I've had occasion to try Uptown Slice about five times now. Initially I wasn't so sure as I've never been a "New York slice" type of guy. However, the fact they do full pies and have stellar reviews meant I had to try them. I wasn't so sure after my first experience as again it's not necessarily the style of pizza I default too. That said it was good enough and very fresh and well prepared. So I gave it a few other tries and I'm now a big fan. For context, I only do cheese or cheese and sausage and will sometimes do extra cheese. Their cheese pie is excellent. I don't think extra cheese is necessary, but I've done it and it's also excellent. The sausage isn't the style that I normally prefer, the sliced sausage, but it too is very good. I tend to go cheese though because even when I ordered "light" sausage it had way too much on the pizza. That seems to be the norm these days though, but for me it overwhelms the rest of the ingredients. I'd rotate between the two, but not sure if I'll get light sausage when I order. Anyway, the pizza is fantastic. Sauce for me is what it makes it, but crest and cheese are spot on as well. I do love garlic bread, specifically cheese garlic bread, and have had both. This has seemingly changed recently, but anytime I've had it it's been good as well. Currently it's more of a traditional garlic bread delivery which is slightly better. They do have two locations which is nice. One is dine-in, but they do accommodate orders if to go if needed. The other is the Uptown Sline Depot which is a to-go location. Both are great and they deliver the same result. The dine-in was packed on a recent Saturday visit and the concept with some craft beers, etc is good. Two things if the owner is listening. Go lighter on the toppings if asked. Second though and more important please expand outside of Sheboygan. You'd kill it in West Bend with little competition which you'd easily best. read more

This place is friendly, welcoming and affordable. We grabbed a slice of sausage and a grape soda. Tastes like delicious nostalgia.

This pepperoni slice MIGHT BE THE BEST SLICE IVE HAD IN WI SO FAR! I've had pizza all over, and nyc and this one was just sooooo good. The red sauce was slightly spicy and not sweet like a lot of places so it had great flavor. The dough was crispy but still had a bit of chew. They use the good pepperonis and they had all the toppings to add on the tables to go. The arugula burrito was pretty good but I wish one of their white pies was available as slices for takeout. Will definitely come back again. Went for lunch and it was a cute spot with decent amount of tables and bar seating. Got my food super quickly as well. read more

Uptown Slice - Arugula Burrata - Pizza Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

See all

The aesthetic is so awesome! The cheese pizza was some of the best I had and the staff was very friendly! I would eat here again and try their special pizzas! read more

Uptown Slice - Cheese Pizza Slice - Pizza Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

What a find in Sheboygan. I doubt you will find a better slice in Wisconsin. Cheese had great flavor, plentiful toppings and the dough was the level of crisp and chewy. The calzone was packed and the garlic butter on top was exactly what it needed. This is on my stop list every time I'm up in the area! The staff was super friendly! read more

Uptown Slice - Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

See all

I'm been here 3 times already but each time has been a great experience. I waited to give a review but now it's a definite must come eat here if you love pizza. The service is great the ambience is great. If you're here for just a slice to go or some slices with friends and a drink. You can't go wrong !!! If I ever go to NY this is my base metric that NY will measure against. read more

Uptown Slice - Under side chat is perfect. - Pizza Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

See all

The only New York style pizzeria in Sheboygan, as far as I know, and it's great! I've visited twice now on trips to the area, which has a pretty solid food scene, btw. The Uptown Slice crust is crisp and light, with the right amount of chew, and the sauce and cheese taste great, too. There are standard every day slices, during normal business hours, anyway, and they feature different special slices every week, so plenty of options to choose from. I enjoyed the Gabagool with capicola and arugula and the Apple Gorgonzola with bacon on my most recent visit, and both were delicious! I've had the cheese slice and pepperoni slice on prior visit. Yum! Dine in and enjoy a slice or two with a beverage, as they have a few beers on tap, as well as soft drinks. There are TV's to keep your attention, if needed, if you dine in, or you can place an order for carry-out or delivery. They are currently open Thursday through Sunday, Noon to 9:00PM. Check them out. read more

See all

This is my favorite pizza in all of Wisconsin! The service is friendly and the atmosphere is fine. If you like New York style pizza slices this is the spot for you! I love the different topping options! read more

Outstanding pizza. Great Brooklyn vibe in Sheboygan. Loved the thin NYC style pizza and craft beers. I've bookmarked this to ensure we stop when we're in town again. read more

Delicious hot fresh pizza! You can try many different kinds. Three Sheep's beer topped off a great meal.

Pizza not good...not sure why have an outdoor seating but don't allow dogs?? Would have stayed and ate outside and grab drinks had they allow dogs. Costco pizza much better. read more

Great staff and service. The pies are top notch too. Chill bar to sit at as well if you are eating in house. read more

Uptown Slice - Half sausage half pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

Great NY style pizza. A lot of variety and pizza offered by the slice, which comes in handy when you have a family of picky eaters. Service was fast and friendly, even with my Cubs hat on. 100% recommend. read more

Get pizza here! The pie was excellent, the staff was right on, and the place was clean and well lit. There were families, couples, folks sitting at the bar. read more

Excellent the best pizza ever had as good as Umbertos in New Hyde Park Long Island. Please make some i Italian dishes

The best pizza I have ever had! Must try! Full pie of anything or else by the slice is great way to experience multiple styles

Great little neighborhood joint. Growing up in Jersey, this pizza was like a slice of home. Thin. A bit floppy. Great sauce. A bit sweet. Lots of options. They have real pizza ovens. Solid beer selection. One TV for the games. Price is reasonable. read more

So good!!! I like veggie, he likes meat, they do a FABULOUS job combining it for us!!! This is the place for a taste of New York!!

Just wow. An authentic New York style pizza by the slice that delivers in Sheboygan. If you have not had by the slice, or love NY style, get to Uptown Slice. My first job was in NYC and I was broke and lived on pizza by the slice. Being from WI, so great to get back but I missed the pizza. Only option was Sal's in Appleton during Mile of Music (don't ask, just go to both - you're welcome). Uptown Slice delivers authentic pizza with the crisp crust, sauce and cheese. The owner goes to NY to study and learn. The true test is the simple cheese slice or go single ingredient. I get a cheese and a sausage slice. The lovely Maureen usually gets a veggie number (we met with NYC so we're both loving it). We add a beer. Cool, small environment. Sheboygans got a winner in Uptown Slice. Try it. read more

amazing pizza, wide variety of slice pizza to whole pizza. Great menu and great service

Excellent pizza. The classic pepperoni pie was great. Small and crispy pepperonis on it and plenty of them

In town from Chicago for the weekend... going back for seconds tonight! My goodness, that pepperoni pie was special... Perfection.

Fantastic pizza! As we were 3 dads taking our collective 4 kids out for pizza, we appreciated that we could buy by the slice so everyone got what they wanted without having to come to a group consensus. As for the pizza, absolutely delicious! The crust was perfect and the toppings were fresh. Great variety in the slices and creative flavor combos. The Bee Sting was my favorite! read more

Awesome, new NY style pizza spot in Sheboygan! I love the option to come in and grab just a slice or two, or order whole pies to go. Becoming a tasty habit! read more

See all

The place has a cool vibe but on the small side. I had a slice of the SAUSAGE GIARDINERA. I got the slice from the case, it was hot, crispy and very taste. I was in and out in 5 mins with my slice to go. I will be returning to try other slices. I great addition to Sheboygan. read more

Uptown Slice - SAUSAGE GIARDINERA - Pizza Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

See all

Great atmosphere , awesome staff, and best pizza i have found outside NYC. STOP IN AND ENJOY. You wouldn't be disappointed

Hi, I love pizza like the next person. I didn't like this pizza at all. I had a slice of sausage pizza and it had no taste at all and what I could taste was the burnt crust and you pay 6 dollars a slice. If this is New York-style pizza you can have it. I will not be going back anytime soon. I paid 38 dollars for 4 slices of pizza and 4 cans of soda what a joke so if you like to overpay for burnt food go for it. I could go to Marcos Pizza and get 4 pizzas for that price and it's a better-tasting pizza. read more

This pizza could be elite with a little something to make the sauce stand out but was still a very good slice. A bit pricey as well but what isn't nowadays? read more

Authentic NJ/NY/CT type pizza, Neopolitan style. When you're craving for that East Coast delicacy, a real pizza pie, look no further than Uptown Slice on Michigan Avenue, the northern section of downtown Sheboygan. This joint is a winner! read more

Great NY style pizza in a very comfortable and relaxed setting. I love that you can walk in and buy just a slice!

This place is AMAZING. I tried one of every slice with my sorority sister, they had a deal going on that you get a 5$ wine or beer with it which we most certainly took advantage of. I tried some flavors I would have normally not tried and I was AMAZED! Great staff and great location. Will definitely be back! read more

stopped in for dinner tonight. Ordered the "bee sting". Had good flavors and was a a good size. It's nice to have some different options in town. Great beer options and friendly staff too. will definitely be back to try some other options. read more