Love Gus's. Probably not traditional comfort food but I certainly consider it to be! Best pizza, fried mushrooms and Texas wieners in town! read more

No effort in making the food... ordered today 7-20-2026 my meatball sandwich was so soggy couldn't even eat it! Sauce was burnt tasting. Meatballs were mushy. Then my wife ordered a panzerotti and they gave her a personal small pan pizza instead.. food was disgusting and will not be ordering from there again... read more

Gus's Pizzeria - The bottom of my sandwich this isn't evening the top!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Pennsville, New Jersey

make sure you check your overpriced order before you leave. they'll hire anyone and notoriously mess up orders. the quality of food is less than par. it's a shame this town doesn't have a decent pizza place. read more

Nice people run it and the food is awesome!!! Try the South Philly CHEESESTEAKS!!!!!!! Its a must!!

The food was fantastic. We ordered ahead for lasagna for thanksgiving as we had lots of people visiting this year. What a great food. Easy to pickup and counter staff was really friendly. Thanks Gus's! read more

Still in town visiting (day 6) and have not yet had a slice of pizza, with only a few choice places to go to I chose Gus's. This is still the only place that hasn't strayed from their roots. The others have gotten so big they forgot what a pizza joint is suppose to be. I ordered (2) slices and a drink, square slices. Not sure how to describe it but perhaps a cross between NY and Detroit, it's what you find in this region. This was done perfect with great crust mainly because it's re-heated to give it a crisp bite. Again, this something you don't find anywhere else, I would not recommend it to a pizza snob you have to be open minded and able to except all pizza. This is my go to pizza joint when in town. If traveling on RT49 in P'ville, give it a try. Peace. read more

See all

Yesterday when I sat down in here for the 1st time in a while I ordered food. They haven't changed a bit and I mean that in a good way. Too bad I'm too "big" for the booths otherwise they'd be more enjoyable for me to sit in. Staff were friendly as they were over the years of me dining here. read more

Obviously they are not Italian probably the worst chicken parm with spaghetti definitely not a true cutlet it was like frozen patties with sauce and cheese there sauce needs improvement and not tasty at all the spaghetti was overcooked and garlic bread gross all covered with oil and tried there pizza not good at all don't know how this place is in business maybe because it's in a small town and the price was way overpriced for crappie food never again don't eat at this place not good at all read more

I got the baked ziti I was skeptical at first, but it does taste pretty good. It came hot with breadsticks and a salad. The breadsticks were not really flavored. They were supposed to be garlic, but they weren't the best but the baked ziti was really good. It was nice and hot. I had a really good cheese pull we had it delivered but it did come pretty fast and that was for four people read more

Gus's Pizzeria - a piece of pizza with cheese - Pizza Near Me - Pennsville, New Jersey

See all

Best pizza ever! Great establishment I've been coming here since I was a kid. I recommend everything on the menu. You won't be disappointed!! read more

This was my third or fourth time ordering. Main reason for low rating is bc the total price Gus's website had indicated I would pay for my entire online order, inexplicably rose by almost a dollar as soon as the status of the order went from ordering/paying to "tracking/making your order." When I compared the pre- and post-order total prices, it appeared the tax went up by $0.04 and the food cost rose about $0.60. Watch for this when ordering online! (There was zero explanation for this $0.64 bump in price, and the place was too busy to ask about it when I went to pick up my order in person.) Second reason is that the quality of the food has dropped with every visit. This time the lettuce was brown and old-looking when I opened the bun. The fries, which are usually a major draw for me, were ice cold and soggy--and bc I'd ordered some black-pepper seasoning on them, they were drowned in it. (Looked like a black-ant invasion on my taters!) The fried shrimp basket tasted good, but was also cold--and I was there well within the time-window that the online-ordering platform had stated to be there for food pickup. read more

Bravo Zulu Pennsville!! When someone who grew up in Pennsville says they like Italian Kitchen but try Gus's. You gotta try Gus's!! I did and I am glad I did!! They made it on Garlic Bread for me. It was big. It was juicy. It was flavorful. It was very good. read more

See all

Best pizza I've had in years. Next time I'm in Pennsville I will get one to take home to Annapolis. read more

Gus's Pizzeria - Best pizza I've had in years. - Pizza Near Me - Pennsville, New Jersey

1st time ordering here. Order the veal parm dinner. Wasn't impressed. Food was luke warm not hot, the veal was a chopped patty, and the bread was hard as a rock. The best part was the salad, very fresh. Won't be ordering from here again. read more

Probably my all-time favorite pizza. I just love their tomato sauce. Their regular crust is kind of thick, but good! Generally lots of sauce and gooey cheese. Their pepperoni is great. They also have thin crust. Texas wieners are ok; but, way too skimpy on the sauce. Stuffed shells/baked ziti are good. Chicken Parm is good enough. Burgers are big, but kind of bland. Wings are very good. They have a drive up window; and you can order online. Can't beat ordering online-they have various discounts and specials. You can get a square, 1 topping for $14.99! Anywhere else, you'd pay $20 for something like that. I've tried all the other places in Salem County, none as good. I live in Elmer, 20 miles away; but, still drive here at least once a week. And, I pass a dozen other pizza places doing it! read more

Gus's Pizzeria - Plenty of gooey cheese! - Pizza Near Me - Pennsville, New Jersey

I called to place an order two hours before closing time and they said they were already closed. I find that ridiculous, especially since I order from this restaurant a lot. It happens every other time I try to place an orde. read more

So sad.................no reviews yet!!! I think everyone who goes here just takes it for granted...we cannot find a pizzeria like this in Florida.:( Every time I go home to visit I have a Texas Weiner or a pizza steak. I have had a pizza steak from the other places in town but Gus's does it best, hands down. For those who have not enjoyed these items, let me splain: A texas weiner is a hot dog split in half, grilled, and served on a special bun that fits it perfectly. It comes with a special chili sauce, very finely chopped onions, and mustard. Just so darn tasty. Legend has it that my maternal grandfather (who passed before my birth) could eat one of these in 2 bites. Very impressive!! I wouldn't want to hurry the experience like that but I can understand. :) A pizza steak CAN be had here in Florida but is not made the same way at all. Down here, they take a cheese steak and ladle on some pizza sauce. In Pennsville (and all places make it the same way but Gus's does taste the best to me) the ingredients...the steak, cheese, and sauce...are somehow all glommed together and put on the roll and they become one with the roll. Add in some sautéed onions and mushrooms and you are talking melt-in-your-mouth nirvana. Admittedly, my husband does not worship the pizza steak as I do but he's from CT and calls subs grinders and rubber bands elastics so what the heck does he know????????? :) There are many other menu items and I'm pretty sure my mother has tried them all...she keeps a drawer full of take out menus and Gus's is her main go-to spot. She raves about whatever she gets and especially loves the hot roast beef sandwich...with extra gravy...for her french fries...what???...you thought my family was into health food???? Oh, and if you're feeling ultra lazy, they do have a drive through for pick ups...top that!! :) read more

Pizza is not good, tastes like cafeteria food. Ordered a cheese steak, came with no cheese and the steak was over cooked.

In Pennsville, near the state line of Delaware and New Jersey we were lucky enough to stay over at a hotel that recommended Gus's pizza. Delicious. Crust - amazing. Sauce - divine. Cheese - heavenly. We will be back on our next trip through. Highly recommend! read more

Why isn't pizza this good in the Midwest? While in the area for business, I asked the hotel clerk who had the best pizza and she recommended Gus'. I ordered the buffalo chicken pizza with bread sticks for delivery. The crust was buttery and deliciously cooked. There were plenty of toppings on the pizza. The hot sauce had just the right amount of kick and heat. The bread sticks were loaded with garlic and Parmesan cheese. Both were very tasty. The next time I'm in town I will definitely dine with them again. I would love to try some other things on their menu such as their loaded fries. read more

I really enjoyed the chicken quesadilla. I am particular on how I like my pizza steak made and Gus's will make it just how I like it. Layered and grinded. read more

I made the mistake of eating a slice of this pizza in a fit of delerium on a hot and humid summer night. You'd be better off with a box of Ellio's. This is by far the absolute worst pizza I've ever had in my life. It wanted to have my taste buds surgically removed afterwards. It looked like a Sicilian pie, but was the most disgustingly doughy and miserable pizza experience to date. If you really don't care about taste or quality when it comes to pizza, then this is your place. Besides no legit pizza place also sells Texas Weiners. That should have been the first clue that Gus is a pizza imposter read more

I've been several times and was never really impressed but last Saturday's visit was probably the worst. While the pizza had a good taste the crust was very thick, soft and doughy. The Italian Sub was a mess, the bread was tough and the tomatoes weren't ripe (come on, really, a bad tomato in New Jersey!). I'm not sure why every one raves about their Texas Weiners because I think they are the worst. The hot dogs are usually soft (like a cheap brand) and they're very skimpy on the sauce. read more

Great food and very reasonable prices. Texas weiners are good, pizza is good, cheese steaks are better than any place in Philly (and I have eaten them all over) and they also have great hot wings. Gus's is a long time Pennsville tradition and with all of the other great places to eat, it would not have lasted so long if it were not really good. read more

Putting everything aside, Gus's is a pizza place, and therefor must have decent pizza. Unfortunately they do not. Their pizza is constantly under-cooked, soggy and has a rare oven taste. I got a piece of cheesecake there last time, when I went to eat it, it was warm, when I asked why, the manager said it was frozen so he had put it in the microwave to get it soft and "ready to eat.' -- That is a disgrace! read more

Had a turkey sub last week. Goood! Turkey was nice and moist, fresh roll, and shredded lettuce - luv the shredded lettuce.

Passing through and wanted some local flavor. This is it! The Texas Weiner is really good. The famous sauce makes the difference. Pizza is great! The dough is perfectly light and crispy. Highly recommended! read more

Gus's Pizzeria - Home of the Texas Weiner - Pizza Near Me - Pennsville, New Jersey

Hot wings are the best around town and the chicken cheese steaks are very good.

Me and my wife just left there the food sucked. Her garlic bread had hair on it. And her lasagna was frozen on the inside and we were given.a hard time about a refund. And no hair nets on anybody or gloves. And when I asked to speak to a manager they didn't have one there and looked at me like I was crazy... read more

This place needs to lower prices. Food not of good quality at all. Texas wieners, I think not! Somebody needs to learn how to make a hot dog on the grill. Will not be going back to this place. Should have known, nobody inside at lunch time. read more

Gus's has the best sauce in Pennsville. Just the right amount of garlic and great tomato flavor. The crust is just right, and I have yet to have a pizza from them where the cheese has been burnt. The service is fast and the indoor eating area is always clean. If you really want a great pizza, stop at Gus's. Their nearest competition is Pat. Bigger isn't always better and Gus's proves that. read more

Love Gus's Food best food in NJ...........Always great service and great food. Eat there once a week.

I've typically been a big fan of Gus's & have loved them for years. However, the prices have gone up, while food and service has gone down hill. I'm sorry to say that with my recent order of 2 menu items, having to wait over an hour for delivery, to only have cold food serve has made the final straw of them losing my business. read more