The taste of real Italian Gelato comes to Pompton Plains! This was a fantastic experience from start to finish. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, with a clean, modern look that made it a great place to relax. The owners spared no expense and it shows. The owner (German) and staff were friendly and patient, offering samples and helping me choose from a wide variety of flavors. Almost two dozen flavors to choose from. The gelato itself was outstanding--rich, creamy, and full of flavor. I tried a combination of coffee, peanut butter and pistachio, and all were incredibly smooth and authentic. The kinder Bueno was insanely good. You could really taste the quality of the ingredients. The portions were generous, and the presentation was simple but appealing. What stood out most was how fresh everything tasted. It felt like the gelato was made with care, not mass-produced. Prices were reasonable for the quality, and overall it felt like a great value. I would recommend this shop to anyone looking for a delicious treat or a cozy place to hang out. Plenty of easy parking. Thank you, German for your kindness. read more

Great place! Great people! Great flavors! A true Argentine Heladería! They also have amazing coffee! read more

Germano’s Gelato - Front store - Gelato Near Me - Pompton Plains, New Jersey

This place is very large with a big space to sit down and have your gelato. The service was excellent. You can taste a little before you buy it. The staff was very nice and there's so many flavors to choose from. Every flavor I tasted was delicious. I can't wait to go back, very clean. read more

Germano’s Gelato - Outside - Gelato Near Me - Pompton Plains, New Jersey

Germanos Premium Gelato & Coffee is not just an ice cream spot, it's a full on passport stamp. The place itself is clean, modern, and slick: high ceilings, industrial vibes, marble everywhere, and a gelato case so beautiful it deserves its own Instagram account. You walk in and immediately know this isn't your average scoop and go situation. Now let's talk about the gelato. This is seriously premium ice cream. Like... nothing compares unless you're hopping on a plane to Italy or Argentina. The texture? Perfect. The flavors? Insane and I mean that in the best way possible. Rows and rows of flavors that make decision making a full emotional journey. The moment I saw Dulce de Leche, my eyebrow went up automatically. That's when I met Germán, and suddenly everything made sense. Argentine roots, Italian technique, zero shortcuts. Boom. Cultural alignment achieved. #VamosArgentina And let's clear something up real quick: ice cream is not only for summer. If it's cold outside, that just means the gelato melts slower. Science. Pair it with their coffee and now you're living correctly year round. Also, shoutout to the teenagers behind the counter, seriously top tier service. Super attentive, respectful, and locked in on every detail like they were guarding a family recipe. No rushing, no attitude, just genuine care and good vibes. Proof that great service is alive and well. Bottom line: this is dangerous-level good. You come in for one scoop, leave planning your next visit and questioning every other ice cream you've ever eaten. Germanos Premium Gelato & Coffee no es una heladería... es una experiencia internacional. Entrás y ya te das cuenta: lugar moderno, prolijo, elegante, con esa onda industrial y vitrinas de gelato que parecen una obra de arte. Todo grita calidad. Ahora, el gelato... esto es helado premium de verdad. No exagero cuando digo que no hay comparación, salvo que te tomes un avión a Italia o Argentina. La textura es perfecta, los sabores son intensos, reales, y la cantidad de opciones es una locura hermosa que te deja pensando más de lo que deberías. Cuando vi Dulce de Leche, automáticamente levanté una ceja. Ahí conocí a Germán y todo cerró. Argentino, pasión, tradición, y cero chamuyo. Ahí entendí por qué el helado estaba a otro nivel claramente. #VamosArgentina Y aclaremos algo importante: el helado no es solo para el verano. En invierno también se come, punto. Encima con un cafecito de ellos... listo, ganaste la vida. Dato no menor: los chicos adolescentes detrás del mostrador, impecables. Súper atentos, respetuosos y prestando atención a cada detalle como si el honor familiar estuviera en juego. Nada de apuro ni mala onda, solo buena energía y ganas de hacer las cosas bien. Así da gusto volver. Conclusión: este lugar es peligrosamente bueno. Probás una vez y después todo otro helado te parece "meh". Volvés seguro, sin culpa y con orgullo. read more

See all

We arrived at nearly 9pm on Sunday (closing time) and there was still a long line. Service, at that hour was very friendly. Lime mint gelato was great and we mixed it with chocolate sorbet. The flavors were intense but well balanced. Texture was creamy and smooth with no ice crystals. Store was clean and still felt new. read more

I really enjoyed Germano's. The owner is such a gentleman and will patiently describe all the flavors available and make you feel at home. The gelato itself is creamy and delicious. I had the Bailey's and Belgium Chocolate combo and wow the flavors popped! Definitely recommend you pay them a visit. Consistent 5-star rankings can't be wrong! read more

See all

OMG This place has just as many flavors as they do in Italy!!! Every flavor is just as great as the next flavor. Delicious. read more

See all

For several weeks, I've been seeing posts on Facebook and waiting in anticipation for Germano's to finally open. I stopped by today after dinner with my family and was so glad I did! I read somewhere that the building has been vacant for almost 50 years, so it's nice to see a new business opening up in town. The store is pretty spacious with a modern interior and an elevated seating area towards the entrance. Even though there was a bit of a line, it moved pretty quickly. There were so many gelato flavors to choose from, and there were even popsicles, gelato Oreo sandwiches, and a gelato cake inside the case. I ordered a small cup with 2 flavors - Belgium Dark Chocolate and Cookies and Cream. Both flavors were super creamy, rich, and delicious. I was really surprised by how much I enjoyed the Cookies and Cream. I believe the man working the register was an owner and he had an Italian accent so you know it's authentic! I will definitely be returning the next time I am in the mood for a sweet treat. read more

See all

We made our first visit to Germano's Gelato today and I'm so sorry we waited so long! I tried 2 flavors and they were amazing and the service was excellent! I can't wait to go back! read more

Germano's gelato is DELICIOUS! They have a lot of different flavors to choose from. I personally loveeee the dark chocolate flavor and the 80% Belgian. The pistachio flavor and peanut butter caramel are delicious too! The gentleman that took care of us was very helpful, he let us try a few flavors. The location is very close to home and they have plenty of space inside for you to sit down and enjoy your ice cream there. 10 out of 10! read more

Germano’s Gelato - Gelato Near Me - Pompton Plains, New Jersey

See all

Fantastic gelato shop! It is so pretty and stylish inside, comfortable seating, air conditioning, excellent service and their gelato is delicious! We've tried many flavors already and they are all so good. Their ingredients and flavors feel pure and real, pistachio that is actual pistachio, not fake green 'pistachio', hazelnut that tastes like actual hazelnuts. I'm in love. Thank you for bringing gelato with top quality ingredients to our neck of the woods. Can't wait for our next scoop! read more

Tried this place and was extremely impressed. The place is immaculate and well lit. The Gelato is outstanding. The have many wonderdul flavors. There is a small area where you can sit and eat your Gelato. A must come and try! read more

See all

Quite possibly the best gelato in NJ. Germano brought the real deal recipe straight from Italy. read more

See all

Fantastic gelato with a great assortment of flavors. Can't believe this business doesn't have more reviews because it's a treasure.

The best ice cream I've had in a long time ! Flavors were delicious ! I had the coffee with chocolate chips and my family had dulce de leche, mint and cooking dough and we were all impressed. read more

Absolutely delicious! Great and friendly service as well. We will be definitely be back!

Being here transported me right to Italy. From the little squared off gelato spoons to the fresh ice cream that tastes like it was made from scratch moments ago, this place is unlike any in the area. I had the mascarpone berry flavor and it was incredible. I will definitely be back! read more

Amazing. This is what true gelato should taste like amazing amaze amazing amazing amazing amazing wonderful beautiful amazing

The most authentic and best tasting gelato experience in the area. German provides a very warm greeting personality and provides a wide array of flavors for gelatos, sorbet and handheld fun items that are perfect for gatherings. You can tell the quality of each gelato flavor within the first taste and they also provide some very unique seasonal flavors as well. All in all, if you want a differentiated experience that will have you becoming a regular customer this is the place to go. Support local business! read more

I absolutely love this place! Super clean and welcoming environment. Our gelato was delicious and a great price. Definitely recommend for a sweet treat! We will be back (a lot) :) read more

Germano’s Gelato - Gelato Near Me - Pompton Plains, New Jersey

See all

My new favorite place !!! And if you are Argentinian or Uruguayan this is the best Dulce de leche I have try in the region, also staff very attentive and friendly, second time I stopped by and try different flavors and all of them are delicious, don't miss out! Must try !!! read more

Germano’s Gelato - Gelato Near Me - Pompton Plains, New Jersey

See all

When I walked into Germano's it brought me back to my childhood, very rememberable about getting gelatos. The service inside and the people were amazing and the gelato was totally fresh and delicious. I'll never forget it. I highly recommend it. Thank you so much for being so fresh and real. John Agnello read more

Amazing service and food. Highly recommend this place. Great for the neighborhood. Flavors are amazing.

First time stopping in and all I can say is Wow!!! Sampled a few different flavors and one was better than the next!! Some f the beat Gelato I have ever tasted! read more

This place is worth a trip. This is Firenze quality in Jersey. No compromise. The flavors burst. Strictly fresh. Try the pistachio and Belgian chocolate. Delightful. Take your time with every bite. It's that good. read more

Delicious, silky gelato. Lots of flavors to choose from. Little pricy but worth it. Carmel and hazelnut flavors were extra delicious.

I'm from Argentina so I was excited to try this place. Did not disappoint! Their dulce de leche, the best! Great service, they will describe any flavor and let you try. read more

OH MY, I had a package with 4 flavors of my choice . I can't choose a favorite. They are all so flavorfull. Make sure you savor the flavors individually and then combine them to achieve a burst of flavors, combined as a masterpiece to indulge in. ENJOY every spoonful . Great atmosphere to relax and have coffee also. read more

This place is AMAZING! The whole team is a family! They work together to provide some of the best ice cream I've ever had! They also have a big space with a good amount of seating space. Very modern look and very comfortable! The ice cream reminds me so much of ice cream from Argentina, so it is so good! They have so many options and you can even order to take home in a to-go box! I come here like every week and it's frigid out, so it MUST be good! read more

Excellent. Certainly the best gelato we've had in the region - we hope they succeed! So far, we especially liked the Sicilian pistachio, the (Belgian?) chocolate and, the unusual (to us) combination of ginger, lime and mint. Ingredients seem 'natural' - e.g., the mint flavor from mint leaves. FWIW, they've been open only a few weeks, and today, a cool, wet-windy Sunday, was our first time there. We were just driving by, and looped back upon seeing the sign. Visit - you won't be sorry. read more

Gelato was very good. Place is gorgeous inside. A few trees or some plants in pots outside would've been nice. In the summer if they could get permission to put some little tables out front with umbrellas that would be sweet. I didn't feel it was too loud as someone else stated in their review and my hearing is very sensitive. Tables and chairs were comfortable. A nice addition to this area. Might I suggest some GF pastries as well as regular pastries for those who don't eat gelato and want something to go with their coffee. There were so many people there and that was nice to see as I like supporting local family owned businesses. read more

Went for the first time today. Loved being able - and encouraged - to try many different flavors. They were all amazing! I think I found my new favorite treat place. Definitely go try them out. You will be glad you did. read more

Finally made it to Germano's, well worth the wait! I had the Siciliano Pistachio, the best I've had since visiting Italy! The owner is super friendly and the atmosphere is warm and welcoming. I can't wait for my next visit! read more

I've tried many ice cream and gelato places in the area and this is the best gelato I've ever had! I tried 3 flavors and they were all amazing! Owner is really nice and you can tell cares that you enjoy the gelato. Will be back ASAP. read more