We had a great experience at High Society Pizza today! Nice selection of traditional and creative pizzas - something for everyone. Everything we ordered was delicious. The staff was incredibly friendly and welcoming, and since they weren't very busy at the time, they even surprised us with a free order of cheesy bread -- which was amazing and a thoughtful touch. Great food, great service, and a relaxed vibe. We'll definitely be back! read more

See all

Tasty New York style pizza, though the crust could have been cooked more. Love that they offer half/half pizzas since I had trouble deciding (and at no extra cost). We got the jalapeño popper and OG. Good amount of toppings. $29 for 16 inch fed 2 of us and we had a couple slices leftover. read more

High Society Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Highlands Ranch, Colorado

See all

The staff is usually always welcoming and friendly. I appreciate their lunch special especially on a nice day bc you can sit outside on their little patio where they usually have some fresh flowers, but the whole pizzas are pretty pricey. It's good but just be prepared to pay unless you take advantage of the lunch special. read more

Really liked the pizza here! First, we liked the fact that they offer 10" pizzas since my wife and I diverge in our tastes. Sure you can order a half-and-half large, but having our own is more convenient and feels decadent. Of course, their claim to fame is their crust, made with water intended to mimic NYC's. I don't know about that (being a southerner), but I thought the crust was great. My wife, however, who grew up in Italy and New York could not stop raving about it. After one visit, she claims it is her new favorite Colorado pizza and as I drive by every Wednesday I have been ordered to stop and pick some up at least every other week. The New York Italian LOVED it. Toppings were fresh and tasty; sauce like Aunt Lucy used to make, according to my wife. I read a complaint on here about not enough cheese but we thought it was the perfect amount (we both think most places use too much). Stopped and talked to the owner, Keith, on the way out and he seemed genuinely thrilled with our praise and very proud of his operation. The decor was simple but light and the giant photos of NYC on the walls were cool. Being in a strip mall means large windows and lots of natural light. One con: it took a little longer to get our delicious pizza than we expected, but it was not overly long. read more

High Society Pizza - 10" Veggie with my personal spatula. - Pizza Near Me - Highlands Ranch, Colorado

The restaurant is clean and bright as you walk in. You order at the counter and they will bring you your food. We have had The OG, The Stinger, and The High Society. The vegetables are fresh and delicious. The red sauce, I like a bit more on my pizza, especially since it tastes great. I have had pizzas in other parts of the world, so I cannot comment on the "New York Pizza / Dough", but I have not been disappointed yet with the pies! Hopefully you won't be either. read more

See all

Was totally sold on their pizza based on one piece. Love the thin, soft crust and delicious sauce and just the right amount of cheese. From what I understand, this is a food truck company gone brick and mortar. They still have their truck that they use for catering orders You order up front and then wait for it to be ready / go back to pick it up. Lots of nice table space. Wish they cleaned the tables more frequently though: They obviously enjoy making the pizzas more, which is good! I believe their pizza is NY style, hand tossed, with homemade sauce. My kind of pizza. They also have a Gluten Free option (cauliflower crust I believe) for $2 more. We ended up ordering a cheese pizza to take with us to share with others Totally loved the experience and food. read more

See all

I've already been here twice and it's now my top pizza places in town. We've only done take out and we pre order every time since the estimated times are around 40 minutes. It's easy to plan ahead and order from their website. You can choose to eat on the patio (which is refreshing!) when you take your pizza out. We've tried the Supreme and The OG. For a first timer, I highly suggest the Supreme for those who love a traditional supreme. It's got the goods and somehow even more flavor. The crust is phenomonal and the sauce is out of this world. The toppings are generous. Nothing falls apart, cheese is in tact, and you can customize anything. The OG was also great, more of a simpler pizza, and a perfect option. I never feel gross or greasy afterwards. And a large is reasonable for the cost. Plenty of parking always and great staff! read more

See all

Been waiting to try this place, but once I realized they have NYC water, we were all in! Good selection of pizzas, salads and subs. They've kept it simple and delicious. Nice seating space inside and out, done a great job with the decor. Guys at the front counter were nice and helpful. Owner was nice enough to give us a healthy portion of their meatballs to try, since it was our first visit. Nice to have them in the neighborhood! read more

See all

We were craving pizzas and were happy to try out High Society! Greeted right when we walked in. Had a lot of menu options and even got a gluten free pizza crust. Salad came out quick and pizzas shortly after that. Pretty empty restaurant for a weekend night although tons of people were picking up to go orders and they were delivering as well. I'd go back! read more

See all

We have had this pizza twice and it has been consistently good each time. Best pizza I have had in a while

Wanted to try out this pizza joint after hearing about their commitment to recreating a 1 to 1 replica of NY water. The owner Keith was super friendly and extremely knowledgeable in his craft, very impressive! Ordered a simple pizza and wings, both were delicious! read more

High Society Pizza - 10" Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Highlands Ranch, Colorado

See all

I am from New Jersey so my pizza stardards are pretty high. The first fail with my slice was with crumbled sausage instead of sliced. Overall the pizza lacked much flavor, fairly bland taste. The crust was a bit cracker like and needed a more doughy feel. More cheese and more sauce might have helped. read more

High Society Pizza - Slice - Pizza Near Me - Highlands Ranch, Colorado

See all

We had to try this pizza place since Coloradough is no longer in Highlands Ranch :-( But we were quickly impressed by this place! The dough is light & airy, yet it really reminds me of back home pizza. The sauce was excellent, you can certainly tell it's made fresh daily. They have a variety of Speciality Pizzas, as well as Build Your Own. We tried a Speciality & a Build Your Own pizza, the BYO pizza we got with meatballs & I must say that the meatballs were really, really good! The Speciality pizza (you'll have to excuse me, but I forgot which one we tried, since it was about 2 weeks ago), but if I remember correctly, it was semi spicy, and also, it was excellent! High Society Pizza was immaculate inside & out. I meet the owner, his wife, infant toddler & the crew that made our pizzas, they were all extremely nice! I'm sorry that Coloradough is now only in Aurora, CO, but High Society quickly made us forget they're no longer around! Give it a try if you're looking for a great pizza! read more

We got a large stinger for take out and while it was good, it was incredibly greasy and overpriced.

New pizza place and well worth the try. Delicious pizza made fresh or order by the slice. Fast and friendly service too. read more

High Society Pizza - The High Society pizza was excellent. - Pizza Near Me - Highlands Ranch, Colorado

See all

Tried them twice. Each time pizza needed more cooking and just wasn't good tasting. Delivered like it was dropped and half of pizza slid against box side. Had issues from food each time now. Pretty done with them. read more

Every time I'm in Colorado visiting family this a go to spot. Their pizza is always hot and fresh. Top of the line ingredients. Recently tried their cheesy breadsticks with bacon and jalapeños, my family didn't leave a piece behind. read more

Great pizza, friendly staff and owner. We will definitely be back. The stinger and jalapeño popper pizza were great.

High Society Pizza was better than I expected, rivaling our favorite pizza chain back in California - nothing else we've tried in Colorado has come close. They got the order wrong on our first visit, but the ingredients tasted good. I would try them again. read more

ABO Pizza once occupied the same location that High Society Pizza now resides. Apparently High Society Pizza bought ABOs out. I really miss ABOs. High Society pizza is ok. My issues with them is the skimpy amount of toppings they put on the pizza. Especially for the price. They brag about using "New York water". So what, your in the West and most people here don't care and don't know the difference. I will probably continue use them in a pinch. Ordering the 10 inch size. The larger sizes are outrageously priced, read more

We didn't like this pizza at all. Being born and bred New Yorkers, our standards are very high. Ultimately, this just isn't New York-style pizza. The crust is oddly thin and cracker-like, and the overall flavor was...lacking. Maybe they should stop saying they sell New York style pizza to set the right expectations? Regardless, there are far more tastier pizzas in Colorado for cheaper, so we won't be returning. read more

We went here because we knew there was pizza. It appears the owner has changed and it really isn't as good as it used to be. They don't have bacon as a topping which these days seems weird. The pizza was just meh and we didn't even eat the leftovers. read more

Online receipt says ready in 35 mins. Order took about an hour and 15 minutes. Was told "we're busy". We had to go home and come back. If you have a lot of time then order but time can vary from 30 mins to an hour and a half. please Work on your customer service. Maybe offer a discount or something. My time is equally valuable as yours. read more

Our go to spot. Every ingredient is very high quality and you can definitely taste the difference. I think they even use water imported from NYC. My wife is picky about eating healthy and even she loves this place. Our favorite is the Stinger but the Caprese pizza is surprisingly perfect. Beer and Wine selection is shockingly good too. The owner is a nice guy who always makes sure service is top notch. Family friendly also as we love coming here with our toddler. read more

Good pizza --The process was seamless, and upon arrival, my order was ready. Delicious flavors and perfectly crispy crust. Staff was great, 10/10 recommend . read more

Gf options which is great. Friendly staff and bright location. I think its an ok place for pizza. Not amazing but not bad. Still like my gf costco pizzas better. 2 for 12-13$ if you like crunchy crispy crust pizza look elsewhere. read more

This is the old Abos which we always liked. Nice to have a pizza place back in the neighborhood. Thin crust pizza. We like it!

Great local pizza. I love all the unique options for toppings. Especially the hot honey! The margarita pizza with balsamic drizzle was great too! Fast and fresh. read more

Very disappointing. Slow service, distracted employees seemed like they wanted to be anywhere else. We were expecting a much better tasting product for the price. My kids didn't like it at all. We all preferred Abo's. Avoid. read more

don't normally leave long reviews, but this pizza place deserves it. From the very first visit, I knew I'd found something special. The moment you walk in, the smell alone pulls you in deeper. It's that perfect blend of fresh dough, garlic, melted cheese, and oven-roasted goodness. The staff is always friendly, even during busy hours. They greet you with a smile that doesn't feel forced. The space is warm, clean, and inviting. There's something about the atmosphere that makes you want to stay. You can tell the place is well taken care of. The lighting is just right--not too dim, not too bright. Music is always playing at a comfortable volume. It creates a great background without ever being distracting. The decor feels curated, not cluttered. You can see the kitchen, which always makes me trust a place more. Watching the pizza being made is part of the fun. The dough gets tossed right in front of you. Everything is made fresh. No shortcuts. Their menu has a solid variety. You'll find classics like Margherita and pepperoni. But they also offer unique creations I've never seen elsewhere. The spicy honey pepperoni is one of my favorites. It's the perfect combo of sweet, salty, and heat. They also do a white pizza with ricotta, garlic, and spinach that's unreal. Their vegetarian options are actually exciting, not just an afterthought. I appreciate that they use real, fresh vegetables--not frozen ones. They even have vegan cheese for those who want it. The crust deserves its own paragraph. It's perfectly blistered on the edges. Soft and chewy inside, with just enough crisp outside. Never soggy, never dry. You can tell they've perfected their dough recipe. The sauce is flavorful without being overwhelming. Slightly tangy, lightly herbed, and just the right amount. The cheese? Melted, stretchy, and never greasy. Toppings are generous but balanced. They never overload the pizza, which keeps the crust from getting soggy. It shows attention to detail. Portions are fair for the price. You get what you pay for--quality. I've never left hungry or disappointed. Even the side dishes are fantastic. Their garlic knots are a must. Perfectly baked, buttery, and served with a rich marinara. The salads are fresh and crisp. Nothing feels like filler food. Drinks are well-selected too. They offer local sodas, craft beer, and even a few wines. Their Italian soda was a surprise favorite. The desserts are simple, but hit the spot. Try the cannoli if they have it. I also love that they rotate seasonal specials. It keeps me coming back to try new things. I appreciate places that don't get lazy with their menu. Service is consistently good. Even during rush hours, they manage things well. Orders come out in a timely manner. I've never had a messed-up order. The staff is attentive without hovering. They check in just enough. And if you're ordering takeout? Still excellent. The pizza travels well and holds up. They pack it thoughtfully, and it arrives hot. The app/website for ordering is super easy to use. Payment is smooth and they keep everything updated. They even remember special requests. I once asked for "extra crispy crust" and they nailed it. Small things like that build loyalty. Prices are very reasonable for the quality. Definitely not cheap pizza, but it's worth every dollar. You can taste the difference in every bite. They care about what they serve. They care about the experience you have. That's what really stands out. A lot of places get lazy over time. But not this one. I've been coming here for months now. Every visit is as good as the last--or better. I've brought friends, family, even coworkers. Everyone leaves happy. This place has officially become my go-to. It's more than a pizza place--it's a comfort zone. If you haven't tried it yet, you're missing out. Great food. Great people. Great vibe. What more could you ask for? read more

Absolutely horrible online mobile ordering experience. Best pizza and service in highlands ranch! Create a "4- click" order experience to match the amazing food you server with such great service! read more

Not a 3 but not quite a 4- a 3.6. Ordered 2 pizzas for pick up, 1 Jalapeño Popper and a gluten free crust Stinger (pepperoni with hot honey). Popper pizza was decent except the crust wasn't great and I expected a little more kick. My daughter enjoyed the gluten free pepperoni. read more

Definitely one of the better smaller pizza places, been here 3 times and all here pretty good.

I really wanted to try this pizza, they have great reviews. I am not able to drive right now and needed delivery but my order only came to $28.00, and they dont deliver for less than $30. I did call to see if they would make an exception, they would not. Sad part is I'm a great tipper so they would have made up some of their delivery cost, AND made a happy new customer. read more

We go often for the mid-day slice deals. It's a great way to try their different specialty pizzas. Haven't had anything we didn't love. Owner is a super nice guy to talk to! read more

The pizza is outstanding! There New York style is true to the process of duplicating the water which makes the crust delicious! Fresh ingredients and friendly service! read more

Good Food, service, nice patio, lots of flowers, casual spot for a good sub,pizza and beer. Plenty of parking.

Delicious! Pizza was hot and flavorful! The people were nice and offered us some beer samples. We ordered and the pizza was ready within the timeframe they advised. The ambience is better than Abos. Although, we did like Abos, this is an improvement! read more

Great option for takeout. Food and service are great. They really cleaned up the place!

I just found out about High Society Pizza yesterday. It's so close to our home! We had to try it today! Simple and delicious!! The owner, Keith, and his team are all awesome guys! The customer does come first at High Society Pizza. Try it, you won't be disappointed! read more

See all