I love this place. Always had friendly personal service, usually the only people in there and the gyro pizza is incredible. Check them out!

First time visit, we ate in. The pizza was fine. Wish they offered garlic bread bc the smell of baking bread from the parking lot had us curious about that bread. The gyro was ok with very, very good pita. Service was friendly and nice. Don't know that we would go out of our way again to return, but certainly would be a consideration for pizza if in the area. read more

Surprised Mainly, I was surprised by the cost 35.50 for a large everything pizza. Yelp doesn't really give that kind of price although Facebook is much closer. U could feed three or four with this large pizza it's just not my thing For 35 bucks/ I can get a pizza and a couple beers. It was pretty good tasting probably 80%.good Thick almost pan pizza read more

Some of the best pizza in Peoria, but absolutely laughable and tiresome wait time. 1.5hrs for a single small pizza, after already being told the wait would be 1hr. This is my second time trying it after a similar first experience, I won't have my time wasted again. read more

Had a spinach pizza and a New Yorker tonight and I'm amazed at how perfect it was, best food in Peoria.

Amazing owner, kind and very personable makes the absolute best pizzas in Peoria! His sandwiches are all wonderful, as well! He uses real, fresh ingredients and he doesn't limit the toppings like the fast food pizza shops. Yeah, you might pay a little more but I guarantee it will be the best pizza you have ever had. I lived in Chicago for years and visited New York a lot, and I feel Fedora beats them all! If you go you will meet the most incredibly nice young man who is the proprietor. I can't imagine anyone being disappointed! You will never want a Papa John's again! read more

Pretty haunted Pizza joint like but pretty damn good spinach pizza but not cheap and no door dash or GrubHub read more

Fedora's Pizza & Deli - Inside - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Illinois

See all

Always great flavor and awesome service. Not in the best location but the food cannot be judged by that. I got a small 6 topping pizza and was full off of 2 pcs. Pizza cooked just right and toppings were plentiful but not overwhelming. I would give the pizza 10 stars if I couldtrip read more

See all

This was a hole in the wall in a questionable neighborhood but once we walked in, we were glad we made the decision. This establishment has been here for over 30 years, and the owner was there and the pizza was the best I've ever had. They like to put a lot of cheese on their pizza and it was just really delicious. We are from Virginia and wanted a Chicago pizza and we got one. I highly recommend this place Just not after dark lol! :-) read more

My son-in-law bought your beautifully delicious pepperoni pizza tonight! Thanks for speedy service and delicious pizza! read more

See all

Pizza is absolutely fantastic. For all the cheese lovers out there, it is piled on to a soft spongey crust with delicious sauce. The place itself is a little hole in the wall type of place with limited seating but don't let that stop you from enjoying a torpedo in the store! The wait time for the pizza was on the longer side but it was accurate with what was estimated. The people are friendly and make it an overall great experience. read more

Hidden gem in Peoria! Best pizza and sandwiches I have ever had. Gyro pizza is unbelievable. I can barely finish 2 pieces.

Update 2022: Still the best pizza I have ever had! Drive from pekin just to get it! Owner runs the place. read more

I've been coming here since 1995 and everything has always been great. The gyros, pizzas, and sandwiches are all fantastic! It's definitely a hidden gem in the city read more

greatest pizza ever tasted, from chin chicago!! This business needs expansion!!!! Absolutely theeeeeee beeeeessttt!!!!

Flat out best pizza in Peoria. I've had their sandwiches and salads and have been excellent. The portions are not for the faint of heart. Your biceps and belly will grow after a couple of pieces. Wish they were open on Sunday for football as I'd order more often. Try the meat pizza. read more

Current menu as of Nov 28, 2021. My first time ... I loved it. Super good!!! All fresh, nothing frozen, made to order. I swear that pizza weighed every bit of 5lbs. Thank you, Nibil, my jeans are tight!!! read more

See all

Very good pizza, cooked to just the right doneness, great cheese and lots of it. Owner/owning family great people.

I was fine waiting an hour for take-out, but then when I arrived I still had a long wait, in total it was an hour and a half from when I ordered to when I had the pizza, sandwich, and salad. The New Yorker was big enough for two people, and tasted good, but was soggy from the coleslaw. The garden salad was a lot for the price, and was not wilted. The sausage and onion pizza was the big draw, and it was fine. I liked the cheese and sausage, but the dough was bland, and there wasn't a nice crust edge to hold onto. It was higher quality than chain pizza, but it's not worth waiting so long for pizza unless it's deep dish. read more

He never misses a beat!! 2 separate trips but both pizzas were amazing, hot and fresh made consistent every time!! The owner is friendly and in tune with each pie he makes!! read more

Fedora's Pizza & Deli - Pizzas - 2 separate visits both great pies!! - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Illinois

See all

Absolutely amazing!! Try the gyro pizza. Amazing value! Left with more food than we could eat- leftovers for days! Fantastic, friendly service. The energy of the place was incredible as well. Best pizza in Peoria! Gyro Pizza was my fave. read more

Veg Sandwich was huge and loaded! Service was excellent, you can see the owner tries hard to please. Decent sized cafeteria style seating inside Looks like a good work-lunch crowd kind of place There's a small parking lot next door read more

Yum yum yum!!! I absolutely love everything about the food. The pizza and sandwiches are amazing! All of the ingredients taste fresh and the food is made to order. My favorites are the Taco Pizza and any of the subs. I'm usually not a fan of toasted subs but once they add all of the toppings.......... this is the type of food you dance while eating because it's so yummy. The prices are great for the quality and taste. read more

Fedora's Pizza & Deli - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Illinois

Best pizza in Peoria! Order ahead because it takes awhile, but this is the best pizza in the area.

We called ahead and the chef put our spinach/white sauce pizza in for us to eat in. The chef served us. Crust has delicious flavor. It's soft, neither thick nor thin. White sauce is so good, and there's plenty of spinach, which is how I like it. He can make anything taste amazing. He made us an iceberg chef salad, and it was so satisfying. I can't wait to return to try the gyro pizza. Call ahead and plan to wait. It's worth it. read more

Cheese pizza for the kiddo and Spicy Italian sandwich for me (with everything). Both were amazing. The cheese pizza is no joke a cheese pizza. Lots of cheese and nice crust. My kiddo didn't eat more than 2 slices because he got so full. Spicy Italian sandwich is HUGE. You can definitely share this with someone and still be full. Bread is perfectly toasted which makes this a winner. FYI order in advance. Takes about 20-30 minutes for pizza. read more

Fedora's Pizza & Deli - Spicy Italian - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Illinois

See all

After hearing how good the food was here from a friend I decided to stop in the next day. I literally have past this place almost everyday for years..I called in my order (large Gryo pizza) . Was told 45 min. Ok not bad since I heard it's made fresh. I get there place is nothing special but it's not dirty or anything. Just very plain. The owner is super friendly..and I could tell he's passionate about his food. He brings it out and tells me to open the box and check it out..OMG it looked soo freaking good. I picked up the box and it was heavy.. we get home and dig in and it was heaven in my mouth. I'm a big eater and I was full after 1 and a half slices.. I will definitely be coming back and suggest if you love yourself then you should too. I'm going to try some of the sandwiches and salads next time. Side note. The tomatoes on the pizza were delicious by themselves. read more

Fedora's Pizza & Deli - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Illinois

Wow! Came in on a Friday night. No one was in the restaurant but orders were backed up. There was only one person working and he was apologitic when telling us it would be an hour for our pizza. Thankfully we decided to order and took our things to the hotel while we waited. The restaurant is not conducive for eating in. Only about four tables with one chair at each table and I didn't see any soda machine so I'm not sure what types of drinks they have. We ordered a large pepperoni, Italian sausage, ham and mushrooms (we also wanted bacon but they had run out). We asked about extra cheese and he said he's never had anyone complain about how much he puts on so we left it alone. After about 45 minutes we returned to pick up our pizza and it was hot and ready. We requested plates and napkins which were given with a smile. The crust was thick but the sauce made it a bit soggy on the bottom but not enough to make it fall apart. Toppings were plentiful, big chunks and fresh. The sauce was delicious with that definite home made taste. The cheese was enough and tasty. Our 14 inch was $19, so not too bad. Parking is in the back and again since it doesn't seem like an eat in place the parking wasn't a problem. The order taker/pizza maker was very friendly even though he was extremely busy. He made jokes and was pleasant both times coming in. I would definitely recommend this place for take out! read more

Damn! This is some fine pizza. I came in here on a Tuesday night because I had been in here before. I remembered that the place was a bit funky but the pizza was acceptable. Flash forward, I visit this place and it's still a bit funky, but not as funky as I remembered. Also there is a different guy behind the counter, I didn't ask for his name, but he was so friendly and engaging. Made me feel like he appreciated my business. I ordered sausage, mushrooms and extra cheese. The sucker came out in about 20 minutes. Man! I ordered the 14 inch large and the thing must have weighed at least 4 pounds. It was just loaded with toppings, and flavor? One of the best pizza's I've eaten. Whole thing cost about 21 bucks. Did I mention that the guy behind the counter was a great guy. Seriously, you can only take this surly counter act so far, I love it when a person aims to please. If it wasn't for the fact that this place is three hours from my house, I'd go back right now. read more

The pizza is a legend and worth the wait wait. Do yourself a favor and order one this weekend. We had the gyro style and it was unique but delicious. read more

Pizza and sandwiches were absolutely delicious. Got the brave pizza w/ 5 toppings (pep, ham, saus, green olv and jalp) and 2 New Yorker sandwiches and a dinner salad. I have no idea how he turns a profit piling that much meat and cheese on his pizza and sammies. It was a workout carrying them to the truck. Only downfall..... if he says he is "very busy!!" On the phone taking your order...... be prepared to wait awhile. Don't go in there in a hurry. But the unrushed product is worth it! read more

Finally there is a place I have found in Peoria IL to take people to if you want to torture them. The waiting time is out of this world and then what they call pizza finishes them off and your potential date says "take me home now". If your looking for revenge on someone, take them to Fedora's. There slogan should be call ahead so you only have a 45 min wait when you arrive. :( read more

I wish I could give this more than 5 stars! I have lived in peoria for 28 years and can't believe it took me this long to find Fedoras. All of the specialty sandwiches are made with soft homemade bread. All of his pizzas are made with true homemade dough. I got the New Yorker sandwich that had a touch of Fedoras homemade dressing! The combination of the pastrami, corned beef, Sauerkraut, mayo, mustard, homemade dressing, and Swiss cheese was a perfect blend that sent your taste buds to the moon! The meat and cheese tasted clean, not your processed deli meat you get at a subway or Jimmy johns. Fedoras also had amazing customer service. It's everything you hope for in a hole in the wall restaurant. read more

Fedora's Pizza & Deli - New Yorker - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Illinois

Don't let the scenery fool you, this place is DELICIOUS! Not expensive either with big portions

35 minutes for a sandwich...a sandwich. That's absolutely unacceptable no matter how good the food. Maybe have two people for cooking/preparation during lunch hours. I will not be back as that is horrendous. read more

This was recommended to me by someone whose car broke down in front of it 10 years ago. Otherwise, how else would you stumble upon Fedora's. It doesn't seem to invite customers in, but the food makes you glad you took the chance. Had a pizza and a sandwich, I think an Italian combo. They were both good. I will definitely return. read more

I always see this place as I pass by in my sweet trench coat. I figured I was due for a new fedora anyhow so I decided to walk in to this promised dreamland of amazing headwear. Alas I was wrong, dead wrong. Thinking that I was walking into a magic abode of fedoras it was in fact a pizza place. My neckbeard was becoming cold so I decided to order something and stay a while. All I could think about was my waifu pillow and how I hoped she was okay. As my pizza came I felt this euphoria come over me, it was great. I ate my pizza and drank my mountain dew and left. I'm never coming back until you rename or start selling classy fedoras. 4/5 read more

My wife and I stopped in with our two kids and everyone wanted something different so we got two small pizzas, a sandwich, and a gyro. Our order could have fed eight people and it was all delicious! The pizzas had a great hand tossed crust with tons of toppings and the layers of cheese were just as thick as the crusts. The gyro could have filled two pitas and there were giant stacks of cheeses on the cheese sandwich. read more

This is the only place that I order a veggie sandwich. It's ridiculously huge, messy and one of my favorite sandwiches ever. I really want to try their gyro, but can't stop ordering the same thing. Super nice owner with great service. read more

While I am sure the deli sandwiches at Fedora's are probably great, I have only had the pizza and it is some of the best you are going to find in Peoria. It is a thicker hand-tossed crust, with plenty of cheese and great toppings. The prices are great too. Definitely check this place out if you have a chance, you won't be disappointed. The owner is friendly, and he works hard to make great food. read more