This place is in Gilroy, CA. Stopped here to get some garlic from town and found this place. Wanted to try something quick. Found this place. Nice clean place, good ambiance, live music on Saturdays. Pizza is nice light neopoletan style, very light and airy. Good place with good vibes and county music. Only negative thing is, I like my topping cooked, here it tasted raw to me. read more

Aden gave me some great customer service and the ambiance is cozy and fun but hands down the pizza is AWSOME! Hands down I don't know why it took me so long to try it out..but no more round tables pizza for me while I am reading in Gilroy for sure. read more

High & Mighty Pizza Joint - I had a very hard time not eating the whole pizza..my wife would have been upset if I had.lol - Pizza Near Me - Gilroy, California

See all

What a gem of a pizza joint. Lots of character, very clean, friendly service. The food was delicious, fresh ingredients and awesome cheese pull. read more

Nice environment, cool pizza options, and friendly/helpful staff. I'm glad we finally made it in to try the new pizza place in Gilroy. I'm thankful for this new family friendly restaurant here in Gilroy. We need more places like this here. The BBQ Chicken Pizza and Brisket Pizza were delicious, and a big plus was the fun (different) soda options they offer. I recommend you try this place and share the experience with your friends and family. read more

The food tasted great and they were really kind with great service. I love the spicy cowboy, would definitely recommend coming here.

The pizza is AMAZING!!! The service and ambience were on point! If you haven't checked it out yet, you need to. They have live music on Fridays. Definitely the best pizza I have ever had in a long time. read more

Great atmosphere, friendly staff and the best pizza in town! Fresh ingredients, just enough crust and fabulous sauce! Definitely recommend!! read more

High & Mighty Pizza Joint - Many - Pizza Near Me - Gilroy, California

See all

Excellent pizza, friendly helpful staff and a nice clean restaurant! Will be back for sure.

Kinda a complicated review. I would give them 5 stars for their Margarita. Also 5 stars, staff was friendly, very clean and tidy. A really nice space. Crust was good. Nice structure and chew. Really what let us down was the pepperoni. They've got a weird taste. Maybe it's just us, but we all thought they had this weird hotdog taste. We had them alone on a pepperoni, and we also got a spicy cowboy. Same weird taste. Probably would get something that didn't have pepperoni next time. Only other criticism would be prices. Margarita, while amazing, was the same price as the pepperoni. Feel like other places margaritas are always a little cheaper. They also don't have any ciders on tap. Would try again, we'd just avoid anything with pepperoni. read more

Great atmosphere, lots of options for toppings, fast service, friendly staff and the margarita pizza was bomb! 10/10 read more

High & Mighty Pizza Joint - Margarita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gilroy, California

Ambiance The ambience of the spot is cool and a bit cozy, def a good pizza and bar spot vibe and I think they nailed it. Food I think the complaint on the pizza being expensive is a bad excuse. I would rather pay 20 to 27 for good pizza and support a local business's that truly cares for its residents than chain restaurants. People seem to forget that the business need to make money as well, can't match chain prices or else they'd be out of business soon. Now and days you're spending about 20 bucks a person anyways.The pizza is delicious and worth it, the quality is great and their options are delicious. They also have great pairing with their local beer options that just make the experience. Service The guys there are awesome and truly care about the pizza and what goes into it. They welcome you in like family and any place that tells you up front that they aren't anything without the residents is a gem. All and all I recommend this spot to anyone wanting to get a local pizza and drink. Really cool spot and glad they are here in Gilroy. read more

Went here recently with our kiddos and ate on the patio! Super cool place and the food was delicious. I ordered a margarita pizza but found it odd that the basil came out separate and not cooked? Not sure if they forgot or what but still delicious nonetheless. We were torn on high price point. Would we pay for it again? Yes, however a similar place in downtown Los Gatos has cheaper pizzas and a more extensive menu so I hope High & Mighty expands their menu a bit eventually. read more

Great pizzas and comfortable atmosphere. The cowboy pizza is amazing and one of my new favorites.

Best alt pizza spot I've had the tri tip pizza is 10/10. They have a good arsenal of sauces to slap on your pizza. Will be definitely coming back. Well done folks! read more

Pizza came out fast. Very good! Feel this place will be famous soon enough! I do like the set up. Seems like there is a little stage there. read more

High & Mighty Pizza Joint - Good pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gilroy, California

Went in to try something new. They opened a.couple months ago and I kept driving by saying " I need to give them a try"! Went in and was not disappointed. Service was great. The person that helped me gave good suggestions about the beers and pizza. We got pizza to go and it had that great brick oven pizza taste. Decent pricing. Will go back! read more

The ambience is very good and good playlist. Music was mostly oldies and country. The pizza dough was very good but if you like no flop pizza this is not your place. The salad was very large and fresh. The beer is excellent in the fridge is stocked with many options, overall the experience was the staff could be more welcoming. read more

High & Mighty Pizza Joint - Pizza Near Me - Gilroy, California

See all

This is my 3rd or 4th time getting pepperoni pizza here. And it's like AMAZING I got some today I just was so excited to go home and eat it. I don't normally eat pizza crust but I love their crust !! So I went to get my pepperoni pizza today after work and the employees are always super friendly to and I like that they offer you water while you wait for your take out. 10/10 recommend pizza read more

ok, got it again (7th time) and it seems like they have gotten it. Last two pizzas were cooked perfectly. Good texture, a little bit of chew...YUMMY, Now 5 stars! read more

It's good but not great as people tend to say. There is problem with a concept. Price that you are paying, it lacks topping for fulfillment. Two kids and two adults $100 and came out unsatisfied with the meal. Then there is a problem. Will not go back soon. read more

It's crazy how good this pizza is, and you never would have thought it would be so good! The gentleman who helped us was amazing, super nice, communicative, told us about the back story. The vibe was perfect, and the pizza was unbelievable. I've worked in gourmet pizza kitchens for 5+ years now. I can say this is the softest fluffiest dough I've ever had. Y'all need to have their pizzas!! read more

High & Mighty Pizza Joint - Pizza Near Me - Gilroy, California

We have a new pizza place in town. It's actually across the street from my house. I decided to try it today... they have some house specials, I wasn't fond of any of them, so I decided to build my own. I got all vegetables with pepperoni and sausage and a 12 inch pizza was $34 it was absolutely delicious, the crust was fabulous and you could tell it was wood-fired. As I was eating the manager, Carlos came over for a visit and asked me about my pizza. He was so pleasant. I wish they had a fountain drink rather than can sodas for 3$ a can. I would definitely visit this place again. read more

High & Mighty Pizza Joint - Super clean, very cute and welcoming. They do live music and karaoke. - Pizza Near Me - Gilroy, California

We have visited 3 times to this new pizza place. Main concern is the consistency as far as the feeling in the restaurant. Employees were all over it the first time around but now after the third visit, it is going downhill fast. We went last night due to walking distance for this place is convenient. It was around 7ish and the place had maybe a four top, with the register person sitting at the register and we placed our order. Not much on any type of welcoming feeling, we also asked about watching the game. Apparently you only had 1 TV showing the game and no offer put it on another TV. So our sitting option was limited. The most noticeable thing that I saw was that your employee who for some reason was taking the outside tables inside around 730 pm. It really felt like they were ready to close up. If we return, we will do take out. read more

Good pizza (not amazing but definitely good), good drinks, and very fun atmosphere. We will definitely return read more

New fave pizza joint in Gilroy. Been doing the pickup thing but it would be a great spot to catch a ballgame Love the beer selection read more

I saw someone posting about this place on Nextdoor and figured I would check it out. The phone number online was incorrect and the webpage said they weren't taking orders. So I went down to orders. They are pretty pricey at $20 and up per pizza. They dont have different sizes. Each pizza can feed 2 people, unless you are really hungry. Took about 15-20 minutes to get the pizzas. Friendly employees. Pizza crust was good, sauce was ok. read more

See all

5.0 Fantastic pizza good beer good service. A bit pricey but worth it, even if it had tariffs, I would still pay them! read more

High & Mighty Pizza Joint - Delicious - Pizza Near Me - Gilroy, California

Friendly service and great quality pizza. A little difficult to get parking but worth the trip.

The bbq chicken pizza was amazing but the service was stellar! Faith was so kind and energetic she made our family dinner top notch! Thank you again Faith!! read more

Love the vibe, service is nice spot is esthetic, music popping!! Feels like a find. The pizza was great! Yummy, fast, good ingredient's. read more

High & Mighty Pizza Joint - Pizza Near Me - Gilroy, California

Great pizza, the flavor of the crust is amazing! Tri tip and bbq chicken were delicious!

Nicky was amazing! So compassionate when mine and my husbands card didn't go through due to a mistake with the bank. She still provided us with drinks and food and offered to come back and pay later. Thankfully our bank problem was fixed by the end of our visit. The caprese salad was fresh and delicious! Their pizza is so perfectly cooked to perfection and the drinks are always a hit! Thank you Nicky for everything read more

Pizza is absolutely delish! We had the BBQ Chicken and a Caesar Salad and a couple of fabulous beers. I had the Maui Coconut Hiwa Porter and it was off the charts great but I love a good porter. We were treated to the ambrosia salad for dessert- what a blast from the past! Homemade in house. The Caesar salad was delicious as well and I am typically a Caesar fan- the homemade croutons were fantastic! There was some country tunes and a big crowd that made the place feel festive ! Go try High and Mighty Pizza! Oh and the food arrived swiftly with great service! read more

See all

Yum yum yum!!! Twice now I have asked if I can get an order a lil earlier because of my lunch time and with no hesitation they say yes of course!!! You will not be disappointed this pizza is Delish and the ceaser salad is yum yum yum too!!!! read more

Pizzas here are good thin crust wood fire oven. Beer selection has enough styles to keep you here. Good music too! Highly recommend this joint read more

High & Mighty Pizza Joint - Outside - Pizza Near Me - Gilroy, California

See all

The hubby & I have been here a couple of times. The pizza is good. The crust is nice & thin. It's got a good bite to it. Everyone is always very nice when we go in. The ambiance is great. Over all... a very good pizza joint. Just... a tad expensive. It's not as expensive as Round Table but, all their pizzas are 12 inches. That's it. A 12 inch (medium) Pepperoni & sausage pizza will set you back $27.00 before taxes & tip. That doesn't include drinks. The parking lot is very (VERY) small so, parking is an issue at times. Especially since you're going downtown. However, I would definitely give High & Mighty a chance & have a delicious slice of pizza pie. read more

Pizza was very good. Service was friendly and quick. The beers on tap were solid. It was not too busy. If you have not been here give it a try. read more

I rarely leave Yelp reviews, but this place was so good, I had to! Love the vibe inside. The pizza is out-of-this world! We ordered the BBQ Chicken Pizza and it was probably the best pizza I've ever had. The dough is super fresh, and you can tell it's great quality ingredients. My toddler even loved it, and as a picky eater, that says a lot. This spot is definitely something South County needed and our family will be back. read more

Excellent pizza fresh ingredients great crust. Music was kind of country western. So far all I had was 12 inch pizza split between my and I. Plenty of food for the two of us. I will be back to eat again. read more

High & Mighty Pizza Joint - 12 inch sausage and pepperoni and half add black olives and onions. Crisp crust. - Pizza Near Me - Gilroy, California

Do yourself a favor and visit this pizza joint gem in Gilroy. Their pizza is dynamite! I tried the Spicy Cowboy 's and was blown away by the quality of ingredients and crust! Apparently the dough is fermented for 48 hours. The service was impeccable and the ambiance gives a western modern vibe. Honorable mention, the ambrosia salad...try it! I promise you won't regret it. read more

High & Mighty Pizza Joint - Delightful Spicy Cowboy's Pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Gilroy, California

See all