This place was recommended far too many times for me to not check it out. Since my initial visit, I've been back twice, so it must have struck a chord.
The restaurant is very easy to find...Cottam ain't that big. It's at the main intersection (4 way stop) on the south side, next to the parking lot.
Atmosphere is very casual...warm wall colours, awesome tin ceiling, friendly staff, etc. Almost everyone dining there knew someone else in the place....so it's got strong community support.
There's tables for 2 ppl, 4ppl, 6ppl...any bigger I'd suggest calling ahead.
Waitstaff is attentive but not obtrusive.
Food is homestyle fare...today's lunch special was egg salad sandwich and potato bacon soup. On my first visit I ordered lunch...homemade burger with fries. It was excellent. On my most recent visit I ordered eggs/ham/home fries/rye toast. Food was out in 10 minutes and was very good.
Total for 2 ppl for bkfst, not including tip was less than $25....so it's a good price point considering quality.
Restaurant is only open for bkfst and lunch...I believe it closes at 2pm. Weekends are very busy. read more