I walked in for dinner and headed to the right side of the room. Instead of taking the path to the cash registers to order I opted to use one of their kiosks, which was super easy. With so many topping choices it was easier to just touch screen pictures than asking a staff member to list what my choices are and for him to listen to what I wanted. That means my only interaction with people working there was thanking the guy who called my number and handed me my bag of food. That went well. As for the food, I got their Bacon Cheeseburger and a milkshake with a coffee mix-in. The burger was large, a little messy, and delicious, two hands needed. I didn't like the milkshake. I had seen on their website Five Guys had decided to offer the coffee mix-in permanently and assumed it was popular and that it would be similar to coffee ice cream. Nope, it wasn't. It was not sweet, it tasted like just adding strong drip coffee to the vanilla ice cream base. I'm sure I would have liked another of their dozen mix-ins options more. Five Guys has free peanuts. I didn't indulge but I saw other customers taking advantage of this perk. This Five Guys has plenty of indoor seating and also some tables outside. The place felt clean, what with all the red & white shiny walls. A very distinctive look, complete with bags of potatoes stored in the dining area. read more

Five Guys - Bacon Cheeseburger - Burgers Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

Yes, as a vegetarian, I should know better than try a burger joint. Yet so many are with it, offering at the very least a beyond burger as a reasonable replacement. Their "veggie" sandwich may be super cheap, but that because it's just peppers and onions. Definitely not worth it. So...we come for the fries as a quick treat when we're working in the area. And I have to say, WHY IN THE WORLD DO YOU DUMP ALL THE FRIES ON TOP OF YOUR SANDWICHES!! We ordered a grilled cheese sandwich...somewhere under here. And this isn't the first time they've done this. I don't quite understand not putting them in any container so the bag gets grease-soaked, and any sandwiches are hidden under them. If it's a marketing deal, I don't think it's helpful. They did give me the equivalent of a whole container of napkins... read more

Five Guys - Hidden under there is a sandwich... - Burgers Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

Undercooked fries, cold and soggy burgers, had one bite and returned to the store. Hope nobody gets sick from this Five Guys. The worst experience for $40 I've ever had. So sad to see a good chain be represented so poorly. read more

Cooked to order, fresh and hot, delicious. Served up in just a few minutes by friendly people read more

Took my son here yesterday before playing golf. He ordered a cheese burger and regular fries plus a drink. i I ordered a regular hamburger and a drink. We enjoyed the salted peanuts in the shell while waiting. The burgers and the fries are some of the best around however our order came to $35. I couldn't believe how much they have raised their prices over the last couple of years. So I mark them as a gauging restaurant. I'll stick to Culver's which is over 30% cheaper. Service was good . Simple counter service with self serve drinks. Simple fast food interior with no drive through. read more

Yumm!! The burger and fries were perfect. Cheeseburger with raw onion, tomato, lettuce, mayo ketchup mustard and the Cajun fries on the side or the fries little they give you so much! The lady taking my order was pleasant and the place was clean. read more

See all

Unfortunately this place has gone downhill. Since they switched to frozen, their beef lacks flavor so that what was one a treat, is now a disappointment Had to drown my burger in salt and ketchup. Please go back to fresh beef! Fries were good though read more

Had the burger all the way very yummy and so big!!! Just order a regular fries because you get a half of a bag full and they are very good too. Even enjoyed a few peanuts. read more

Five Guys - All the way Hamburger - Burgers Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

Firstly, the burgers and fries are good and what you'd expect from any Five Guys location. As per usual you are inundated with more fries than you could ever possibly eat, but they're tasty. My burger was juicy and toppings were correct though my bun was struggling to hold it together. My lack of stars comes from the lack of milkshakes and the lack of notification online about no milkshakes. You can order online. It allows you to add a milkshake with mix-ins to your cart. Then the cart will glitch but not say something useful like "no milkshakes at this location". So you presume you can just go place the order at the restaurant for everything. No. Annoying since this was the draw of going to this particular chain. But you're already there, so you guess it's just burgers. Argh. read more

Oiled and greased machine who delivers end result perfectly every time. And amazing cashier!

I've never been, came here to read reviews but decided to review the pictures which are "gross" that burger looks awful and the fries greasy. Thank you Yelp for saving me money read more

Yes... I went to the original Five Guys in Washington DC and this place is pretty good. It isn't "as good" but it's a good average of Five-guys good. The place is clean, the fries are delish and oily and the burger is packed with flavor. I was slightly disappointed with the amount of fires they put in my bag. It wasn't the usual heap-o-fries I've become accustomed to. It was barely the small order I asked for. (Big crying face) but any way I suppose my wife is happy that I didn't eat the additional 1000 calories of fries. But it did detract from the experience. Booo read more

This is a great spot for a good hamburger and for a good price. I bought the little bacon cheeseburger for $6.50 and it was delicious and filling read more

Five Guys - Burgers Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

I ordered a veggie sandwich. Who would have thunk? Sautéed peppers, onions, mushrooms, fresh lettuce and tomatoes on a bun all under 250 calories. I'm addicted and will be back. Service was amazing and it was all fresh. read more

Great hot dog with the works. Perfectly cooks, fabulous flavor. Lots of choices for toppings. Fries are quality magnificent. Great treat!!!

Who could ever post a bad review about this business? Such great burgers, good fries and friendly staff.

No milkshakes at this location? Cashier had me thinking I was crazy, had to look up the five guys menu online to see they do serve milkshakes but not at this store apparently. read more

Sooooo good! They grill your burger in front of you. You also get to pick your condiments. Delicious fries that they overload you with. Bring it on. Definitel a food fight I can conquer, but not an easy task. Its filling!!!! read more

Five Guys - Burgers Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

I walked in with 5 min before they closed. They were SOOOO curious and friendly and made an excellent meal. Love love LOVE this place.

Burger was near perfect. Little bit pricey but man those dogs sure are good eating. Had me barking

If you have patience it is worth it. They make all orders fresh so the quality is always the highest the fries are hand cut and the best period. The burgers customizable entirely. I just get jalapeno and cheese on mine for some delicious heat. And I am always treated so well, that's why I also make sure to deliver for them if I get an order on a gig app too... that and the food is so good read more

Always a delicious quick bite! I come to This location and never have a had a problem it's always enjoyable and clean also friendly staff members! read more

Their vegetarian option is sautéed peppers and onions on a bun. Seriously? You can't even get a mediocre Sysco veggie burger? And I don't see the rave about the French fries. I thought they were awful. I don't find carrying around a dripping, greasy bag to be a bragging right. No thanks! read more

Best place for French fries ! Large orders cooked to order. Highly recommend this place. Burgers are decent as well

"Little fry"! Finally!!!! Perfect. Love the fresh jalapenos!!! Burgers are amazing. read more

Crowded, but tasty Tons of people there when we went in. But fast service, 5 guys burgers and of course plenty of fries. Try eating out doors. Nice to get out of the crowd. Not much to see though, more of a "I need some space" move. read more

We have gone to several Five Guys all over the East Coast & a couple here in FL. Yum! Just remember the Fries are HUGE portions! Lots to share with friends & family. Funny location, in a mall, by bookstore & right next to Weight Watchers, either brilliant or sadistic, not sure. Plenty of parking, some shaded (good for FL). Folks working this location very friendly, professional. Gets busy for lunch. Hard to get our of this mall area, we kept getting into bank turn arounds. Otherwise, great location! read more

Five Guys - Burgers Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

Well, the New Five Guys fails miserably!! Called the order in, I was 2 mins away. Paid for it and waited, waited & waited. Finally, went to the register and asked about my number...oh your food is over here, they said. Got home and everything is soggy! Nasty! $23 dollars later for 2 hamburgers, 2 fries & 2 drinks. I am not happy and won't be going back. I normally get a "call in" hamburger at Applebee's across the street. But, I wanted to give these "Guys" a try. With Applebee's I can have my fries cooked with NO salt, crisp and my hamburger wrapped so that I put it all together when I get home and it is NOT A SOGGY GOO! Plus, the flavor of the burger at Applebee's is the way a burger should taste, grilled. 2 THUMBS DOWN 5 GUYS! read more

The people are really nice and the fries hands down are the best in all of the land and I LOVE fries! The management and staff were great too. read more

Very good service and high quality burgers! I recommend the fast food read more

This place sucks, food is gross and way over priced. I went there because Hooters was crowded, worst mistake of my life. I'd rather go to Burger King and I hate burger king. Over hyped fast food restaurant read more

Funny how this is the 2nd establishment I visited that has 2 Yelp pages, but at least I figured out it's because the addresses are off by 1-digit. I decided to write my review on the correct address: 6593 S Tamiami Trl vice the wrong address: 6595 S Tamiami Trl. The burgers and fries are good, but for the price there are better places. I haven't visited too many burger joints in the area so far, but if I'm paying $10+ for a Bacon Cheeseburger, fries, and drink, it better be really good. I've been to other Five Guys places in the Mid-west and West Coast that seemed to have a little more WOW that's all. read more

I go here often, the management staff is very friendly as are the team members. The order is always correct. This is my go-to for a great burger and fries. They run a very clean restaurant. Best 5 Gs I've ever visited. read more

My friends told me "Their fries are the BEST!!!" My husband and I tried and it was true! sooooo delicious!!! People are so friendly here and very clean atmosphere. We ate warm peanuts while we waited for our foods. I love "free topping" *^^* I got grilled onion, grilled mushroom, pickles and mayo. fries are so so so good!!! read more

If you like their burgers then you will enjoy them here in the Gulf Gate Area of Sarasota. A good place to stop on the way back from the beach or just to get your burger and fry fix. My favorite is the bacon burger, I just wish they could find a bun that didn't fall apart but considering all the fries you get, I can forgive the bun. read more

Five Guys burgers are the best? It wasn't close to the best burger I've ever had but it was good. The burger was a little greasy and crunched up in a foil wrapper. It looked like it was just slapped together really fast. This was my first Five Guys experience so I will have to give it another try. So far Wendy's is a good comparison to the burger I received at Five Guys. The French fries were like greasy fair fries. read more

Like all the Five Guys around, this place has great burgers. The portion of fries is way to big though, even for two people. I had to throw about half the fries away. read more

10 stars if I could give it!! I LOVE THIS PLACE! Best burger in town when it comes to food chain places. Is 9 in the morning and I'm craving one. The fries are amazing as well! read more

If you want a burger in Sarasota then you have found the place. The burgers are almost the best I have ever had. Today I took my employee to five guys for the first time in his life....... I am still wondering how!!!! We both got our bags and he looked in and said, "I think they forgot my burger!". I told him to dig under the mound of great fries and he will find it. As every time I come here, I couldn't be happier. The burgers are the best and there is no way to describe the fries. For as many fries as you get..... I still want more!. The employees that work there are the most friendly, fast and attentive you could ever ask for! I only have a hour for lunch and the restaurant is about 10 minutes one way to get there but yet I always make it back in time! Five guys........ I will be again, and again and again. I could be the 6th guy if you wanted!!! read more

Really great fresh burgers topped the way you like it! A small fries is all you need as its the same size as large in most places! The one thing I'd like to see them add and I wrote it on their website suggestion is a choice of Cheese other than American! If they would add Swiss Cheese as a topping choice I think a lot of folks myself included would enjoy that! Everything fresh made not frozen!Even when crowded they get the Burgers and fries up quick! Help yourself to as many shelled peanuts as you like while waiting for your order! Nice place! Tables inside and several outside! read more