A friend had recommended this bakery and looking through her page her work looked good so i contacted her and asked her to make cake pops for a friends birthday. I sent her the inspo pic and let her know thats what i wanted. She said she was able to do it and charged me $55 for a dozen of cakepops, which was on the pricier side from all the other bakers I asked but looking at the quality of work on her page I didn't mind because I wanted to give my friend a cute "instagramable" treat for their birthday. What I got was just atrocious.. first the color of the coating was this ugly turquoise color and some of them the coating was done super uneven and messy. Then she completely ignored the sprinkle detail, and to top it off she puts an orange candle on it that just clashed horribly with the blue color. It was so poorly made It would have been embarrassing to bring that to someone so I had to take the L and throw them out and still spend more time and money to rush to the grocery store to buy something else. When I contacted her she said she'd give me a full refund if I returned the cake pops to her and when I told her I threw it out she caught an attitude and asked why I would want a refund if I threw them away. When I told her I threw it out because it was so poorly made and unusable for a gift. She offered a partial refund and when i told her I wouldn't accept that I wanted the full refund she just left me on read. Just super disappointing all around and a waste of money. Never again read more

See all

We are SO impressed by them. When another bakery dropped the ball (forgot our custom sugar cookie order for my dad's birthday and refused to make them due to long dry times), Ever After came through -- at 3pm the day before our morning party (MUCH less than 24 hours), they were able to make my entire order last minute with 8 custom designs, including awesome cartoonized cookies of my dad's face. So impressed by their complete execution of my vision under a tight deadline, reasonable pricing, and the cookies tasted great too! We are blown away and happy to support a business that cares about their customers. My family and I would highly recommend. read more

Ever After Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Lake Balboa, California

Wendy made a beautifully decorated cake inspired by K-Pop Demon Hunters! Cake tasted delicious! I sent her an inspo pic and she wrote back 24 hours later confirming my order/request. We also ordered cookies and they were a hit too! I love that Ever After Bakery is conveniently located in my area. Highly recommend ordering from Ever After Bakery for a special occasion!! read more

All around great. We placed 2 orders for custom birthday cakes and they met the short deadline, these guys make the cakes look exactly like the image we showed them & definitely tasty. Wishing you all the best guys! Thank you again! read more

Wendy made our wishes and dreams come true with a stunning package for my son's 6th birthday party. We ordered a beautiful, two tier cake, cookies, and cake pops, all in the theme of Pokemon. I reached out to her with my vision, and her mama mind was instantly able to mesh with mine! She knew exactly what I wanted, and when I sent her the inspo pic of what I liked, she presented something even better, and magnificent!! The colors were gorgeous and the shiny toys on top added major pizzazz. Everything was delicious and tasted top tier! The pricing was extremely reasonable, and everything went smoothly. I would work with Wendy again for my next event. Thank you so much Wendy for making the whole package possible, and memorable! We appreciate you! read more

I was referred by a good friend and wanted to like the cookies I ordered but had to get them redone because they were not good. When I picked up the cookies we're still warm so the frosting smudged. The communication was nice at first but I had to send photos and let her know I wasn't happy. The order seemed rushed and very amateur to be honest. I appreciate her making them again but afterwards I didn't even get a "hope you come back or hope you liked the second batch" I had a family member pick up and even he said they weren't that nice. It was for a 50th birthday so I was disappointed. The 2nd batch definitely tasted and looked better but I wanted to like these a lot more than I did. read more

See all

I ordered a dessert package with a cake, cake pops and cookies for my granddaughter's birthday and everything turned out adorable. My granddaughter was so happy with everything and the kids loved the cookies! read more

Ever After Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Lake Balboa, California

We did medium dessert packages for our Wildflower themed baby shower and we had so many compliments on how pretty everything looked and tasted! Easy to communicate and coordinate with too! read more

Ever After Bakery - Medium dessert package - Bakeries Near Me - Lake Balboa, California

See all

I cannot say enough wonderful things about Wendy! I reached out to her on very short notice for a custom cake for my sister's birtday, and not only did she deliver on time, but she completely exceeded my expectations. The cake was absolutely stunning--beautifully designed with such attention to detail. It wasn't just a cake, it was a true work of art. On top of that, it tasted as amazing as it looked, according to the birthday girl. Wendy is incredibly talented, professional, and clearly pours her heart into her creations. I feel so lucky to have found her and will definitely be coming back for all future celebrations! read more

Ever After Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Lake Balboa, California

See all

Wendy and her family are a small, independent bakery that makes magical cakes and cookies and all sorts of delicious baled goods! I ordered a cake for 30 with a reptile/bug theme for my daughters 10th birthday. I also mentioned that she loves cats. I sent a couple reference pictures of what I was looking for. Honestly I expected her to quote me some outrageous price like every other bakery but I was floored when she gave me such a reasonable price! OMG how can she afford to do this!? The cake itself was magical AND delicious. My daughter got teary eyed when she saw the cake! Her husband who delivered the cake was such a sweetheart and took care of delivering and setting it up exactly where I wanted it. Over all this bakery is HIGHLY recommended!!!!! read more

See all

So happy with this came! Wendy at Everafter bakery communicated quickly and she made exactly what we wanted. The cake looked exactly like the pic I sent her. We got the marble cake with chocolate buttercream and it was good. Would high recommend and will use again!!! read more

Ever After Bakery - Monster Jam Two Layer Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Lake Balboa, California

I know about Ever After Bakery from seeing them at the farmers market and a friend that using them for her daughters' parties. So, for my birthday, this is where I went. I did cookies because I knew a cake would be too much. This is now my go-to place, and I will be telling everyone I know. read more

Ever After Bakery - Birthday cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Lake Balboa, California

I ordered a dozen custom LA Dodger and LA Lakers cookies for a family members birthday, they came out fantastic and taste fabulous! Wendy does a great job and is happy to do special themed orders, I give Ever After Bakery 10+ stars! read more

Ever After Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Lake Balboa, California

See all

The inspo cake is what i sent as a referral picture and was told they could make it. The cake I received when I first picked it up was disappointing and sloppy. I told her I was not happy with it and she was nice enough to fix it up. She said that she only uses edible pictures, I don't understand why this was not made clear when I was ordering the cake that clearly had fondant. I wanted fondant, not paper that was peeling off the cake. The piping was a mess, I'm not sure what was going on with the corner. The paper banner looked super cheap. Overall it was poorly made and more stressful because I had to figure out a way to come back and pick it up while setting up for a party. The second time it looked better but even then the letters were sloppy and the fondant numbers were slipping off before we even cut it. So disappointing. Edit- she did not "discuss" the edible paper vs fondant issue with me when I was ordering this cake. I sent her a picture, she gave me quote and I paid her asap. There was no communication about the cake having to be done different for the quote I was given, I would've happily paid more. Super unprofessional. read more

See all

Ever after bakery is phenomenal! I ordered Harry Potter themed cake. She sent me a few photos and I chose one. Cake was even better in person, taste was amazing. All of my guests were amazed by the cake. She responds messages quick enough and even delivered it too. Amazing service, delicious cake. Highly recommend! Will order my kids cake again next year for sure. read more

Ever After Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Lake Balboa, California

It was my first time ordering from EVER AFTER BAKERY - and it won't be my last. Communication was great. The look of the cake exceeded my expectations. The cookies were delicious and the cake pops a huge hit. Delivery was prompt. Couldn't be happier :-) read more

See all

This is a family run business. Wendy bakes out of her home and has little Bake sales on her porch. The house is quirky, with funny weird decorations on the outside- nothing that you would imagine a bakery to be. And you don't go inside the house. Order a few days ahead and remind her on the day of because she gets booked with a lot of orders . Her son brings out your order. Her cherry pies are fresh out of the oven. A thin light crust with an incredibly tasty cherry filling. read more

See all

Off the charts awesome looking cake, and so so delicious. Will always order from here! Initially communicated through Instagram however, you can find her here on yelp or Google. I sent her a picture of a cake I found on Instagram for my daughters birthday and she was able to replicate it beyond what I imagined. Not only did it look really cool and matched our beach themed party perfectly, it was so delicious. Even fondant that to me is normally not good on other cakes, it was so good. The buttercream, the cake itself... very yummy. So many compliments! Definitely worth the price. read more

See all

My go to bakery for weddings, baby showers and birthdays!! Their work is amazing and my guests always complement my sweets table! read more

See all

Our regular cake shop wasn't available so we took a chance with this shop as we needed a cake made within a week. Communication was nearly non existent. The cake was poorly frozen and left a pool of goo at the bottom of the delivery box. I understand home bakers may not have walk in fridges for storing cakes but look at the picture it's a mess. My daughter who loves cake didn't even finish the slice after it thawed out. And if a kid pushes away from a cake you know what that means. read more

Ever After Bakery - Poorly frozen cake. Nailed it - Bakeries Near Me - Lake Balboa, California

Wow! The best sugar cookie we'veever had! We met Ever After Bakery at a pop-up event for the Bob Baker Marionette annual festival, and enjoyed several delicious cookies. What a delightful bakery and the baker/owner was lovely and so helpful. My kids are begging me too visit them Ever After Bakery again soon! Five stars all the way! read more

Ever After Bakery - Bob baker marionette themed sugar cookies!!! These were the best sugar cookies I've ever had!! - Bakeries Near Me - Lake Balboa, California

Excellent bakery! We have ordered from them several times and everything has been fantastic. ***The sugar cookies are highly recommended*** They took a lot of time and care to prepare some custom designed cupcakes and cookies for us per our request. Their design/decorating skills are top notch! Our orders have been ready on time as promised. They are our go-to bakery for birthdays and holidays. read more

Wendy made beautiful cookies, exactly how I was picturing them, in incredibly short notice. I'm so excited to share these with our teachers! Her communication was stellar, pickup convenient; I will definitely be ordering from her again! read more

Ever After Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Lake Balboa, California

Amazing cookies, they are soft and so delicious and cure all at the same time. I've bought from them a few times and every time cookies have been amazing. I recommend them to all my friends and family. Also everyone is so sweet and nice. read more

Everything is fairly limited due to the pandemic but we wanted something fun to do with our son for the holiday. I saw a DIY Valentines Day cookie kit on a Mommy group and wanted to try it out being fairly local to me. So glad I did! I was a bit confused about pick up but Wendy was super responsive to emails and phone to explain. It was completely easy - order/pay online and porch pick up. We loved decorating and eating the delicious cookies! I've never had chocolate chip sugar cookies but they were a hit. Thank you! read more

Ever After Bakery - The after - Bakeries Near Me - Lake Balboa, California

Really disappointed with how my cake turned out for my daughter's birthday. It was a neon glow party theme so I wanted it black with bright neon colors. The fondant was more like a dark brown, and nothing neon about it and you can clearly see mistakes and cracks on the cake (you can see some on the top in this picture) Instead of it being all covered in fondant, the details were printed on edible paper. I didn't get any message that this change was made. I was setting up for my party and didn't even get to check out the cake when it arrived. That was my fault. I was so embarrassed putting this on my dessert table (pictured below) and having my 100 guests see it. It was so much smaller than anticipated as well. I had no other cake option at that point, so we had to roll with it. When I messaged Wendy the next day, she said she cut her hand and had to get rid of all of the fondant apparently. I wished there was communication prior to this so I could be prepared and grab a cake from costco or the supermarket instead of being shocked that it was nothing like my inspiration picture (on the left). She ended up giving me back my money but I sent her back half (still $65!) for giving me a cake even though we didn't even eat it. She never responded or thanked me for that. I still think $65 was too generous for what I received and the stress and embarrassment I dealt with. Didn't try the cookies so maybe she's better at that. Unfortunately, what I got did not feel professionally done at all. When I told some friends about the story, they thought I tried making the cake and that's why they didn't say comment. I don't bake cakes... read more

Ever After Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Lake Balboa, California

See all

Wendy made my daughter a beautiful burn way cake for her Sweet 16 Birthday. It was the highlight of the party. My daughter and her friends were excited to watch the top burn, then see the hidden message underneath. The heart shaped cake was beautiful and made with a lot of detail and glitter :) I highly recommend Wendy and will use her again. read more

Had my baby shower 10/28/23 and I sat with this for a bit as it was a busy weekend but ended up reaching out to Wendy 10/31/23 personally through text as she felt at liberty herself to text me day off asking "latest you can pick up time." Based off the text she stated she was running late, had it not been a baby shower and I not placed the order more than a month in advanced I could have possibly understood why she was running late. However, I reached out to her through out the week before event to confirm the time frame I needed dessert by, being as it is a baby shower I would consider she would understand the event time frame I needed by was early 12pm and as I was communicating with an advanced order + verbal confirmation it should have been ready. Sadly, it was my first baby shower and I had my brother pick up and didn't think of asking him to check order first, sugar cookies upon arrival I wanted to try one and I opened one. The entire cookie icing came off with plastic wrap, all cookies where rubbing off smudged and not dry. We saved a couple for next day, which you can see in a pic of the pumpkin is still all crinkled even next day. The $50 cupcake boo inspo theme I added to the order came with white frosting only, nothing in relation to theme or what I sent her. , ($50 for plain white cupcakes I felt i could have picked up at Safeway after all.) "BOO" cake pops looked messy to me. The only thing dry was the cake and an order of blue cake pops. She's around on Facebook groups and her worked looked neat, seeing as to her having an entire website for orders it did seem very professional and promising. Absolutely disappointed in her no contact or response to my message in relation to this. She could have communicated this she clearly knew what I would be receiving as a heads up or some kind of concern. I personally would not order again from the lack of professionalism entirely from running late, to the order, and no contact. read more

See all

These cookies are adorable and taste very good! The ones I tried were decorated as little sea creatures. They're sugar cookies, and taste very fresh. Individual packaging is convenient. Recommended. read more

Ever After Bakery - Sea creature decorated sugar cookies. Yum! - Bakeries Near Me - Lake Balboa, California

I ordered a carrot cake for Easter and it was so delicious! The design was perfect and exactly what I asked for. Will order again.

I am a big fan of Ever After Bakery. I often purchase cookies and seasonal baked goods from their home porch, but recently contacted them to make cookies and cake pops for a charity golf tournament. The desserts were amazing! Highly recommend! read more

Best baker in LA! I dream and she creates! I've used Wendy several times. She is the best. Taste is amazing and presentation is always perfect! read more

Ever After Bakery - Cookie stacks & cake - Bakeries Near Me - Lake Balboa, California

See all

At the end of the school year, I wanted to give cookies to my office and custodial staff. I was leaving my school and wanted to end with something special. I had been a customer of a Ever After and was hoping they could make custom cookies. I e-mailed Ever After with my idea! The cookies were so cute and personalized, and so delicious! They were a big hit with everyone. This neighborhood bakery rocks! Support independent businesses, and enjoy their goodies while doing so. Sorry forgot to mention Wendy, the owner-lovely to work with. read more

Ever After Bakery - Cookies from Ever After - Bakeries Near Me - Lake Balboa, California

Ever After Bakery made us a beautiful batch of custom cookie. Would for sure order again.

We found them while running errands and spotted a poster. Beautiful cookies and everything we got from the cinnamon bun, cookies, and banana bread were delicious read more

This review is being made because sort of messed up our wedding. It look like Wendy was a really good Baker and she was on one of the Los Angeles morning shows. That's where I saw her. When it comes to a cake for a wedding you have to start kind of early to make sure you get it done in time for your wedding reception. I contacted her 6 months earlier at the beginning of 2023 and she quoted me a price we talked about everything we were going to need to do. I sent her a picture of the cake I wanted an email she said great she could do it. I told her that the wedding was August 4th. She said contact me when it gets closer and we will go ahead with it. I contacted her 2 months before the wedding. Finally she contacted me back we did a three-way call with me my fiance and her. We talked about everything we were going to do and she said she would send out a invoice so we could go ahead and book it. She never contacted us back never sent an invoice never did anything. We called her on many different days and at different times of the day and left many messages. Finally we happened to get a hold of her. She said she had so many kids and she was so busy and crazy. She said she was going to send out an invoice that same day. Never got an invoice never heard back from her. We called her multiple more times and she never answered the phone. As time was going by it was getting so close to our wedding that we had to go with another Bakery. Actually one that had an actual shop in a plaza where you could go in. They gave us slices of cakes to try and we were able to make our choices. We put a deposit down that same day and away we went. We sent them a picture of the cake we wanted made. When we got to the shop they already had a printout of the picture of the cake we wanted and they made notes all over the picture of what we wanted and how we wanted it to be. Much more professional. Wendy seems to be a one woman show working out of her house in Lake Balboa. She should have just told us if she couldn't do our cake. She let us to believe she could do it and was sending out an invoice but it never came. Don't ever waste your time on her. If you see some good reviews from people saying hey the cookies turned out good. It seems like only the ones where she's making cookies have good reviews. All the reviews of her making a cake never turn out right. From other people saying they talked to her got a price supposed to get an invoice but got blown off and never heard back from her. To people saying that the cake didn't look like it was supposed to and they were embarrassed. I hate giving people a bad review and I clearly wanted to use her. I would have but she never got back to us ever. I hope this helps someone to not pick her. read more

This bakery was recommended by local moms in a group on FB. Unsure why no one has had the chance to write a review on yelp but I will kick start it! :-) I ordered cookies from Wendy for my daughters birthday. She was quick to respond, prices are fair and they taste just as good as they look! These are the Harry Potter cookies she made. Simply Beautiful! read more

Ever After Bakery - Harry Potter Cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Lake Balboa, California

Ever After Bakery made our Elf on the Shelf appearance even more special this year! Cookies not only are a piece of art, but they also taste amazing. She even made a trip to my house to drop of the elf on the shelf card after we forgot to pick it up. Great customer service. read more

Ever After Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Lake Balboa, California

She is super nice and easy to work with the cookies we're delicious. She made Father's Day cookies for my hubs. The only issue is the picture melted a little ( probably my fault hiding them in the closet instead of the fridge) but on delivery they were PERFECT! Tasted perfect. I would order again. read more

Such a great find! I ordered the paint and frost your own cookie kits and they were a huge hit in our house! We got frosting, a variety of sprinkles, paint palettes.... my son loved it and we all enjoyed eating the cookies. Delicious!! Great activity for the kids to do.... especially while we are all holed up right now. Everything was packaged perfectly and the owner was super quick to respond to all of my questions. We'll definitely be ordering more goodies from here again! read more