Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Fancy Pizzeria

    4.9 (48 reviews)
    Closed 11:00 am - 2:00 pm, 4:00 PM - 8:00 PM

    Order Fancy Pizzeria Takeout or Delivery

    Fancy Pizzeria Photos

    FANCY PIZZERIA ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Casual
    Good for groups
    Dogs allowed

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Fancy Pizzeria

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Victoria B.

    On the day we visited, DH and I were the first customers of the day. We were cautioned that the first orders take just a little longer to fulfill as the kitchen is just getting started for the day. We sat at the huge wraparound windows, listened to Italian crooners on the sound system and people watched while we waited. DH ordered a pepperoni pie and I ordered the Fungi pie, a wood mushroom pizza and added sausage as advised on one of the signs in the restaurant. Delicious! As I understand it, the sauce, crust and real lemonade are all made by hand in house with specially filtered water. That certainly explains the epic taste. Our hostess was especially engaging. She noticed our license plates weren't local and we spent so much time chatting DH was afraid my food would get cold. This was a great experience and the best reason to support local businesses.

    Gluten-free mushroom, spinach, and artichoke pizza
    Michele W.

    This is a delightful Gila Valley find. I had tried it before, but they were out of gluten free dough (the chef apologized that they'd had a delay in their caputo flour delivery--the special order secret ingredient in their dough). I had a salad, which was tasty, but didn't scratch the pizza itch. Fast forward a couple months and I found myself back in Safford. I was greeted warmly by the owner/hostess/waitress, who remembered the week they didn't have gluten-free flour and thanked me for returning. Before I looked at the menu, she warned me off the white sauces that are made with flour (I appreciated her being proactive on that so that I didn't get my heart set on something I couldn't have). I built my own mushrooms, spinach and artichoke cheese pizza. And...wow. Just wow. I was diagnosed celiac about 7 years ago, and this was the first pizza I've had that actually felt like pizza. It was delicious! I practically danced in my seat. I raved so much to the owner (wish i'd gotten her name) that she brought her husband/owner/chef (wish I'd gotten his name too!) to hear. He said it was important to him to get the proper "mouth-feel" and flavor so that everyone could enjoy the experience. This is next-level customer service. This will be my go-to restaurant whenever I'm in the Gila Valley. I need to go with more people, though, so that I can also try the garlic knots made with that delightful dough! It would be worth a detour wherever you are headed in south eastern AZ to enjoy the great food and warm hospitality of this hidden gem.

    Conal B.

    Wonderful privately owned pizza place with a laid-back atmosphere Very polite and personable service. The food was absolutely delicious and I really enjoyed the fresh made lemonade. Highly recommend.

    SW BBQ Chicken Pizza
    Chandra M.

    I came here because of the Yelp reviews and boy am I glad we did! Small place but they are expanding so that's good. Great pizza, beautiful light crust not too much sauce. Potato salad was great as well, just like mom's. Very friendly owner, I truly hope his business thrives!

    Pepperoni Pizza - "well done"
    Sarah S.

    Best pizza around by a long shot! My wife and I found Fancy Pizzeria after reading some scuttlebutt online about the grand opening. We live quite a ways out of town, but figured it would be a nice date night in the big city. We were not disappointed. In fact, we were ecstatic to find this place. Not only was the food delectable, but the atmosphere was nice and chill, and the staff was friendly and warm. I had the regular pepperoni pizza "well done" because I like a crispier finish to my crust. My wife had the gluten free pizza with pepperoni, mushrooms and olives. She's probably a tougher critic than me, because most gluten free pizzas are hot and miss. She said this is her favorite pizza ever, and judging by her reaction after each bite, I know she's not lying It's been several months since our first visit and we have been back many times. We can't say enough good things about food, the ambiance, and the staff and owners. We love this place so much that we recommend it to our friends and family...and even the occasional stranger on the street. If you're looking through yelp reviews to help you decide which pizza place is best...save your time, stop reading this and go to Fancy Pizzeria. They have something for everyone. There are other mouthwatering items on the menu, but honestly, I love their pepperoni pizza and crust so much that I never try anything else.

    Marinara
    Angela M.

    Service was terrific! That was the positive to the experience. Drive thru pickup. I was able to add two bags of ice at the window. Amazing ice that doesn't melt quickly might I add. Friendly staff working. Slight wait behind another customer on arrival but in and out quickly overall. Why I'm in the middle... the food had so much left to be desired. Enjoyed the bread on the garlic knots but where was the garlic? I may have higher expectations of a stronger flavor? The marinara taste ok but was very thin. The pizzas were dry. I understand wood fired but there wasn't great flavor either. It was ok. Don't enjoy the lack of sizes and the price was a bit high for the pizza. I would have gotten extra cheese on the bambino because it felt like it was on half the pizza. We did get a free pizzookie because the order was over $50 but that's the downfall too. Two 12" pizzas w/1 extra veggie topping and garlic knots was $59 subtotal. Steep for what it was. Not bad, not great experience. Would try again hoping to have better outcome. There's sandwiches I had my eye on.

    Caprese-style salad with grilled chicken and a side of fresh potato salad

    See all

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Hands down best place to eat in town! Margherita pizza is a must try. Service was great! Atmosphere was cozy.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Fancy Pizzeria

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    R&R Pizza Express

    R&R Pizza Express

    3.7
    (63 reviews)
    1.8 mi
    $$

    Family dinner - with allllll the fixings!!! Pizza, salad, wings, and we also tried the zeppoles for…read morethe first time! The salad bar is always so fresh, so that is a definite must have for us ! I was desperately trying to relive my glory days of Louisiana beignets by ordering the zeppoles, but they are not as doughy and were not beignets ... nevertheless they were good, slightly crunchy and served with a vanilla custard/pudding. The pizzas were yummy, but you know me ... I am an extra sauce kind of gal so next time I'll ask for extra sauce . I wanted to get the wings extra crispy, but they said they didn't have time to do that. They were actually quite busy and we did go at the peak time of dinner so I understand. I did, however, get my extra sauce so that made me happy although I only ate two wings. What I love most is that they have a couple of video games that you can play in a small designated area! This was great for the kids!! It was quiet inside and plenty of space for everyone, I do love the casual atmosphere! We really enjoyed our time here and will definitely be back!

    Another successful pizza party after a week-long training class! Stopped by two days before and…read morePeyton was very helpful. Ordered extra large meat lovers, supreme, pepperoni, and two orders of wings. Delivered on time and just as good as previous pizza party. Service and quality are great! Dependable and what else can you ask for today! Put this one on your list.

    Photos
    R&R Pizza Express
    Buffet Salad for 10
    Buffet Salad for 10
    Left to right, Veggie and Pepperoni; Meat Lovers; and Pineapple with Ham and Bacon

    See all

    Left to right, Veggie and Pepperoni; Meat Lovers; and Pineapple with Ham and Bacon
    La Unica Restaurant & Tortilleria

    La Unica Restaurant & Tortilleria

    4.3
    (367 reviews)
    40.6 mi
    $$
    Family-owned & operated
    Pet friendly

    After a long wait at another Mexican restaurant, we walked over to La Unica Restaurant &…read moreTortilleria and I'm so glad we did! We were seated right away on the patio, which was a great start. Our waitress was very attentive, and the service stayed consistent the entire time. The food was chef's kiss. The rice was excellent, and the fajita platter my husband and I shared was flavorful and more than enough. The margaritas were on point too. We ordered the huge Cadillac margarita and it did not disappoint. This will definitely be our go-to spot every time we're in Willcox for the wine festival!

    It was crowded due to annual wine festival but we were seated quickly. Lovely patio seating…read more Chips and salsa to start. Nice menu, plenty of libations to choose from. Mezcal margarita delicious. Food choices numerous, including breakfast options! All your favorite Mexican dishes were available. Food was great, nicely plated, and delicious. I was delighted with our patio seating. People watching always a treat. This is a gem, serving local families, tourists and wine festival attendees without batting an eye. Food allergies not a problem,.... Just let them know and they are happy to accommodate. Great experience. Thanks!

    Photos
    Lime and salt pairs well with tequila. Sorry we don't make the rules.
    Lime and salt pairs well with tequila. Sorry we don't make the rules.
    Fried Ice Cream, anyone?
    Fried Ice Cream, anyone?
    La Única proudly serves our local Willcox Wine. We have a variety of red and white wines!

    See all

    La Única proudly serves our local Willcox Wine. We have a variety of red and white wines!

    Fancy Pizzeria - pizza - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...