My favorite ice cream place! They have good sizes. I usually get the cotton candy flavor

Best Ice Cream in the White Horse Beach Area. Great selection of flavors in both soft serve and regular ice cream. The service is top notch! It's usually so busy there, we take our ice cream back to the beach house and thoroughly enjoy it by the water. read more

Gellar's was a fun stop. When you step up to the window to order, you can smell the well seasoned flat top and the sizzling greatness upon it. I was almost side tracked from my ice cream ordering. As a Texan.. one scoop at Gellar's in a waffle cone is plenty. I was amazing at the serving size and then accepted the challenge. Great ice cream selection. I didn't try any but there are an assortment of hot dogs, burgers, sandwiches, fries, etc. Staff was nice and didn't rush us slow midwesterners. I recommend Gellar's if you're in the Plymouth area. read more

Gellar's Snack Bar - This was one scoop of Peppermint Crunch in a waffle cone. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Manomet, Massachusetts

See all

Solid 4 star ice cream spot. Like others have said - they serve Richardsons ice cream. Haven't had any food from there yet. Picnic tables out back. Customer service was super friendly. read more

See all

Friday nights they have fresh seafood, whole belly clams - so good! great fish and chips as well. pleasantly surprised and nice service. read more

There's a reason that Yelp classifies this as an ice cream and snack shop. When you're in the Manomet area and have a hankering for ice cream, Gellar's is the place to stop. Nothing fancy, just cones that are reasonably priced in a selection of classic flavors. read more

WARNING- this cute roadside RIP OFF joint will leave you upset if you stop here. We Could have gotten 4 soft serves at McDonald's that tasted better, for the price of 2 tiny cones I got here. They don't have 24 soft serve flavors- they have 3. Skip this place and you'll have a better day- get ice cream or food somewhere else!! read more

Food is super good. Ice cream from Richardsons is a hit. The pastry chef does amazing work.

I've stopped here over the years for ice cream and soft serve. It was ok for the price and location down street from the beach. Today we stopped for a meal. It was ridiculously overpriced. 2 clam strip - 1/2 pints (not knowing how many clams fit in a pint) We got 2 tiny boxes with maybe 15 clam strips in each. They were not good. No fries. No coleslaw. That's it. $24. An order of wing dings. 5 wing dings - $7. Kids chicken tenders. 2 pieces with fries with coleslaw? $7 I could find dinner plates for about the same price anywhere. The portions were pitiful, and overpriced. Really aggrevating. I'm sure the kids working there and great kids. Anyplace else in the area would've been what we were looking for. read more

I have been coming too Gellars since I was a youngin. I've known Suzy for 30.+ years I respect her a lot when I was in Afghanistan she would send me care packages mostly over the course of the year that I was there, furthermore when I came back also gave me a lot of free ice cream for the first couple years. Definitely the best ice cream around and my favorite cheeseburger and fries. read more

Here in Plymouth visiting family. My partner and I wanted to get some quick late night bites after a dip in the pool and unfortunately I will never come back to this establishment nor recommended to anybody because the customer service was just awful. At the start the person taking care of us seemed to be nice but ended up having a nasty attitude, not really sure why. We ordered a 4 piece chicken tender mini meal with fries. According to the menus on the wall, they advertise that the mini meal includes 4 piece tenders, fries, coleslaw and a roll. I had asked the person helping us out if he could double it as my partner and I were going share it. He said sure. We waited for our food & I see he had only given us 4 pieces of chicken tender even though I had asked for double (which should've been 8). I kindly expressed we wanted double the amount of tenders and he loudly expressed that the meal only comes with two and so he did double it. I wasn't a fan the way he responded. Also, my partner has ordered his ice cream in a cone and gave it to him on a cup. And he didn't include any of the sides that come included in the mini meal such as the Coleslaw and roll. Honestly just don't bother, I'd rather eat fast food chicken than grab food at this establishment ever again. read more

We're always passing this place on our drive to the beach from my fiancé's parents place so I figured it was time to try. It definitely has a small town, mom/pop shop feel to it. What became automatically interesting to me was that they have 20+ flavors of soft serve... I don't know very many places with that kind of soft serve variety. we got the tiramisu and coconut soft serve with peanut crunch topping. I didn't think the flavors were spot on with what they claim to be which is why it's a 3 star for me. read more

Gellar's Snack Bar - Coconut and tiramisu soft serve with peanut crunch topping - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Manomet, Massachusetts

A landmark as far as I'm concerned! I moved to Manomet in 2003 and have been to Gellar's several times for everything from a cup of coffee, an ice cream cone, Christmas tree, Haul rental, car repair throughout the years. Now moving away and Gellar's is my last stop picking up a UHaul. Always a dependable place with friendly people! read more

I came in the other day to this cute little shop on the side of State Road. I was informed that it has been there for 96 years (so cool!!) A young gentleman named Brian made me the best cheese burger I have ever had. He was so nice and friendly while he was serving me and he made a delicious strawberry frap! Highly recommend this place great ice cream and employees! Will visit again! :)) read more

First time visiting. They were out of several flavors of soft serve and then we were told "you can only get a large size" of soft serve. Makes no sense to me. The raspberry soft serve had a strange, fake taste to it. Most of it went in the trash, especially since I had to get a large size! read more

Smallest portions I have ever seen! I wish I would have looking in the container before I drove away. $12 fish dinner! Fish sandwich was similar in size. Want to love and support the people of Manomet, but this is the last time I eat here. read more

Gellar's Snack Bar - Smallest Portions Ever! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Manomet, Massachusetts

Very nice staff, very friendly and helpful service. I've cream was underwhelming, unfortunately. The coffee ice cream didn't actually taste like coffee to my sister and I... If we hadn't been told or was coffee flavor we would never have guessed. Father tried the mocha chip and it mostly tasted like chocolate, no mocha flavor. Back to Kush Kone. read more

If you find yourself in Plymouth's bastard child of a village (Manomet), and I say that fondly because I grew up there, definitely drop in for a cone. The correct way to eat Gellar's Ice Cream is on the wall surrounding the church and cemetery across the street - don't be waylayed by the picnic tables. Your legs must swing over the side of the stone like a toddler in a highchair for the genuine experience. Despite any snackbar stigma, I can attest to the fact that the place is immaculate - the owner, a long-time Manometian, manages with an iron fist. While ice cream's the draw, my boyfriend is pretty much obsessed with the burgers, hot dogs, and fries. Stay away from the chicken fingers though - I can't exactly articulate why, but I hate them. read more

Even though they don't put animal crackers on the ice cream cones anymore, like they used to back in the '80 when things were good and people were rich, the ice cream here is still pretty tasty. I recommend the bubble gum flavor or a root beer float. In the summer (they are open year-round), go south on Rt. 3A to Holy Cows (will be on your right) if you want to get a larger serving of soft serve. The boss, Suzie, at Gellar's is always sitting near the front window, and cashiers, especially the very friendly one who always wears her hair up in pigtails, can't give you large servings. Because they don't take debit cards and that's all I ever seem to have on me when I'm driving by, I don't go there as often as I used to when I was a kid. The place has been there forever though, and locals who hang around drinking coffee all day, gossiping and harrassing the cashiers, call it Manomet Town Hall. read more

Cheap- that's the best way to describe our ridiculous small portions of soft serve ice we received this evening. The girl serving 4 of us argued the the portions were correct and it was so obviously small it was embarrassing. I was embarrassed to treat visiting family to Icecream there. We've run into this issues before even with the owner there who had corrected the size , but this was unacceptable. There are too many options to choose from to have to accept this. I would recommend driving to Plymouth center and going to Ziggy's for a better value. Very disappointed for a local business that's been here for so long. read more

I visited last weekend and observed the elderly woman who appears to run the place verbally berate a young female employee. The portion size was far too small for the price. These two factors guarantee I will never return here. read more

We found this place completely by chance. We had dinner (hot dogs, hamburgers and fresh fish sandwich). Wow, what great service. Family run since 1926. It turns out my 82 year old Aunt used to go there with my uncle many years ago so we went back for ice cream with her and it was great. They make individual soft ice cream flavors for you (something that is new to me) as well as normal hard ice cream. The whole family loved it! Worth going to even though it is out of main part of town. read more

I've only been for ice cream. They offer 20+ flavors of soft serve, but I recommend going for their homemade ice cream flavors. The Seaside Smores was a delicious vanilla ice cream with graham cracker flavor throughout and large, gooey marshmallows as hidden surprises. I'm looking forward to trying the other homemade flavors such as "Shark Bite." read more

Gellar's Snack Bar - Seaside Smores. (Check out that mallow peaking embedded in the bite at the top.) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Manomet, Massachusetts

See all

Went to this place today for the second time this summer. Both times the elderly woman who owns it has been sitting in her chair by the ice cream scoops "supervising" the teenagers working and BARKING orders at them. It was AWFUL. I felt so bad for the young man waiting on us, who was super friendly. If I didn't want a root beer float so bad, I would have asked to speak to her. Terrible. read more

Terrible! $30 for a fist full of CHEWY AND SMALL baby whole belly clams! $4 for a bottled soda. The owner should be ashamed of him or herself. Didn't even come with fries. COMPLETE WASTE OF MONEY DO NOT COME HERE. Complete GABAGE! STAY AWAY! Plus they are CASH only so clearly they are double dipping every way, shape, and form! read more

Have been coming here for years and always got the same thing, went here twice this year and the second time after ordering the normal small we were given 3 baby size ice creams and after commenting to the girl there about the size she didn't acknowledge us and we were charged $15 for 3 baby servings. My mom was pissed she wasted $15 and I felt really bad, we definitely wont be back. read more

This place is a gem, it's a local place that's been around forever, ya no shit the seafoods eh. Go downtown to the places that specialize in seafood. That's common sense. It's an ice cream shop and a dam fine one at that read more

Gellars is a favorite spot in Plymouth. You can pick up an easy meal, but I come here for the ice cream. They serve hard and soft serve in various flavors. read more

Gellar's was the hot spot to go when I was younger and spending the summers in Manomet. Your typical summer Cape snack bar. Lots of food options, and even more ice cream choices. Yummy treats perfect for topping off a good beach day. Highly recommended. I used to love their bubblegum flavor, but transitioned to the good ole' vanilla soft serve. YUM! read more

Gellars has been a staple in the Manomet area for quite a while and they get some things perfectly right. The ice cream. 42 flavors of pure headache delight. The gourmet, fun, and ever changing flavors make it hard to choose but once you do, there's no disappointment. The other menu items will serve as a quick fix as well. My only gripe is the cost. It's gone past the normal Mom and Pop store prices and skyrocketed into premium national chain prices and for a lot less creamy goodness. The good ol' days of taking the little league team out after a hard fought diamond dispute will now require a second mortgage. read more

We had a fantastic experience at Gellar's, which was all due to our new friend Jon. Not only did he do a wonderful job crafting our icecream, but his charismatic personality made him a top notch employee. He was very thoughtful and now we definitely want to go back!! If Gellar's wants to continue being a successful establishment, they should hire more people like Jon! read more

The best thing about Gellar's is NOTHING changes! If it ain't broke, don't fix it. I have been going to Gellar's since the 1970's and now we go there with our kids. It's our first stop to and from Manomet when we go there in the summer. I love the nostalgia, the kids love the ice cream! I think we have probably had every flavor on the menu, all o the ice cream is great. Their root-beer floats and chocolate frappes are second to none! We got lunch there this weekend, size and prices were great. The only negative thing is they don't put an animal cracker in your ice cream anymore... but since that's my biggest complaint, they're not doing too bad. Can't wait to go back next weekend! read more

I had never been to Gellar's before, and so came upon it quite by accident. Last week, while cycling in the area I stopped in for a bite to eat. I paid for my corn chowder with my last bit of cash. When I pulled out my credit card for an ice cream cone the owner said, "so sorry, we don't take credit cards". However, on the heals of that comment she smiled and said, "so what would you like, it's on me?". Conversation soon followed. I asked about the history of the snack bar (I'm a retired history teacher) and so got the full scoop (intended). The owner then asked me about my family and then gave me directions for different routes back to Plymouth. Whoever said New Englanders are not friendly or generous of spirit? "Suzy?, you made my day. Thanks! Jeff Beverly, MA read more

EXCELLENT ice cream and seafood. Friendliness of servers could not possibly be understated. A must-visit in the area.

The older women who works here is so disrespectful. My high schools theatrical company was looking to rent a U Haul and when we couldn't pick it up in the morning but in the afternoon (a day before we even needed the truck because they were closed) she said some choice words and hung up on me! Never have I been so awed by the way someone in "customer service" treats their customers! read more

The food was good but a little pricey. Onion rings, clam roll, cheeseburger and a lemonade $37 and change. No on line menu to choose from. Wanted a scallop roll but were told they were out of scallops. They have outside seating but no shade. They need to modernize and get an on line presence of a web site or get on Facebook. read more

I grew up about 500 ft from Gellars. Great ice cream! Burgers and fries are better than Carl's Jr! I'd get an ice cream and go across the street and sit up on the stone wall at the church and watch the cars go by as I ate. I go there every time I get to town and sure enough there's Suzie Gellar inside. She'd spot me at the window, and put a big smile on her face. We'd do some catching up on 'local' news. Yes, I highly recommend going to Gellars and sample some ice cream. You'll be glad you did! read more

If it was possible to give negative stars i would. Went with my girlfriend on a Tuesday around 2. She ordered a seafood salad sandwich and i ordered a scallop roll. The seafood salad was crabmeat with a watered down mayo and the scallop roll was 8 pieces of fried scallops on a hot dog bun for $15.50!!! That is insane. The scallops weren't even big, they were like the size of a quarter. The service was also another issue. The whole process took 40 minutes to order get our food and pay! While we were waiting for our food there were people in line ready to order who weren't even being helped. Way over priced and made our stomachs hurt read more

Wow if they made their servings any smaller you would need a thimble for the ice cream. Not much flavor with the cookies and cream and coffee. I would say this place is not at all worth the trip. Go to Stop and Shop and buy a 1/2 gallon of no name brand it would be better read more

I love this place. Just wish their hours were posted online -- I never know when they close at night!