My favorite pizza spot in Gilroy! This was our second time here and it definitely didn't disappoint. We ordered the 2-meat combo and the BBQ Hawaiian, and both were really good honestly, all their pizzas are solid. That being said, the Spicy Cowboy and the BBQ Chicken are still our top favorites. The flavors are always on point and the quality is great. If you're in Gilroy and craving great pizza, this place is a must. read more

High & Mighty Pizza Joint - BBQ Hawaiian & 2 Meat BBQ Combo - Pizza Near Me - Gilroy, California

My partner and I came to this pizza joint because we LOVE PIZZA. As soon as we walked in we were greeted right away by a very nice worker! He let us know where we could find the menu up close, as opposed to the giant one listed above us. My partner and I decided to go with the Cowboy Pizza and the Pesto Pasta. BOTH OF THESE FOOD ITEMS WERE SPLENDED!! Compliments to the chef, seriously. We really wanted to pair our food with lemonade, but they did have any like they listed on the menu. We ended up going with two ciders from "2 TOWNS CIDERHOUSE." My cider was POG Cosmic Crisp but unfortunately it was a little flat and not as enjoyable. My partner got the Mango Cosmic Crisp and he enjoyed his better. I wish they had lemonade, or I wish I would've just stuck to a water cup or a different type of beverage. They have a lot of options for 21+ but they also have a Stubborn Soda Machine with 8 different flavors. There is plenty of seating indoors as well as outdoors! The inside is decorated with lights, plants, and a majority of the seats are a nice brown leather. Overall, it was wonderful. "Better than Round Table." - Isaac Cain Alvarez (his fav place lol) I told him we have a new spot to celebrate his birthday! read more

Tried High & Mighty Pizza Joint in Gilroy for the first time, and I've gotta say--this place seriously impressed me. The pizza was phenomenal--perfectly cooked, non-greasy, and you can really taste the quality in both the cheese and the dough. The crust had a great texture, and everything just came together exactly how you'd want it to. The vibe is what really makes this place stand out. It has that classic, old-school family pizza restaurant feel--like something straight out of the '80s. It's a great spot to sit down with family, enjoy a meal, and even grab a beer while you're at it. If I had to nitpick, I do wish their large pizzas were a bit bigger. Prices are about average, but honestly, when the pizza is this good, it's not even a concern. I wouldn't call it New York or New Jersey style--but for what it is, it's really solid. I'd rate it an 8.1/10, which is a strong score from me since I usually reserve 9-10 for true East Coast pies. I'll definitely be coming back. read more

See all

Recently visited with my family during Father's Day weekend. The restaurant is clean and the staff was very helpful and friendly. We ordered a half pepperoni and half BBQ chicken pizza and it was very delicious and came out in a timely manner. They have a good beer selection on tap and even more in a fridge as well. read more

Nice cozy place to grab pizza! We tried quite a few recommendations from the staff, I can't remember all the names of the pizzas but they were delicious! They even recommended different drinks you could mix at their drink machine. 10/10 definitely recommend read more

See all

I haven't been here in a while. Took a pepperoni pizza to go. Staff was super friendly, pizza was awesome!! read more

High & Mighty Pizza Joint - Pepperoni to go with - Pizza Near Me - Gilroy, California

Their normal pizzas are awesome but I cannot get behind their Detroit style pizza. It was salty and burnt. We surmised that it was the pepperoni that made it salty. My family members said it was ok but for me it bordered inedible. Their standard pizzas were great though. Floppy and flavorful. The chicken bbq was unique; would get again. By the way the ranch is 50 cents but it's nice and thick and not watered down. Love that our children were running around and there's plenty of space and no one cares or mildly cared but don't say anything. Would def get their normal pizzas again but will pass on the Detroit pizza. read more

See all

Stopped here on our way to Monterey. Super great! Staff was friendly and efficient, beer was cold and pizza was deeeeeelicious! Ordered the Tri tip jalapeño pizza (added roasted garlic because we are in Gilroy) Definitely would recommend! read more

See all

Mmmm I love this place, the staff is super nice, especially the blonde girl and the two girls with brown hair. Vibe is pretty good, sometimes they play some pretty sad songs but they have live music pretty often. Food is spectacular, LOVE the ceaser and the land of plenty pizza. CHURRO PIE IS A MUSTTTT, skip the s'mores pie! read more

Tried the BBQ Chicken and the 2-Meat BBQ combo pizza (we did a half-and-half) at High and Mighty Pizza Joint in Gilroy. Overall, a really solid spot. The BBQ chicken pizza leaned a bit too sweet for my taste, and they do add cilantro--so if you're not a cilantro fan, keep that in mind. That said, the crust was excellent--crispy, flavorful, and definitely one of the highlights. The 2 meats bbq meat ( briskets & Sausages ) was excellent. loved the bbq taste. You can actually see their half-dome pizza oven from the parking lot, and the BBQ aroma hits you before you even walk in. Smells amazing and sets the tone right away. Also wanted to give a shoutout to Jackson, one of the staff. I honestly thought he was the owner because of how much he cared about the place and the customers. Turns out he's not--but his attitude really stood out and made the experience even better. Would come back, especially for that crust and the overall vibe. read more

High & Mighty Pizza Joint - Half and Half : BBQ chicken and 2 Meats Combo - Pizza Near Me - Gilroy, California

Delicious pizza and garlic bread was my favorite Pizza was thin and has crispy crust. read more

High & Mighty Pizza Joint - Pizza Near Me - Gilroy, California

This place is crazy good. Amazing pizza. Epic beer selection. Great atmosphere. Friendly service. Love it!

More of a 3.5 star joint . We went in for a late lunch on a Saturday afternoon. And tried the 3 cheese pizza and the Caprese plate . The Caprese is a generous portion , but little flavour really . No salt, tomatoes came right off the fridge and muzz was generic .(3/5). The pizza was a little bit better and large enough for two, but still using the generic tomato sauce and cheese blend which was just ok . read more

High & Mighty Pizza Joint - Caprese plate - Pizza Near Me - Gilroy, California

See all

Really great pizza in the New York style. Wood-fired oven makes all the difference. Friendly service, super high quality. If you're eating in, there's a nice selection of beers. Lots of parking. My new go-to. Recommended! read more

Our group of four came here last night. We bought a few different pizzas, a Caesar salad, and a small ambrosia salad. The pizzas were delicious. The Caesar salad was crisp and had a great dressing on it with what seemed to be homemade croutons. The fact that there was ambrosia salad on the menu was very surprising to me, so I thought I would order it. It was creamy and so flavorful, I'm gonna try to make it at home. What was fantastic too was the Customer Service. They were friendly and very helpful. read more

Pizza and staff great. small town atmosphere. Wait time short for pizza. Will return In the future on my next journey for pizza. read more

What a fun and flavorful surprise in Gilroy! This place does wood-fired pizza right -- the crust is perfectly crunchy outside, chewy inside, and you can smell that real wood oven magic. We ordered the BBQ combo pizza, and wow -- smoky brisket, pork, and classic BBQ flavors on a pizza? Sounds wild, but it works so well. Creative, bold, and absolutely delicious. The vibe is just as memorable -- they play cowboy music, there's a stage for live performances, and the décor has a playful Western feel that my 10-year-old nephew loved. It's casual but full of character. And let me just say -- the owner is one of the kindest person I've ever met. Super warm and welcoming, and so passionate about his food. After chatting with him, he even invited us to check out his BBQ spot next door (spoiler alert: also amazing). If you're in Gilroy, don't miss this place. It's more than just pizza -- it's an experience. read more

See all

Stopped here for an early dinner. It did not disappoint. The stars were the Caprese Salad with thick cut slices of mozzarella and juicy slices of tomatoes and the perfectly balanced BBQ Chicken Pizza. The pizza itself was delightly with a thin but airy crust. Great balance of sweet and savory BBQ flavors. They had 8 beers on tap. Decent variety. The staff were friendly and the actually restaurant had a relaxed bar vibe. Not a bad place to grab a pizza to share and a couple of cold beers. read more

High & Mighty Pizza Joint - Caprese Salad - Pizza Near Me - Gilroy, California

See all

Came here with a bunch of hungry teen boys after visiting Sky Zone. Ordered two pepperoni and one tri-tip jalapeño pizza and a Cesar salad. Everyone was friendly. It was a packed house. Cool vibe for hanging out in a relaxed atmosphere. Plenty of adult drinks to choose from. Both wine and beer. Pizza was fresh from the oven and it was delicious. The kids agreed it was very good, perfect amount of cheese and pepperoni. The tri-tip pizza was surprisingly very good. Could have had a couple more slices of meat but overall I would try it again. read more

Service was amazing & pizza is superb as I travel all the way to Santa Cruz for my pizza & now I can just a few minutes to get the best pizza in town. The place has a good vibe with great energy and will be my go to for my pizza. read more

High & Mighty Pizza Joint - Pizza Near Me - Gilroy, California

I can't say enough about this place . The pizza in the wood fire the soda isn't your normal ( corporate sponsored) soda even . Thank you for that ! The inside is very warm lighting and they has a bluegrass live playing . And the outside seating was so nice and dog friendly. I would only go here for pizza if you're in Gilroy! And the staff is great read more

The most DELICIOUS pizza!! Cesar salad fresh, light dressing giant Parmesan cheese, yummy croutons. Sodas unique and refreshing. Easy spot to stop at!! Cushy chairs to relax. Friendly staff! Easy parking space. First and definitely not our last visit! read more

Ambiance is ok. Country western themed. Food is the important item here is just underwhelming & boring compared to other pizza joints. BBQ Chicken pizza is bland & basic BBQ sauce, thin pieces of chicken, with some onion slivers slapped on & very little cheese. Service was perfunctory. "High & Mighty" falls flat on their face. Save your time, money & energy - Keep driving over to 1st Street another mile to Round Table Pizza where they understand how to make great pizza. read more

I'm not really a pizza guy and I'm very picky but let me just say their brisket pizza was sooo good!!. That's the only pizza I've tried but definitely my favorite! read more

Had a salad there with best croutons (homemade) I ever had. I am a foodie and do not eat salads as much as I should, but this is all I have been craving Since I had it! read more

First, they were SO accommodating! We brought our dog to sit outside, it was full but a wonderful young woman brought us chairs. We ordered the spicy cowboy and a side of chicken for the pooch. The pizza is hella yummy, unique and the chicken on the side for the pooch was also really nice and juicy! The same woman even brought out the order for us. Next time I'm getting the cherry pie pizza! Love this place! read more

We ordered the 2 meat bbq pizza: pizza was good and the tri tip pieces were excellent. Not very generous with toppings, pizza was about 1/3 crust, however dough is delicious. read more

Food, service, & ambiance was amazing! We will definitely be back!! Tried the Margarita Pizza with brisket yummmmmmmmm read more

See all

This is the newest restaurant in Gilroy and it just happens to be offering my favorite food---PIZZA. I arrived at 11 AM and they had just opened so I was the only person in the place for the first 15-20 minutes. The waitress greeted me and I ordered my old stand by; Pizza Margherita. I wanted to taste a pizza without all the added meats or sauces that were offered that might cloud my taste buds and skew the review. On my first visit to any restaurant one of the first things I do is check out the restrooms; they were spotless. One is so large you could park a car inside and still take care of business. The pizza arrived hot and brimming with cut up tomato chunks instead of the traditional sauce; that was a pleasant surprise. The crust was soft and complaint but cooked through, as it should be. Gooey, tasty mozzarella cheese covered the soft warm dough and fresh basil leaves were added as a garnish on top of it all; just they way it is done in Italy. Yeah, it was good, real good! The only negative for me was my drink order. I like an Arnold Palmer to drink while I eat my pizza. In Italy they would say "mezo e mezo" - half and half; half ice tea and half lemonade. The drink selection was abundant with bottled ice tea as one of the choices but no lemonade to make my drink of choice. High & Mighty's motif is a County/Western theme and on Fridays they have live music. As I was leaving the waitress thanked me, a pleasant surprise compared to many Gilroy restaurants. This is a fun place to eat with a good pizza. I am planning on taking my wife and granddaughter there to try some of their other types of pizzas. Gilroy has a WINNER with High & Mighty pizza. read more

I was in town for work and wanted to have a yummy solo meal. I landed on this spot through yelp. The ambiance was nice! It was casual, very open. You go to the front to order, grab a number then have a seat. They bring you the pizza to your table or you're dining in. I opted for a half and half pizza. I believe it was the 3 Cheese with Mushroom and Pepperoni with Pineapple. Got a bottle of root beer to wash it all down. I was sitting down at a table waiting for my food. Felt like forever.. then the sever brought the pizza to my table. He first apologized for the wait, let me know it was a little burnt and since that's not the standard they were already making me a new pizza but that I could have this one any way. What service!? Honestly best customer service I've had in forever. The initiative they took was greatly appreciated and I'll be back! Not to mention, when I finally got my pizza!? It was so goood that I demolished the whole thing. LOL. I boxed up the "burnt" one and took it home with me. While that was definitely up more burnt on the crust, the pizza was still good the next day! I highly recommend this spot the next time you're in Gilroy! :) read more

High & Mighty Pizza Joint - My half pepperoni & pineapple half 3 cheese & mushroom pizza. :) - Pizza Near Me - Gilroy, California

Friendly and amazing service. Their pizzas are so good too. Check this place out. I've gone here twice so far and I'm looking forward to the next when I'm around town. read more

We had an amazing time going to this place! Hubby and I were just randomly looking on Yelp and came across this place that we thought looked really cute! The parking was pretty good and spacious as there wasn't too many cars on a Sunday night. We walked in and was greeted with such vibrancy and life. The staff was so sweet and really did make us feel at home (as they said "mi casa is su casa"). We sat down and we didn't wait long at all. The food was also really good, we got the BBQ Chicken with a root beer and it really hit the spot! Kind of reminds me of base camp pizza from Lake Tahoe (if that place is still around). Anyways, we would definitely come back and bring some friends. The atmosphere and location is amazing, and the decor was super cute! Definitely feel like a comedy show can happen there sometime soon (hubby and I love comedy shows so it would definitely be a bonus!). read more

High & Mighty Pizza Joint - BBQ Chicken Pizza 12' - Pizza Near Me - Gilroy, California

Absolutely best pizza around! The place is clean and the service was excellent! Nikki was helping us and couldn't have asked for better lunch date read more

High & Mighty Pizza Joint - Lunch date - Pizza Near Me - Gilroy, California

So delicious! I had veggie (Land of Plenty) and hubby had tri-tip jalapeño. Caesar salad was also excellent. We had Stubborn Soda, but they have lots of beer and wine options too. Super cute place. read more

High & Mighty Pizza Joint - Pizza Near Me - Gilroy, California

See all

We went in at 6:15 on a Friday to order a pepperoni. We knew there might be a wait which was fine it was a Friday night. Sent my son to check on the order they said they would call our name. 6:45 sent my son to check again they said sorry we gave it out to someone else it will be a few minutes. At 7:23 my son was mad and went for a walk so I went up again at 7:45 and finally it was done. Pizza was ok but pricey for a 12". I will be spending my money elsewhere. read more

To start off we were greeted immediately and about the nicest service we ever have!! And then it didnt take long for our delicious pizzas to come out.. Not only that it has the CUPPING pepperoni where the oil just stays and its AMAZING. It is definitely top 5 pizzas ive ever had and ive been to many so that says alot. It is a beautiful place and the the music is just the right volume. My kids decided to dance on their stage so it is a very family friendly place for sure. Definitely a place to eat at! read more

High & Mighty Pizza Joint - Margherita with pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Gilroy, California

Their service and food are really good. My husband first found this place a while back and I decided to try it with a friend. I have to say that it's my favorite pizza places ever. I love their toppings and how soft and buttery their crust is. The ambiance is also very unique but very relaxed at the same time. read more

WOW! We were at the Gilroy outlet looking for something to eat and we came by this pizza place which has pretty good reviews. They definitely exceeded our expectations and I can say this is one of the best pizzas I had. Very thin and authentic. They also had a great selection of beers and they were generous letting us try some before choosing. Other than that the place has a really cool vibe with live music in the evenings. Service is great highly recommended. read more

High & Mighty Pizza Joint - Pizza Margarita - Pizza Near Me - Gilroy, California

Pizza was delicious and didn't take too long to come out. The selection of cream sodas were so good and very original. I would go back just to try more of the soda and pizzas. The ambiance was very nice and chill during a Saturday afternoon. There were only a few other families but the music was nice and plenty of areas to sit and hang out. Service was amazing as well! read more

Cute pizza joint for friends and family with a variety of beer and wine available to order. Staff are warm and welcoming and have fast service! The pizzas are so good! But their bbq is amazing as well, I wish we could've ordered that separately as a plate! Prices are a little bit more high, but you definitely get what you pay for in quality. I would visit again to try other things :) read more

High & Mighty Pizza Joint - Pizza Near Me - Gilroy, California

See all