We stopped at Grace Pizza Restaurant on a Saturday evening around 4:15pm because we were already in the Chambersburg area and needed a solid pizza plan before another event later that day. When we walked in, it was quiet quiet -- like, "are we early or is this a hidden gem?" quiet. We were maybe the 5th and 6th people in the place. I found Grace while panic-scrolling Yelp for a legit slice within a very specific radius, and it popped up right at the top. A bunch of reviews mentioned the mysterious "yellow crust," which immediately hooked me. Yellow crust? Say less. We were officially intrigued and fully on board for whatever adventure this was about to be. Then we saw it. The 4 Flavor Pizza. One medium pizza. Four different kinds. Two slices of each. For $17. Absolute genius. We didn't even glance at the rest of the menu after that. Our lineup: Hawaiian, pepperoni & mushroom, onion & sausage, and bacon & meatball. I have never seen a pizza shop offer this and honestly... why isn't everyone doing this?! We grabbed a Coca-Cola and a Diet Pepsi, bringing our total to around $25, and I asked if they could cut the slices in half so we could really maximize our flavor-sampling experience. Zero hesitation. No side-eye. Just a cheerful "sure!" (10/10 already.) The pizza came out quickly and looked fantastic. And yes -- the crust really is yellow. Not "kind of yellow." Not "maybe the lighting." YELLOW yellow. There was absolutely no hiding the fact that something different was happening here. Adventure Buddy immediately went into detective mode, cracked the case, and couldn't help himself -- he asked the person behind the counter to confirm his theory. And as much as it pains me to say it... he was right. EGG. Tons of egg in the dough. That's the secret. The result is a crust that's fluffy, slightly sweet, and completely unlike your standard pizza crust. Grace Pizza was a win for me. This is a very specific kind of pizza -- the kind you crave when you want something a little different -- but when that craving hits, I'll know exactly where to go. Plenty of parking since it's in a strip mall. Pro tip: check your directions ahead of time. Grace sits on a main road that is a real pain in the ass to turn around on if you miss your turn. Don't say I didn't warn you. read more

See all

We stopped in and ordered a pizza and it was very good I highly recommend this place to anyone that's looking for a good pie

I have to admit when I ordered here I didn't realize they also served Mexican food. I was traveling with my 82 yr old Father and I looked up online a pizza place to stop by and get food from. I saw Grace pizza but I did not see say & Mexican food underneath. When I walked in and I heard Mexican music and saw mostly Mexican people eating here I was very skeptical about the pizza being any good. I'm not trying to be racist I just never had pizza made by Mexicans unless there was a Mexican pizza and I don't like that. Anyway the young owner kid said it would be fantastic New York style and he was right the thing was huge lots of toppings the wings were crunchy and crispy and great!!! You have to go to this place!!!! Yum yum get me some!!! Service was excellent as well . Please make sure you go here for your pizza and I'm sure for your Mexican as well!! -Mark read more

See all

Service was great but it is really a Mexican restaurant. Also way too much cheese on the pizza.

Ordered large meat lovers. Good pizza for a good price. Will order from here again. Friendly staff.

Stopped in on our way through town. The place was empty at 7 pm on a Sunday - which concerned us a bit . We were not disappointed! The pizza came molten lava hot and was absolutely delicious. The dough was an interesting yellow color and very tasty. Would recommend! read more

My wife found this place by looking at the nearby reviews on Yelp and we decided to try it a little before noon on a Sunday. It felt perfect for us. A combination of Italian and Mexican. My wife loves Mexican food and I love Italian food. We did think it was a little interesting how they came together in the same restaurant but the reviews we saw were good. Most were outside of Yelp but they were Five stars in Yelp with two reviews. You can only enter the parking from traveling West on Lincoln Way East because there is a median in the road. This makes it a little more complicated if traveling from the other direction. When we arrived the parking lot was not very busy and the business is located on the right side of a very small strip mall with a couple other businesses. We entered and there was one other table seated with about 12 vacant. You order at the counter in the back and have a seat. I decided to get the Meatball Parmigiana Sub and my wife decided to try the Sopes at the recommendation of the young lady working. As we were seated several individuals came in to pick up delivery orders. Our meals arrived a short while later and looked really good. My wife was really impressed with the appearance and taste of her Sopes. The Meatball Sub was good but did not really stand out. I have had better but it hit the spot. Overall, a good stop but we would actually recommend choosing a Mexican menu item because that appeared to be their strength in our opinion. read more

See all

Pizza is really good. We had the supreme and it was generous. Service was excellent. Salads were very fresh. Would recommend.

Ordered pizza to go & it was ready on time. The pizza sauce was too sweet for us, and the cheese on top was not our choice. The crust seemed undercooked read more

Good pizza and good price. Very professional and friendly service. Was ready when I get there and was given paper plates napkins etc. read more

Went here today for a quick bite. Very friendly service and outstanding food. We got the authentic Quesabirrias and it was very fresh and flavorful. You can't go wrong. We also got the 2 slice cheese pizza special and the pizza had a nice crunchy crust. I'd like to try the Mangonadas dessert and the fresh juice: horchata or hibiscus on my next visit. read more

Great pizza, super friendly owner. Their 'Bambino' or personal pizzas are about $8, toppings $1.50/ea. Will be back again.

Very tasty pizza, served hot. Warm cozy environment. Lovely wait staff. Highly recommend.

This is the kind of place I am always on the lookout for, locally owned family run establishment. They have pizza and subs but I go for the Mexican food authentic tacos, burritos, tamales, quesadillas, quesabirria and soups. Friendly staff and great food. The best thing is they are local. read more

We order pizza a lot. New York style is our favorite and haven't been impressed with our previous haunts since pandemic tightened the purse strings all around. This is the best pizza I've had in several years! Graces pizza I'm your number one fan!! Asked for extra sauce and got it. So happy!!! read more

I order from here all of the time and their food is awesome I've tried many things on the menu and I am always satisfied can't wait to try the Taco bowl, think I'm gonna go today read more

This is quite a gem! The tacos were so yummy and I would have taken a picture, but I ate them up quite fast. The service was quick and the staff was very friendly. Will definitely be making this a regular place for taco Tuesday! read more