I've gone to Fort Ball many times and usually find good options in the buffet. The bathrooms however are really gross and it doesn't appear that much gets wiped down, do the employees use a separate bathroom? I hope so, because I don't feel very clean after using them. read more

We want to thank the manager, waitress and cooks today who prepared the delicious buffet of Italian food/pizza/salad & exceptional service to our hungry team after playing Heidelberg. Everyone loved the food and appreciated you packing up extras for the 4 hr bus trip back to Indiana! This is a great business with exceptional food and service!! read more

Fort Ball Pizza Palace - Italian Near Me - Tiffin, Ohio

I have been ordering food after work; I would say they are extremely friendly! And a great place to get food from. The food is amazing and always prepped as it comes to order and taste fresh every time. Their pricing is extremely well priced. It is a very nice pizza parlor I strongly recommend on visiting this location and trying there amazing food. They have an amazing customer service. read more

This is a great place with the best buffet in Tiffin. So many great things to eat from here. The service is fantastic and the ambiance is inviting. read more

I have been coming to Fort ball for over three years now, and it's pretty mediocre. Sometimes a few small surprises but always matched with a few disappointments. The pizza and buffet is decent at best, but the price matches so that checks out. My main complaint is the completely out of date and run-down decor. The seats are falling apart, it's dim but not in a "mood" type of way. But my biggest complaint of all would be the restrooms. I waited to write a review for three years to give a local business the benefit of the doubt, but there have been holes in the men and women's restroom doors for over three years, the restrooms are mysteriously wet, the hand soap dispenser leaks soap all over the sink, and the restroom doors only lock with a hook latch you'd expect to find on a gas station stall, let alone that it's on the actual door to the restroom. It is very clear that the owners/managers have lost whatever passion they had for their restaurant and sacrificed it to keep enough food getting dried out under the heat lamps on the buffet trough. Hopefully they make some changes and I can update my review, in the meantime...have two stars for at least qualifying as a place that sells food at a decent price. ***UPDATE***: They have at least attempted to "fix" the restroom doors. They have now put a wooden patch over the holes, which is at the very least more than nothing at all. SECOND UPDATE 4/14/19: Nothing has changed, one waitress running the entire dining room and cash register, all salad dressings unlabeled for an interesting salad lottery. Stained drop ceiling, poorly lit back room. read more

See all

Alfredo was undercooked and cold. The pizza wasn't very good. Worker was scratching their body and face and was touching dough I don't recommend. It's sad cause they used to be good. Waitress was nice and friendly though. read more

drove 30 min out of route because it's the best looking place open but there hours are completely different than what maps tell you

If you are looking for a quick, easy, and everything but a healthy place to eat this is the place for you. They gots a plethora of rancid eats on that buffet of theirs. I starts out with a plate of that fettuccini and macs and cheeses and i topped that off with some of that garlic bread. Overall i gives plate one a 7/10. Macs and cheeses was subpar. I then goes up and i gets myself a plate of pizza with some pepperoni on it, not a bad endeavor, about a 8/10. For plate three i gets myself 2 dozen of them pickled eggs, those made my stomach churn a little after I endulged in them so I had to make a trip to the facilities. I done blown up that toilet so bad I had to get the manager to come and unclog that toilet of his. Overall this little pizza palace is a nice local restaurant and i gives it a 7/10 for the overall experience. One critique i gots for this establishment that would perhaps upper my rating is the rancid ratio of carbohydrates to other nutrition groups available at that buffet.Them pickled eggs i eats is probably abt the only thing they gots up there that contains any sort of protein read more

It had been years since I had been here before this visit. I definitely remember the food being much better. All the food was hot on the buffet, plenty of options but honestly none of it really had any taste or flavor. The pasta and pizza sauces are def missing some spices. Toppings were lacking on the pizzas. Even the garlic cheese sticks were disappointing on taste. They need to revert back to before whatever they changed. Not impressed AT ALL. read more

Fort Ball pizza is some of the best pizza I have evah, evah eaten and yes I know how to spell ever, I'm trying to make a point! Every time I visit Tiffin I try to eat pizza here at least twice before I leave town. The crust is just right, not to thin, not to thick and cooked to perfection. The sauce is amazing and combined with the crust is a recipe for success. I will not go into the toppings because they are second and third fiddle to the crust and sauce. If you have the crust and sauce down everything else is gravy. I am back in Austin now but will have many dreams about you Fort Ball pizza. How your crust had the perfect combination of crunch and chew, how your sauce, melted in my mouth and your perfect amount of cheese, not too much and not too little. Now if I could only clone you and bring you to Austin, I would own this town! Your pizza is fabulous and a highlight to my visits to Tiffin. read more

I love this place, always have and always will. The food is really good, the people are great. If I visit Tiffin and do not eat Fort Ball my trip is incomplete. The bread and dough is made fresh daily and it is amazing. I ate at Fort Ball daily for over 5 years while working there in high school and college and it didn't get old. It is the same delicious food today as it was then (over 25 yrs ago). The owners and employees take pride in their food and service. It's truly an establishment. read more

We heard this place was really good, but quickly found out, "NOPE" We got there late afternoon, time for supper. They had 4 tables of people, and only a couple dried out pizzas on their "buffet". The italian food- one pan was empty and only a small portion of fettucine available as shown in pix. 2 pcs of our 4 sets of silverware had dried stuff on them. Staff replaced them silently. The "Italian dishes" side tasted edible and OK, but not amazing. Note the empty pan to the left and only a small amt of dried out fettucine in another. Note the crustiness of the pans. They just brought a portion of fettucine in and poured it in old pan! We sat and waited and waited for more pizzas to come out. More people came in, and only one pizza at a time would come out. The pizzas typically only had 1-3 items sparsely placed. They left the old pizzas sit way too long, which the customers figured out b/c Nobody ate them. During our 90 min there, I counted approx 50 ppl come in and want to eat. They brought out a total of 3 new pizzas while we were there and one new Italian dish. Staff was polite but slow to pick up dishes (not that we had many) and we had to ask for our 2 drink refills of pop and water. The staff was intent on hanging back by the kitchen door at the soda machine. Cleanliness? Meh. Restrooms? Blech, they needed a real cleaning. Someone should teach them how to clean the toilets, it was OLD filth. We will not try this restaurant again. We did try asking when more pizza was coming out, the girl muttered something about the cook just got there. read more

See all

The food was really good only thing was the pasta had a little to much sauce. I would ask for less sauce i you plan on ordering it.

Dirty place, The booth seat in the very back side by the windows is broken, A person could easily get injured or worst and fall right on the floor. Said something to the lady working and she said "Oh they just fixed it", if they did actually fix it then they did not do a good job and could care less about customers. read more

Wow. This town is hurting for a decent pizza place. Frozen crust and way too much sauce. I ordered green olives and sausage on my pizza, I got green olives but no sausage. I know green olives can be salty, but it tasted like they replaced the sausage with extra salt, I could feel my heart rate and BP increase after one piece. I won't be going back. read more

Went on a Friday night and ordered the buffet. Everything was delicious. Raviolii, lasagna, pizza, Italian sub slices, dessert breadsticks, dessert apple pizza, and salad bar was amazing. Only flaws was it took me 4 tries to finally get a beer they actually had on the menu listed and they did not have a pizza on the bar that I had wanted to try (which they told me would be on there when I had phoned them first even after they said it was not a request buffet) The beer menu at the tables are outdated. The atmosphere was very laid back and family oriented tho! Overall happy and I will be back for sure. read more

Best Food ever. No complaints. Just a very happy and full stomach. I recommend everyone should try.

This is the best pizza in the world. Consistently great za and an awesome buffet. The subs and foldoves are delicious as well. Friendly folks making the pizza too. I grew up eating this pizza, and I never tire of it. read more

I have had their pizza 10's, if not hundreds of times (even worked there for a minute), and will never tire of their food. Their pizza is not too thin, not too thick, and the home made sauce has a nice combination of sweetness and spiciness from the Italian seasonings. They also have fantastic subs on fresh made bread, great pastas in huge portions, and the best Italian Smorgasbord around. read more

This is one of our favorite places for Italian food when we are in Tiffin, Ohio. They have a nice selection of items to top your salad with. The only thing is the lettuce is shredded, which is ok, but some may not prefer it that way. I enjoy the whole pickled eggs and sliced beets topped with some French dressing on my lettuce. They also have jello, puddings, and other soft foods, which children enjoy as well as adults. Good selection of pizzas, lasagna, spaghetti, Ravioli, Mac n cheese, fold overs, white pizza, and cinnamon sticks. The buffet is stocked well, even at peak times. If a buffet isn't what you're looking for, they do have several selections on their regular menu that you can pick from. The menu includes things like pizza and a nice selection of submarine sandwiches. Note - their subs are excellent and are made with fresh Italian bread loaves. They have soft drinks and beer available and prices are reasonable. Review #8/2016 read more

Fort Ball is nothing more than a run-of-the-mill pizza shop. Their claim to fame is their "Italian Smorgasbord", but it typically misses the mark. Even though the selection has gotten better on the buffet, it's still sub-par as a whole. Who really wants a pizza buffet, though? Are you really concerned with quality, or are you just there to stuff your face? The buffet attracts a certain crowd, and that is totally fine, but not my cup of tea. I'd prefer a more refined slice, in stead of a place that produces food put of a trough. Fort Ball has seemingly been around forever, and will continue to survive in a town flooded with mediocre pizza places. I'd suggest A.J.'s Heavenly for a more refined pie. read more

Coming from Chicago it's hard to find good pizza around. Fort ball is ok. It consistently seems to be VERY greasy. We tried the buffet but my fiancee swore we'd never go back as the Tiffin natives made it quite unappealing and unappetizing watching all that food being guzzled down some of the largest butts I've ever seen in my life. When we order Fort Ball again out of desperation for pizza, we will make sure we get carry out. We have decided regrettably that Pizza Hut is about the best pizza you will get in Tiffin. :( read more

Finally got my other half to take me there. Been trying for 5 years or so, and could not eat. Not their fault. That being said, call before you go. They're having staffing issues and the dining room is closed. read more

Mediocre. Definitely a restaurant that hasn't changed in years. It is the type of place you can't hate.

The best pizza in Tiffin. The owner's are very nice the food is very good and workmanship of the cooks are good

Best pizza in town! Stop by for the buffet every time I'm home to visit my family. Wish I could find pizza this good in South Florida. Staff is always friendly, food is always amazing. read more

Stop anytime I am in town. Lunch and dinner buffet is cheap and has an incredible amount of food. Beer and all-you-can eat pizza/pasta/salad. What else do you want? read more

I know everyone has their own preferences for pizza and sauce, but this is literally the only pizza I have eaten for 40 years. When I want pizza this is what I want and get. BLT foldover's, Italian subs, and to many kinds of pizza to name. Love their food and will always by MY pizza of choice. Staff is always amazing even when there is a waiting line to get in , buffet is always full, salad bar is excellent for a lunch or dinner and it is family friendly. Keep up the good work. read more

Easily the best pizza in town. Its buffet is also excellent. I've come to Fort Ball for several family events and a great place to show to your out of town friends. read more

I have no idea how this place has such a high star rating. Perhaps it's because the buffet is dirt cheap? Anyway, the food was awful. The pizza was disgusting, the pasta was watered down, overcooked and gross. The service was polite and nice, but the food was just awful. Will not be returning. read more

One of my favorite places to eat in Tiffin Ohio. We've been going here for years and it's always good.

Good if you catch a fresh pizza terrible if not. Buffet pizza was cold, dry, and old. It had been out for probably 20 minutes before I got there and new pizza was not brought out for over 40 minutes after I got there. Even when the place was packed they didn't put out fresh pizza. When they finally did however the pizza was good, hot cheesey and had a good crust. read more

Ok, Smorgasbord is in the name ... That's all that needs said. Their buffet is great, the right combination of artery clogging deliciousness and a smattering of vegetables for salad. Their blt subs and pizza are great!!! Always our faves. read more

Love the pizza but you cannot get salad bar when you order a pizza and eat it there. The menu allows salad bar with a "dinner" when you eat there for an additionsl $4. I was willing to pay that but since we ordered a pizza...she wouldn't let us. If we wanted it...we had to pay buffet price. Senseless.... read more

My other favorite hometown pizza place - with the added benefit of an Italian buffet! I absolutely love their pizza and cheesebread, and the buffet is nice if you get there during peak times when fresh food is consistently served/changed out. Their sauce is a little more mild/salty and the crust can be a little on the crunchy side - very good if that's what you're craving! Like any restaurant, staff come and go and service can vary, but the food is consistently good from either location. read more

This restaurant was recommended to us by a local. We tried the lunch buffet for first time today and it was great, great variety of pizza and other Italian goodies read more

A consistently good pizza and salad buffet with plenty of options, including pasta dishes. It's not the best pizza in town, but it's tasty enough and the price is right. Great macaroni salad! They do a good job keeping the buffet stocked. I've seen them let people get the buffet even when it's officially ended unlike so many places that start whisking away the food as soon as the clock strikes. The staff is very attentive about removing plates from your table and asking if you want a refill or anything else. They have a banquet room for parties and special occasions. read more

So good! Great pizza and fold overs. Buffet is a steal. Best in town! Keep up the good work. They are a national treasure.

Good food. However service is not well. Workers stood in the corner and talked and did not bring us our drinks for 20 minutes because they were busy talking read more

I've only tried the buffet and I don't recommend it. The food was blah, no taste, soggy, just plain bad. Never went there again.