The best thing about Egger's Ice Cream Parlor on Forest Avenue is its historic presence at that location for over 90 years (1932). It is surely a community fixture with generations of families stopping by to celebrate the best things in their lives with homemade ice cream and an assortment of candy in dozens of glass jars along one wall. I admit to stopping in after an epic brunch at a nearby Greek diner, and to being too stuffed to dive into their flavors of the week 'screams. My friend was not as disciplined as I, so she ordered a cup of some chocolate peanut butter which she kvelled over. Apparently, they also had an orange long stringy confection that she wanted for later indulgence. All very cool, but she isn't diabetic. The ambiance of Egger's is definitely mid-twentieth century, and could use a fresh coat of paint to brighten the joint up a bit. Maybe better lighting, too. Otherwise, growing up in the City (Washington Heights) in the same era, this malt shop/candy emporium with long counter and spinners brought fond memories of my childhood flooding back. That, my friends, is always a very good moment. Four Sugary Super Sundae Stars. Those were the days! read more

Stopped in for a summer treat after a long day out hoping they wouldn't be too busy and I'm so happy we did. Egger's is a classic with a good variety and selection of flavors. They have the classic ice cream diner experience with candy, sweet treats, and counter with bar stools. It's well worth the price and the flavors are exceptionally tasty! read more

Egger's Ice Cream Parlor - Cherry Vanilla - Candy Stores Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Best place to get ice cream on Staten Island. The fudge , white cream, and peanut butter sauce is most likely homade and can not be replicated anywhere else. I miss the old set up it had with that big room. In need of an arcade machine as well . read more

Wouldn't recommend! Please don't support this business for their dishonesty and poor customer service. I've heard many negative things about this business from others as well. read more

Came here on one of the coldest nights. Love the interior. Service was quick and the staff were nice! The hot fudge here is really thick which I love. I recommend the choco choco chip ice cream!! Can't go wrong with this place. read more

See all

Best ice cream anywhere. Excellent quality ingredients. Adorable atmosphere with an old time feel.

Why was it so hot in there?!?? No AC ?? One dinky fan. Felt bad for workers Apparently it's always like this, read more

I have no idea how this place is still in operation but the management team needs a refresh. not only do they lie and deceit their hardworking girls but yelling and screaming at their workers infront of customers ? I do not condone mistreatment against workers who are underage ! UNDERAGE. an establishment that is suppose to be a nice family place where I feel safe to bring my friends and family to. I witness a mess from whoever the owner is towards the youth that work there there is NO ac in an ice cream shop? the workers are working in unfair conditions honestly I've never seen anything like this. Go to Ralph's at this point ! read more

I don't know what happen to this family run cozy feeling loving place, some of my fine child hood memories were made here. We walked in and were treated like homeless on line at a soup kitchen on thanksgiving . We might have sat. But after rudely being told menus are for dine in people only. Why would we want to stay . Sheesh I'm mad we even paid $50 for ice cream while people wouldn't even let us see a menu. Tuesday crew must of been the C team. Felt like we inconvenienced them with our business . So don't bother keep ur sprinkles. Put a cherry on that. read more

Always a delight to go to Egger's! I went in late October and took advantage of their pumpkin s'mores scoop and a vanilla pb scoop. Oh! I opted for the junior scoop- the regular scoop =2 scoops and that would've been a bit too much because I wanted two different flavors. I added fluff and peanut butter for toppings. My partner and I were seated in the parlor and we found the staff to be nice. We came her Saturday evening after dinner and it wasn't too quiet, few other customers as well. I advise to pay in cash for the cash discount. read more

Egger's Ice Cream Parlor - Candy Stores Near Me - Staten Island, New York

As a staple ice cream parlor in Staten Island, we decided to try out Egger's on a Saturday evening! There is a good amount of parking in the strip mall parking lot and the place wasn't too crowded when we came. This is surprisingly more of a sit down ice cream place where they give you a menu and take your order rather than the usual take out ice cream places that I am used to. However, they do have an option to order out! We were allowed to sit anywhere we wanted, so we sat at the counter. It took a noticeably long time for the staff to take our orders. However, when they did take our order, the staff was perfectly nice and our ice cream came out relatively quickly! I got 1 scoop of the coffee ice cream and my boyfriend got 1 scoop of vanilla ice cream with chocolate sprinkles. 1 scoop is actually technically two smaller scoops, so we came to the conclusion that 1 actual scoop must be the junior scoop. The ice cream was pretty good and met our expectations! The vanilla ice cream came with plenty of chocolate sprinkles, so you will definitely be satisfied. The interior decor of the place is cute, and they do have a lot of ice cream dessert options, so I would recommend stopping in! read more

Egger's Ice Cream Parlor - coffee ice cream and vanilla ice cream with sprinkles - Candy Stores Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Great and creamy chocolate egg cream drink! Best egg cream drink on Staten Island.

WOW!!!! Went to eggers last night and had a wonderful experience. The waitress was so so nice. She took our orders and reviewed with us what we wanted and she made our ice cream sundaes to perfection!! The service was impeccable. I also got to taste a few ice cream flavors before choosing what I wanted. I love Eggers chocolate chocolate chip ice cream. My friends loved their ice cream as well. The ambiance and decor in here is so old fashioned and cozy. I love the old fashion stool chairs like an ice cream bar. The store is also very clean and organized. I will definitely be back for an ice cream sundae. Thank you so much Eggers! read more

See all

Old school ice cream parlor that packs a mean punch! Not only does this parlor gives you your ice cream fix it also has a wide variety of old school candies that bring back some good old memories. Candies through out time are right here as if you traveled back, wayyyy back! What more can you ask for?? Well, the ice cream of course! The "chocolate chocolate chip" REALLY left me WoW'd! I had a large scoop full in a bowl over a warm freshly made Belgium waffle topped with Reese's pieces, chocolate syrup and fresh whipped cream.... THIS SOOOO HIT THE SPOT!!! The ice cream had a real good quality to it and a creamy consistency. Not firm or frozen, and no ice chips found in ANY bite. Just silky smooth chocolaty goodness... MmmMmmmm! Hands down one of the best ice cream experiences I've ever had =D read more

See all

Old school ice cream shop! How fun. Ice cream, cakes, candy, and soda. It felt so reminiscent to see the Jones soda in the fridge. Good place to bring kids. I usually just get something to go but they have seats for dine in. The ice creams are great and plenty of options - my favorites are the chocolate chocolate chip & chocolate chip. I usually go for the hot fudge for toppings and have even bought a jar to bring home. Service has been decent the few times I've went, I did not experience the same negative interactions that other reviewers have shared. read more

Egger's Ice Cream Parlor - Candy Stores Near Me - Staten Island, New York

The staffs are friendly. Ordered a rainbow cookie and watermelon sorbet both are flavors of the month which are delicious on a hot summer day. If you pay via card there is a surge charge. read more

Egger's Ice Cream Parlor - Candy Stores Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Local spot that I frequent. Great counter service, good variety of ice cream flavors. Old timey music playing. Great for a day date or bring the kids. They have downsized a bit, but have moved tables around. It's very cozy in there now. They do ice cream cakes, ice cream parties, and have 2 more locations on the island. read more

Was looking for an old fashioned ice cream parlour but this place was just tired looking. One person serving do a long wait and ice cream was just ok. No need to revisit! read more

The workers here are amazing, but the owner, Daniella, is incredibly disrespectful. I witnessed her harassing employees on multiple occasions, and I, too, was a victim of her harassment. The store itself is disgusting. I'm honestly shocked they're still in business. Daniella is a terrible owner, and her employees deserve so much better. It's a completely unprofessional environment. She shows no empathy toward her staff, and there's no real help available because HR is her mother. I worked there for a while, and not once did I come home feeling like I'd had a good day at work. If she doesn't like someone, she cuts their hours and even withholds pay. As for the store conditions, there were mice and bugs everywhere. We were told to act like we didn't see them, even as they crawled around. Daniella constantly belittled employees and summer interns. She is, without a doubt, one of the most disrespectful people I've ever met. I truly hope she learns how to treat people with the respect and care they deserve. P.S. Daniella, if you're reading this, treat people better. Your business is only standing because of the amazing workers you take for granted. One day, they'll leave, and all you'll have left is your ego and the rats. by, ex-worker read more

4/5/22 I literally just now brought my 5-year-old daughter here because we just missed the ice cream truck and I told her I would get her ice cream for doing well in school. We walked into Edgar's on Forest Avenue and we were completely ignored by the 2 young woman that were working there. When they did make eye contact they looked completely miserable, with the most unwelcoming look I have ever seen. We were ignored for 7 straight minutes while I stood there with my young daughter in my arms, who was looking forward to her strawberry ice cream. Eventually I got fed up and I said we're out of here. There was no one else in the store! I couldn't believe that we were just ignored like that! I know Staten Island has terrible customer service, but this is one of the worst that I've experienced in a long while. My family will never go here again. read more

Egger's Ice Cream Parlor - cars parked outside - Candy Stores Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Quick summer sweet treat that you can't beat! I went to both locations, Forrest Ave and Richmondtown Eggers. Richmond town has a lot of parking. Walking around such an old part of NYC history is a awesome part of getting ice cream. The Forrest Ave location is in shopping place easy to park, inside there is a larger old fashion counter and additional seating off to side. Summer without ice cream is never a good summer. read more

See all

The icecream was amazing. They have a variety of flavors to choose from and many toppings. They also have many cup sizes! Although because the food is so good, the service is a little slow but the employees are nice overall. read more

I brought my class of 7 special education students to Eggers on a class trip last week for what I thought was going to be a fun-filled celebration. However, a few mishaps occurred, some greater than others, that I feel need to be surfaced for the public to be aware. The day before our confirmed event date, I received a call stating a new hire double booked our class with another school. No problem, I understand that these sorts of things happen sometimes and we were asked to arrive a half hour later. I said we would try but the buses were already secured for a certain time so there was no guarantee. I was reassured that even if we were to arrive early, that they would accommodate. Fast forward to the following day, my class arrived 15 minutes after our originally scheduled appointment time (so 15 minutes "early" based on the call the day before). As soon as we arrived, two associates immediately confronted and began screaming at my class to "Get out, get out, get out. You can't be here!". Taken aback at the horrific customer service, I immediately turned around and began to usher my students back outside to the sidewalk. As we walked out, Anna came to us and politely asked if we could wait 5 minutes and they would be ready for us. As I spoke with Anna, my students who were still outside began peering into the window and were repeatedly reprimanded for simply looking into the store by the same two associates who confronted us earlier. If not for Anna's calm demeanor, I would have ended the trip right on the spot. As for the trip itself once we were in, Anna was a fantastic and engaging tour guide despite her colleagues repeated efforts to derail the trip with their awkward glances. Even though we were ultimately accommodated, the first impression coupled with the general feeling of being unwelcome there made my students anxious and defensive, questioning whether they were being discriminated against. I did call the manager (a female) to express my concerns following the trip on the same day. They took my information and said they would be in touch for "what they could do for us". One month later, and I have yet to receive that call back. I expressed that I was not looking for and still am not looking for any compensation. All I want is for the two clearly disgruntled employees to simply do better and understand how to treat young children and for the management to follow through on their word when customers express concerns. read more

What is happening to Egger's ice cream parlor? How very sad to see how it has drastically declined over the years of me patronizing this establishment. They recently closed off their dining area leaving only the counter and 3 tables crammed in the rear corner of the store. I'm so sorry and disappointed to see what's happening to this establishment that I always enjoyed making a stop for a nice ice cream treat. read more

I've heard awesome things about this place and wanted to love it but I thought it was just okay. They do give huge scoops and the ice cream is good - just wasn't amazing to me and I've had better. I got the flavors strawberry with fresh whipped cream and cookies and cream. For the strawberry, I would have loved if there was more strawberry bits inside but the ice cream itself was creamy and smooth, and they gave a lot of whipped cream! For the cookies and cream, I also wished there was more oreo pieces inside as well. The interior of the store is super cute inside, filled with lots of candy, even the super old ones that brings back memories of when I was a kid. Still worth a visit at least once, but not sure if I'd come back. read more

Egger's Ice Cream Parlor - two bowls of egger's ice cream - Candy Stores Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

Five star product. One star service. Been going to Egger's for 40+ years and each time I go back I run into service issues. Such a shame that a great Staten Island institution is ruining itself. read more

This is a fabulous place and my husband and I have gone here for many years. Today, Tuesday, July 22 at 2 p.m. I decided to visit Eggers with my friend. The woman behind the counter, Danielle, was very nasty. We decided that once we got our ice cream, we would sit in the room in back. This witch came charging in telling us to leave as it was waitress service only. There is a policy. Therefore our patronizing the place was not enough, unless we gave her a tip??? We, as paying customers, left and sat outside at a nearby restaurant. I want to tell everyone how wonderful the staff always has been to us. Apparently this creature should never work with the public. Please Eggers, fire this nasty person. read more

Forest Avenue location! The ice cream is delicious, and I have ordered many cakes over the years from them, but my most recent on 9/30/23 I was very disappointed. The cake was not decorated at all the way I requested. I ordered almost the same exact cake previously with no issue. So, it's not like they can tell me they don't decorate it that way. I understand people make mistakes; however, we went over the order 3 times. Anyhow, what was even more aggravating was the nasty woman I had spoken to about it. I was very polite and had said the cake was not decorated as I requested can anything be done about it. Her reply, that's what it said on the order. I tell her whoever took the information wrong. Then she tells me, oh we don't decorate it that way. I said you need an attitude adjustment if you want any more business. read more

I moved to Staten Island in 2002. My family and I used to come here often. Now its not the same anymore. It lost its vib and the portions are too small for the price. And the ordering is hecktic and the people behind the counter were not organized. Terrible service. I now just go to Carvels on forest and be done with it. Its sad to see the decline of these old estabishments just like this country as a whole. The only good thing is the they are alway other busniesses waiting in the bushes to take over market share. Its just a matter of time. read more

Used to be a GREAT ice cream parlor. The workers were complaining about making customers orders aloud. Saying they were going to quit if they had to make another milkshake. Gave a small instead of a large ‍. Just disappointing. Not quality Customer service read more

I've been an eggers fan forever. I've never had a problem. They are amazing and the owner is lovely. Went to the forest ave store tonight and the ice cream tasted very off, sour. Wasn't sure if it was the ice cream or toppings but a few of us used the term sour about our orders. Daughter ordered a root beer float and it was coke a cola with ice crea., which was gross. The cherries and or wallnhut toppings tasted awful. I never ordered chocolate syrup and jt was on my order. And just overall , no one finished their ice cream for the first time ever bc we have been eggers fans for 20+ years. Just wanted to let you know here because I want to see eggers not only survive but continue to thrive. I'll update my review to 5 stars as soon as the owner sees this and maybe talks to forest Ave staff. read more

Favorite ice cream on Staten Island! It's always delicious, but today was over the top. Mya makes the best hot fudge sundae and the value for the price is exceptional!! read more

Eggers continues to have the best ice cream but the service has been declining steadily. Delivery orders are frequently wrong, or under portioned. Telephone pick up orders constantly not ready and again under portioned (half empty containers). In person service is slow. Recent stop had 1 counter girl and a manager who just stood there watching the girl handle a line of 5. read more

Ice cream is delicious and the manger Lee was so good to the kids. Walking in the front door is like walking through a Time Machine. From the old diner counter to the old candies. Family loved it. read more

The young staff that work here are deplorable. Do NOT waste your money. If I could give zero stars, I would. I moved back to the area a few months ago, and since it's been nicer out, I've been here about 3 times in just a few weeks. Each time I went, the service was HORRIBLE. The people at the register completely ignore you as you wait stupidly to be asked if you would like to order. One night, the order was wrong. Another night a friend and I sat for 30 MINUTES until we had to physically walk into the other room and request to order. Finally, the third night, I was stared at while 7 people were behind the counter. Although it's obvious these kids are only there for a check, the manager needs to wake up. Almost every review on this site is poor. It's just embarrassing. read more

We had an incredible time at Egger's Igloos for the third year! The service is amazing and the ice cream is the best most delicious ice cream you can possibly imagine! The kids loved writing their letters to Santa and then meeting him! Making a special Christmas tree decoration was so much fun too! We have made Eggers Igloos our family favorite tradition read more

Recently I tasted Egger's ice cream at a friend's house on Staten Island. The chocolate was smooth and flavorful but the banana was extraordinary. The combination of real banana taste and the richness of the cream combined into something special. While I would not rank it above Brickley's in Rhode Island, it was definitely up there in the elite ice cream rankings! read more

Egger's Ice Cream Parlor - Smooth chocolate ice cream! - Candy Stores Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

Spent a lifetime getting treats from this place. Just a super traditional ice cream parlor with all of the sundaes, shakes, etc., that you would expect. Excellent handmade ice cream in great flavors! read more

Ice cream is decent but they consistently get orders wrong take forever to make and just have poor customer service. The aesthetic of the place is quite nice and the pecan pie ice cream is worth a try. read more

Saw a roach just casually crawling up the wall above the milkshake mixers. Called the health Dept but I will never go back. I don't think they clean too good. read more