awesome experience Owner Pete was great along with his staff Like the multi sections to sit Very comfortable and friendly. Very nice selection in a small area. Were all were very happy my brother referred us to the place. read more

Great place Knowledgeable staff Large area for hanging out and smoking. Great selection of quality cigars. read more

Came in for a smoke today. What a cool spot! They have a fully stocked humidor with an impressive selection of cigars. The staff where friendly as can be. I sat in the guest lounge..and was treated like a regular. Nice comfy leather chairs, easily accessible ash trays and a huge flat screen that faces a coffee bar. Affordable membership fees get you access into the members only lounge which boasts a man cave feel. Definitely will return, and I intend on becoming a member as well. read more

See all

Great " old school " cigar shop. A good cigar shop to me is that great blend of new and old, of leather sofas and brass footrails on mahogany sided bars. I am an occasional cigar guy. I enjoy a good cigar with my family and buddies for holidays and special occasions. Problem is, after 2008, many of the bigger, classy cigar outfits crashed and burned . A lot of what remains is stodgy old cigar stands selling paper bag wrapper stogies. My buddies were taking me out for my birthday, and I wanted to celebrate with a few Don Diegos or Romeo and Julietas. I had heard about Goodfellas from a friend, and decided to check out the place. luckily on this day, the were having a manufacturer's event sampling wine infused cigars from Moscato, with very attractive hostesses, and grab bag deals. Yay ! They have a very inviting and comfortable seating area to sample your purchases. So if you want an old school, classy place to sit an hour and enjoy your favorite cigar, Goodfellas is definitely the place to go. read more

Awesome shop and John(owner) is professional and extremely knowledgeable about cigars. Absolute pleasure to hang out with. Any cigar fan should visit here!!!! Thank you John and keep up the great work!! read more

My favorite cigar lounge when I visit Long Island. Always a good time and have some awesome cigar selection.

Goodfella's Cigars is a fine smoke shop in by the gun range in Medford. It features a roomy humidor stocked with the best from Ashton, Punch, CAO, Romeo y Julieta, Macanudo, Drew Estate, and others; you will find what you need. Or choose from a number of pipe blends in shelved apothecary jars, if that's your thing. The bottom line is you are going to smoke: There is a climate controlled lounge in the back, for puffin' in front of a widescreen, should you want light one up there, or bag them and take them home. I can say that the owner was good enough to listen to me rant about the recent federal tax hikes on smokes as he rang me up, and even tossed me a lighter, gratis, when I asked him for matches! The place gets five stars on this thing of ours. read more

Great cigar shop! Very knowledgeable staff and always friendly. Massive selection of fine quality cigars. Just tell them what you like and they will give you many to choose from. Also very clean and spacious humidor big enough to get lost in. read more

Great upscale atmosphere with a helpful staff and reasonable prices. Smoking lounge and members only area with other amenities. When I walked in I was greeted and asked if I would like a cup of coffee. I just thought that was the greatest thing. read more

Heading out towards the east end of L.I. and lookin for a nice lounge to clip a stick and light up for a while, Goodfellas is the spot. Good selection from Arturo, Perdomo, Rocky Patel, Montecristo & more. BYOB, great ventilation (no burning eyes) comfortable executive seating, large flatscreen, great atmosphere! read more

I am routinely in the area for business and always looking for a new lounge to relax in. Goodfellas was great! From the moment I walked in the door I was greeted by Curtis. He welcomed me and immediately asked me what I like to smoke, and had good recommendations. The atmosphere was friendly and they have convenient seating for everyone. Many lounges have their seats set up so that inevitably you're wrenching your neck to see TV if you have a bad seat, but GFs doesn't have this problem. My only knock was the prices. I know LI is expensive but I do think their prices are a bit high, but the prices to join the members lounge are very reasonable. The only reason I gave them 4 vs. 5 stars is because of the cigar prices. Other than that, I will definitely be back the next time I am in the area read more

Great cigars and atmosphere. Fun group of guys that are a wealth of knowledge when it comes to cigars. It's very relaxed and easy go by yourself or with a group of friends. read more

Located 3/4 of a mile south of LIE on Rt. 112 (Exit 64), Goodfella's Cigars offers a wide range of cigars for both the beginner to the most seasoned Aficionado and everywhere in between. The staff is very knowledgable as well as friendly without any of the stuffiness you'll find at some lounges. The store also sells pipe tobacco, humidors and accessories. It features both a general and a members-only lounge, with flat screen TV's (HD in the members lounge). They also have Netflix and Pandora radio as well. Alochol is not served here but you can bring your own. Soft drinks are available for purchase. Free Coffee is available as well. Memberships are reasonably priced and do come with some benefits. Whether you're looking for a single cigar to enjoy yourself, a gift for a friend or collegue or someplace to watch the game, both the staff and regular customers will make you feel more than welcome. Enter as a customer, leave as a friend. read more

Great place to enjoy a smoke and make new friends ! Very friendly and knowledgeable staff