This ice cream is delicious! If you are traveling between Cleveland and Erie this is well worth the 2 mile drive!

Wasn't sure it was open, but flag outside said open. They were definitely open. The gentleman & young lady working were very nice. Offered samples to try. Ended up with a flight that consisted of 6 scoops of your choice & a chocolate chip dipped waffle cone with 2 scoops. Lots of different flavors to choose from. The ice cream sure was heavenly. read more

Heavenly Creamery is a locally owned place to get ice cream. It has lots of basic and interesting flavors. Many are the usual classics but there's some more interesting ones. Good service and prices aren't bad. They also have a non dairy sorbet. Cool places for sitting inside. It was an old church before becoming an ice cream place. The old pews are the seats. It has a fairly big menu for not having that much space inside. There's a mix of classic and modern flavors for a decent price. It has some healthier choices.They have a grape sorbet. It's about $3.50 for a cup. They give you a lot. It also has a loyalty card. Save by bringing it in. They give you a free bowl when it's completed so don't forget you have this. read more

Heavenly Creamery - Grape Sorbet - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Conneaut, Ohio

Heavenly Creamery is an ice cream shop in a church. I'm always pleased to see former church buildings being reutilized. And I'm always happy to see ice cream shops. Heavenly Creamery had good selection and lots and lots of seating and standing room. You could bring a whole team of kids here after a game and everyone would not only fit but be able to walk around.. It's too bad that I don't recall what I had at Heavenly Creamery, but it was four months ago! I know I liked it. I'll be sure to go by the next time I am in Conneaut. read more

See all

Great rich ice cream made on site. You won't find better. The only thing I miss about living in Conneuat is the ice cream.

Great ice cream and various flavors really like the Sundaes! The location is awesome! Services is awesome to the owners are very friendly and willing to make whatever you like read more

The ice cream was delicious but we didn't eat it inside because it smelled awful in there! It seriously smelled like we walked into a bathroom after someone had done their business! It was awful! We got our ice cream and took it outside and ate it. It was really yummy! I had the pineapple habanero on a sugar cone and it was delicious - just the right amount of spicy and sweet! Friendly staff! Was really busy for just about 9pm on a Tuesday! read more

Best ice cream with different flavors all the time. Love the atmosphere with the church pews

Yummy good ice cream with excellent service. Drove an hour to get there and definitely worth the drive.

Great ice cream . Many different flavors to choose from and great service . I highly recommend this place for anyone who loves ice cream n

Absolutely love this place!!! Every fall I've gotten their ginger molasses ice cream and have it with warm pumpkin spice cookies from the oven. Their ice cream is literally the best. And trust me, I've gone on tours at ice cream factories all over the country. This is honestly the best and it's right in my backyard! read more

Best ever, even Zola loves it! You would be a fool to not go out of your way to come here.

I'm allergic to dairy and this place has a nice variety of dairy free options. Place it's in a church so it like heaven in every bite. All made in house and the wait staff is great read more

Not cool, sign outside and on door says closes at 9pm, its 845 and their doors are already locked. Got off highway just for this and they "closed early"... and on a Friday??! read more

This place is the best ice cream shop I have ever been to. The ice cream is all homemade in the basement. I talked to the owner: he says he makes ice cream almost every day. It's all real ingredients. People will ask why cherry is brown instead of red and he said it was because they actually use pitted cherries and not just flavoring. He also said it takes 3 days to make it- they make it, the harden it, then they soften it. The atmosphere is amazing. It's all very clean, but has stained glass and looks like an old church. This place should flourish. I wish this place was closer to where I lived! read more

Heavenly Creamery - Stained Glass, Great Atmosphere, very clean! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Conneaut, Ohio

See all

LOVE that this place is an old church! It's a little bit plain inside, but I love that they've kept the altar and windows as-is. Could stand to have a little more decor on the walls, but decor doesn't make ice cream taste good, so that's really just a nit-picky comment. Standing in line, I was overwhelmed at the flavors and wanted to try at least 8 of them. I reeled myself in and asked to try 2 or 3, then placed my order. Upon hearing me comment on having wanted to try the melon sorbet and wondering aloud if the pina colada was made with real coconut (I'm allergic), the gentleman answered my question while scooping an additional taste of pina colada and melon! Mind you, the place was packed and they were closing in 10 minutes, but he still took the time to answer my questions, talk about their ice cream, and give me a sample without me directly asking for one. When I commented that their melon sorbet tasted like I bit into a frozen watermelon, he said, "It'd better taste like that, I juiced melons for 8 hours to make that batch!" Unbelievable. I appreciate good, homemade food and treats, and this is a true and rare diamond in the rough! Having grown up visiting family Conneaut, I'm thrilled to finally have tried this place and plan to make a trip (or three) there every time I return from here on out! Keep up the incredible work, Heavenly Creamery! Those flavors are amazing!!! read more

They have great homemade ice cream. The flavors truly taste like what it says the flavor is. Staff is always friendly

So when I pulled up there were no cars and it didn't appear open I drove around the block and then decided to check it out. Walked in and there was a man sitting in a chair doing some paperwork. He greeted me and offered me samples. The ones I tried were great at first but had a bit of a "kick" to them on the aftertaste. I still give this place 5 stars because it offered a nice respite during my travels. Took a hour break did some work and had great conversation with the man who ended up being the owners son. If you are in the area def a great place to stop, visit, and shop local. Apparently the are constantly changing flavors and will have over 120+ each year. read more

Amazing and absolutely heavenly place. Fresh home made hand churned and oh my. The best freshest most exciting creamy flavors like nowhere else! Not anywhere from buffalo ny onward even read more

See all

Equal parts deliciousness and charm. If you're passing through you have to check this place out, its an experience. The ice cream base is top notch, even with no flavor (plain/sweet cream ice cream) the quality is evident, add to that the unique flavors they do offer and you have a real treat. We love stoping by whenever we're in town. This is the kind of weird ice cream your pregnant wife is going to crave and you'll be making special trips to go get it. Don't worry, it comes in pints. read more

My waistline is in real trouble here. The Heavenly Creamery is delicious. My family wanted to try this new local ice cream venue, so we went over the weekend. We were impressed! The ice cream is homemade, and they offer a variety of interesting flavored and toppings. Everything tastes great. The setting (an old church) made for a unique experience. Everything is bright inside, and in glad that many of the old church fixtures (pews, pulpit, stained glass windows) were left. They helped make this a really cool place. The ice cream was great, the building is cool, the staff was friendly, and the price was reasonable. I'll definitely go back. read more

See all

There is a decent selection of flavors, all homemade, new flavors every so often, staff is nice. Taste 4/5 Quantity 3/5 Price 2/5 Mood 3/5 Bar N/A read more

This was a delightful find on a recent road trip. Such a quaint shop and great way to repurpose a beautiful old church! So glad we stopped here! read more

Good ice cream. Cool flavors. The only problem I have is the people aren't the nicest. Maybe that was just me but the girls seemed to have a lot of attitude and were snobby. read more

A cute old church turned to an ice cream shop! New variety of flavors every day. Great service and great experience

Simply put, Heavenly Creamery's ice cream is the best ice cream I have ever had. I got to try it this summer, and I've been thinking about it ever since. This is especially crazy because I'm not even a huge fan of ice cream. I enjoyed the butterscotch and almond mocha flavors. The flavorful ice cream has a dense, luxurious texture and tastes like it is made by people who know what they're doing. It's a marvel that they can produce such excellent quality and offer so many flavors. The shop, set in an old church, is clean, super cute, and novel. The staff is friendly, helpful, and patient. You can't help but feel cheery after visiting. read more

Great little ice cream place, in an old church. Bright, clean and great ice cream. Sample any ice cream before you order. Favorite stop when the grandkids are in town. read more

Great addition to Conneaut! Excellent homemade ice cream in very creative flavors! I have had the pistachio and the chocolate banana. It will be difficult to stay on my diet this summer! The building is a restored church near downtown. read more

Heavenly Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Conneaut, Ohio

Awesome ice cream here and they have a lot of interesting flavors. Definitely stop here if you're in town and looking for some sweet cream in Conneaut town. ;-) read more

Heavenly Creamery - This place is a very cool converted old brick church. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Conneaut, Ohio

WOW, what a cool place. And Yes, the ice cream is homemade and very good. Like the fact that you can try any favors you like. If you are in the area, do stop and have some great ice cream! OH, almost forgot. The spoons and straws change color as they get cold. They sell bowls if you would like to purchase that, which I did for a great nephew. read more

Too much fun. Great ice cream, creative environment and very pleasant owners. Go here often. Eat ice cream. Make this a cash cow for these nice people. read more

My wife makes me drive 80 miles round trip for ice cream and I don't complain one bit! Very complex and amazing flavor combinations . This isn't just for kids! The ice cream cakes are also very good. Friendly service , great selections , and delicious treats make this our number one frozen treat destination! read more

Wow!!!!!! That's all I can say. The service and the ice cream is truly amazing. I would recommend everyone should go at least once but I guarantee you will stop by again very soon. . read more

Honey and chai tea ice cream are my favorites! They have a variety of unique flavors to choose from.

Loved this place!!! The staff was amazing and always made sure we were having a good time. Ice cream was so good, you could tell that everything was homemade. The decor was beautiful, clean and not to mention the fact that it has the stained glass and the church theme was fantastic. Will definitely be going again. read more

First, the ambiance is perfect being in an old church. Then, there is the 20 something flavors of homemade ice cream that are constantly changing to tempt your sweet tooth. Lastly, the staff is great and very helpful. read more

What an awesome place. Great ice cream and atmosphere. Everyone should visit. One of Ashtabula county's true gems.

It was so good. I got the milkshake. The milkshake was so creamy and good. It had a great taste to it

Very creamy and large selection of flavors. The chocolate with raspberry was my favorite.

Super homemade ice cream! Beautiful build8ng and spotleess inside! Great stewardship of previously vacant century old church. This familyowned and operated icream and dessert shop is a must in NE Ohio! read more