Pizza was unremarkable. I ordered a cobb salad, was given the wrong salad and had to go to the front desk for eating utensils. Definitely a do not return experience. read more

Great atmosphere. A staple in Sheboygan falls. The desserts are delicious !! Big selection. Service is friendly and quick!

We came here based on the solid reviews and the menu. My daughter wanted a cheese pizza and spaghetti, so she got the kids cheese pizza meal ($5) for the pizza, drink, Oreo and applesauce and I got the spaghetti meal. It came with a salad and 2 breadsticks and was big. Was it the best spaghetti and cheese pizza I've ever had- no, but it was good and cheap. I also got a beer and all of it together was $20. I'll take it. The place is neat too. Lots to look at. Service was really good also. read more

Falls Firehouse Pizza - License plate walls - Pizza Near Me - Sheboygan Falls, Wisconsin

See all

Ordered a fire extinguisher pizza for delivery. It was hot, fresh, and amazing! Delivery person was friendly and appreciative of the tip, which we appreciate. We highly recommend this establishment! Great pizza! read more

So the food was amazing. Had a delicious taste and we might consider coming back. However, server was sub-par. We placed our order. We kept calling the server to get refills and he did not Come. After like 30+ minutes the hostess came by and she had to get our refills for us. Mind you he kept stopping by the tables around ours but not ours. He wouldn't even look at us. After the hostess took our drinks he comes and asked if we need refills....30+ minutes later!! All the tables around us ate, left and new people came in and our food was nowhere to be seen. After an hour we asked how much more time it would be and he said it should be a few minutes. We finally got our food and saw that the new people around us got their food about 10-15 minutes after we did, yet they arrived 20-25 minutes prior to that. I think he just forgot to submit our order and our table in general. Did not tip due to this bad service. Gave the check out our feedback and hope he takes it into consideration. read more

See all

Did a takeout order, appetizers, soups, salads, pizza and entrees. The guy taking our order was friendly, helpful and made suggestions. The restaurant is a very comfortable place. When we got home, everyone really enjoyed everything. They did a great job preparing everything just perfectly for a takeout order. Check them out. read more

I had the spaghetti with meat sauce and pretzel sticks. It was pretty average/good. My husband had a pizza it was average as well. Prices were very affordable and staff was friendly. Lots of good options on their menu. read more

Have tried to eat here several times and always seem to catch them closed. It's a long drive, but finally caught them open. I was very surprised. Pizza was GREAT. Thin crust, crispy, very tasty. Thought the price was a little high for the size of the pizza, but I don't mind paying for really good food. They even had Diet Root Beer. Waitress was very polite and attentive. Hope to come back soon :-) read more

Falls Firehouse Pizza - Great Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sheboygan Falls, Wisconsin

Unfortunately, getting decent food or service is a thing of the past. Very sad that everything has gone downhill. Their hours also keep changing. They are no longer open for lunch. read more

Both the food and the ambiance are great. We've had trouble lately finding the business open. Service has been good every time we've been there. It's worth traveling to Sheboygan Falls just for their food! read more

Good pizza, fast, delicious. Get the bread sampler. Their speciality pizzas a awesome

Very tasty pizza and pretzel sticks. The pizza was thin crust but loaded with cheese and toppings. The pretzel sticks were soft, chewy and buttery. The restaurant is in an old renovated firehouse. Very nicely decorated. Good service. read more

Falls Firehouse Pizza - Dining room - Pizza Near Me - Sheboygan Falls, Wisconsin

I like Firehouse pizza more than many of the offerings in Sheboygan. They have taco pizza which is (to some) sacrilege, but to me is delicious. Pizza isn't greasy. Could use a bit more flavor in the sauce, and a bit higher quality cheese. Overall good not great. read more

On our honeymoon adventure, we made a pit stop in Sheboygan Wisconsin for some rest and food. We saw Falls Firehouse Pizza and got excited, who doesn't love pizza. We ordered the Smoke Alarm Pizza (BLT pizza) and the Beef Ravioli. The smoke alarm pizza was on a flat bread crust and was absolutely delicious! 10/10! The beef ravioli was good. Very cheesy but I felt like something was missing. The ravioli came with garlic bread and a soup, we ordered the sour cream potato soup. It was very delicious and very flavorful! The garlic bread was also delicious, it has a soft crunch to it. Jess was our waitress and she was fantastic. We would definitely eat here again and try some other pizzas! Adam and Jessica VaDeWater read more

Great pizza! Probably the best taco pizza in town. I've never been disappointed with any of the specialty pizza. Love the jalapeño on the pineapple and Canadian bacon. read more

We had the best service the best food thank you Lindsey for making our first visit a great one

I have no idea why this place was so dead on a Saturday night. The food was awesome; pizza delish and our server, a young lady, was phenomenal, attentive and friendly. I am new to Sheboygan Falls and am from NYC; so I am always up for good pizza. It's not NYC style pizza but it is still good thin crust and was awesome in my opinion. The decor is very cool and it looks like they put a lot of attention to the styling and ambience (it is a former firehouse!). I'd say this place is a tightly held secret in Sheboygan Falls. Maybe the Sheboyganites and Kohlerites will discover this place soon and it will not be so secret anymore. ;) Support local businesses and try this local gem!! read more

Was rather suprised to see canned mushrooms on my pizza...not sure if this was the norm or if they ran out of fresh ones. Otherwise excellent. read more

We ordered a hamburger pizza. It was a thin crust with a healthy dose of cheese and beef. The pizza was a bit bland, but it was a solid pizza and hit the spot. It also wasn't greasy, which is nice. There other food looked good, but we unfortunately didn't try it. I had a glass of Pinot Grigio while there--I'm guessing it was beginning to oxidize, but it was drinkable. Our server was friendly and our bill was decently priced. Take a walk at the local park while visiting--it's gorgeous. read more

Always yummy, always consistent. If you don't like a thin crispy pizza crust, you may not like this....but the ingredients are always super fresh and they don't skimp on the cheese. They also have something for everyone: pizza, soups, sandwiches, salads and pasta. And to top it all off, THE most delicious homemade desserts. A MUST try if you are in or around Sheboygan Falls. read more

This was my first visit. Not sure if I would go back. It's loud and a bit chilly since we were seated close to the door. I ordered lasagna, but it appeared to be more of a casserole. I really couldn't pick out the layers. And I think it was microwaved in the dish it was served. I had a glass of Merlot, and it was a generous portion, but I've had better. read more

Delicious pizza! Their pepperoni is my favorite. The cheesy garlic is also very good.

I went here once, and it was very good! I had a lunch-size pepperoni pizza, and the crust was very good. The also have AMAZING desserts. I had a brownie that was almost like fudge...in a good way. The service was great, and i really like how the inside is decorated, especially the license pate wall. I plan to go back soon! read more

Best pizza in the world! thin crust, spicier sauce... amazing!

Great lunch specials and pretty solid pizza. Definitely a great place to stop in Sheboygan.

Ordered delivery from here while staying at the Inn at Woodlake. We got two ten inch pizzas, one appetite extinguisher (sausage, pepperoni, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, olives) and one bacon cheeseburger. It just was not good. Everything seemed fresh and they weren't greasy, but they just really weren't that flavorful or anything to write home about. I've had better frozen pizza. I hate to ding a local business, but it just wasn't to our liking. read more

This is the best pizza I have ever had, I go here often. The toppings are great and the crust is crispy, I have never had pizza like it. If you are in Falls you need to stop into Firehouse. read more

Very average to say the least this is not a place I can recommend this is not a New York pizza average to say the least

I liked the pizza, the salad and garlic bread. The service and delivery was also really kind and efficient. My hubby didn't love his pizza, but I think it was because he was hoping for a different style of crust. I loved that we could order individual pies (I'm a vegetarian and he is not :)) and that the slices were small. I'll definitely try this pizza again! read more

On our last night in town, we walked over to Firehouse Pizza for dinner. We were seated quickly and the server was very friendly and attentive. On her recommendation, I ordered the Baked Spaghetti and a glass of Riesling to go with it. The only troublemaker of the dinner was the wine (which was mostly my fault), but more on that in a minute. The spaghetti arrived quickly, in its own mini-casserole dish. At first I thought it was too large a serving (I ordered the smaller serving size), but easily finished it. It was delicious. The Riesling was average, but served at too warm a temperature for my taste. During dinner, I accidentally spilled my wine glass (so glad I hadn't ordered a red!) and our waitress was at our side with paper towels to clean it up almost immediately. She even reduced our tab due to the spill, even though it was entirely my fault. I opted for a dessert to go and had a very large selection to choose from. I picked a chocolate eclair torte that was delectable. If we were in town longer, I'd definitely be back! read more

When in Sheboygan Falls, WI, stop here first. Great thin crust pizza and old Sheboygan Falls ambiance. Muriel is on west exterior wall! My favorite pizza! read more

Falls Firehouse Pizza - When in Sheboygan Falls, WI, stop here first. Great thin crust pizza and old Sheboygan Falls ambiance. Muriel is on west exterior wall! - Pizza Near Me - Sheboygan Falls, Wisconsin

We have lived in Sheboygan Falls for about 13 years. My wife and I both share the opinion of supporting local businesses. The reward has been our local businesses are blessed with staff who are authentically friendly and are there to help and serve the customers. We are never treated as though we are bothering someone. On top of that, Firehouse Pizza serves quality great tasting food efficiently in a clean and interesting environment. We have never been disappointed and their delivery service is top-notch. read more

The food is great and the price is reasonable. I absolutely love the atmosphere here. Going to firehouse pizza is a real treat!

Superb pizza, excellent crisp crust takes NO getting used to (see other post)...you are instantly a fan! Waitstaff is superb, thoroughly enjoyed this entire experience...will definitely be coming back! Worth the drive from the Milwaukee area! If you like Balistreri's pizza, this is even better! read more

The quality of the toppings is what sets Firehouse pizza apart. Their crust might take some getting used to if you don't like it crispy, but the cheese and toppings are so great, you won't care. read more

Pizza wad good but could have used more toppings. Waitress had a good sense of humor but one person had to wait 15 minutes to get her ham & cheese croissant after everyone else was served. With no explanation on why. read more

Yummy pizza, beer, and homemade desserts. Soups, salads, and sandwiches available too. Everything made by pizza chefs and bakers. Highly recommend the bread basket. Wonderful family fun place, cool decor, and amazing pizza. You won't be disappointed. read more

Wow! What great pizza! We had the Garden Hose and the Taco pizzas; what a treat! Service was wonderful and staff was so friendly! We loved the food and the experience! Thank you! read more

We have tried off & on here for many years! Sometimes it is good, but mostly not so good! The product is always inconsistent and usually younger type employees with lack of training? We could use a great Pizzaria!!! read more