Cute hole-in-the-wall!…read more Closer to Cornell than the Frosty Cow! Lots of flavor options, but sad you can't get more than one flavor. I tried the custard and it was delicious! Not as eggy tasting as I expected... actually not eggy tasting at all. Still creamy and sweet. Large portions. Also tried the cotton candy hard icecream which was good but not my type of flavor. Make sure to check out the toad tire garden when you're here! A few benches in the garden for sitting too. Overall, I would recommend! Not quite as polished as the Frosty Cow, but it has its own Ithacan charm about it.

Great place for an ice cream treat. Great people, customer service and very fair pricing…read more Probably more flavors available here than most ice cream spots. Some dairy free are also available. Enjoy!

Delicious ice cream! Friendly staff. Good ice cream. Kid friendly. Picnic tables to sit onread more

Decent Ice cream selection. Usually has one dairy-free option...would be great if there were two…read more Good service, well-maintained and clean building. Nice covered area with tables. But, unfortunately, right on a really busy road and next to the town much site. It is sort of a standard I use to compare other places against. Only a few are better, but many are not quite as good.

Dryden Creamery was such a fun stop before our final ice cream run at the Frosty Cow. It had cozy,…read morefamily-run vibe; there was a mom and a couple of kids behind the counter. We got the matcha soft serve, and woahhh - it was absolutely delicious!! For the price, it's a total steal. The matcha flavor was rich and concentrated, exactly what I dream of in a good matcha dessert. If you're a fan of bold, earthy matcha, this place is a must. Sure, there's a slight gritty texture from the powder (as expected), but it's surprisingly smooth for how strong the flavor is. They also had Taichi drinks, which was kind of unexpected but weirdly fun to see at a small-town creamery??

Have been searching for matcha/taro soft serve- and it is great !!!! Worth the trip ! Yes…read more Really interesting ice cream flavors - I had sesame and it was fantastic !! Super friendly locals

Our bus stopped on the way home at this amazing ice cream shop. I've driven by but this is the…read morefirst time I've tried their ice cream. They carry homemade ice cream and some selections from Perry's. They also have soft serve. Everyone on the bus said this ice cream was great...from sundaes, milkshakes, soft serve with dips and hard ice cream it was unanimous. I had a great flavor I've never seen anywhere..... chocolate ice cream mixed with chocolate pieces and coconut pieces in a chocolate and nut dipped waffle cream cone. The place was packed but the service was great.

This is the summer of exploring ice cream shops. Now that the weather's warming up I'm finding…read moremyself visiting a new shop once a week, starting with Super Cream Dairy Bar. Walking up to the order window you're greeted by a friendly cashier who's eager to take your order. You look around at their large menu before deciding on getting a scoop of their newest creation: Earl's Ice Cream. After reading the description and learning that it's named after a local farmer, your scoop is up within minutes and now you have the option to sit outdoors in the sun, under their covered patio, or indoors in the AC. If you're needing a bit more than just ice cream you can also order food off of their snacks menu which includes fries, tenders, and other finger foods!

Pretty sure this is the same ownership as super cream in homer. Service here is insanely fast and…read morethe ice cream is amazing. Highly recommend

My husband and I frequently visit Footie's and have never left disappointed. We've even taken our…read moredogs for their birthday! The staff are always fast and friendly. The green apple caramel nut sundae was epic!

When the shop opened it had a good selection of Perry's Ice Cream, which is great. It has…read moreapparently changed ownership and has changed ice cream brands to something different and NOT great, to say the least. Very disappointing.

Super cute place! So many flavors! If I lived in Cortland I would definitely come here more often…read more The service was great and the people were very kind.

CASH ONLY! I loved this place. Their soft serve was really great, and they also offer hard ice…read morecream with vegan options, plus a gluten free and vegan cookies and cream. I got the chocolate soft serve with rainbow sprinkles and it was the perfect sweet treat. If you only want a little something, you can get a kids size like I did, but they also have small, medium, and large sizes too. One thing to know is that it is cash only. If you do not have cash, they may offer an IOU like they did for us. There is an ATM next door, but I had issues with it not accepting my card, and my friends had the same problem, so I ended up paying in quarters. They were very kind and patient about it though. The line can get pretty long, but it moves quickly, so it is not a bad wait at all. It would be nice if there was more seating, especially since so many people come here, but overall it is still a really great stop for ice cream.

Cute seasonal ice cream spot in Ithaca!…read more Located in downtown- the line can get pretty long in the evenings- even on weekdays. Cash only so be prepared. I am partial to soft serve but have tried both their hard icecream and soft serve. I prefer their soft serve but wish they had more flavors. I tried the classic chocolate twist and the two berry twist soft serves. In the two berry twist, I didn't like the pink flavor- it was too icy and more like a sorbet/dole whip than true soft serve. I liked the purple flavor thought! Overall, I still frequent Sweet Melissa's for softserve close to Cornell! Would recommend!

As the name suggests, this little shop is right off of US RT 11 and easily missable if you're not…read morepaying attention. But I urge you to pay attention because within the walls of this shop is the sweetest staff serving us great frozen desserts to help you fend off the summer heat. With their reasonable prices you'll be tempted to get more than what you originally came for -- and I say, do it!

We've hit pretty much every ice cream stand in Cortland and Tompkins Counties, and several in…read moreBroome and Chenango. This shop stands with the best of them and is the best in Cortland County. It compares favorably with the Big Dipper in Apalachin, and in fact now gives you more for your money. Service is great, as is the shaded dining area.

Great spot for soft serve, just a short drive away from Cornell!…read more I tried the red velvet soft serve and really enjoyed it. It didn't taste like red velvet cake at all... it just kind of tasted like vanilla, with a hint of chocolate maybe? Nonetheless, the color is fun and I liked it. A very cute spot for icecream. Quite a few picnic tables to sit at although only one is shaded so it can get pretty hot. There is also a drive through which is nice! Lots of flavor options! Overall, I would recommend!

I'd been wanting to check out Frosty Cow for a while and I finally got the chance to go with my…read moregirlfriend and a friend... except none of us actually ordered anything. And no, we didn't see any cows either. Strike one. The second time was more eventful. I went with a different group of friends, and this time we did get ice cream and see the cows. (Let me be clear: the cows are not part of the official Frosty Cow experience, but somehow, they're always part of the story.) They're just... there. Big, red-eyed, slightly intimidating cows, chilling nearby like unofficial mascots. We got lowkey scared at first, but of course, that didn't stop us from taking a ridiculous amount of photos. It's unpredictable, though; Another time we drove past, and the cows were nowhere to be found. So if you're planning your visit around cow sightings, maybe call ahead and ask, "Are the cows out tonight?" Totally normal question. As for the ice cream, it's definitely worth the hype. We got the Fruity Pebbles flavor, which was creamy and nostalgic in the best way. My girlfriend found it a little too milky for her taste, but I loved how rich and dairy-forward it was. The cereal bits gave that perfect crunchy finish. All in all, whether you're in it for the ice cream or just hoping for cows, Frosty Cow is a fun little stop worth checking out.

While in the area for the weekend we came here twice. The prices are fantastic for the amount of…read moreice cream you get. Both the candy corn sundae and s'mores sundae were delicious. Lots of hard ice cream choices plus soft serve options. Super friendly staff. Will definitely be back the next time we are up in Cortland.

The first time I ordered an ice cream cone at Super Scoops, I couldn't believe my eyes. I was…read morepresented with a cone topped with four giant scoops of delicious ice cream and I had to enlist help to finish it! You may want to be specific about your sizing preferences before you order, because I was blown away. Super Scoops is a super cute little ice cream shop in Homer. Although there are many other shops in the area, the customer service at this establishment has kept me coming back. They feature a good number of Purity's hard ice cream flavors as well as soft serve treats. You can't go wrong with a double scoop of Madigan Mint or, my personal favorite, a Boomberry milkshake. The people who work here are really great. They're funny, personable, and make you feel welcome. What a great place to visit on a hot summer day..or on any day when you're craving a sweet treat!