First time going into this toy store, amazing service! The lady behind the counter was super…read morefriendly, greeted us when we walked in and made an effort to get to know us and what ours needs were. She was very warm and welcoming, showed us in the right direction of what we were shopping for. Highly recommend and will definitely be back! Thank you for such a great experience! She also has the best selection of toys!

Such a gem! After being in town a few days and driving past Blue Turtle Toys multiple times, we had…read moreto pop in! They carry the best selection of unique toys for all ages and interests! High quality brands at fair prices - you can't leave without buying a few goodies! We will be back next time we're in town!

Had a good time going through the isles. Recommend a visit for nostalgia reasons alone.read more

This place is an amazing shop filled with nostalgia of old. With twist and turns for collectibles…read more It comes off kind of crowded, but the displays are actually well organized works of art. It is a place of things not needed as a norm, but for a collector as myself I could go broke over the amazing things they have. The workers are pleasant and have their own uniqueness which makes the experience even more enjoyable.

Good mix of stuff. Good prices. Mix of old and new collectibles. Friendly staff…read more Organization is a hot mess but it was fun looking through things.

If I could rate less than 1 star I would, worst dudes running a game store period. Not in it for…read morethe culture take your money elsewhere

Wonderful place! Great value and service! Large selection!! Great Value!!! Great Prices!!read more

Friendly owner and staff who seem to genuinely love what they do. This place had a lot of stuff…read moresprinkled in and it was great. Think all the standards (Star Wars, DC, Marvel, etc) and A LOT of lesser known things. True vintage board games, lunch boxes, etc. the perfect place to go with/shop for a collector. Prices seem a little higher than what would be on eBay, but then when you factor in eBay shipping it evens out a lot of times. Plus it's more fun.

Yellow Springs Toy Company is a chock-filled shop that seems to sell every toy ever invented. The…read moreage range of items is from newborns to seniors. There are bath toys, books, and blocks. There are plushy, puzzles, and puppets. You get the idea. And to top it off, there's a very friendly lady there to help sort it all out for you. The only drawback to the store is that the building is old and not ADA compliant. The entry is via very steep stairs and no landing. It's kind of scary and I'm glad there are handrails. For those with mobility issues, don't worry, as there is in-store pick up, local delivery, and US shipping.

What a fun find in the heart of downtown Yellow Springs! I'm wondering if they're new-ish given…read morethat I'm the first to review this business on Yelp. I'm a sucker for a toy store that sports creative and educational toys. Nine times out of ten I walk out with a purchase either for myself or the kiddos in my life. This visit was no exception. We ended up purchasing these fun stickers that convert a cardboard box into a car (they also had versions that create a mini play kitchen - how fun?!). The shop was filled with educational items - engineering, arts/creative, invention toolkits, art history, etc. They also have a small section in the front with quirky items like a mustached baby pacifier. My only reason for holding back on the fifth star was that some of the tchotchke style items seemed overpriced to a point that I couldn't justify spending more for local - for example $17 sunglasses for kiddos.

This is one of the best experiences I have had at a store. Everyone was so kind and helpful and…read moreMaya was truly amazing. I can't wait to go back, thankful to have a place to find MTG cards that doesn't make you feel super intimidated and everyone just wanted to help. Very different from other comic stores I have been to.

This is the best comic and card shop around. I enjoy the friendly staff and how well stocked…read moreeverything is. They have the absolute best prices in town and always gives the customer a fair price. I highly recommend this Dayton Gem!!

- check Amazon prices before you buy. Some are higher, some are lower…read more - They offer 10% off $1-$99 and 15% off $100+. - Check our sone adorable children's books! - There's a game room in the back where you can play board games with others!

I highly recommend this very unique store​. Great selection of comics, books, and collectibles…read more Everything is nicely organized and very clean. These are quality items. I've always received top dollar when selling my comics here. The owner is very friendly and knowledgeable. Don't bother going anywhere else.