Fudgy&#x27;s Ice Cream

318

567

6131

3 years ago

I absolutely love Fudgy's Ice Cream! I am a huge fan of their milkshakes, and although I've only been there a couple of times, I've really enjoyed their milkshakes. I got to try four of their flavors and tried some of my mom's chocolate dip shell. I really love the ice cream flavors, swirls, and milkshake options. There are so many things that I wish I could try there, although I'm almost never in the area. I will definitely be here again if I'm nearby or driving through. read more

Fudgy's Ice Cream - a cup with a lid - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Amenia, New York

Helpful 3

Thanks 2

Love this 3

Oh no 0

Samantha W.

0

22

14

1 year ago

Creamiest ice cream I've ever had and doesn't make me crave a drink from eating it. Tastes so rich and flavorful and is super soft. Fast and convenient service from their window. The tables outside could be cleaned better as there is dirt and stains and bird poop. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Todd Y.

0

27

1

11 months ago

Fudgy's has a great soft ice cream mix. They have been in this hole in the wall for 25 years that I know of. It's a terrific little cash only joint. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ashley H.

0

3

1

1 year ago

Ever since I was a kid I've been coming to Fudgy's Ice Cream. I absolutely love their ice cream and look forward to visiting for a delicious refreshing treat every summer. They have an abundance of flavors and cones to choose from, including cotton candy! Cotton candy is one of my very favorite flavors and sometimes hard to find but they sell it! I cannot recommend Fudgy's more not only for their excellent ice cream but also for their exceptional customer service. There is also a gorgeous seating area that I love to sit at whenever I go. Thank you Fudgy's for your amazing service and hospitality and for serving us for all these incredibly years! May there be many more to come! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Frederick N.

0

2

0

1 year ago

Great service, not expensive, and the ice cream is the best! My grandchildren love it when we go there!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Shianne P.

Elite 26 All-Star

4

136

1275

4 years ago

Ice cream is delicious. I had two scoops of Peanut S'mores and my friend had one scoop Peanut s'mores and one scoop pistachio. Staff was friendly. read more

Fudgy's Ice Cream - a display of different flavors - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Amenia, New York

Fudgy's Ice Cream - a hand holding an ice cream cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Amenia, New York

Fudgy's Ice Cream - a hand holding a cup of ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Amenia, New York

Fudgy's Ice Cream - a display of boxes of ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Amenia, New York

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Kylee J.

0

3

1 year ago

I love it at fudge's ice cream workers are the nicest very nice people and understanding my old friend's family own it and they let me in at Mack my own ice cream very sweet poeple love it and and definitely recommend it for anyone who loves ice cream and other delicious things read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Jerome C.

0

32

0

5 years ago

Hands down the best soft serve in the county, and I have tried them all. Generous portions, fairly priced, good service. Excellent ice cream cakes too. I drive 20 minutes out of my way to patronize Fudgies, they are worth it. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Laura S.

3

9

1

3 years ago

Highly recommend. This place is amazing once again highly recommend. Their ice cream it's something else, is extremely good

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Georgia H.

1

10

1

4 years ago

LITERALLY SO YUM WOW. it's always great, reccomend the dirt sundae!! workers are also so kind

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Dave C.

0

17

0

4 years ago

Great Ice Cream at Great Price Nothing fancy but they've been making people happy for decades. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 1

Cathy G.

28

772

118

7 years ago

Lots of flavors, friendly folks. We opted to try the soft serve with a peanut butter swirl. The ice cream was rich and smooth, but the peanut flavor was VERY subtle. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Lisa E.

491

1073

6426

11 years ago

I'm selective about eating dairy but Fudgy's is a must on my trips up Route 22. Located in Amenia, NY it is usually quite busy. Today it is raining and it is very lonely here. Serving Perry's ice cream, it is reasonable the service is friendly. It is a destination that makes my journey enjoyable !! read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 3

Oh no 0

Heather R.

22

4

0

5 years ago

Says it's open until 9pm Saturday but the lazy kids in there decided they were too tired to stay open even though there was 20 people outside at 8:09pm they wouldn't serve. Just lost out on a few hundred dollars in business. Very poor customer service. Never going back again. Just pathetic!!!!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Lee M.

308

506

3541

11 years ago

Excellent flavor choices of Perry's Premium. I had A single scoop of Deep Sea Treasure ( caramel ice cream with seat salt caramels mixed in). Very creamy sweet and salty! Price was excellent, my cone and daughter's dish less than $5 ( price of one item back home). read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Denise L.

3

1

0

5 years ago

Hands down BEST ice cream in the area... red rooster in Brewster for south of 22 and fudgys for north of 22... just skip all in between!!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Josh R.

0

4

3

4 years ago

This place is not open till 9pm like it says. It was closed by 8:20. Having your hours right would be a good start. Don't waste your time coming here like I did. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Amanda D.

Elite 21

357

192

447

9 years ago

Great place to stop and kill time if you're early for your MetroNorth train at Wassaic - and only about a two minute drive from the station. Whatever brand of ice cream they serve is better than average and the menu of flavors is huuuge. There's a few tables to sit and enjoy your treats off to the side and we always seem to see some kind of cool wildlife when we're there (herons, hawks, etc.). read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Saul G.

1

23

8

11 years ago

It was an experience of a lifetime, and well worth the 1 hour drive up from NYC that we took to get there. The icecream alone is worth the drive up and back from the city, even with some of the sumer time traffic. The sign was authentic and completely welcoming. Walking up to the small plastic counter mounted with sliding serving windows is like walking up to an oasis in a barren desert. Some of the windows have smudges of customers past, but that only adds to the experiance. The staff is mostly younger women, who have an attitude that is heartwarming and honest. Those two qualities are often lacking in larger establishments. One women even remarked "Everything is a disaster tonight" which demonstrates their extreme tidiness, considering the overall lack of disastrous happenings. Our icecream was prepared quickly and freshly, you could almost see the cows out back being milked. The cost was affordable, but to be honest they could charge a kidney and I'd return for more. I ordered the peanut butter swirl, and my friend ordered soft serve chocolate and vanilla swirl. To say they were extremely delectable would be a gross, brutal, awful understatement. As we drove away in our navy blue Chevy pickup truck (a five seater that has a nice big back to store logs that we occasionally deliver to our family), satisfaction rushed through me just like the icecream. The cones were crunchy, but not crumbly. Sweet but not overpowering, a masterpiece of subtle wafer. Amenia is centered around Fudgy's and for good reason. Fudgy's changed my life for the better, and I couldn't imagine my life without it. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Allison C.

Elite 21

238

1654

463

14 years ago

All I'll say is this: Red Velvet Milkshake. (Oh, and good ice cream at reasonable prices with a friendly staff and a close proximity to the MetroNorth station in Wassaic...yep. Those things are good, too!) But, seriously. Red Velvet Milkshake. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Azile Y.

303

1357

661

8 years ago

Just a good local ice cream shop! Sizes are HUGE- opt for smaller than you think you want.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Steven S.

282

13

2

7 years ago

Ice cream was good. Kid behind the counter wouldn't spare tap water for my dog's mini-bowl and made me buy a $2 bottle of water instead.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Seb M.

0

10

0

6 years ago

I've never met a single person in and out of the area that doesn't love this place. Such good ice cream! I definitely recommend!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Shannon C.

29

8

4

9 years ago

This is definitely my favorite place to get ice cream in Dutchess County, but your brownies could use some work, or start storing them elsewhere. Not sure why, but mine tasted terrible. I ended up throwing away my brownie sundae. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ashley A.

0

4

0

7 years ago

The people at the window are always so nice. The ice cream prices are cheaper than all places around. You get so much for your money. Definitely my favorite ice cream place!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

A S.

0

126

21

9 years ago

Really terrific, quality ice cream with a large selection of interesting flavors. Everything my family tried was excellent. I loved the grasshopper mint flavor. Highly recommend! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Winnifred L.

0

3

0

15 years ago

Delicious, yummy ice cream! The people that work there are super sweet and I've only had good experiences there. The last time I was there, the lady let me try 5 flavors before I finally decided. There are unique and seasonal flavors. Even my birthday cake was from there! It's your typical vanilla and chocolate ice cream with the chocolate cookie crumbles in between, but the cookies were really fresh and still crunchy. If you're ever on Route 22, you should stop by Fudgy's. And if you're heading south, stop by Roundtuit for a yummy, greasy pit stop and then head over to Fudgy's. Though you might want to eat the desserts that Roundtuit also has... read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Susan M.

0

1

0

11 years ago

This is simply the best ice cream shop anywhere! They have a wide variety of soft and hard ice cream flavors as well as a huge assortment of ways to enjoy said flavors! The staff is wonderful and the prices are more than reasonable. I can't say enough good things about Fudgy's - except it is AWESOME! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Emily B.

94

42

9

10 years ago

really good ice cream, a variety of flavors. make sure you have cash though, they don't take cards.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

More info about Fudgy's Ice Cream

4789 Rte 22
Amenia, NY 12501
Directions
(845) 373-8291
Call Now

Hours

What time does Fudgy's Ice Cream open?

Fudgy's Ice Cream opens at 11:00 AM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.

What time does Fudgy's Ice Cream close?

Fudgy's Ice Cream closes at 8:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.

Mon-Sun 11:00 AM - 8:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Fudgy's Ice Cream take credit cards?

No, Fudgy's Ice Cream does not take credit cards.

Indoor Amenities

Does Fudgy's Ice Cream allow dogs?

Yes, Fudgy's Ice Cream allows dogs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Fudgy's Ice Cream have bike parking?

Yes, Fudgy's Ice Cream has bike parking.

Does Fudgy's Ice Cream have parking?

Yes, Fudgy's Ice Cream has parking options.

Other Amenities

Does Fudgy's Ice Cream have free WiFi?

No, Fudgy's Ice Cream does not have free WiFi.

More Info

Health Score

Review Highlights - Fudgy's Ice Cream

“Great place to stop and kill time if you're early for your MetroNorth train at Wassaic - and only about a two minute drive from the station.”

Mentioned in 2 reviews

Verify this business for free

People searched for Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt 360 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Explore benefits

Kelly’s Creamery

4.4(47 reviews)

6.9 mi

I've worked in Wingdale for 11 years and never knew this place existed! We visited for a coworker's…read moreretirement, and I was pleasantly surprised by what a gem Kelly's is. The atmosphere is wonderful, with a food truck, miniature golf, fire pits, and an ice cream creamery that make it a fun spot for all ages. I ordered the pulled pork with coleslaw, and it was honestly some of the best I've ever had. If you're in the Dover area, I highly recommend stopping by. Great food, a relaxed atmosphere, and a unique local spot that's definitely worth a visit!

They have tons of options here both Vegan and Non Vegan. I had the Vegan Bordeaux Cherry made…read morewith Pea protein. It might be the best Vegan ice cream I've ever tasted! The cherries were fresh and delicious. The vegan ice cream base was firm and satisfying. You must stop by and try it!

6/15/2024

See all

Picnic area

45 On Main

4.2(30 reviews)

9.1 mi

Such a cute spot with so many different kinds of goodies! If you're in the mood for something…read moresweet, you're guaranteed to find something you love--or discover something new to try. I had the cashew bark, which was absolutely delicious, and a chai that was perfectly spiced and really hit the spot. The atmosphere is just as great as the treats. They have seating and even some games, which makes it a fun place to hang out and relax while you enjoy your snack. The staff were also kind and helpful when choosing what we wanted. If I lived in the area, I would definitely be a regular here. Highly recommend stopping by if you're nearby!

This is a coffee and chocolate shop that is so much more than just a cafe. I can't share enough…read morepraise for what this business has added to the Kent community. The owner, Gary Kidd, goes out of his way to make it a destination with activities for kids and adults - photo booth, board games inside, outside games, and a winter igloo outside currently. Their handcrafted chocolates are phenomenal and there are all kinds of drinks to pair with them - coffee, tea, hot chocolate, bobo tea and specialty drinks that are named after local spots (including the three independent schools in town). Ice cream is served year round. The ever-changing decorations inside are not to be missed - the Harry Potter theme one was particularly great with clouds suspended from the ceiling along with wands and other things throughout the store. Make plans to visit Kent and stop by.

See all

Grassland

5.0(2 reviews)

10.5 mi

Grassland Dessert Cafe is more than just an ice cream shop -- it's Lakeville's new heartbeat…read more Owners Bill and Lorna have lovingly brought back to life the old Lakeville pharmacy, transforming it into a vibrant, joyful gathering spot that captures the spirit of small-town magic with every scoop. Step inside and you're greeted by the warm smile of proprietor Bill Colgan, whose boyhood memories of the Skipper Dipper on Long Island inspired this delightful adventure. He's recreated that nostalgic charm here -- with a twist! Craving a classic? The Orange Freeze and Root Beer Float will send you straight back to summer afternoons gone by. Want something modern? Don't miss flavors from Gifford's Ice Cream, like the rich, espresso-swirled Campfire S'mores, or the wildly indulgent Sea Salt Caramel Cookie Crunch -- the kind of flavors you can't stop thinking about. And if you're celebrating -- or just feel like going BIG -- order the Everything But the Garage Sink: a jaw-dropping creation with 20 scoops of ice cream, piled high with toppings. It's perfect for birthdays, school advisory groups, or a spontaneous family feast. This isn't just a dessert stop -- it's a place where memories are made. Whether you're a local or passing through the Northwest Corner, Grassland Dessert Cafe is a must-visit. Grab a cone, say hi to Bill, and feel the joy of community, one sweet bite at a time.m

Such a fantastic addition to our community! The ice cream, shakes, açaí bowls, and more are all…read moretop-notch, and the iced strawberry matcha is a total standout--don't miss it. Warm, friendly service and inviting seating both indoors and out make this a spot you'll want to return to. Huge kudos to the team on a job well done!

Grassland decorated for July 4th!

Greek Yogurt Bowl

See all

Candy-O's

3.8(6 reviews)

8.1 mi

Cute little candy and the ice cream shop in Millerton. There is a wide variety of ice cream flavors…read moreand lots of vintage candy. Our server was very friendly and gave samples of ice cream. I enjoyed the flavor of my chocolate ice cream, although the consistency was a little "whipped" for my taste. I also would have like to have seen my favorite flavor, chocolate peanut butter. Husband orders a Carmel swirl and said there was not much caramel in it. Appreciate the late hours! Nice stop for dessert.

Rude owner, felt profiled due to my race. She was rushing me. Making rude remarks. She lost a what…read morewould have been a high paying and frequent customer for sure. She needs to learn to run a business. How she has so many high reviews is beyond me because I've spoken to others in town and they say she is snappy, rude, accuses people as she did me. Lurks around you and is just plain cranky. And all for overpriced and not impressive candy and crappy clothes. The ice cream is the only selling point but guess the gas stations will get my money now. Small store anyway. Felt claustrophobic by her and the shop. NEVER returning.

See all

Modern Milk Bar

5.0(9 reviews)

21.9 mi

Late review, we stopped at Modern Milk Bar in Sheffield, Mass over this past weekend…read more We all loved the ice cream, it was of exceptional quality. They even make the sauces in house. My wife thought her Hippie Dippie sundae was fantastic. She felt it was unique the way the ice cream was inside the brownie portion in the cup. Just incredible. Needless to say, we're looking forward to our next trip to Modern Milk Bar. It's a "Must Stop" if you're taking a trip through the Berkshires area.

LOVE THE ICE CREAM!!!!! The folks are great, with super…read moreservice... I love that they're open until 9PM

See all

Holy Cow

4.3(178 reviews)

19.1 mi

My wife actually introduced me to Holy Cow when we lived nearby, and from that very first visit I…read morewas hooked. It's easily one of the best places to grab ice cream on a warm summer evening. There's something special about enjoying your favorite flavor while watching the sunset. Fast forward a few years, and now we're bringing our own kids here to make those same memories. The ice cream has always been consistently delicious, no matter how many times we've visited, and the staff has been friendly and welcoming every single time. It's one of those places that never disappoints, and we're always happy to make the trip back whenever we're in the area. Highly recommend if you're looking for great ice cream and a relaxed atmosphere with family or friends!

Holy Cow indeed! The best soft serve ice cream. Simple done right. Light and creamy…read more My go to is a chocolate dipped vanilla cone in store, and usually get a pint or two to bring home. There is no indoor seating. There are plenty of picnic benches outside, but minimal shade. The staff is friendly and welcoming. Note: This is a CASH ONLY establishment.

May 2023

See all

May 2023

Caddie Shack

3.9(26 reviews)

18.1 mi

Based solely on the mini golf...Poorly maintained! Shrubs overgrown. Poorly made renovations…read more Strange hole placement.

This food was absolutely amazing and the owner made the best burgers I have ever had in my life and…read moreme and my friend and aunt play a round of minion golf on one of the best conditions for a course I have ever seen.

Caddie Shack - There are no barriers keeping balls from going into the water hazards, so they provide you with little skimmers to scoop your ball out!

There are no barriers keeping balls from going into the water hazards, so they provide you with little skimmers to scoop your ball out!

Gifford's, Hood and Old New England for hard serve options

See all

Fortunes Ice Cream

4.7(51 reviews)

23.3 mi

Up in Tivoli while driving around the area discovering this part of the Hudson - and after having…read morethe sun beat down on us all day, we needed a pick me up. Ice cream. always helps but we were blown away by the astounding flavor selection. I had a double scoop of labne sour cherry and halva honeycomb- I was in my middle eastern Heaven. My husband followed suit with a milkshake made with a rose water saffron pistachio ice cream and a shot of espresso- like an Arabian dream. Really worth the every dollar. It's rare to be left feeling lifted and happy and not just satisfied. True artisans here- do not pass it up! Plus the staff is just as excited about your choices as you are - lovely people

Really great ice cream! We just got vanilla and loved how soft and creamy it was. They have both…read moreindoor and outdoor seating. They also have pints for purchase. Will definitely return!

Sitting in the back yard shade

Labne & sour cherry, corn blueberry

See all

Panacea

4.7(26 reviews)

0.4 mi

Had a great time with my family there when we went for my mothers birthday. We all shared a bunch…read moreof different dishes (which were phenomenal!!) with options for everyone! Was very impressed with their innovative dinner menu and cocktail/ wine list which looked very well curated. Great and attentive service along with a rustic yet cool ambience and great music selection. Over all a great experience from start to finish! Will definitely be back!

Had a really delicious meal here last night. It was a pasta dish with mushrooms and it was very…read moretasty. The restaurant is small, cozy and charming. The service was excellent and prices were reasonable. Highly recommended.

Perfect for hosting a private event

Sweet potato side

See all

Dining room

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

5 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Steven M.

4

14

1

11 years ago

If you a0re driving on Route 22 passing Amenia, approximately a mile south of the main town is this little strip mall with 5 or 6 stores. In the middle of it is this little ice cream stand only open April-October. It's a fun place to stop and get really good ice cream. If you like the Carvel brown bonnet, you will love their chocolate dipped soft ice cream. They have many different flavored ice creams and toppings. Don't drive past this if you want good ice cream. read more

Gloria M.

1

9

2

11 years ago

Whenever I am driving on route 22 (which isn't that often), I stop in for a chocolate dipped soft vanilla ice cream cone...no, I'm not a creature of habit, I'm addicted to it. I always look at the extensive list of perry'a ice cream flavors and the choice of toppings, but then my regular choice calls out! I'm not there often enough to get bored of it. Maybe one day I'll be less boring and try something new...maybe if I'm around it more often. read more

Kimberly C.

0

8

2

15 years ago

I have been taking my kids to Fudgy's for years. They have a great selection of ice cream and frozen yogurt to chose from. Everyone is sure to find something they'll love. I actually have a hard time choosing, even though I should only be eating the "Only 8" diet ice cream. read more

Mp A.

0

6

1

6 years ago

best ice cream joit around five star .

Brandie L.

2

6

0

13 years ago

i love fudges . enough said!!!!

Fudgy's Ice Cream - icecream - Updated August 2026

People who viewed Fudgy's Ice Cream also viewed

Holy Cow

4.3

(178 reviews)

My wife actually introduced me to Holy Cow when we lived nearby, and from that very first visit I…read morewas hooked. It's easily one of the best places to grab ice cream on a warm summer evening. There's something special about enjoying your favorite flavor while watching the sunset. Fast forward a few years, and now we're bringing our own kids here to make those same memories. The ice cream has always been consistently delicious, no matter how many times we've visited, and the staff has been friendly and welcoming every single time. It's one of those places that never disappoints, and we're always happy to make the trip back whenever we're in the area. Highly recommend if you're looking for great ice cream and a relaxed atmosphere with family or friends!

Holy Cow indeed! The best soft serve ice cream. Simple done right. Light and creamy…read more My go to is a chocolate dipped vanilla cone in store, and usually get a pint or two to bring home. There is no indoor seating. There are plenty of picnic benches outside, but minimal shade. The staff is friendly and welcoming. Note: This is a CASH ONLY establishment.

The Jolly Cow

4.6

(77 reviews)

It reminds me of a modern Dairy Queen. There is a little sloped roof building with an extensive…read morecolorful menu posted above so ordering windows. Soft serve and hard ice cream abounds with classic and creative flavors. The team is super nice and efficient. There is a pavilion out back with picnic tables. I just went with the mainstay chocolate vanilla twist in a cake cone. For a small it was a generous portion. The prices are really reasonable compared to what I am used to in Jersey!

The fam were in the area for a weekend and we'd already had some bad whiffs (both our hotel and the…read morerestaurant we went to for dinner were stinkers). We were all praying a dessert 'nightcap' could salvage this trip far from home. No pressure, Jolly Cow, no pressure. This was obviously 'the place to be' - countless people coming and going. All sorts of "hang out" areas (under a tent, in the grass on benches, you name it) - so we were feeling good that we picked a winner. We waited in line for a spell and when we went to start our order we encountered our first remora... cash only. (People still carry cash, huh?) Crisis averted (yeah, my kids had cash on them!) - back in line to try this again. Family of four all getting some serious treats and all for under $20? Sweet! (Dad puns unavoidable, sorry.) "Small" cone was the size of a Smurf (aka - 3 apples) which is crazy (good). I went with their 'Razzle' which is a step-sibling to DQ's Blizzard (I think the last time I had Reese's Pieces ET was still trying to phone home) and... pretty darn incredible. (Although it too was just TOO much of a good thing and I wish it was even smaller than their small.) You saved our weekend, Jolly Cow. And that's the "utter" truth. (I warned y'all that the dad puns weren't going to stop.)

Brendee's Ice Cream

3.5

(14 reviews)

•$$

Staff is very nice and accommodating. Good ice cream. Lots of choices. Prices are fair for all…read morethe items

I really hate to give this place such a low rating as I think it has so much potential as a small…read morebusiness. I like to start out by saying the Ice Cream is delicious, but that's seems to be where it stops as I can buy really delicious Ice Cream from the supermarket also! The store is kind of funky to get into as you feel like your walking thru someone's garage over studio equipment to get into their kitchen instead of an Ice Cream Store Front. I don't feel the cool Ice Cream atmosphere here, no red and white stripes, no clown kiddie set up, or no farm milky theme, no real personality other then sitting in some random neighbor kitchen you've been invited to a couple of blocks over from your place. The lady behind be the counter seems pretty bored working there and seems just to be doing time for the money. Very nice to the customers but couldn't give any suggestions, was to nice to be a grumpy old sarcastic mean cashier we could make fun of. Just a nice lady. This place needs something to bring life to it like a wheel to spin if you can't decide on what you want, what ever the wheel lands on is what you get for the night! Or a Birthday Special of a giant bowl of one scoop of every flavor they have with a swirl of all the soft serves and every topping they have all in one bowl, then have a challenge that if you can finish it with a friend in 30 minutes or less you get a free T-shirt for your birthday! Or put some hokey spray painted benches out front to sit on to make it the best dive place ever!

Grassland

5.0

(2 reviews)

Grassland Dessert Cafe is more than just an ice cream shop -- it's Lakeville's new heartbeat…read more Owners Bill and Lorna have lovingly brought back to life the old Lakeville pharmacy, transforming it into a vibrant, joyful gathering spot that captures the spirit of small-town magic with every scoop. Step inside and you're greeted by the warm smile of proprietor Bill Colgan, whose boyhood memories of the Skipper Dipper on Long Island inspired this delightful adventure. He's recreated that nostalgic charm here -- with a twist! Craving a classic? The Orange Freeze and Root Beer Float will send you straight back to summer afternoons gone by. Want something modern? Don't miss flavors from Gifford's Ice Cream, like the rich, espresso-swirled Campfire S'mores, or the wildly indulgent Sea Salt Caramel Cookie Crunch -- the kind of flavors you can't stop thinking about. And if you're celebrating -- or just feel like going BIG -- order the Everything But the Garage Sink: a jaw-dropping creation with 20 scoops of ice cream, piled high with toppings. It's perfect for birthdays, school advisory groups, or a spontaneous family feast. This isn't just a dessert stop -- it's a place where memories are made. Whether you're a local or passing through the Northwest Corner, Grassland Dessert Cafe is a must-visit. Grab a cone, say hi to Bill, and feel the joy of community, one sweet bite at a time.m

Such a fantastic addition to our community! The ice cream, shakes, açaí bowls, and more are all…read moretop-notch, and the iced strawberry matcha is a total standout--don't miss it. Warm, friendly service and inviting seating both indoors and out make this a spot you'll want to return to. Huge kudos to the team on a job well done!

Alleyway Ice Cream

4.8

(206 reviews)

•$$

The only thing more adorable than Saugerties' main street is this little offshoot. The name is apt,…read moreas you're just eating ice cream in an alleyway. And it's good ice cream. They have your standard flavors with a little twist to let you know they're using high quality ingredients (Madagascar Vanilla, Fruition Chocolate), and a few fun ones that might catch your eye (key lime crunch, thai tea cookies and cream). We were disappointed that Miss Lucy's was out of their banana pudding, but they had banana pudding ice cream here, and it truly hit the spot for my daughter. The people are nice, the price is reasonable, there are comfortable tables in the alley and a nice ivy-covered wall to sit next to. Really, it's just an excellent way to end a summer evening after dinner in Saugerties.

The name of this spot is so funny and cute at the same time. They got outdoor seating next to it…read morewith some shade but if it's raining, idk bout no ice cream. Unless you really want it but idk if they open like that on rainy days lol. I got the Vietnamese coffee one and SMACKS. Food smacks, not slaps btw. Cuz you smackin' yo lips together on how delish it is. The area has street parking that's coin operated but towards this back area I saw a parking lot. It looked to be free idk. I would assume so

The Udder Place

4.3

(3 reviews)

This was SUCH a tasty chocolate ice cream. It was not at all bitter like the description "dark…read morechocolate" suggests. It was perfectly rich and fudgy. There was a hint of raspberry which I wished was more prominent but I can't knock it too much because it was still a very good ice cream. Solid, easy and quick while you're shopping on the Water Street Market.

I love love this ice cream. The best in New Paltz. Just wish they were open later in the evenings…read more Really nice people too.

Candy-O's

3.8

(6 reviews)

Cute little candy and the ice cream shop in Millerton. There is a wide variety of ice cream flavors…read moreand lots of vintage candy. Our server was very friendly and gave samples of ice cream. I enjoyed the flavor of my chocolate ice cream, although the consistency was a little "whipped" for my taste. I also would have like to have seen my favorite flavor, chocolate peanut butter. Husband orders a Carmel swirl and said there was not much caramel in it. Appreciate the late hours! Nice stop for dessert.

Rude owner, felt profiled due to my race. She was rushing me. Making rude remarks. She lost a what…read morewould have been a high paying and frequent customer for sure. She needs to learn to run a business. How she has so many high reviews is beyond me because I've spoken to others in town and they say she is snappy, rude, accuses people as she did me. Lurks around you and is just plain cranky. And all for overpriced and not impressive candy and crappy clothes. The ice cream is the only selling point but guess the gas stations will get my money now. Small store anyway. Felt claustrophobic by her and the shop. NEVER returning.

Delicioso K

5.0

(5 reviews)

I couldn't believe the owner blended these herself! The flavors are classic yet surprising. The…read moreshop is decked out in colorful artwork, matching the spiked Ice Cream vibe. My Wife and I decided to try the flavor of the month and it didn't disappoint. Served up in a cute stemless martini cup and cocktail umbrella. Cute. 1 scoop was enough this visit but I'm trying to see what that milkshake vibe is like. Signed.. The Mocktail Madam (hehe)

This place is amazing, was skeptical at first but this is now my favorite ice cream....it doesnt…read moreaffect you in any way....the reason I like it is because it is SO MUCH MORE refreshing than regular ice cream and its homemade. So so good....going back to take some home.

The Frozen Rainbow

3.7

(29 reviews)