Truly the best pizza I have ever had. Such a great experience, everyone was very nice. Definitely recommend!!

I have eaten here prior but only slices. On my birthday I decided to order a whole pizza, some wings and a salad. It was actually really disappointing. The wings were cold as well as the pizza. I actually watched them remove the pizza from the oven, place it in a box and cut it . They then taped the box closed which i thought was strange but , ok.I drove home to Freeport, about 3.5 miles. By the time we arrived home, the food was cold . What this tells me is that the pizza was already made , baked earlier and reheated. I believe that this was the reason that they taped the box closed, so I wouldn't look at it until I got home.I was expecting a freshly made pizza. Same deal with the wings. Anyone who gives this place more than 2 stars doesn't know good pizza. This place is definitely not the standard. You could tell by the way it looked that it was reheated. I will not go there again. read more

Best Pizza you will ever get and have been going here for years. Its been here for years. Recommend you go.

Best pizza!! I've had a lot of pizza and this place is superior! This is as close to New York City. You can get around here.

In Oakmont. There's not much to be said for pizza over this way. I drove to j&S which is not super close. It was so good. I wish they'd open a location here. We need it! read more

Good food, different pizza toppings to choose from we enjoyed the taco one. Warm welcome. And convienant where it is located! Recommend!

So I just walked out of j & s pizza. Why, I asked for 4 slices of Sicilian pieces ( center ones please) the young lady at the counter said ok there's one coming out of the oven now. Because the owner saw that there were 2 slices ( side pieces with crust) on the counter he told her I could only have what was already cooked. I could not believe the I couldn't get 4 slices of freshly cooked pizza. What's the world coming to. I then walked out not believing what had just happened. Never again. Minus all stars. I am adding one star because I cannot post this review until I do. read more

Quick Sunday takeout and it was incredible. The spaghetti pizza!!!!! I'll order it every single time. The steak Stromboli was stuffed full and delicious. Can't wait to go back! read more

J & S Pizza - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Natrona Heights, Pennsylvania

See all

We spent over $30 on 2 bottles of skunked beer, a half dozen wings that were dried out and had no flavor except for the oil they were fried in, and an Italian hoagie with brown lettuce, 1 slices of of ham, no cheese and a partial slice of salami. This place is horrible. Be advised. read more

J & S Pizza - Toasted Italian hoagie. Where is the meat??? What the hell kind of hoagie is this? - Pizza Near Me - Natrona Heights, Pennsylvania

Horrible tasting pizza. I think the ingredients need to be switched up in my opinion.

This is my favorite pizza and there are a lot of places to have pizza around here. There is something about the cheese here you just can't beat. My only sadness is in the fact that they aren't open more;) read more

Delicious pizza, service good (not great but good), eating area can get a little messy, BUT All minor with the best pizza around. read more

Good pizza. Wait staff could be nicer and friendlier. Eating area nice. Not always the cleanest. read more

I can not speak to the pizza... But I can tell you the fried dough is delish!! My Gram took me there 30+ years ago for fried dough and it tastes the same! So super yummy! And at $1 a piece I got some to share with my siblings. What a delight. read more

J & S Pizza - Fried dough! - Pizza Near Me - Natrona Heights, Pennsylvania

I tried the eggplant, stuffed meat, square thick cut and thin mushroom and pepperoni pizzas. I would get the eggplant and stuffed meat slices again. I was not a fan of the thick crust (a little bland and doughy). The mushroom and pepperoni had yellow and white cheeses, it would have been better without the yellow cheese. I had their simple side salad (lettuce, tomato, onion and cheese.) It was fairly large and filling for a side salad. The staff was friendly and eager to help. The place is divey and could use some sprucing up. It really is nice to have a pizza place where a wide variety of single slices are available... read more

Amazing pizza, great service, best pizza in swpa. Highly recommend. Never had a bad meal. Been going there for over 30 years

Outstanding pizza. Great crust and delicious Sancerre. Been a neighborhood staple for decades.

If you order take out and there is something wrong with your order, it pains them to make it right, even when its their fault. About their Pizza...if you like your pizza with a crispy crust, this isnt the pizza for you. You need 2 hands to eat a slice, one to pick it up and the other one, to quickly pick up the floppy end to save your toppings from sliding off. Floppy is the perfect word to describe it. Honestly, from the floppy pizza to the frozen fries to their lack of good customer service, J&S is mediocre at best. read more

Use to order from here once or twice a week and then we noticed that the prices were different based on who was working, Delivery with tip sometimes was less than picking up. Was told today that a Cabrese Salad does not come with a dressing so it is suppose to be $1.00 extra when you ask even though it is under salad and you get one dressing per salad. Then I was told I should always get charged $1.00 for extra olives (4) for these miniature olives. Then the tomatoes used to be real nice and now you get half or quarter tomatoes. Pizza Morena's it is! Will not go or order here again. read more

Tried to give it another go this place was usually amazing, last time they delivered us soup. This time our pizza was burnt and cold. We waited over an hour and a half. Wont be ordering again read more

I ordered 5 pieces and only one (of the 4 actually received) was right. Service is mediocre at best as well. There are so many other places that are better and that will actually deliver to places they claim they deliver to. read more

I really enjoy most everything about J&S Pizza. I am 47 years old at the time of this writing. I remember J&S when they were in the old Highlands Mall....yeah the mall with two directories, which is comical because it was so dinky that even a toddler couldn't get lost! Hahaha Anyway, our family always enjoy the food and service. The family that owns it are true Italians and they greet you with a smile. They're always busy which is a testament that the food is delicious and consistent. Many others in the Valley and myself will keep coming back. It's quite a breath of fresh air getting food at a family owned restaurant and that they have a stake in the community. It was inevitable that they had to hire a slew of high school kids to keep up with the demand. The plain thin pizza & tuna subs are great! That's basically all l get there! You can dine in or take out! I hope you enjoy it as much as I have! read more

Lot of different selections, purely Italian cuisine. Full range menu will definitely Jace more than enough options to choose from.

Pizza is the best around, even with all the competition. If you haven't tried spaghetti pizza, try it. A meal in a slice. Their thin crust reminds me of NY street pizza vendors pizza, excellent. Very much worth a try. Oh and their Stromboli and salads are right up there too! read more

Stopped here for some pizza after visiting a buddy in the hospital nearby. I've been to J&S before, but it's been a while. My 10 year old - quite the pizza lover and critic - went with the exotic pepperoni pizza slice. I tried a slice of their white topped with tomato, and a slice with eggplant and mozzarella on top. They have quite a variety of slices to choose from, as well as calzone and other menu selections. They heat them up as they are ordered, so you always get it fresh and hot. The serving staff are friendly and efficient, and it's obvious the cooks in back are busy. Everything looked clean and well kept, including the rest room. Good food! I especially liked my slice with eggplant on top. Everything was seasoned just right, flavorful and generous in size. Our food, with drinks and 20+% tip - less than 20 bucks. Great spot to stop. Well done, folks! read more

I order from here frequently, and have been for years, and it's always consistently DELICIOUS, and the service is just as wonderful. I've never had one bad encounter from this establishment in the 20 or so years that I've been ordering from them. I usually order a large thin crust pizza with pepperoni, and a large Italian hoagie. Sometimes I'll get chicken wings instead of a sub. Everything is always fantastic. The pizza has a sweeter sauce, but I love it. The pizza is deliciously greasy and tasty. The subs come on homemade rolls that are so tasty and fresh. This is true Italian food. The service is always phenomenal. These people really have a good work ethic and you don't see much of that anymore. I recommend this place over any pizza place! You MUST try if you haven't yet. read more

I love j&S. I think it's the best everything I've ordered there is delicious and I love the sauce Italian Hoagie Spaghetti Pizza,Steak Stromboli and much more read more

Best pizza ever - have traveled the world and their pizza crust and sauce can't be beaten. We've been going there for years and love it

I've grown up on J&S pizza, since the days when they started in the Highlands Mall. After all of these years, nothing has changed. I live in New York now, but still long for the pizza here. I come here every trip back. Awesome service, clean environment, pizza to die for, what else could be asked? Eggplant pizza, the absolute best, or the thick Sicilian with pepperoni, my two personal favs. read more

J & S Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Natrona Heights, Pennsylvania

The restaurant is a nice looking restaurant when you walk in, but the people are not. When I walked in everyone just stared at me and kept looking at me while I was eating which was very uncomfortable. The food isn't so great, the pizza tasted like cardboard and it was cold. The (1) slice I got took 10 minutes just to heat up and it wasn't even cold. When I walked in they said hello, well one person did. When I left however nobody said anything which was odd, being they have like 20 works all just standing there upfront. I wish the costumer service was a lot better and I will be going to another pizza shop. All good I can say is that the restaurant looks very nice. read more

they have been around for over 40 years and the pizza hasn't changed. I've had the same 2 slices each time I've come in for 30 years a piece of spaghetti pizza and stuffed spinach n cheese both are $3.75 each. When you go in meet the owners they all came from Italy.Lots of parking. read more

See all

This place is ridiculous, every time we order they somehow managed to screw something up and make no offer to make it right! Food is not that great anyway and can't compare to Old Forge pizza is which is the real deal . Will never order from there again .. I would give Zero stars for all around bad business. read more

Always fast, friendly service with a smile! We're from out of state and enjoy coming here with the family every visit. Glad they were open on the 4th of July. read more

J & S Pizza - Chicken salad. ..delicious - Pizza Near Me - Natrona Heights, Pennsylvania

See all

I have been eating here for over 20 years and have never been disappointed. Whether you're looking for a some authentic Italian food or pizza/wings on game day they got you covered.. read more

I've gone here since they were in the old Highlands Mall. Some of the best pizza ever! Great service, great prices, great staff! Always highly recommended! read more

I think it is some of the best pizza in Western PA. The eggplant pizza is awesome. The owners are great people that are very accommodating. This place is a must see!!!! read more

My favorite pizza. The plain thin reminds me of slices from NJ and NYC. Fold it and go!!!

I don't know what all the hype is about this place. I ate here a lot growing up & have never cared for it. To this day, everything tastes exactly the same. I think the food is just unseasoned. Their thick crust pizza just tastes like a loaf of bread with toppings on it, its not even crispy on thr bottom. I'm sure I'll eat food from here again, because my family loves it, but I'll never feel satisfied with the flavors. I normally add my own seasonings at home. read more

I have lived here for 17 years and have eaten pizza from every place in the area. J and S is by far the best pizza I have had. Not only is the pizza fresh and delicious but the selection is excellent. Not only is the pizza the best around but the family who own and run the place are some of the warmest, kindest people you will meet. read more

I have always ordered a regular pepperoni pizza from J&S, which is always good. This time, I ordered a pepperoni pizza and a taco pizza. The pepperoni was fine, the taco pizza was seriously the WORST thing that I have ever eaten, and I'm not a picky person. First, is was soggy and they baked it with lettuce on it which made the whole thing a pile of goo. The meat on the "taco" pizza wasn't even seasoned, if it was, you sure couldn't tell. It smelled like puke. It was a smelly gooey mess. They give you taco seasoning packets to add to the pizza. I've never been to a place that baked the toppings like the lettuce and tomatoes on the taco pizza. It was always baked with the taco meat and the lettuce and tomatoes were added after baking. This was takeout or else I would have taken straight back to the counter. Don't order this pizza. You will never forgive yourself. read more

J & S Pizza - Soggy mess. The pieces we attempted to eat went in the garbage. - Pizza Near Me - Natrona Heights, Pennsylvania