The pizza is consistently great even delivered! They used to have gluten free crust. I've never eaten it. I didn't know they had other Italian food and sandwiches! Gotta try it! read more

Love the pizza. Be sure to allow plenty of time as they stay quite busy during warmer weather months when the lake is popular.

This is our favorite pizza. Period. We can't wait to get back in the area to have it again.

Drove up and saw a worker picking calluses off her feet don't recommend this place at all.

We stopped in with some hungry teenage boys after getting our rv set up. This place is pretty small with just a few tables. We ordered a supreme pizza, a large cheese, and a large pepperoni. This pizza was pretty good. Crispy crust, fresh ingredients, and leftovers warmed up later were delish. We will eat here often when at Grand Lake. read more

Such a delicious meal from here while staying nearby at Grand Lake! There are lots of pizza spots to choose from around the area, but this is clearly the best. The chicken bacon ranch sub was amazing along with the cheesy bread and The Boss pizza. It was very good reheated as well. I would absolutely order Goodfella's again and probably get the same thing! read more

Quick service and great pizza! Have never had to wait very long, and never had a bad experience there.

nice little place. pizza is so ym. I recommend the white chicken pizza. they deliver sometimes too!!

If you remember Kens in the 70's or Mazzios in the 80's this is what we have here. They have an efficient carry out with drive up window. Small seating area inside. Wings are not worth ordering in my opinion as they are bone-in basted style. Salads have STRONG red onions that are not shown in ingredients. Subs have that good creamy Italian dressing! I've had good pizza here before. It's fast and cheap .. That's it! read more

See all

Pizza is da bomb. I love this place. Staff is super friendly. There are several around Grand Lake. This one is in Cleora

I consider myself a pizza snob. I have pretty high standards for pizza and this place did not let me down. The crust was nice and soft and the dough does not sit heavy. Make sure whatever you do to order the cheese breadsticks! read more

We were surprised at the quality of our pizza! The crust was awesome, full of flavor, and our salad was quite good as well. This is a hidden gem... read more

Friendly staff. We really enjoy "the boss" on original crust. The pickup window in Cleora is quick and convenient.

This is a great little hometown pizzeria. They have some very tasty pizza varieties and you get what you pay for here. Their service is also great! We went in and placed our order, and the cashier said that it would be about 45-50 minutes before our pizzas were done. However he said if they were to come out earlier that he would call and let us know..... and he actually did! We had just pulled up in the parking lot and he called to let us know that they were done and he brought them right to the truck for us. We'll be back for sure! If your looking for some good local made pizza this place is for you. read more

Thank Goodness we have such a great pizza place so close to us. I know they've been really busy this year!

Teeny, tiny restaurant, but absolutely the BEST pizza I've had in the past few years! I don't usually eat the crust, but Goodfella's crust is perfect. We had original crust, and it wasn't too thick or too thin. 100% recommend. We will be back for sure. Looking forward to trying all locations! read more

So good!! We have eaten in and delivery. Both are great. We live out of town the opposite direction of the restaurant and were shocked they would deliver. We have never had that luxury before. Cheeseburger pizza on original crust is amazing. Please check Goodfellows out! read more

The pizzas were very good and plenty of toppings. Well worth the money. We will come back again since they are located only 4 miles from my house. Found some MidWest pizzas have a lot to be desired but this place is the exception. 100% better that local chain pizza joint located in bigger city's. read more

One of the best pizza places I know of. We usually get the gangster and the Hoffa Pizza's. Very friendly, helpful and fast service! So if you find yourself at the lake close to Kahoots give them a try you will not be disappointed. read more

Always good pizza. A nice hidden gem at Grand Lake Haven't had a bad meal. Works out great to call in an order on the way up to the lake on a Friday evening. read more

Awesome pizza every time we have ordered it. Fast even on holiday weekends with a good selection of great tasting pizza options. We love the gangster and the Hoffa buried in cheeses pizzas. read more

Excellent Pizza, Top notch service, Friendly, fast, and clean. They have the best RANCH!!! Best Pizza in the area by far. Make sure you try the "Hoffa Buried in Cheese" you will not regret it. Consistently good! read more

Usually I would say this is the best place for pizza at the lake but not anymore. Unless of course you like being treated like crap. I called to place my order and the guy (Tim) that answered was so rude and treated me like I was bothering him. When he took my order he gave me a total ($56) and then tried to hang up. I had to tell him to wait because I wanted to pay by debit card. He said well if you have to pay by card then fine. I told him never mind and he hung up on me. He called back 40 minutes later asking if I wanted to pay by card still. I told him that since he was so rude and hung up on me that I didn't want anything. He asked if I wanted to cancel my order and I said yes. He laughed and hung up on me again!! I have ordered pizza here more times than I can count and this has got to be the worst service I have ever had from anywhere. There are other places to get pizza and I will be using them from now on. read more

Great Pizza, wings... Service is excellent as well! We use them all the time! Their wise guy thin crust is our fav, we add beef!

Good food and service!!! 4 of us easily finished a large - it was more like a medium.

Awesome pizza, best on Grand Lake!!!

Their online menu indicates a 16" Meat Lovers pizza for $13.49. I phone ordered and picked up. Price was $15.99 and was 14". Checkout girl said I was on wrong web site. Hmmmm. Came home and checked again. They need to update their web site. read more