Oh my goodness haven't had Pizza this good in years. I talked to the owner and everything is made…read morefrom scratch. And it was very very yummy. I couldn't quit eating . We ordered the Hawaiian and it was cooked perfectly and the crust oh my it was crunchy but not over cooked and it was great . We also ordered the house special and it was the same so yummy. If you want to try a great pizza in a small community but also the best ever go here. . I know we will definitely be going here for pizza when we are hungry. Please try this you wont be disappointed

Alright so I usually love local small town restaurants and I'm a sucker for locally owned and…read moreoperated. This one is a true gem in the middle of small town iowa. Today we came to Sigourney to spend time with some family and they asked us to join them for some pizza from this local place called Nicks Pizza. Im always down for some pizza. We decided to give the menu a spin and we got breadsticks. (sorry no pictures they were gone as soon as they hit the table.) The breadsticks were amazing home made deliciousness! They were almost a mix between pizza hut and northern lights pizza bread sticks and they were AMAZING! We ordered the Greek pizza and the house pizza. The crusts were homemade perfectly crispy and perfectly sauced. The Greek pizza had perfect gyro meat and a mix of onions it was amazing. The house pizza was like a supreme pizza but the most delicious topings and the perfect crust. Im not sure if im sad or glad I dont live closer. If I lived closer I might weigh a few hundred more pounds because I would be here every day! This is a great stop here in Sigourney and I will for sure be back. If you are in town stop by and see what i mean. 5 star all the way!

The people, the food and the owner are amazing if you want really good food and a good atmosphere I…read morewould go to the cafe and I also would go to Toby's other restaurant at the square amazing!!

Food is excellent and staff is super friendly and always checking on you. Prices are good too.read more

Cute little restaurant with lots of seats. We were in the…read morelocation to drop off our boy at college and this little town loves their pizza. There were so many pizza joints so we had to try a couple. This spot was very clean, friendly and fairly quick. After we ordered we saw a sign hidden away pointing out specials which was a little disappointing since we were not told about the specials while we were ordering. Pizzas and cheese bread had a great taste. Good, crispy crust and a flavorful pizza sauce.

We were driving through, and I was thrilled to find a pizza place that had gluten free crust! Crust…read morewas crispy and it was loaded with toppings. Great service and the restaurant was very clean. We were also impressed with the staff's immediate consideration to accommodate our son's, with a disability, needs and making him feel comfortable without us even needing to ask. Love that!!

Fast efficient staff; good smells throughout the dining area. Duchess Pizza was easily shared…read morebetween two along with a sizable side salad.

Pizza is fantastic. Onion rings are small for $8.50 and pretty generic. Will be back for pizza.read more

Pizzas on the buffet table were unlabeled, no idea what they were. The ones I tried were thin & the…read morecrust was tough. They don't take credit cards. The cinnamon rolls were good.

This pizza is hard to beat! I really can't think of a better-tasting pizza anywhere that I've…read morevisited. It's unique. Made with the best ingredients-the sauce & so much cheese. They have a wide variety of pizzas, great salad bar, & the homemade cinnamon & caramel rolls are to die for. The owners are very nice & welcoming-staff is friendly. You MUST try it. They have never disappointed! My friends always want to eat here-everyone is obsessed with it. It's famous, or should be!

Four of came here for lunch. We came early which was good because it filled up quickly. And had one…read morevery large party. But service did not suffer. I got a burger and it was good and came as I ordered it.

I love finding downtown institutions and was surprised this has only been here since 2000, the way…read moreeveryone comes to visit and hang out. In many ways, it's a Jersey diner. I had an 8oz ribeye steak sandwich and it was an actual steak on a sandwich. The Texas toast was done perfectly. The steak was done rare like I asked and tasted amazing. All the staff were friendly, many high school or college age. Just my kind of place all around. And with a second room behind, you'll always have a seat for you and your kin. Come on over to Tasos' and sit yourself down.

I love Pagliai's pizza. The beef, mushroom, and red onion pizza is my favorite and their homemade…read moreliquid gold ranch is exceptional. I would recommend this pizza place to anyone passing through Grinnell, Iowa.

We'd heard of this pizza spot since we arrived to Grinnell, so naturally we had to try it…read more Immediately greeted as we walked in the door and loved that we could see all the chefs in the kitchen right then and there. It was busy but not so much that we didn't get sat right away. Our server was also busy so someone else took our drink order - and then gave us menus. We ended up ordering the meatballs, a salad, and a classic pie, and walked out also with a cool vintage looking Pagliai's tee! The meatballs were large, came with two, and really flavorful. The sauce was classic tomato but not basic, you could taste the aromatics and that was so good. Basic salad but really delicious runny ranch to go with it, which I loved. I dipped the crust from my pizza in it and it was just so good! For the pie we split it in half - half with meats and the other half with special. The crust was thin and also seasoned nicely and couldn't say enough about how delicious the cheese was. It was so gooey and thick - it made the pizza so incredibly good. Besides our server taking us on due to the prior one being too busy, the vibes inside were chill and casual, music was good and the atmosphere was pleasant. Everyone behind the pizza counter had smiles and acknowledged you. Was a real delight. Everywhere in Grinnell folks rave about Pagliai's and we understand why. We'll definitely have to come back!

Delicious food, wonderful service and atmosphere. We celebrated our 25th anniversary here. Will…read moredefinitely be back!

The 5 stars explains it all!!! Such a laid back atmosphere but yet still formal environment makes…read morethis a "go-to" place. A little out of the way most times but glad way went the extra mile tonight. I recommend this place 100%!!! The filet lollipops, for an appetizer, were amazing!!! Then came our entrees. All of us got steak and NO ONE was disappointed!!! All done to protection, the way a great steakhouse is supposed to operate. Our server was above and beyond helpful in making our decisions easy and would take his advise time and time again when ordering. Filet was perfect and the Gouda cheese potatoes as a side were to die for!! Definitely go here!!!