5/5 Stars -- Ohio's Ice Cream Legend…read more By far the best place in Ohio to get fresh, amazing ice cream. I mean, Toft's Dairy has like 50 flavors--seriously, there's something for everyone. You can grab a cone, a cup, or even buy ice cream to take home for the family. And it's not just ice cream--they have milk, specialty drinks, and even fun merch like t-shirts. My personal favorite? Peanut Butter Cup + Peanut Butter Pretzel--absolute perfection. Creamy, nutty, salty, sweet... all the things you want in a summer treat. Sizes? They've got three, but honestly, the small is perfect: enough to satisfy that ice cream craving without going overboard. Medium is basically a full meal, so pace yourself. What makes it extra special for me: we know someone who works there (we met her at Kalahari), and she loves giving suggestions on flavor combos. Her tips always take a cone from great to legendary. And of course, there's the Cedar Point connection--stopping at Toft's after a day on the rides or after a big sporting event is pure nostalgia. Sticky fingers, huge smiles, and ice cream that tastes like summer memories. Bottom line: Toft's Dairy isn't just ice cream--it's a tradition, a memory, and hands-down the best sweet spot in Sandusky. You go once, and you'll be back again and again.

After a great lunch at Jolly Roger I was headed back towards Cleveland and wanted to grab some ice…read morecream; Toft Dairy had popped up in my online feed recently so I figured I would give them a try. I have had Toft's ice cream a couple of times before, but the scoop shop experience can always be different. This location is actually there headquarters, factory and the scoop shop. The building has a covered patio out front, there are some cow statues and an original dairy cart out front. Inside they have a large service area with a huge amount of flavors, plus coolers with packed ice cream and ice cream pies. I ordered a medium sized cup with Banana Foster and Caveman Chocolate ice creams. The cup was $7.50 which seemed a bit expensive until I saw the portion size, this was really about 4 scoops of ice cream. The ice cream is nice and smooth with a nice texture and mouthfeel. The banana foster ice cream was slightly sweet and had a mild banana flavor I did not taste the advertised burnt sugar swirl. The Caveman Chocolate was very good with a rich dark chocolate ice cream and a nice amount of chocolate truffles, although again I did not taste the thick fudge swirls. Toft's has some very good ice cream, the scoop shop lacks some of the charm of other ice cream places, not too surprising since it is part of the factory. The ice cream is a bit expensive, but the portions are big. Probably the most flavor choices I have seen at an ice cream place.

wow....3rd generation owner hits it out of the ball park. friendly, great service! and huge…read moresmall ice cream cone...tasted perfect on a hot day. will definitely be back often! lovely to see the place come alive again...have missed having DG's .

This ice cream shop is hands down the best I've ever been to! The ice cream was incredibly creamy,…read morerich, and packed with flavor. I tried the cookie dough and it was loaded with huge chunks of cookie dough in every bite. The staff was super friendly, patient, and made great recommendations. The shop itself was clean, welcoming, and had such a fun atmosphere. You can tell they really care about quality and customer service. I already can't wait to come back and try more flavors. If you're anywhere nearby, this place is absolutely worth the trip!

Flavors were great and service super friendly. We got the cake batter, caramel pretzel, chocolate,…read moreand Cookie Monster flavors and loved them all

Very very good dessert. I would recommend this place to anyone. We were visiting cedar point and…read moreneeded something sweet after dinner. This place hit the spot. You get to choose exactly what you want and how much you want. It's pay by weight, so you are also in control of how much you are going to spend.

My favorite ice cream shop around. The ice cream is amazing and the chili dogs with relish are…read moreterrific. The staff is always polite.

The Fruity Pebbles flurry there is amazing! I would highly recommend this place, the icecream is…read moregreat and the staff is even better!

Love this place. First time visiting and the cookie ice cream sundae was to die for. The staff was…read morefriendly and considerate to assist with making the ice cream to go. The environment was family fun kid friendly, warm neutral inviting tones , souvenirs that can be purchased as well. Bonus: they sell individual pints of ice-cream too.

My husband and I were in Sandusky for a work conference and decided to stop by Sandusky Scoops --…read moreand wow, what a treat! From the moment we walked in, the shop had such a fun, welcoming vibe. The Kim was friendly and patient as we tried to decide from all the amazing flavors. The ice cream itself was outstanding -- truly super-premium. You can taste the quality right away: it's dense, creamy, and incredibly rich, with that old-fashioned flavor you only get from real, small-batch ice cream. Every bite was pure happiness. We each tried a couple of different flavors and couldn't stop raving about how smooth and flavorful everything was. It was the perfect little getaway from our conference -- a moment to relax, laugh, and indulge in something truly special. If you're in Sandusky, do yourself a favor and stop at Sandusky Scoops. You'll leave smiling (and probably planning your next visit before you're even out the door!).

Wow!!! Super cute and charming! My friends and I visited this adorable lake side ice cream shack…read morewhen at Catawba Island this summer! The staff were sweet and the ice cream was delicious! Since I love everything fruity, I got the lemon blueberry cheesecake flavor in the kids size, which was the perfect treat! They also offer sundaes, shakes, and malts if you're in the mood for something more decadent. The only thing I disliked was the wait, but the retro vibes and yummy ice cream made it well worth it! I would definitely recommend if you're looking for a fun dairy shed on a hot summer day!

I grew up coming to this ice cream stand. Three generations of my family has!…read more This year is no exception. Love the brightly painted seating, outdoor games, music playing, and super friendly service! The prices aren't super cheap, but I love supporting small businesses so it's worth it. They always have a Dole Whip which is the absolute BEST! This time was raspberry and it slaps.

Went to this place and got served cold food, and the Ice Cream portions were small and Pricey…read more Wouldn't Recommend going to this. New ownership sucks and some of the workers can get snippy.

Nice small town ice cream shop. Everything was delicious and the staff was friendly. The slushies…read morewere really good!

I got just a swirl ice cream dipped in chocolate. It was good. On a blazing hot evening it did the…read moretrick. I had a question about something else and they were helpful and friendly.pretty good local joint.