My family moved to the Buffalo area about 10 years ago. I have patronized this pizza restaurant twice by myself. The first time was shortly after we moved here. I ordered an individual pizza with cheese and three other toppings and a soft drink. The restaurant seemed clean, the menu offered a variety of pizzas, sandwiches and Mexican food. The service was good, the pizza tasted good but there was something about the crust that I didn't like. The outer edge of the crust seemed dense and crispy- almost like biting into a hard cracker. I prefer crust that has more chew to it so I would render my evaluation of this crust as below average. During my second visit I decided to try a sandwich instead of a pizza. The service and ambiance were the same as the first visit. The sandwich I ordered was a Philly Cheese steak sandwich with chips. The server brought the sandwich fairly quickly, however, the sandwich was definitely not what I expected. The sandwich was nothing more than a hotdog bun with about 2-3 thin slices of deli roast beef, with a single slice of cheese, a few pieces of green pepper and onions. After this dismal sandwich, I decided that I would not eat there again. It had been quite a few years since that last attempt, so I decided to give the restaurant another chance. A few nights ago my wife and I along with our two neighbors went there for dinner. My wife and I ordered a large "deluxe" pizza and soft drinks. She also ordered a small salad. Again the service and ambiance were good. The salad was below average- mostly made of the white core of the lettuce. The pizza tasted good and all the ingredients were fresh, but the crust was hard and crunchy. So for me the bottom line is if you want pizza that tastes okay but the crust is hard and crunchy then Hip Pocket Pizzaria is the place to go. I can't recommend the Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich nor any of the Mexican dishes (haven't tried any)! There aren't many good restaurants in the Buffalo area to choose from, so I wonder if the local customers are just okay with the quality of food offered here? read more

Burrito enchilada style is always good. Mom had two massive tacos. Food is always good. Pizza is awesome especially the crust. Love this place. read more

Great food, big variety includes something for everyone. Check out the low carb Monterrey chicken melt. read more

Hip Pocket Pizza Parlor - Monterey chicken melt - Mexican Near Me - Buffalo, Missouri

Flavor would be good on the pizza... had a pepperoni spinach black olive large pizza It just looked sad when I opened the box won't be returning for this pizza read more

Most boring pizza available. Tried it twice and super disappointed both times. They serve way more low quality nachos and burritos than pizza. Offering 5 bucks for 5 star reviews on Facebook? I guess that is the only way they can get good reviews. The pizza wasnt "nasty" it just tastes like nothing like a pizza should. They are trying to pay for fake good reviews....you are welcome for my honest review for free! read more

Called in an order today the person who took the order didn't get it right they shorted us a salad and then refused to provide another without charging, I didn't get the other salad and will not ever go back if you make a mistake make it right, they lost a customer over a 3 dollar salad. It was a to go order. read more

The service was great, very nice and friendly. However, drove far to get this abomination of a pizza. We have had all kinds of pizza with different kinds of crust and would have to say this was the worst we have ever tasted. It was almost like a unsalted saltine cracker crust. When we ordered they were out of pepperoni at 4pm. Not sure how a pizza place runs out of pepperoni?! It is overly priced for what you receive. This is the first time my family has never finished a pizza nor had a 2nd slice. Pretty disappointed. read more

Being the only pizza place in town doesn't mean you shouldn't strive to be the best. We went here tonight for the first time. It's okay. The pizza dough tastes like Red Baron frozen pizza. The toppings are a little better. Chain pizza places are better and that says a lot. The Nachos Supreme was really tasty, though! It seems this pizza place is more well known for good Mexican?? read more

The best pizza by far! Puts other pizza joints to shame now that we've tried it won't get pizza anywhere else

I feel bad leaving a bad review at a small town pizza chain but $32 for a "Giant" pizza is pretty ridiculous, so here goes: Crust is legit expired MREs from Russia, or a mix of saltine crackers and cardboard? Absolutely horrible crust. I think the people saying it's amazing crust, probably have never tried any other pizza! Mushrooms slimy and pretty sketchy. Almost no pizza sauce either, so it was very dry and crumbly. Blows my mind how much people love it though I think these people are getting free pizza to leave a good review. I'd say go down to the gas station and pick up a few slices, they'll taste better read more

I came here with some friends from work for lunch... I'll never be back. It took an obscene amount of time to get our food. I had a mini chicken pizza. The crust was hard enough to chip a tooth, the sauce tasted like a tin can, the chicken tasted freezer burnt. I would rather have cheap gas station pizza than eat this crap again. Their tagline is "Unforgettable Pizza "... I won't be soon forgetting how terrible the pizza is. read more

Love the Mexican food here although the pizza is good too. Nice small town home owned restaurant.

This is the best pizza I have ever had. They have gluten free options and the service is great! I always eat here when I am in Buffalo. The tacos and enchiladas are so tasty and everything is so good it is hard to choose from their big selection. Nothing is fried. I can't wait to do back! read more

Hip Pocket Pizza Parlor - Canadian bacon and hamburger pizza - Mexican Near Me - Buffalo, Missouri

We were just passing through and chose this place to eat. Great sandwiches and home made pizza.

Having grown up in the area, I've visited this place every now and again. The pizzas are somewhat lackluster; the crust tastes and crumbles like crackers. If you want something good from here, I recommend ordering some of the Mexican cuisine, a salad, or a sandwich. The sandwiches are delicious and toasted, and you're guaranteed to be surprised by the size of the Nacho Supreme. However, this place is pretty expensive, no matter what you order. Even so, Hip Pocket Pizza has a nice, calm atmosphere; it feels more like a home than a restaurant. read more

Just had a ham and cheese sandwich. It was good but didn't knock my socks off.. came with chips and s pickle. Wish the chips were homemade but that's cool. Got a large pizza to go. I found 1.25 to be a bit crazy for topping but ok. Hopefully its worth it. From my brief experience i'll come back. I like that they have a working drive thru read more

I've never been overly-fond of this place. Having grown up in the area, I did find myself going every now-and-then. Then again, I worked really close to it for awhile, so it was convenient for dinner. I don't really care for their pizza, I'm actually partial to the Pizza Hut down the road. As for their Mexican food, it's not at all authentic, but it is decent and cheap. If you're looking for a local place, then hit up Hip Pocket, otherwise just go to Pizza Hut. read more

I grew up in Buffalo and this place ALWAYS gets a visit when I return to town. The Pizza is one of a kind. I have never had anything like it. I order mine with extra cheese and get pepperoni, black olives and fresh jalapeños. The pizza is absolutely incredible. I love it! They also have good Mexican plates also. MUST TRY!!! read more

Was really excited to try their pizza, after reading several reviews on Google. Unfortunately, it was a huge disappointment on so many levels. First, the size for the price - really? We got a large supreme for $23, which you'd think would be thick and big and dripping with melted cheese, and loaded with toppings, but no. More like a medium, it had a few pieces of sausage, a little more pepperoni, a few mushrooms and other veggies, but not a lot of anything. The crust was absolutely horrible! Like cardboard really... flat, flavorless - reminded me of Naan... and the worst part - there was a piece of bone in the pizza too. SO GLAD I didn't chip or break a tooth on that! It's really disappointing that you can't find a good, authentic pizza between Fair Grove and Buffalo. I hate to say this, but the $6 grocery store frozen pizzas actually have more flavor and stuff. Oh well... live and learn. read more

The pizza at Hip Pocket is what earns it four stars. It's a bit much to say I'm a fan, however, because car loans cost less than the pizza here. The crust on their traditional thin-crust pizza is a cracker-style (as opposed to pretzel-dough or bread-dough style), and it is a saltier style, but still quite tasty. The toppings are very fresh, or at least they taste that way, and it is hard to trick my taster. I do not eat their Mexican food, and I would never advise going to a pizza place for Mexican food, just as I'd never advise getting pizza at a barbecue joint. If you are flush with cash, this is the best pizza in town. If not, stay at home and make a pizza, because Pizza Hut is no good and the gas stations are worse. I await the day that Casey's returns to Buffalo. read more

Excellent pizza. We love the cracker type crispy crust. Service is excellent and price is good.

LOVE this place! They make their own crust! Why would you go to a chain restaurant that uses par cooked crust when you can have this? Pepperoni pizza is delish! Love the sub sandwich too. Great locally owned pizza place. Check out the tables in the back room--45 years worth of locals engraving their initials. read more