5/5 Stars -- Ohio's Ice Cream Legend…read more By far the best place in Ohio to get fresh, amazing ice cream. I mean, Toft's Dairy has like 50 flavors--seriously, there's something for everyone. You can grab a cone, a cup, or even buy ice cream to take home for the family. And it's not just ice cream--they have milk, specialty drinks, and even fun merch like t-shirts. My personal favorite? Peanut Butter Cup + Peanut Butter Pretzel--absolute perfection. Creamy, nutty, salty, sweet... all the things you want in a summer treat. Sizes? They've got three, but honestly, the small is perfect: enough to satisfy that ice cream craving without going overboard. Medium is basically a full meal, so pace yourself. What makes it extra special for me: we know someone who works there (we met her at Kalahari), and she loves giving suggestions on flavor combos. Her tips always take a cone from great to legendary. And of course, there's the Cedar Point connection--stopping at Toft's after a day on the rides or after a big sporting event is pure nostalgia. Sticky fingers, huge smiles, and ice cream that tastes like summer memories. Bottom line: Toft's Dairy isn't just ice cream--it's a tradition, a memory, and hands-down the best sweet spot in Sandusky. You go once, and you'll be back again and again.

After a great lunch at Jolly Roger I was headed back towards Cleveland and wanted to grab some ice…read morecream; Toft Dairy had popped up in my online feed recently so I figured I would give them a try. I have had Toft's ice cream a couple of times before, but the scoop shop experience can always be different. This location is actually there headquarters, factory and the scoop shop. The building has a covered patio out front, there are some cow statues and an original dairy cart out front. Inside they have a large service area with a huge amount of flavors, plus coolers with packed ice cream and ice cream pies. I ordered a medium sized cup with Banana Foster and Caveman Chocolate ice creams. The cup was $7.50 which seemed a bit expensive until I saw the portion size, this was really about 4 scoops of ice cream. The ice cream is nice and smooth with a nice texture and mouthfeel. The banana foster ice cream was slightly sweet and had a mild banana flavor I did not taste the advertised burnt sugar swirl. The Caveman Chocolate was very good with a rich dark chocolate ice cream and a nice amount of chocolate truffles, although again I did not taste the thick fudge swirls. Toft's has some very good ice cream, the scoop shop lacks some of the charm of other ice cream places, not too surprising since it is part of the factory. The ice cream is a bit expensive, but the portions are big. Probably the most flavor choices I have seen at an ice cream place.

Very pleased with the new-to-me pizza spot at 5-14, I will most certainly be back. Wait wasn't bad,…read morefood was very good! Great cheese

Tasty. Clean. Courteous. Creative crusty creations. Popper pizza. Smokehouse pie. Pumpkin pie shake…read moreand most importantly Tofts soft serve used in all dairy treats. Vegan cheese is available to meet your needs. Intentional and innovative establishment in Smalltown Castalia =] Check it out for sure!!

Great ice cream and great staff! Cute place, clean and friendly. The ice cream was delicious!read more

My whole family wanted ice cream after diner, my oldest said there was a place on the way back to…read moreour condo, well this is the place, it was great, everyone got ice cream they enjoyed, I actually had a strawberry malt, it was good, could have extra malt, anywho lots of flavors, and fries and hot dogs, like I said I ate before but a great place for that ice cream dessert. The place is put together nice with lots of seating, and it's all wood, with pictures of ice shanty's on the wall... and when you place your order and get your snacks quick. Oh and I saw the banana split, man, it was massive!!

We took a day trip over to Port Clinton to walk the shores of Lake Erie and enjoy the sun set…read more Along the way I searched for an ice cream shop and Scooter's Dairy Bar came up on Waze. We decided to give it a shot and were pleased with our choice. Scooter's offers a wide variety of ice cream in both dairy and non-dairy varieties (contrary to the dairy bar name) for incredibly reasonable prices. The serving sizes were generous and the staff was super friendly. The parking situation isn't the greatest; however, there is a large lot just across the street that you can stop in to run over and get your treats. Check it out if you're in the area and craving the nostalgia of a small town ice cream shop

It's not the best ice cream nearby, but it's good. This is your nostalgic dairy shack of quick…read morefried hot food, drink treats, and ice cream desserts. They do carry the non-dairy Dole whip in orange flavor. The young staff were friendly and quite quick. Judging by the location, they cater to mostly the local neighborhood and nearby school functions foot traffic. They support the military with a discount. Parking lot is small, but plenty of street parking. The patio has about 6 tables with umbrellas. Area was clean and free of trash. A nice stop if you don't want to go stand in the other tourist lines with prices. #UpCloseSavor XP

I drive an hour just for this ice cream. My family loves tofts. Usually were go to the Sandusky…read morelocation, but this one is tinier and usually not as crazy. The staff is always young, but at least nice. There are so many flavors to choose from.

It literally says in the description "generous portions" they could not be more wrong with saying…read morethat is my ice cream had about 4 m'n'm's in it. The ice cream tasted bad in general and it was seven dollars for a small. Overall I would never recommend to anyone unless you want to waste big money for a garbage product.

Great prices and great ice-cream! I've never had a bad experience here. The employees misunderstood…read moremy order once and fixed it without any hassle.

Cheap prices, no hassle ordering at the walk up window, & yummy ice cream. Hard to go wrong by…read morechoosing to grab a snack here during the heat of the day. I had the seasonal special with fresh strawberries & it really hit the spot.

Food is great. I have tried the burgers, fish, and chicken sandwiches. Can't beat the flurries or…read moreice cream cones. Place is always packed. I was told that ladies with big ta tas, with see through shirts worked here so I thought that was why there was a long line. Nope, just a hot spot for locals. Nice little small town place. Definetly will come back.

The service was quick and the food was really good. A great value, too. The staff were very…read morepleasant! I look forward to stopping again if I'm ever passing through that area. Highly recommend their frozen lemonade drink! Unique and flavorful with actual lemon slices in the bottom. A pleasant surprise.

This 4/12 visit will be my last visit unfortunately as the twist in a cup w sprinkles... the ice…read morecream was over filled w no lid... then I asked for a lid and the one girl just sat it on top of the sprinkled ice cream along w the other girl shutting the window

Stopped in after all day in cedar point and got 4 sundaes. All were great. I suggest peanut…read morebutter sauce. Buckeye something.

Food choices friendly service Fun local spot…read moreVery packed in the summer Yummy soft serve for

Food is so good. The service is nice. It's a great place to play down at the hill. I ride down…read morethere every single day. It's such a great place.

Flavors were great and service super friendly. We got the cake batter, caramel pretzel, chocolate,…read moreand Cookie Monster flavors and loved them all

Very very good dessert. I would recommend this place to anyone. We were visiting cedar point and…read moreneeded something sweet after dinner. This place hit the spot. You get to choose exactly what you want and how much you want. It's pay by weight, so you are also in control of how much you are going to spend.