Always has a good atmosphere inside plus the pizza is incredible. If you're not feeling pizza the wings are at an affordable price and are really good as well. read more

We just really like Goodfella's Pizza. This was our first visit to the Miami location right in downtown on Route 66. Cool building, very clean and great service, but best of all the Pizza! This pizza is absolutely the best and love it. We had The Boss and a pitcher of Ultra and was not disappointed. A must visit in Miami. read more

Goodfella's Pizzeria - The Boss... - Pizza Near Me - Miami, Oklahoma

Great pizza and service. Especially love their thin crust. I would put it up against any thin crust from Chicago.

Great service and great pie! This little pizza place had big taste! It's not much to look at but you're not there for the ambiance you're there for their great pizza!! read more

Great spot to stop for pizza. Restaurant was clean, our order came quick, & the pizza was great! So glad we missed our turn. read more

Place smelled good walking in, both because of the pizza, plus the placement dining area was exceedingly clean. We got The Boss on thin crust & it was great. Server brought our pizza in good time. So glad we missed the road to our intended destination & found this little gem. read more

Goodfella's Pizzeria - Empty plate says it all! - Pizza Near Me - Miami, Oklahoma

They're always delicious!!! The sandwiches are my favorite but I'll mow down a pizza or calzone fast!! Crew is super excited and the managers an amazing dude!! They're downtown and open late which is unique a few games to play and an open brick floor plan!! Go try it!!! read more

Hands down best pizza around !! Good prices pizza was full of toppings all the way to the edge !! Unlike poppa gs that has two inches of dry crust around the pizza! read more

Great pizza and a friendly staff, plus classic pinball machines and video games. Great decor with a comfortable feel, located in the heart of downtown Miami, OK. read more

The pizza is very good, the service is always friendly and I love the new place! Nice and clean and open!!

Terrible pizza. Delivered wrong pizza. Cold and took 50 minutes. Thick doughy crust, undercooked. So nasty, so disappointed Drove 11 hrs today and just wanted pizza. I wish I could get my tip back!!! read more

Pizza and spaghetti was awesome. The staff was very kind and friendly. Had a great time stopping here on Route 66 trip! read more

Goodfella's Pizzeria - a slice of pizza on a plate - Pizza Near Me - Miami, Oklahoma

We stayed in Miami over Memorial Day weekend and thought we would try something local for pizza. The hotel had a rack of flyers and Goodfella's was the only one for pizza. We also looked at the options on YELP. I couldn't get the website to take a delivery order so I just called in an order for pickup. We bought two small specialty pizzas, after a 15% tip it came to around $28. The pizzas were ok, just not worth the price. read more

Nice independent pizza joint. We got a 10" Bada Bing (Canadian Bacon and pineapple) on the original crust (they also offer a thin crust and gluten-free). Good flavor, particularly the crust, and lots of cheese that made it a little hard to cut and bite through. Inside is cute with five or six booths around the perimeter, a couple of tables in the middle, and gangster movie posters on the walls. read more

Goodfella's Pizzeria - Outside front of the building - Pizza Near Me - Miami, Oklahoma

See all

In town for a recruitment visit at NEO with my son. The coaches took us to dinner here and it was much better than expected. We ordered a few pizzas and cheese bread. The pizza was delicious and the bread was almost too cheesy. Very cool spot to visit if you happen to be in the area. They also have beer on tap and a drive-thru for easy pick-up. read more

Good pizza, POOR customer service! Picked up our pizzas and got over 10 miles down the road when they called to tell us they mixed up our order with another. Drove back and exchanged with them. NO offer to refund any money (their prices are on the high side anyway!) or coupon for next order, nothing! Once before they forgot to put our order in so we had to wait an extra 30 minutes. 20+ miles extra driving, the colder pizza, and listening to the very hungry grandkids all the while...NOT worth it. Will find a new favorite take out pizza place that appreciates their customers. read more

Best pizza in town! A little pricey but worth it!! Great selection and customer service is great

The wings are excellent. The pizza and calzones are ok, nothing really that stands them out from other pizza places. I paid $9.50 for a small cheese pizza that was worth maybe 7 bucks. By small I mean it was basically a personal pizza. The calzone was just a simple calzone, small for it's prize also. Also if you are a ranch lover don't bother with it here, the last 3 times we have ordered the ranch has been watery. Not just a little bit like the consistency of water. We will probably stick to Papa G's. read more

Just moved to the area. Really good pizza. Generous toppings. Fair price. Will definitely order again.

Delicious. Perfectly thin crust. All the toppings one could ask for!

ordered 2 large pizzas, got there only made 1, had to wait for other, never offered any discount on there mistake,

Favorite pizza in Northeast Oklahoma. Wife and I had a medium thin beef and onion pizza. It was awesome.

Best pizza in town! Sorry Papa G's, there's a new pizzeria in town! Chicken bacon ranch is delish!