Came in looking for set of screws for some furniture that needed replacements. Someone was not only…read moreable to point me in the right direction, they walked me through the store to their well stocked section of nuts, bolts, screws, etc. and hand picked out the exact items I needed. Could not have had a more seamless experience.

They were very helpful when I. And I. Late in a Friday night at the last minute. They treated…read moreh like I was the first customer of the day. Great teamwork and friendly staff. Quality paints.

Top service - they help solve problems. They actually have people who know about hardware and…read moreeverything else they sell.

It's my go to place for hardware...but yesterday I was assaulted by an aggressive dog inside the…read morestore while its owner was at the counter. Came at me as I entered the store, yanking on the leash , barking and showing teeth. Good grief. Only service animals please.

Excellent local hardware store! Mark is super knowledgeable and helpful! Great place to pick up…read moreanything you might need for fixing up the house - paint, stains, screws, drill bits, electrical and plumbing supplies, gardening tools and so much more! No need to run to the big box stores when you just need a couple items. They're also an authorized dealer for Benjamin Moore Paint. Highly recommend!

I've been going to this Hardware store for over 50 years . It's a family owned business and they…read moretreat me like family . They always have what I need. If they don't have it they will get it . God bless this store .

Attention: All in Lake Hopatcong-Sparta Regions : Avoid the hassles, ignorance & arrogance of the…read moreBig Box stores- just travel on over to this place. Eric (owner?) and staff are just out of this world wonderful, helpful, knowledgeable & courteous - not to mention their money saving ideas and methods. The prices are competitive and in many cases Lower than the Big Boxes - What more could you want ? Its all here at this place called American True Value and the place and people there really live up to its name. The standard by which other similar enterprises should be measured by & emulate. Come on down next time you need something and experience the real delight of Excellence, Quality Products & Great Pricing -You Won't Be Sorry and you'll be coming here all the time. A.Yodice, A.W.S.

Love this place!! Don't go to big box when you have this…read morelittle gem right in town. I often find the prices are cheaper here as well. I will look online for a saw blade, drill bit, etc... and decide to pay the extra few cents and save on time and gas. Guess what?... they are always in the ballpark or better prices. Also a great place to exchange propane tanks. Fast and easy! No standing in a line and groveling for an employee to help you. Lastly, every time I need help with finding something, I never have to ask, I am always approached first, and usually by the owner. The bonus is, they often give instructions to make the job simpler. Aside from my personal opinion of supporting small businesses, I can assure you, those big box stores will not and cannot give you the service and expertise you will receive at this hardware store.

I visited the McAfee Hardware store today, Saturday, January 10, 2025 and I have to tell you they…read morejust never failed to amaze me and always succeeded my expectations. The owner was there and we chatted for a while after we explain exchange pleasantries and happy new year, etc. and I had to get some keys made and needed a few sundry items and they are just so friendly. They'll walk you to the item help you make a selection and it's just a great family business And we love going to McAfee hardware store in McAfeeNew Jers

Always good always knowledgeable Very nice They still know…read morewhat the hell their doing !