I'm a self-professed "Cheese Steak Snob". That being said, Hoagies on Main has the best one around. I have given them no less than three opportunities, and each time they've hit it out of the park. As mentioned in another review, the meat portion is very generous, and delicious sauce, cheese and onions are all mixed in perfectly. You have plenty of choices for cheeses. Also, you get to choose from either a chewy hard roll, or a soft roll. I've had both, and they are always excellent. Tonight, we had two cheese steaks and my kiddos shared a cheese pizza and chicken tenders. The kids loved the pizza, and there were no leftovers. On the way home, my youngest daughter asked "when are we coming back?" You walk out smelling like the place, but it's worth it! read more

Great Hoagie; fresh seeded roll, sharp provolone, and great Italian meats. Inside dining area was clean enough and cozy, but a bit cluttered. Staff was friendly and it seemed like the staffs family was hanging out. read more

See all

Friendly people, fantastic food. The cheesesteak was stuffed full of quality meat. The hoagie rolls are so fresh. Everything was amazing! read more

Hoagies on Main - Cheesesteaks so good, I came all the way from the W. coast just to eat here. - Sandwiches Near Me - Palmyra, Pennsylvania

See all

Ordered the south Philly Italian and it was delicious. Perfect Italian hoagie. If you haven't tried this place out you definitely have to. Parking is small so keep that in mind. Def will order again. read more

Solid small business providing great cheesesteak and hogues at decent prices. Food was very good and plenty of meat and toppings.

Best cheese steaks in the area. Just make sure you order early as they tend to sell out of rolls. Rolls are made fresh daily. Have some tables inside for dining. Nice family run place read more

I love this place, and the people working there are great! This will be the forth year that my organization will be getting hoagies for our annual event at the AACA Museum. The quality of their hoagies ranks with the best. These are Philly style hoagies with top quality ingredients on great rolls. They go out of their way to make everything perfect for an event. read more

Best Cheesesteaks in Lebanon County! Other Hoagies are delicious, and packed full of meat and fixens.

Nice assortment of Italian subs! Two choices of rolls; hard/seeded or soft. The roast beef is excellent and we also like the four cheese sub. We love their hours expanding to include dinner! read more

I live locally. 1st time there. My wife and I had the lunch special. 1/2 hoagie, drink and chips. Fast service, stuffed with meats and toppings. I love the Philly hard roll. We will definitely stop in again. read more

Service is great. They even made me a sandwich which I ate as a kid in another state. Delivery is awesome. Food is good.

Well, I feel I must update my review. I just got home from work, on a Friday evening. I know they close at seven, so I called as quickly as I could, at 6:43 PM. I asked if they were still accepting takeout orders, and I was told, yes, as long as it's cold subs. I said that's what it would be. Then, the guy that answered the phone, said, "hold on. Mom, did you just put all the meat away?" Yes, she had already put the meat away, so I was unable to place an order. and, he also told me they are going on vacation next week, so it'll be a while till I can place another order. Still liking the one sub I had, but they make it tough to place an order. So, as of now, I logged into yelp, updated my review, and it's still seven minutes before they're supposed to close. read more

Super nice people with AWESOME service. The problem is that the hoagies are too big, salty and lunch meat isn't great...

Wildly good veggie sub. This isn't your typical "veggie delight". Was going to eat just a bite but finished half. This sub was HUGE and a warning- it is super messy. you definitely don't wanna eat this on the go or on a first date! read more

Sensational. Always nice people, always fresh, great bread. Fantastic. I love their old school Italian. Always on point. read more

How this has so few reviews and so low a rating is beyond me. Stopped in for a quick lunch and was very pleased by the portions, the price, and the friendly staff. I will absolutely be back. read more

I made my first visit to the restaurant today. You quickly discover a very large menu from this family run restaurant. Prices were good, customer service was good, food was good, portion size was good. What beats that? The people leaving anything less than 5 stars on previous reviews clearly do not understand how ratings work. You can even order ahead of time. Support small businesses, support family run businesses. read more

Tried it for the first time today, and I know I'll be going back, and back.... and back! Prices are good, portions are huge, and sandwiches are tasty! Their bread is amazing and makes all the difference! read more

Fifty years ago as youngster my older brother took the family out for cheesesteaks at some pizzeria along route 30. It was years before I could drive, but I always remembered that first really good cheesesteak. And ever since I tried to duplicate it locally. For decades!! I believe I tried every pizzeria and sandwich shop within 30 miles of Hershey in the ensuing years and many farther away. Some local shops came close, but were not consistent. One week close, next week not even close! One day my daughter said try Hoagies on Main 601 W main st ., Palmyra. Eureka! Finally the long search was OVER! Just like Rt 30 so long ago, but even better. And Huge! I took my time having one cheesesteak almost every week for over half a year and always the same high quality, great taste!! The Hoagies are great too but the Cheesesteaks are my favorite. 50 years is a long time to wait, but I am sure glad I found a great cheesesteak locally again!! read more

Don't eat here they messed everything up, the owner was extremely rude when I tried to have my order fixed and I spent 90.00 for food that I will now have to throw away. The owner refused to return my money. The building when I walked in was not very clean and the people are rude. I was told to bad that my order was messed up and our party guest had no food to eat. Will never go back. What a waste of 90.00. BEWARE AND STAY AWAY FROM THEM!! read more

Very delicious food and the service is awesome and fast they're always putting new stuff on the menu like the chili cheese dog the people that work there are so nice if something isn't right they'll fix it the store is super clean A great place to have a real Philadelphia hoagie and they also have hot sandwiches to keep up the good work ladies read more

This is the first place I ate moving to the area from Colorado. I was craving a decent sub. The hoagies were good. I have been back multiple times, and I haven't been disappointed. read more

My order was cheese steak pizza / mushrooms w/ add on banana peppers. Taste good no mushrooms though the steak is really chopped up and seemed to be like steakums not a steak for the money it cost. 12.00$ is a little much for this type of steak and I would have enjoyed the mushrooms if put on the sub, not worth the money. The other sub ordered was very good and at good cost (turkey sub ) $7.00 delivery time was good and driver was good I will order again but I won't be getting the steak and cheese again maybe an Italian. read more

Tried cheesesteaks they made us feel bad all day. Cluttery visible plant food dead plants very mom and pop

The last 2 orders (sandwiches) were made incorrectly and missing ingredients. Unfortunately I will be going elsewhere

If I could I would give you a zero star I would. We got two subs & fries. The subs were completely soggy, like just completely ridiculously soggy I couldn't even eat it. The fries weren't even cooked, completely soggy as well. We were told at 210 it would be 25 mins. We got there at 240, now how could this happen in 5 minutes...? The "manager" tried to say the subs were done in 10 minutes and were sitting for half an hour but then why in the world were we told to come in 25 minutes? THIS PLACE SUCKS. Never ever returning again and will spread the word about this. Hoageez on main in Hummelstown is 100% better. DO NOT GO TO THE PALMYRA ONE EVER THIS PLACE IS TERRIBLE. read more