Great , quick service and Best pizza and shipwreck salad!! Delicious! !!!! Staff are very friendly and they make the best shipwrecked pizza just like the old River side read more

A delicious indulgence in all things Italian-American. The Original calzone was heart-wrenchingly good! Also pizza by the slice at lunch hour is only $2.50 per slice. Deep dish style. Quick and friendly service! read more

Iggies Pizza on the Bay - Original Calzone - ham and cheese with ranch dressing. - Pizza Near Me - Caseville, Michigan

We love iggie's Pizza! Staff are so friendly and welcoming! Quick service with a smile! It's more of a to go pizza place, no place to sit inside, a few chairs/tables outside. If you pay with a credit card, you can't leave a tip, make sure you have some cash for tips for the amazing staff! The breadsticks are amazing!! read more

The pizza was okay. Lots of cornmeal on the crust. Got a BBQ chicken pizza and the people we were with got regular pizza. The BBQ chicken had very little chicken. Lots of BBQ sauce. It was just okay. I tried the regular pepperoni pizza our friends got and it was lacking in sauce. And all of it was fairly expensive for the mediocre quality at best. read more

It was raining on vacation and our beach day got thwarted. We were staying near Iggy's and thought a close by pizza and some TV was probably our best bet. We wound up very pleasantly surprised! Iggy's is great! Just a small, charming carry out counter with super fresh pizza. The dough was crispy and chewy with a nice little dust coating, the sauce was rich and plentiful, gooey cheese, and pretty good quality toppings. The kicker was it was so wonderfully garlicky! You could smell it wafting out of the box on the way home and the taste delivered on what the aroma promised. We just got a medium and a small cheese bread to split between the two of us and it was plenty. We had lots of leftovers to sustain us for the car ride home the next day and looked forward to each bite! read more

Iggies Pizza on the Bay - Medium pizza with pepperoni and half mushroom. All the ingredients were quality, crust was crisp and chewy, and it was garlic heaven. - Pizza Near Me - Caseville, Michigan

i thought this would be a really good pizza place seeing as though casevilles a small town and there's not many pizza places around. the service and workers were truly so kind and positive vibes but the pizza was very undercooked and unseasoned along with the bread. if you like pizza super doughy then i recommend. read more

Medium is the new large. But the pie was pretty good crust was crunchy yet soft enough for this bone thrower to eat. PRICE was a little more than the chains, but that is expected. Pepperoni had a nice kick. Would suggest to others read more

I can't believe every year that I'm in Port Austin I missed out on this place......so glad I finally made it in! You must try the chicken bacon ranch! The kids devoured it! Pepperoni too!! We also got a big Greek salad it was very Fresh service was fast and the very friendly staff was awesome !! You must stop in and try! I will be back again next year!! read more

Iggies Pizza on the Bay - Very yummy! Chicken bacon ranch! Pepperoni too! - Pizza Near Me - Caseville, Michigan

First, I love the fact that they will do have half-sies on the pizza toppings. THANK YOU! Other places around here won't let you do that so it forces you to buy more pizza than you need... or decide that you're not going to order at all. Second, the crust is like the old school Pizza Hut pan pizzas but not as thick - I absolutely love it and I'm not one who eats the crust! This crust, garlicky and salty, yes I eat it! Lastly, they put on enough cheese and sauce, perfect amounts. Oh and try the shipwreck salad - OMG so good. Latest menu and new website... read more

See all

Ordered a custom large 1/2 & 1/2 pizza plus the Shipwreck salad. Both were ready in the promised 15 minutes. Both were incredibly tasty. We will definitely be ordering food from Iggie's again. read more

Iggies Pizza on the Bay - Front of menu - Pizza Near Me - Caseville, Michigan

Not a good pizza. The small 8" square pizza, $11.50, looked like a homemade pizza and the crust wasn't cooked all the way as if the dough needed to rise longer. They charge 75 cents each for dry crushed chiles and parmesan. I've never seen this before. Just build that into the price of the pizza and give away as every other pizza place does. How they have gone downhill from last cheeseburger. Last year they must have had a different cook. read more

Iggies Pizza on the Bay - 8" square uncooked crust $11.50. - Pizza Near Me - Caseville, Michigan

Worst cheese bread I have ever had. Your better off eating the box. The pizza is nothing to write home about but it is edible. Folks who eat ranch, you better load up. read more

Great calzones! Haven't had their pizza yet because I can't go without the calzone lol. I'm usually not a fan of calzones but they are so good. Plus the workers are so nice . read more

While I wasn't necessarily expecting to find a fantastic pizza in a small town pizza shop in Caseville, typically I find a better made and better tasting pizza then what is available at one of the pizza chain stores. Unfortunately, that was not the case in this instance. We ordered two large pizzas (one cheese only, one more a supreme style) for pickup and a family size greek salad. The pizza was only ok-the crust was a bit burnt and the sauce tasted watered down. Outside of that, there wasn't anything particularly bad. It was particularly bland. I'm not sure how you can mess up a greek salad, but nothing was good about it. First, it wasn't family sized (as in feeding ~2 adults, 2 young children) but more like a salad for two. There were a few purple onions, a few olives, some bits of feta cheese but significantly less than any other greek salad I've ever had (essentially just all chopped lettuce). In addition, it had chopped beets-which was a bit weird as I would have expected sliced or some other style in a salad then chopped into small bits. Then to top off the lousy salad, there was no salad dressing on the salad and none included in the bag. This place use to be a Little Ceasers and then understand that the old Pizza on the Bay business was recently sold. Whatever the case, they have a lot to learn about making a good pizza and even more when it comes to salad. There are better choices in Caseville and surrounding area when it comes to pizza. read more

The pizza we ordered was made fresh for us in about 12 minutes or less! We got the Hawaiian 5-0 and to say the least, it was delicious. The crust was fluffy and soft, brushed with what I am assuming was garlic butter before being sprinkled with Parmesan. The pizza also held good value the next morning as a cold breakfast slice. If you are in "the thumb" and looking for pizza I would suggest giving Iggies a try! read more

Gluten- free pizza is terrible - tasteless crust that is under cooked. It is obviously a frozen pizza.

2020 Cheeseburger winner???? im not even sure that was a beef burger! Overpriced and horrible burgers! Never tried the pizza

Tried this place because I heard it was good. Definitely lived up to my expectations. Great customer service, and even better food. Try the 3-cheese bread!! read more

Yes!!! You are open for the season. Had an amazing Tall, Dark & Handsome calzone. Can't wait to order the beloved Shipwreck Salad on a return visit. Wishing you continued success. read more

I need to first admit I'm not a fan of pizza but had Iggys for the first time last year and it was Amazing. I was so happy when they opened this year after their winter break and was so disappointed. The sauce is different and even the dough tastes different and or maybe how they cook it. Puzzled and so Disappointed. I'm not crazy because everyone in my family agrees with me. #blah read more

Just across from caseville beach, we thought we'd give it a try. No seating so we took our pizza back to the park. We got a pepperoni, bacon, and jalapeno pizza. It was awesome! Way better than Riverside, which we went to yesterday. If you're here on vacation like us, you gotta check out Iggies. Crust was light, crunchy on the outside, and soft and chewy on the inside. And it was a perfect ratio of crust to toppings. I'm glad the dough wasn't too thick, like some places that try to skimp the toppings by overdoing the crust. I'll happily spend my money here. Great job, guys! read more

Solid pizza place in vaca town. Picked up 3 pies, very reasonable. Tried the vegie, a pepperoni and a combo. The dough, sauce were tasty w/ a healthy amount of toppings. If you're in town looking to pick up its a good place. Certainly beats Lil Caeser's. read more

Every time we eat here my entire family gets some form of food poisoning. We had heard it is under new management and wanted to try it again but all of us got food poisoning again. I am never going to this restaurant again for the food. The only upside is that the staff is very nice. read more

the customer service was absolutely horrible here. i called to place a large order of 7 pizzas and they hung up on me the first time and then preceded to tell me i was prank calling them because i laughed because my large group i was in was staring at me making the order. then my mom called and they refused to take a call from my number since it comes up on the same plan. this place satisfied me last year when i ordered from them and this year i will still be satisfied but but their customer service is absolutely horrible. but good pizza. read more

Pizza is decent. Dough was too soft. I like a crisper crust. Ordered a bacon cheese pizza with very little bacon on it. Need more

The service was very friendly. Pizza was hot and ready at time given to be. The daily special was well worth the price. The pizza crust was a nice miss it of crispy and thick. The garlic butter included was a nice treat. The three cheese bread had great flavor. A deff family favorite. read more

Had a pizza from Iggy's last week and it was WONDERFUL! So good, I ordered one again last night! The best crust I've tasted! Very buttery...worth eating and I usually skip the crust. Fresh ingredients and pleasant fellow serving it up. I'll be a regular patron here. read more