While in the area for the weekend we came here twice. The prices are fantastic for the amount of…read moreice cream you get. Both the candy corn sundae and s'mores sundae were delicious. Lots of hard ice cream choices plus soft serve options. Super friendly staff. Will definitely be back the next time we are up in Cortland.

The first time I ordered an ice cream cone at Super Scoops, I couldn't believe my eyes. I was…read morepresented with a cone topped with four giant scoops of delicious ice cream and I had to enlist help to finish it! You may want to be specific about your sizing preferences before you order, because I was blown away. Super Scoops is a super cute little ice cream shop in Homer. Although there are many other shops in the area, the customer service at this establishment has kept me coming back. They feature a good number of Purity's hard ice cream flavors as well as soft serve treats. You can't go wrong with a double scoop of Madigan Mint or, my personal favorite, a Boomberry milkshake. The people who work here are really great. They're funny, personable, and make you feel welcome. What a great place to visit on a hot summer day..or on any day when you're craving a sweet treat!

wonderful ambiance, delicious ice cream and great food. set…read moreup with a 50's overtone inside, with plenty of seating outside as well. clean, well maintained, with outgoing, friendly servers stop in for a burger or a cone, stay for the atmosphere

I visited your ice cream shop recently and wanted to share some feedback regarding my experience…read more While your ice cream is quite good, the customer service fell far short of what is acceptable. My group stood in line at the second window after the first one was taking a long time, only to watch multiple people get served elsewhere while we were ignored. When we moved back to the first window, the second one suddenly opened. When I calmly mentioned this confusion, the employee working--who identified herself as Tessa--became defensive, rushed our order aggressively ("what else, what else, what else"), and then loudly talked about me right in front of me, telling someone else that I was "freaking out" and claiming that window only opens when it's busy (even though there was clearly a line). She also made a point to mention that the interaction was recorded on camera. As someone who runs an organization where customer service is our number one priority, this was a disappointing display of a lack of emotional intelligence and basic hospitality. A simple acknowledgment of the confusion or a polite apology would have instantly resolved the situation. Additionally, if there is a specific rule about when the second window is supposed to open, there really needs to be a clear sign posted. Given how many out-of-town visitors you receive, relying on unwritten rules only leads to frustrated customers. I hope you will use this as a coaching opportunity for Tessa on de-escalation and customer relations.

Delicious ice cream! Friendly staff. Good ice cream. Kid friendly. Picnic tables to sit onread more

Decent Ice cream selection. Usually has one dairy-free option...would be great if there were two…read more Good service, well-maintained and clean building. Nice covered area with tables. But, unfortunately, right on a really busy road and next to the town much site. It is sort of a standard I use to compare other places against. Only a few are better, but many are not quite as good.

Home-made soft-serve and sorbet! Great flavors!…read more We found Sweet Melissa's Ice Cream shortly after lunch. (Jul 2026) We had to try their ice cream bars: homemade lemon chocolate chip ice cream, with a coat of crumbled lemon cookies, half-dipped in homemade dark-chocolate shell! Clever and delicious! We also had a dish of homemade Blueberry Guava sorbet! Intense red-purple color and sweet frozen flavor! Great summer treats! We ate faster than they melted :-)

Cute seasonal ice cream spot in Ithaca!…read more Located in downtown- the line can get pretty long in the evenings- even on weekdays. Cash only so be prepared. I am partial to soft serve but have tried both their hard icecream and soft serve. I prefer their soft serve but wish they had more flavors. I tried the classic chocolate twist and the two berry twist soft serves. In the two berry twist, I didn't like the pink flavor- it was too icy and more like a sorbet/dole whip than true soft serve. I liked the purple flavor thought! Overall, I still frequent Sweet Melissa's for softserve close to Cornell! Would recommend!

When the shop opened it had a good selection of Perry's Ice Cream, which is great. It has…read moreapparently changed ownership and has changed ice cream brands to something different and NOT great, to say the least. Very disappointing.

Super cute place! So many flavors! If I lived in Cortland I would definitely come here more often…read more The service was great and the people were very kind.

Just what we needed on a hot summer day! Small chocolate vanilla twist cone for me and a Mexican…read moresundae AND chocolate malt for the old man. Once I realized how good it was, I wanted to kick myself for not trying one of the amazing sundae options. Will definitely make it back before the end of the season! Super friendly staff!!

Always good. Always friendly…read more The best part of a small town is local businesses that cares.

Cute hole-in-the-wall!…read more Closer to Cornell than the Frosty Cow! Lots of flavor options, but sad you can't get more than one flavor. I tried the custard and it was delicious! Not as eggy tasting as I expected... actually not eggy tasting at all. Still creamy and sweet. Large portions. Also tried the cotton candy hard icecream which was good but not my type of flavor. Make sure to check out the toad tire garden when you're here! A few benches in the garden for sitting too. Overall, I would recommend! Not quite as polished as the Frosty Cow, but it has its own Ithacan charm about it.

We have been here before and they have a broad menu. Unfortunately when we arrived neither of the…read moreice cream attendants acknowledged us. The woman who ultimately served us gave me the wrong order claiming I ordered a twist. I did not. When I restated my order she got snippy and said I should order a certain way. I wanted a specific flavor and asked for that again. She brought another order and it was vanilla not the flavor I ordered after pressuring us to order something else. I returned the ice cream and she claimed angrily that people can't taste that flavor. It was vanilla there was no flavor. I returned it and asked to be reimbursed. When we were leaving she immediately gave us mean us and started talking about us. It's unfortunate we were really looking forward to ice cream on a nice day. The customer service and claims concerning the flavors turned into gaslighting and an uncomfortable situation for our family.