butt off every time I've ever had the pleasure of coming to eddie's calzones. He works 7 days a week to provide the best possible experience to customers and puts more effort into making sure everyone has a satisfactory experience while being the greatest person I've ever met. Tammy is also one of the sweetest employees who goes above and beyond in enhancing the already amazing experience. If you ever have to get some late night food in Athens this eddies is the place to go!!! read more

We had a 50% off coupon that the manager didn't apply. I noticed after we already paid. So I told the manager and he tried to deny it saying it did apply but he was lyinggg. Why administer coupons if you're not going to honor them? read more

Calzones are gas but there was a rat trap right under our booth we were eating at lol like at least try to hide it? Kinda nasty read more

Eddie's Calzones - a wooden table and chair - Food Delivery Services Near Me - Athens, Georgia

I went there tonight for the first time, I'm giving three stars really based on the service alone. They were very helpful and informative, telling me the calzone I ordered would take a little longer because of the ingredients I ordered. Long story short, the customer service was great. However, I have to take two stars off for just the quality of the calzone. It was small and really salty, and the ingredients I ordered (pepperoni sausage and jalapeños) really tasted generic. The tater tots I ordered were pretty good but, again, generic. If you are starving or desperately need some food after drinking downtown all night, this would be a good place to go. Otherwise, go to Mellow Mushroom for a calzone. read more

The calzone was great. They only had one employee working for lunch and she did a fantastic job. The health rating is 83B. That is clearly the fault of the owner for having poor management skills. The employee I saw today was very clean. She drives from Atlanta and should get paid more. Average calzone is around 9 dollars. I had to give 3 stars because of the health rating. Really it needs to be improved, but clearly the owner is not managing all the employees. If the health rating drops below 80 I would suggest not eating here. I suggest everyone check the health rating before you order. The food was great. I would suggest the owner get the girl who worked today to manage the employees on the evening shift some. She knew what she was doing. And she was very clean. Something that the other employees clearly must not be too much of with a health rating of 83. They stay open until 4am. read more

See all

Eddie's used to be really good but today was not. Poor calzone with no cheese and cold marinara sauce. Better luck next time

The calzones were over priced and mine came out with undercooked cheese, raw dough, and cold sauce. it was also insanely hot in there and the service was terrible. don't come here ever, just go to little italy. read more

This is actually the worst calzone I've ever had. I'm 19 years old and I'm leaving a yelp review, if that says anything about how bad it really was. The dough was raw and tasted extremely old, the sauce I got was literally freezing cold, the ingredients were just not good at all, and was served on a paper plate. And to top it all off, it was a $15 calzone, with $2 for a water bottle. Very disappointing, and I don't plan on ever going back here. read more

The mozzarella sticks were amazing. The ranch was high quality and the pull factor of the cheese on the stick was high. After our meal, we went to the bathroom right after an unidentified character decided to vomit in the hallway. Your employee Tammy was wonderful to us. Some people are rude and disrespectful when there is vomit on the floor but Tammy was kind and thoughtful and made sure we did not step in the mess. She was very careful asking us to step around and did an amazing job cleaning up whatever was done. We left with a very good feeling about Eddie's. Thank you for this positive experience. read more

I'll give them credit for variety, but you can have 40 calzones on the menu and if none of them are worth getting again, why bother? We came in on a weekday night during winter break with a big group of 9 people. It looked like there was only one guy working, he took all our orders and we sat down to wait for our food. I ordered a basket of fries and one of tots so we'd have something to snack on while waiting for our orders. Everyone got their calzones one by one, he gave mine to one of my friends by mistake (luckily he noticed because his was supposed to be BBQ and I got Chicken Cordon Bleu). Eventually we all had our orders and were eating and no fries or tots. Everyone finished or decided to stop and take the rest home, so I was just about to get up and ask about canceling the fries and tots since we were ready to leave, when he brought them out. I'm going to go out on a limb here and figure Athens just doesn't get the concept of appetizers because that happened to me at Fuzzy's tacos as well. As for the taste of the food, no one was raving about their calzone, myself included. It was well cooked and generously stuffed with cheese, but the quality of the ingredients was lacking. The chicken in mine was pre-cooked and sliced (like the stuff you get in grocery stores in the lunchmeat section), the ham was chunks of boiled processed ham, the cheese was nothing special. The marinara for dipping was SUPER sweet, which yes some people like that but not me. Also odd was that they only had bottled or canned beverages, no fountain, and no ice. So cups of water were extremely awkward to request and obviously no refills. Finally, I have to mention their staffing issue. After we ordered, another guy came in to work and from what I could overhear, they got into a fight about the first guy (we'll call him supervisor) asking him to do something. Employee 2 was half-yelling at Supervisor for telling him how to do something, saying he'll get around to it and do it his way. Eventually, Employee 2 walked out. A customer who seemed to be a regular or a friend of Supervisor came in a bit later and Supervisor started ranting to him about Employee 2, even getting his cell phone to show the friend what Employee 2 apparently texted him. This exchange doesn't give me high hopes for this place, and I definitely wouldn't come back if I'm in the area again. But I guess it's a good spot for late night in a college town...although $9 for what you get isn't exactly cheap. read more

Parking isn't the best situation at the moment but as far as I'm concerned what I ordered was fantastic, I ordered the chicken & bacon calzone and the mozzarella sticks they were absolutely delicious 10/10 would definitely recommend and would go there again read more

This was my first time visiting and eating from Eddie's Calzones. I was going to go somewhere else and get a salad or something, but as I walked past Eddie's I was felt a force take control of me and heard the gentle whisper of my dark side tell me "... forget the diet. Treat yourself..." I wasn't up for a debate, so I obliged. I walked in around 12:30 lunch time and found the restaurant completely empty. No people eating, no one at the register, and all of the chairs up on the table. I wondered if they weren't open yet or maybe remodeling. But no, after a few seconds a guy came from the back of the restaurant and took his post at the register just as I was about to leave. This guy at the register gave off massive ex-con vibes. Don't get me wrong, he wasn't bad or anything, he just wasn't entirely sure how to be friendly. Again, not rude at all, I wouldn't want him fired, but I could see how some people might be rubbed the wrong way. If customer service were a river, Chick-fil-A would be the salmon jumping over waterfalls and this guy would be floating down the river with a beer in one hand and a cigarette in the other. But anyway... I was so taken aback by the lack of customers, wondering if it was actually open, and wondering if my cashier had ever smiled past the age of 15 that I felt rushed looking at the menu overhead. I ordered a pesto calzone in my rush, because it was the first thing on the menu that I read. He asked me "for here or to go?" I looked around at all the chairs on the tables. "uh. To go." I gave him my name, paid, and sat down in a booth to wait for my order. He disappeared again. I guess he was also the cook. Huh. Luckily the wait wasn't long at all, and he called out my name to the empty restaurant. I don't know why I felt the need to say "oh, that's me!" as I got up, but I did. I am not proud. He handed me a plastic bag that held a Styrofoam container. I set out in search of a good spot to eat the calzone and eventually wandered onto campus and sat down under a shady tree. I popped open the Styrofoam and looked at that glorious calzone. It's big. And thick. On the side was a small container of marinara. I dug around in the bag for my plastic cutlery but there was none. Oh. I briefly debated going back to grab some cutlery but decided my hands were fine utensils just as long as the calzone wasn't too hot. So I picked that bad boy up with both hands and ate it like the Khaleesi biting into a heart on Game of Thrones. Immediately I thought "wow, Eddie does NOT go shy on the cheese." and I stick by that. That calzone was super cheesy. Easily a block and a half of cheese in there. My second thought was "is it raining?" because I felt droplets of wetness gather on my pants and shirt. But no, it was not raining. Grease was falling from the calzone and onto my clothes with every bite. I put the plastic bag over my lap to prevent further garment ruining, and continued on. Grease was dripping from my chin. Grease was dripping from both elbows. A small pool of grease had gathered above my upper lip and eventually made it inside my nose. "This is what you signed up for, you fool. This is what you get when you break your diet." I thought. But I kept eating. Damn, it was delicious. When I say that this was greasy, I mean that when I finally finished eating the whole calzone and looked at the Styrofoam box to prepare to toss it in the trash there was enough orange grease floating around there to easily drown a toddler or two. I went to grab the napkins from the bag to clean my, er, all of me, but just like the cutlery there were none. And I was soaked with grease. I struggled to pick up my cell phone and purse without transferring grease to them, but it was no use. They also got soaked. I tossed away my trash and immediately went into the closest building on campus covered in grease and marinara. The woman inside thought I was a student on tour, but immediately realized I was not when she saw marinara dripping from my face and I just yelped out "RESTROOM!" She pointed left in horror, and I rushed off. After roughly 20 or so paper towels and all the foam soap that dispenser could muster, I was finally clean. I snuck out past the woman who had greeted me and made the walk of shame back to the office. That night I woke up pleading with my body not to purge. I knew I had made a mistake and begged my gastrointestinal organs to just let me off with a warning. Unfortunately, they showed no such mercy. - TL;DR Service is strange. Food is delicious but greasy and I could feel my arteries clogging. Wear an apron and maybe some gloves. Be cautious if you don't have an iron stomach. read more

Very good. Cal zones are very good if you are hungry. Wait wasn't too long. Food is served in a plastic container and you need to remember to grab silverware. Overall very good read more

Okay... so who ever was working late night Saturday November 23rd deserves a promotion. They made the most fire Mac and cheese calzone. Applause for this man or woman. Thank you for making my night. read more

Tried to order again after 10 months and still did not receive my calzone in a timely manner . Very disappointed .....

Amazing food,great service,large amount of wings for 50 cents,great prices,and ran by great people

I mean, it's a greasy calzone place downtown. It seems like some people have gone in expecting way too much. For what it is, it's not terrible. I will agree that the environment is pretty grody, but let me reiterate, it's a downtown, drunk food place, not a gourmet place. *In reference to Eddie's comment: I don't literally mean greasy, I meant more of a figurative greasy vibe. read more

So good!!! I'm normally not a calzone fan because they tend to have too much dough and not enough filling. Eddies are the prefect amount of dough with plenty of delicious fillings! My go-to for a calzone in Athens! ETA: we ordered through Bulldawg food.:) read more

Their calzones are overpriced and greasy, and this chain is also sexist. On their website, they have a statement that says "So, picture this: it's late, you're hungry, and your girlfriend doesn't want to make you a sandwich" It is 2019!! What were you thinking? read more

This place is terrible now. I've been coming here for 4 years, literally every night after bars. Eddie used to be in the front taking orders. Now you can order one of like 4 old pre-made calzones OR wait 40 minutes for your choice. WHAT THE HECK?! I'm shocked. I get that they are busy but I have been coming and ordering custom orders and waiting 15-20 minutes for years!!! Just goes to show you how much of a chain this is rather than a local business. Shame on you Eddie and shame on your employees. Eddie come back and treat your customers right. read more

I ate one of their free calzones. I'm glad it was free. Someone else said a glorified hot pocket. That's a good description. There was little in the way of chicken or bacon in the calzone, mostly just rather bland cheese. And dough. So much dough. They really should bake their calzones longer, because they are doughy and it's not all that appealing. Outside of the free event they cost $8.25 per calzone. That's probably about twice as expensive as they should be given the quality of the calzone. Quite honestly, why would anyone come here when they could go to Mellow Mushroom or Transmet and have a better meal? Unless it's free, that is. read more

I would have to say this place was good. All the calzone we got was delicious: the omelette, chicken pesto and phillycheese steak. Service was good too, everyone was nice and our food was brought out soon too. Of course we went around 11pm. read more

Eddie's Calzones - Menu - Food Delivery Services Near Me - Athens, Georgia

See all

After giving this place 3 chances since it opened, I'm giving up. For a restaurant that specializes in calzones, I'm just not impressed. The calzones are not great but not terrible either. I'd rather get one from Mellow which says a lot because I try hard not to frequent chain restaurants. Also, no fountain drink machine? Just lol. What puts me off the most is the service. Eddie's has easily the worst service of any restaurant I've frequented in this town. The employees I've dealt with have been short and rude over the phone and equally as bad in person. No one has been the least bit pleasant any of the times I've been here. Eddie's has potential but for now I'm only awarding two stars. TL;DR: ok food, service leaves much to be desired. read more

Super oily, but maybe that's just the way of the calzone? Impressive selection, they are very creative with the variety of different calzones. Kind of weird they have out everything in to go boxes. But in the end half of my group couldn't finish their calzones, so it made sense for them. Went for the Buffalo burger with blue cheese. Was pretty tasty, just felt like I needed a shower after. read more

Eddie's Calzones - Interior order counter - Food Delivery Services Near Me - Athens, Georgia