This is by far my favorite pizza place! The staff is always super friendly and fast! We've sat down at lunch time, and it was great service! We typically do take out, and it's always just as fresh! Their pizzas has the most cheese, and the best sauce ever! read more

Love the food, love the service, and love the ambiance! This is my favorite stop every time I'm coming through middleville! read more

See all

Pizza is amazing, always made to perfection. The sauce is what separates Faros from everyone else, it's unique and awesome. I highly recommend Faro's in Middleville MI. read more

I have blown this place off for about 2 years and what a mistake I had been making. This place is my new favorite and will be my #1 delivery food choice moving forward. Meatball platter was perfect. Best cannoli ever and must order item each and every time. The red sauce made is so sweet and delicious. My new favorite place and took me 2 years to try it and that was my bad. read more

Faro's is a Middleville institution. I Love this place, always have.. even when Phil's was still in town, it was still hard for me to choose one or the other.. since I was like 10 years old, I've dug their food. The food is good, the dining room service is a bit slow and the location just seems a bit janky and under-maintained... but I don't mind when the food is this good. They happily deliver and they know how to make good pizza. I do wish that they offered beer with dinner though. It seems like their location right next to the river and not far from the Paul Henry trail could really be a good spot for outdoor enthusiasts and locals alike. I've wanted to take a kayak down the river and stop here for lunch several times, I just haven't made it happen quite yet. The sauce is good, the crust is good, and they know how to brown the top of the pizza like it should be browned. All I've had are pizzas and sandwiches here, but I think that's all I need. read more

Do not, I repeat do not take your coat off in this place. It was 38 degrees out side and barely 50 inside. The pizza got cold being carried across the dining room from the kitchen. So much for the embiance. The pizza was amateurish. The cheese was not melted on most of it and the Toppings were still cold under the cheese. Obviously made by someone who didn't care. The crust was raw and paper thin in the center and thick and overdone around the edges. Maintenance issues everywhere. You can do better almost anywhere else. read more

Pretty impressed with this small town's quality of pizza. Ordered a deluxe pizza and cheese bread that were both better than expected. Fresh tasting toppings without the greasy taste that is typical from chain pizza joints. Price was up there but worth it in my opinion for what you get! read more

Middleville classic! Quality pizza every time and brings back memories of growing up here. Recommend olive pizza

Pizza and breadsticks are a little greasy but it's real good. They make my favorite BLT pizza better then most places. Good place to take the baseball team after a game. read more

Made a mistake last week. I put my review under a Faro's in Grand Rapids. That being said, this place was ok The service and food were pretty good, but the cleanliness was lacking in a large way. There dead bugs in the window sills and the bathrooms were (for lack a a nicer word)... gross!! They obviously hadn't been cleaned in days if not weeks. On cleanliness alone, we probably won't be back. read more

The pizza was great! First timer from out of town and was not disappointed in how much cheese was piled on! Small little dining area was nice as well. read more

By far my favorite restaurant in Middleville. My family has been eating here for nearly 5 years, and we continue to be amazed each time we eat here. The food is always superb and much of it is homemade, while the service always feels like you're being greeted by family. The manicotti is my favorite. Though whichever dish you decide upon, you'll be served loads of food for little money. I also really like how the owner supports the local community and the sports teams, my son being on one of them. Faro's brings the small town charm and great food that make this a standout restaurant in Middleville. read more

Authentic Italian food. Delicious sauce and pizza. Want to try homemade pasta next time.

I grew up in Middleville in the 80s and 90s this is by far the best hometown Italian restaurant there is around the area.

Looks like they fixed their hours, or closed and reopened. Still not sure what was up with that, but they're open every night now. The pizza is still pretty average. I love the garlic knots, but that's not really enough for me to want to order a whole pizza. Delivery is pretty quick, so points for that. read more

We used to go here all the time however the service and quality have faltered of late. Today we waited for 10 minutes at the counter before being acknowledged by anyone despite there being 4 persons working. After waiting 40 minutes past the estimated time they had said it would be ready they then screwed up the order. Perhaps ownership has changed, but it will be a long time before we go there again. read more

Good pizza and great other items. Whether it pasta, burritos, or subs there non pizza food is great, and the pizza is pretty good too. They normally can get the order prepared fast. I've never had it delivered so I can't speak to how fast they deliver. read more

Pizza has great sauce and is the best around. The wet burritos are also better than anyone else offers in town.