If you need a good trustworthy jeweler ,look no further. Everyone here is so nice and knowledgeable. I don't know why I didn't come here years ago. Came here about a month ago because I had a chain that I went to my regular jeweler to have the lobster claw clasp replaced because it was loose. The first time I wore it I lost my amethyst pendant from it when I went back I was told it's fine you must not have closed it correctly. I had an amethyst earring that I wanted to make into a pendant to make up for the one that I had lost so I took it to Edward Warren and I also showed them the chain and the jeweler said that it was loose that I should take it back, and she also showed it to another jeweler there, who said the same thing. The only way the other jeweler agreed to replace it with because I told him to other jeweler said it was a bad class, and I decided that he was never going to get my business again and then I needed some other repairs and things done and I went back two more times, so I definitely recommend them they do good work. They are very reasonable. I'm not in the market to really buy new jewelry but they have some beautiful, beautiful jewelry and I'm sure they do custom work too read more

The professionalism. The pleasantness. The efficiency. The pricing. Will go there again.

A jeweler who has become part of our story. It's hard to put into words what Edward Warren Jewelers has meant to us over the years. From the moment my engagement ring was designed, to adding my wedding band, to now handcrafting my three-year anniversary band... every single experience has been filled with kindness, care, and unmatched craftsmanship. What makes this place extraordinary is not just the jewelry--it's Edward himself. He remembers your name. He remembers your story. He treats you as if your piece is the most important one he's ever made. In a world full of commercial jewelers and rushed transactions, he gives you something rare: time, attention, honesty, and heart. Every ring he's crafted for me holds a memory, a moment, and a feeling... and somehow, he makes each new addition even more beautiful than the last. The diamonds... the quality... the artistry... nothing compares. People think going to a real jeweler means paying more, but the truth is you will not find this level of quality at these prices anywhere else. His work is exceptional, yet still accessible. Choosing Edward Warren wasn't just a purchase--it was one of the best decisions we made for our life together. He's become a part of our milestones, our celebrations, and our story. And for that, I'm forever grateful. If you want more than a ring--if you want a piece of art created with intention, passion, and genuine care--you deserve to experience this place. Truly unforgettable. read more

Edward Warren Jewelers - Jewelry Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

This place is Awesome!! Cory gave me a hand repairing a Cross and Chain my daughter got me 17 years ago and he did a great job. Then me and my wife took a look at some Bigger Diamond's and decided to Upgrade her engagement ring to a .65 carat Beauty. Can't wait to pick it up next week. She deserves even Bigger but would not let me lol read more

Lovely custom design ring made! Great staff, very helpful and knowledgeable. Nice to shop a small business! read more

Edward Warren Jewelers - Custom ring - Jewelry Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

See all

Cory was great! I needed help with a watch band that was too large and ceased having difficulty keeping the clasp closed. Cory spend time sizing it for me and showing me how to close it properly. Thank you for your time! You were very patient and kind! I appreciate your help! read more

Can't say enough about the wonderful people and excellent inventory at Edward Warren Jewelers in Pickerington. Last Friday (7/7/23) my wife and I visited EWJ. I was wowed by Warren's depth of knowledge, creativity, ingenuity, quality of product, and most of all his patient demeanor as he thoroughly answered our every question. We highly recommend Edward Warren Jewelers. read more

This is one of our favorite jewelry places in all of Columbus. All of the staff are super friendly and have the most knowledge that I've experienced. Their prices are better than most and they stand by their work 100%. We brought in a couple of necklaces for repair and the prices were very fair for the work that needed to be done. This is definitely the place to go if you are looking for something nice for anyone. Rings, necklaces, custom made jewelry, and unique pieces are all over the store. You won't be disappointed with a visit! read more

Funny story about how Edward Warren Jewelers saved me from myself! Today I took my my wedding band, engagement ring, and my mothers ring to their establishment hoping they would be able to help me with my issue. About one week ago I went to clean all of my rings which are solid yellow gold. I put them in the same jewelry cleaner as always which was blue in color and I was unable to see the bottom so I just dropped the rings in and walked away. When I went to take them out about 4 hours later, I found a pair of earrings my daughter put in there two months ago and forgotten about them. Her earrings were sterling silver and the gold cleaner broke down the metal and there was what looked like chunks of rust at the bottom of the ring tray. Needless to say when I pulled out my rings they looked tarnished beyond belief. I immediately tried scrubbing them and could not get out the tarnished rust look. I then decided to take my rings to edward warren jewelers. Panicking I asked if they were able to clean them to try and remove the tarnish that got on them from the broken down earrings. The manager of the store took the rings to the back and assured me he could fix my rings. He brought my rings back out to me 5 minutes later looking BRAND NEW!!!!! It was such a relief. I truly wondered if I had ruined thousands of dollars in gold jewelry. Thank god for Edward Warren Jewelers who were so efficient in helping me restore my beautiful rings! I walked out with 10 tons lifted off of my chest! Thank you guys so much! read more

My wife's pearl necklace needed the clasp to be repaired. We took it to another place first. They were unaccomodating, weren't sure what was needed (might need restringing?), and wanted us to leave it so they could repair. We are cautious people and didn't trust the situation. We decided to try Edward Warren Jewelers. Hopefully, they could help. We walked in and were greeted immediately. The young man (who I am sure is a family member) came over and we explained the problem. He took a look and we said, "does it need restringing?" and he said "no, no need, I think I can correct this right now". He separated one part of the clasp and expanded another part, with his hands, lo and behold, the clasp was fixed. We asked him how much we could pay for this and he said, "no payment, on the house". This jeweler is clearly honorable. Whenever we need or want anything to do with jewelry, we will be going to Edward Warren. So happy to have found such a good business right in our area. read more

My wife took the invicta that my father bought me for Father's Day to this store because it was referred to us by a friend. My watch was much too large and I needed some links taken out. They seamlessly fixed my issue in a quick manner and they were so kind! Will be bringing my business back here for more service in the future! read more

Edward Warren Jewelers - Jewelry Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

My pearl necklace.., I have taken in to this jeweler 3 times to have the clasp fixed. The clasp would just undo itself and the necklace would slip off Last time, the lady removed at least two pearls on each side . Yes, so far , it doesn't come undone. But where did my pearls go? I thought I liked this jeweler, now not so much read more

Handed a watch down to my son. Went to see them maybe 15 minutes before they closed. They repaired the band, resized it, put a new battery in it, and cleaned it quickly. The jeweler could tell the watch was special and focused on my son and understood the significance of my son receiving the watch. Great customer service and he sold a young man as a future customer read more

Off 256 in Pickerington is the best little jewelry store you'll find. Warren took my great-grandmother's antique ring setting, restored it, and added new diamonds for my fiance to pop the question, and he did all this for a very affordable price. The customer service is amazing, as well as the quality work. read more

Honestly you just don't see small businesses like this anymore...I will always drive 10 minutes further to deal with real people like this than expendable mall staff that don't care about you at all...and just count down the minutes until they get to go home... Warren has always taken care of me like I was the most important customer they have...yet I never can afford to spend more than $500 at any time...I still manage to come home to my wife, or my parents or even my daughter with an incredible gift...sometimes for even $200.... And they follow up with me....it really just blows my mind..this guy has like 40 years experience in the industry and he can't even be 60 years old...I've been in the store when he and his staff have been helping first time buyers (nervous young men) and they're so kind them...it was really nice to see. Bottom line, if you have a specific jewelry request or just want to be treated with respect no matter what your budget is....this is where you go...you don't waste time at a mall getting treated like crud....I am a customer for life. -Dan K. read more

I hate jewelry stores and jewelry, but my wife enjoys them. I met these SUPER TERRIFIC people because I had gone to many other places. This is the only jewelry store that I have ever felt good about. They are just the best. read more

I have went to see Warren since shopping for my wedding band, I wish I would have saw him for our engagement ring. He has always been great to me and excellent service. When my center stone went missing and needed replacement he found me a better diamond at a great price and even fixed the prong setting to ensure this one never goes missing! I am coming from the DC area to work on a custom special piece with him because EWJ is the only jeweler I trust. read more

Getting engaged is one of those things that must absolutely go perfectly - there is no room for anything less. I couldn't more highly recommend Edward Warren Jewelers to help in your engagement mission - Warren and his team are 100% 1st class in everything they do, from easing your overall nerves to delivering a phenomenal product that meets your needs - whatever they may be. I met Warren several years ago and recalled his passion for the jewelry business when considering my options for exploring engagement rings - it was a no brainer to go visit his store in Pickerington. Warren not only pinpointed a high quality ring that my fiancée adores - but he helped me with my questions and worked to meet my budget. There was no pressure or urgency on his part - just fundamental customer service to address all areas of concern or confusion. Warren's fine jewelry collection also features special pieces that are ideal for other special holidays too - not just weddings. It is a little bit of an effort to get to his location but once you are there you'll be happy about the hidden gem you found. read more

I purchased a special-order titanium men's wedding band here years ago. As it turned out, the wedding never happened thanks to a class act jerk suffering from "I can't keep my dick in my pants syndrome." Fast forward to 2009 - I was planning my wedding to my now husband, and needed a wedding band. I wouldn't dare use the ring I still had (tried to sell that thing on Ebay, Craigslist, and everywhere else) so when we went to EWJ to look for a new one, I just threw the idea out there. I explained what had happened and didn't have to get past, I was engaged before, and Warren offered to buy it back for what I paid for it on 2004. I got the ring off my hands, got a new and totally different ring for my husband and did not lose one red cent of my money. read more

I have purchased multiple gifts from Warren and Cory over the years and I willing drive from Columbus because I know I am guaranteed quality Jewelry and incredible service. I know very little when it comes to Jewelry so I really depend on them for advice. I have never once felt uncomfortable or like they were up-selling me. If you want a great selection and impeccable service... make the drive to Pickerington and visit Warren and Cory. read more

My husband and I went to EWJ for the first time to design a custom ring for me on Mother's Day. The associate was very kind, showed us a variety of designs and said she would call us the following week. A week passed with no communication, so I called her. She said she was still working on it and would call me in a few days. Again, a week later and no communication. read more

I went in with 3 sentimental rings and an idea. I walked out yesterday with a BEAUTIFUL unique wedding set! I am SO impressed with how friendly, patient and creative everyone was. They treated me like family from moment one and were genuinely happy for me. I was absolutely speechless seeing their creation! They've earned a customer for life! read more

This store has a special place in my heart because my husband picked out my engagement ring here! I absolutely love my ring and the customer service is great too! I can't say enough good things about this place and it's all because of Warren! He's the nicest guy and super helpful. It seems like he really cares about his customers and does everything in his power to make you happy with your purchase! I've been back a couple times and it's nice that he remembers me and my husband. I would recommend going to this place for all your jewelry needs. It's pretty far out east in Pickerington, but well worth the drive! read more

My husband bought my engagement ring here. I was able to wear it for a few years and then the diamond fell out. Luckily, I found the stone and put everything in a baggy to take up there to get repaired. What I was told was that it would cost me $200-250 to get it fixed and there is no guarantee it wouldn't happen again. In fact, they told me it would definitely happen again due to the setting and I would have to bring it back in every few years to have it fixed. I walked out and refuse to go back. Why would I want to wear a ring that I'll constantly have to worry about the stone falling out? Extremely upset with this place. read more

Best jewelry store you can go to! Everyone is great, they have beautiful jewelry and they are not pushy sales people like you get at some stores. They take good care of their customers and know what their talking about. I have gone there for years and have them take care of all my jewelry needs. They even cut a 2 rings off my finger that were swollen and saved me a trip to the hospital! Great store! read more

Edward Warren Jewelers is the only jeweler I will give my business to! I came into the store looking for the perfect ring to show my girlfriend (now wife) exactly how much she meant to me and be a stunning ring that stood out from all the rings that are commonly posted on Facebook with the caption "I said YES!" Working with Cory was an absolute pleasure as he took the time to not only assist me in finding this perfect ring, but he also spent time educating me on each stone we looked at and each setting. This process was quick and painless as we looked at the wide variety of individual stones and settings they could be placed in. The end result was a ring that was so much more than I ever could have imagined! My wife gets compliments on her beautiful ring on an almost daily basis from complete strangers, and it is a timeless piece of jewelry that is heirloom quality! The months passed and it came time to look at wedding bands, so I naturally returned to EWJ and once again was blown away by the level of customer service and personal attention we received. We were given many options to try on and pick what we liked, we did so and they were ordered on the spot. There was not a single problem in the entire process, and when I underestimated the my ring size, Cory was quick to get it sized up and ready for the big day! I have since returned and purchased watches, bracelets, etc. and every piece of jewelry I purchase is of the highest quality and a piece we will cherish for a lifetime. If you are ever in need of anything jewelry related I HIGHLY suggest you contact Edward Warren Jewelers and ask for Cory, if they don't have it already he will make sure to get you exactly what you want! read more

Edward Warren Jewelers - This photo was taken on our wedding day in May 2015. The staff at Edward Warren Jewelers was absolutely excellent! The rings are perfect! - Jewelry Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

My wedding set was causing snags to my sweaters and needed repair to the setting. My husband is a Firefighter and wears a chain with St. Florian and his clasp needed to be reattached. I took them both to this shop and was treated very well. Repairs were done for items and I thought the charges were fair. They were done in a timely manner and they even cleaned another item free of charge while I was there. I also sent an email to them prior to driving over there which was answered in a timely manner by the owner. I feel this shop has earned my respect and trust. I will return in the future and recommend to anyone who appreciates a good local jeweler. read more

I had to get some watch links/batteries, an old ring sized and find a gift for my GF... typical dude stuff of waiting till the sh+t piled a mile high before handling it. Cory, the manager took care of everything for me while I chilled at looked at potential gifts.He literally made me feel so welcomed, like I was about to spend $20,000 or something....they're just good ole fashioned good people in there. Anyways, after about 20 minutes I had my watch all fixed up for $20, the ring sized for free and I got my lady a great gift for $100 less than I was planning to spend. I've now utilized these guys twice, and couldn't be happier. read more

I was having a really hard time finding someone I could trust to repair my wedding set, until my daughter got engaged! Not only did Warren and his team create one of the most beautiful rings I've ever seen for her, but he offered to look at my ring to see if it could repaired. I can't express how grateful I am to this wonderful company for the care and thoughtfulness they put into the repair of my ring. Not only did they go way above and beyond what was expected, but they were incredibly timely and made a point of having it back to me before I left for vacation. The ring I received back looks unbelievably amazing (if possible, even better than new) and I can't wait to have them work on my wedding band. I can tell you I have found my jeweler! It's been a long time since I've received such great customer service....I won't be going anywhere else! read more

Took in a couple watches to be repaired, had them back to me earlier than they told me it might take, honest people, will be going back for any needs read more

I would not go anywhere else for jewelry. Not only do they have a wonderful selection, they are friendly and always stand behind anything they sell. I have purchased every one of my nice jewelry pieces here and have never been disappointed. I have also purchased several items for my husband. Highly recommend! read more

Awful. Went in to have my engagement ring sized down & was pleased because I was told it would be finished before I needed to leave the country. However, when I picked up the ring it was missing a stone on one side! They said since it was so small they "predicted" some stones would fall out.. Why wasn't I told this beforehand?! I left it there to be fixed but I am still confused as to how a jewelry store takes in an engagement ring & returns it to the customer without noticing one of the stones is missing.. After it was finished it was delivered to my house which was a appreciated but now I am overseas and today I noticed the area where the stone was replaced has turned BLUE! And after a closer look that side looks awful compared to the untouched side. The stones are dull and not in place. I couldn't be more disappointed. read more

I had my engagement ring resized here about 3 years ago. Couple months ago the resize job got a crack on the ring band and then couple days later the piece of platinum (if that's what they used to resize my ring) just fell off. My ring, which is a family heirloom, now has a chunk out of it. So I called the store and spoke with the owner and he was so rude. I told him the situation and he said " well I think 3 years is a long time for a resize to last" so I asked him if I should bring the ring in to look at and he said " well if you're asking for us to fix it for free...well NO!" I told him I don't know why he was bring rude all I did was ask a question and I don't think 3 years is a good amount of time for a sauder job to last when My moms resized rings have lasted decades! He proceeded to say "well just bring in the ring and ill look at it" YEA RIGHT! Even if he would fix it for free I would not give him the time of DAY or business ever again and I've passed on the word to all I can. read more