First time going into this toy store, amazing service! The lady behind the counter was super…read morefriendly, greeted us when we walked in and made an effort to get to know us and what ours needs were. She was very warm and welcoming, showed us in the right direction of what we were shopping for. Highly recommend and will definitely be back! Thank you for such a great experience! She also has the best selection of toys!

Such a gem! After being in town a few days and driving past Blue Turtle Toys multiple times, we had…read moreto pop in! They carry the best selection of unique toys for all ages and interests! High quality brands at fair prices - you can't leave without buying a few goodies! We will be back next time we're in town!

Rude employees, most items are bent or damaged in package…read more. Not a place to fund truly vintage to yet s.

My first time here. It's a great shop with a great selection of figurines and collectibles. The…read morestaff person was great, knowledgeable. I appreciated the good service and prices.

This is one of the best experiences I have had at a store. Everyone was so kind and helpful and…read moreMaya was truly amazing. I can't wait to go back, thankful to have a place to find MTG cards that doesn't make you feel super intimidated and everyone just wanted to help. Very different from other comic stores I have been to.

This is the best comic and card shop around. I enjoy the friendly staff and how well stocked…read moreeverything is. They have the absolute best prices in town and always gives the customer a fair price. I highly recommend this Dayton Gem!!

Wonderful place! Great value and service! Large selection!! Great Value!!! Great Prices!!read more

Friendly owner and staff who seem to genuinely love what they do. This place had a lot of stuff…read moresprinkled in and it was great. Think all the standards (Star Wars, DC, Marvel, etc) and A LOT of lesser known things. True vintage board games, lunch boxes, etc. the perfect place to go with/shop for a collector. Prices seem a little higher than what would be on eBay, but then when you factor in eBay shipping it evens out a lot of times. Plus it's more fun.

Not sure how I haven't reviewed this place…read more Always a go to when I'm in the Dayton/Cincinnati area to browse used films. They have a great horror section, tons of collectibles, and are fairly priced. Staff has always been solid when I've been in.

My first visit. Fantastic collectibles, figurines, toys, and memorabilia. I wish I lived closer,…read morebut I will return.

I have always loved Ollie's biting stopped by there to look for rugs 2 days ago (Miamisburg) and…read morewas shocked! I hadn't been there for several months and the store was nasty. Stuff in the aisles, shelves all. In disarray and the floor was Disgusting!!! I almost walked but I knew I could probably find rugs so I stayed, I didn't even want to lay the rugs down to check them on that floor!! I got my rugs and left without shopping around . Checking out was a whole other experience . One older guy who was struggling and pretty rude at that! Then an older woman came up to help me and the other 8 ppl in line behind me. Ollies u dropped the ball BIG TIME. DO BETTER!

The outside looks nice, but as soon as you walk thru the first set of doors, it's pure chaos, the…read morestore is FILTHY, NASTY, unorganized. The older man who works the register is an old grouch. We tried to help bagging our items, & he snapped at us, telling us to leave it alone, as he likes to organize what he puts in the bags, when the line is 12 people back. The checkout is even worse. Guess they think your in line for a Maze. Ollie's needs to do better.

They have a great selection of games and puzzles. I went in for the 3-D puzzles for my…read moregranddaughters. The store is very quaint and very cozy. Their puzzles and games are very reasonably priced. They always have a puzzle out on the table that you can sit down at and put together when you're not shopping, lol . The most amazing display in the store is the puzzle of the New York skyline they have along the back wall. If I remember correctly, it has well over 10,000 puzzle pieces. The staff is very friendly. Steve really knows his puzzles. He knows what he's talking about. Thanks, Steve! I appreciate you.

I'm very surprised there's not a review of this location yet! I asked the cashier how long they've…read morebeen open, and he told me since last July! ...how have I not been in here before?! I believe there's another location in the Beavercreek mall. This location is much larger and has much more to offer in terms of variety. There's everything here: puzzles, board games, card games, logic puzzles, and more! All of the products are arranged in an aesthetically pleasing manner. This store is very neat and organized, and there's so much to look at! My favorite area is the front right, where they've currently got the logic puzzles. I'll admit, I buy most, if not all of my puzzles online... But now that I know there's a local store, I'll come here instead. I'd much rather support this business. Staff is very friendly and helpful. I already love this store and I'll be making many return visits!

Such a fun store to browse in. They have a lot of different toys then Target and Walmart would…read morenormally carry. A lot of hands on toys as well. The store is always clean and the people working are amazing. Great little store for unique and fun toys. Great for gifts too. Prices are higher, but with support a local small businesses.

This place is busy on a Saturday afternoon! Good selection no matter what age you're shopping for…read more They also making custom birthday boxes which look so fun. The employees were very friendly and knowledgeable!

Cool spot. Friendly costumer service. Solid selection and good vibes. Highly recommend.read more

I was in Dayton for a day-trip and decided to help out a local business. I admittedly originally…read morewent to Game Swap, but was even referenced to this shop by the employees. I was amazed at the amount of merchandise for Magic and Pokémon. After looking around for half an hour, I asked one of the employees if any of the cards behind the display cases were for sale, he had to price them out, but was willing to pull any out that interested me. I had him pull out my grail - an EX/NM 1st Edition Dark Charizard from Base Rocket and he gave me $50. I decided it was too good to pass up and he rang it up for me. The experience with the great prices and relaxed atmosphere will have me checking out the Mason location very soon.

I really like to know what all you all have against Michael. He's been nothing but kind nice and…read morehelpful to me every time I've been in there. people aren't required to have the certain kind of face to work at a store. how about you not be so judging. did you ask for assistance? Did you say oh I have a question how much is this item? What is this for? Oh will this fit in my butt? No you instantly judged him so how about you go to another store and leave him alone, rude people how dare you. Good luck find what you're looking for with that attitude Polly Pricy pants.

Adult beverages may have been involved. Still, when my niece insisted we bring my sister in here on…read moreher birthday after multiple cocktails, we were still the soberest people in the store. And we laughed our butts off at some of the antics Like what you ask. Some woman was buying penis molds for jello shots. She asked if they had any penis's in a smaller size and two men in the store raised their hands. There was a woman raising holy #ell cause she wanted to spend $100 plus and they wouldn't let her. She had a credit card but no ID. She said they were discriminating cause her girlfriend is black. IDK...she wasnt there. Ended up owners and woman dropped multiple F Bombs before they kicked her out and just outside the door she did a face plant. I had enough entertainment for one night and headed home...lol all the way. Lots of merchandise, in every size and style if your into that.