Absolutely amazing experience! The atmosphere was incredible, the food was delicious, and the…read morepeople were wonderful. Everyone was so friendly and welcoming, and our server was absolutely amazing--attentive, friendly, and made the whole experience even better. Everything from the food to the service to the atmosphere was top-notch. You can tell they really care about making sure their customers have a great experience. I'll definitely be coming back and highly recommend this place to anyone looking for great food and amazing service!

I just ate here with my family for the first time. When we got there, shortly after they opened on…read morea Saturday, it was already crowded. Despite that our party of six was seated quickly and we were offered dining room, patio or covered patio tables. We chose the dining room which is cute, dark and unfortunately a bit loud. Our service was good and our server was friendly, but it was difficult to hear her and her us.A couple of us had Manhattans, which were very good, but the glasses were different sizes, which made me think maybe mine was not the same volume. My dad ordered the beef Marsala pasta, which was a generous serving and he seemed to enjoy it. The rest of us ordered different pizzas - everyone liked their choice but there were a couple standouts. The walnut was a revelation, walnut puree, fontina cheese, whipped cream cheese, mushrooms, and roasted walnuts. It was unique and tasty. My truffle pizza was also excellent, with authentic flavor and not the overwhelming fake truffle notes you sometimes get. The sausage pizza was also good, according to my BF.

Fantastic atmosphere and great food! Speakeasy in the basement is by far the best part!read more

The underground bar was the best place we stopped at in Elkhart Lake.. staff and clientele were…read moregreat! The decor was fun and we had so much to look at. Definitely a place all 5 of our party would go back too!!

Sunday brunch was a good value. Food and service were good. Must have a Bloody Mary at the bar…read morebefore dining.

We traveled from Stoughton to try a few supper clubs in the area. Starting our weekend, was the…read moreMillhome Supper Club's Friday seafood buffet. The Millhome has an amazing banquet hall attached to the supper club, reminding us of the Colonial House. When you enter, the bar is straight ahead, and the hostess check-in area is off to your left. We didn't have reservations, but arrived shortly after 4 on a Friday and were seated right away. We had the most amazing waitress! She was so attentive, refilling drinks without being asked, bringing extra napkins, etc. The food was just delicious. The salad bar was so heaping full, talk about not wanting to ruin the perfection when you dig in! There were lots of salad options like potato and macaroni in addition to the greens. They had two soups, and my husband wanted THIRDS and a to go container of their Jalepeno fish chowder. Next up was the main course, the seafood buffet. Your options are mini crab cakes, deep fried scallops, shrimp, baked cod, mashed potatoes, pork, corn, broasted chicken, crab legs, and the most delicious tenderloin tips (my mouth is watering just writing that!). My favorites were the baked cod and the tenderloin tips! Their mashed potatoes and corn paired well with both of course! My husband is crazy for crab legs, so he loaded up on those and the other seafood options. We would love to come visit the Millhome again, as we had such an enjoyable and AFFORDABLE experience!

Excellent. First class environment, proper staff, nice decor, food was great. If it's fall, it can…read moreget pretty noisy with the hard floors and all the people so if you're planning on having a quiet conversation, this is not the place for it. That's not a complaint just an FYI.

This is one of the only restaurants in this quaint town however it was a great option. The space…read morewas large so it could accommodate lots of people. The staff was great and attentive. Food didn't take too long to come out. The cocktails were fun and delicious with local flavors. As for food we loved the octopus and seafood pasta. We also got the broccolini and tortellini, both great but didn't stand out as much as the other two, but really not a bad bite. I would recommend if in the area the town is also cute but nothing really to go out of your way for. Price point was definitely a nicer meal but I enjoyed.

First time here. We drive past alot and always wanted to stop. I think from the outside we were…read morehoping for a little bit more updated style inside. After we sat, I went to the bathroom and I realized there was a back area with a bar, that was a little bit more updated and not such an older feel. I think it would've been nice to have that option suggested to us when we were checking in to sit down as you can not see it when you walk in. The menu had lots of choices however the food was very basic. Nothing was bad necessarily, but nothing led any of us to say "oh yeah, we have to come back here!" The waitress started off very attentive but as people were leaving she seemed very preoccupied with cleaning tables and we sat a while and eventually had to ask for the bill. Not rushing back....

Stopped on our way to Road America, very close to the track. Good breakfast here, friendly service…read more Would go back again.

Elkhart Lake, Wisconsin…read more This place is easily 4 plus stars... have been here perhaps 50 times... always solid. Recently had the Short Ribs - Excellent and the Panini sandwich with Pesto and Burrata - also excellent.

I really enjoyed my meal at Lake Street Cafe in Elkhart Lake. We tried the Mediterranean-style…read moremeatballs and the sea bass. The meatballs were tender, flavorful, and served in a rich tomato sauce with toasted bread. The sea bass was cooked perfectly, with a nice golden crust, and came with spinach, roasted carrots, potatoes, and a creamy sauce. Everything tasted fresh and was presented beautifully. The portions were satisfying without being too heavy. I would definitely eat here again.

Had a great lunch on a recent Sunday. We really enjoyed the corn & sausage chowder, a delicious…read moregochujang chicken sandwich special with the sweet potato fries, and a savory pear + Gorgonzola panini on cinnamon raisin bread with carrots and hummus. Everything was a winner. We sat at the window, overlooking the river. Beautiful setting, attentive service, and a great menu.

Was staying at the American Club in the winter for a spa getaway. Had dinner here on a Friday night…read morewith my wife. It's a weird spot. It's decorated like a cabin but it serves fairly upscale food that doesn't taste very good. As others have mentioned some of the food is too salty. I ordered a pork chop and it was terrible. It was supposed to come with blue cheese and there was virtually none. It was over cooked and charred. Staff was nice but the food does not match the vibe at all. It has the lighting and feel of a ski lodge (the cafeteria kind not the upscale kind). They need to dim the lighting and ease off the salt.

The baked cod in a white wine butter sauce was amazing!! If I wasn't in public, I'd have picked up…read morethe dish it was in and drank it. It was THAT flavorful. Also tried their grilled shrimp risotto... the pesto added to the risotto makes for a delicious flavor profile.

My wife and I went on a Thursday evening for their burger and fry special and drinks. Very few…read morepeople in the restaurant. We were seated and the owner told the waitress that seated is to go home. Slow night. The bartender was to take over but she never came to our table. She tended bar with a few customers and cashed out bar customers and let us sit. She had time to huge some of her friends that were leaving. It was clear we were not going to get service after 15 minutes of waiting. We had menus and water and zero service. We got up and left.