We tried 4 pies, the Oops!, Berry Buttermilk, Oreo, and Bourbon Praline. They were all great,…read morewell-baked and interesting flavors. The menu is huge and rotates, so there's always something for everyone. They also have a rotating selection of local ice creams! I had the tea latte flavor & loved it, but the lavender was a little too strong for my friends. The pie-themed and historical decor is really cool and very comforting. Service is great, chatting with the staff was fun, and I will 100% be driving the hour back to get more pie.

Some things are just worth coming home too. Piefalootin never disappoints. The hardest decision we…read morehave is what kind of pie we're going to get. There are so many choices! Today I got a build-a-pie. You heard it right. I got a little of everything that added up to a full pie. This place is like grandma's on steroids. My favorite is the coconut cream pie. Always thick, creamy and delicious. Piecrust can't be beat. If you like a traditional pie. She always has the basic staples plus lots of new and exciting flavor combinations.. Follow her on Instagram for daily specials. Wish I lived in town and could visit more often. If you want to have a pie for the holiday, be sure to order ahead. The window typically closes a week or two out. Staff is always friendly, efficient, knowledgeable, and ever so helpful. Cherri dispositions abound at this Sweet establishment. You'll probably even meet the owner, TRACY. She's definitely involved and keeps things running smoothly. Everyone knows about this place. If you haven't been be sure to stop by. You can take a pie to go or eat inside at one of the mini cute tables.