Delicious pick two for lunch .. had a 1/2 pizza and greek salad and it was delicious! Staff is…read morealways friendly and they are both courteous and quick with your order ! Tables are wiped clean as well!

Nice place to order pizza from. I order when I walked in. You can eat inside or take out. You get…read moreto see when they're making the pizza right in front of you and when they put it in a fire oven. A lot to choose from including making your salad in front of you.My Pizza was delicious with sausage and chicken. I didn't wait too long 12 to 15 minutes tops. It was delicious and amazing. Thank you.

Colony Pizza GOOD: Meat pizza toppings were flavorful…read moreBAD: Crust and value for price (too high for quantity) Staff is friendly. Colony pizza has a diverse menu that I would give another try. Locals seem to love this place, but I found the pizza very average. The toppings were very good - greasy meats, can't go wrong. I like a nice crispy crust that can support the toppings. Their crust is very soft and chewy. Every slice needs a steady two hands as the crust falls like a limp noodle with any weight. It may sound picky to some, but a good crust really goes a long way and a good, crispy crust that holds toppings well makes for the tasty mix of texture. Also 19 bucks is steep for a 12 inch pie, even with some meats.

Nothing special here. Limp soggy crust with little flavor. Sauce with little flavor as well as the…read morecheese. Ordered onions and found a few chips and nothing more. Pepperoni was good. Ordered take out. Staff was very friendly.

Valerio's Italian GOOD: Nearly everything - my pizza rolls…read morewere delicious, the seafood alfredo hit the spot - great service and warm decor that brought back memories of the childhood corner Italian place BAD: Nothing much, the pasta was slightly over cooked (didn't effect my enjoyment) The place gets a little hectic as it fills but the staff does a good job. I was very pleased with Valerio's. After several Italian places fell flat since visiting, Valerio's was a win. It's a warm, family place with hearty food and great service. I can't wait to go back and try a calzone or pizza.

Me and my family love Valerios!! It is a yearly tradition to go to Valerios every summer, and the…read morefood is always delicious and the ambiance makes you feel like you were just plopped right into Italy! The service is always friendly and it is nice that the restaurant allows the guests to seat themselves. Great restaurant, great food, and awesome service!!

I was in Erie for a conference and wanted to go to a local restaurant that had great reviews…read more I enjoyed the staff and seeing the Pirates game on the TV. The menu wasn't deep but I like that because you go with what you're good making and avoid decision paralysis. I had a pepperoni pizza and a draft sour beer. Both were good and I'd probably get them again. Definitely a good place to get some eats and a beer.

Firestone's Kitchen…read more This was the BEST pizza I've had in Erie as a traveller looking to settle here. I've tried 3 others, mostly very flat on crust or flavor (all independent places). Firestone's pizza has an excellent char, solid sauce and flavorful toppings. The restaurant also has a beer/wine store, and a eye pleasing meat counter/butcher. I have no complaints - friendly service, fair priced pizza for excellent quality, and the liquor section has some charm to the decor. ***From the road, look for Gordon's (even though Firestone Kitchen is the eatery). Gordon's is more prominent from the road.

Great food. Quick and dependable service. We got a ton of good sampler and it tasted great.read more

Wow, our pizzas were so disappointing tonight! A wood fired crust does not make up for a dry pizza…read morewith little sauce and few toppings. Staff seemed friendly but Very poor quality!

We always wanted to try this traditional old school Italian restaurant when in Erie, but it was…read morefully booked on a Saturday last Aug when we attempted. It's located in Millcreek Mall & you can enter from mall parking lot or from inside mall itself. Our server was friendly & efficient with nice recommendations. I loved my pasta carbonara & our guest loved her spaghetti & meatballs (two HUGE meatballs). They have a nice happy hour & I had a French martini mixed well. We loved the zucchini blossom appetizer. The large wedge salad was good. And the garlic knot bread with shaved Parmesan is a nice touch, we got an extra basket. My husband & other male guest had the linguini & clams and were not as pleased. One said it was just ok, broth weak & unflavorful and the other guest gave it a 3/10 saying clams were overcooked & chewy. Desserts were good, we had pistachio gelato and strawberry shortcake. We would return & try again if in the area.

We stopped in for dinner tonight! Overall experience: 6.5/10! The service was great. She was super…read morepatient with us, and we really appreciated that. The appetizer we ordered was the Fresh Tomato Pepperonata... this was a 10/10... it was amazing and gr8 way to start the meal! Perfect way to get in your vegetables. Was a little disappointed that the server picked it up without asking us... since almost half the plate was still left. We also ordered the "Sicilian" with Chicken Pizzette. This was also a 10/10! Our favorite of the night. The artichoke, Spinach, and tomato combo created blast of flavor in your mouth. The Carbonara was a 3/10. The server mentioned it would be more creamy and saucy and we were ok with that. For us it was WAAAY to salty. Not sure what happened there. Could have been the prosciutto as mentioned by the chef, but unsure. They were gracious enough to take it off the bill. We'll be back for sure. If you're in the Erie area and craving Italian food, definitely worth checking it out especially if you're near Peach street.

Short and sweet it pays to check out different restaurants well being out of town shopping. The…read morerestaurant has been a staple in Erie for almost 40 years...which was a definite perk in finding food after shopping. Staff was friendly...food made fresh to order...the dough in stromboli was bon appetit...the spices and combination of flavor made it taste like it was fresh out of Italian kitchen. Will be back for sure next time in area to try the pizza or calzone.

I just called Mamma Mia's to order a Stromboli and they told me I was banned. She informed me that…read moreAugust 2021. I ordered a Stromboli and I never picked it up. I blew in my car and I never paid for the food. Number one if they would've contacted me I probably wasn't even thinking about the food. They're lucky I called them to let them know that my motor blue. But to ban somebody for something as stupid as that. I actually knew that I wasn't allowed to order. They didn't tell me I was banned. She just wouldn't accept the orders from my phone so I would use my grandson's phone or use my house phone, but of course I'm in my car so I decided to place the order without thinking about it. It's actually most times when I order I just go pick it up and her son's usually there or somebody else is behind the counter, but I have been ordering for Mamma Mia's since they were on peach Street 25 years ago. And I will order from them again they're Stromboli's aren't as good as they used to be when the other people owned it but they're OK. Guess I'll be going to Stevo's.

I love their pizza, but they are not reliable to be open when I want pizza. Very inconvenient and…read moreinconsiderate of their customers.

Make sure you check your order before leaving their parking lot, we went to the shop, placed our…read moreorder, clerk wrote it down, order was brought to the car, didn't check it, got home and of course it is not what we ordered.