Great service. Employees were helpful and kind. Pizza was not to my taste--the cheese tasted buttery, there was not a lot of sauce on it, and the sauce that was on it was a bit sweet. I probably won't come back--I prefer my cheese a bit sharper and more sauce--but I hope people who like their pizza this way patronize them. read more

Renovated for a year to open a bar, and that cash cow of a bar they were hoping for closes at 10:00 pm. Complete joke. Has to be a tax write off so the owner can invite his friends over and drink in his bar. If that's not the case, the guy is scared of making money. I could go on and on about how this makes zero sense. Add a bar to the most well known spot for food after the bars in Ames, but don't sell alcohol to the people that hold this business together. And it's not like anyone is asking for beer at 2:00 am. We're talking an hour or two before that when students are leaving the bars early and grabbing a slice. Let us enjoy a beer with our pizza during that window. That's prime time for your actual customer base. Jeff's was perfect without the bar, but why add one if you're just not going to use it when it actually makes sense? read more

I live outside Chicago so I know what a good pizza is. I was kind of on the hungry side and I decided to give Jeff's a chance while staying in Iowa. I like the fact that they have good deep dish pizza and I would recommend them. I've had Pizza twice within the same month and I would say they're deep dish stuffed is worth the trip. read more

tried jeff's during our stay in ames and everything was delicious! we got the hand-tossed pizza crust which was delicious, but i'd definitely go with the thin crust if you are ordering for yourself! the pizza flavors were delicious! the wings were also good, we got the hottest level and it was SPICY!! the prices were very reasonable, especially for the portion sizes. definitely give this spot a try if you're in town! read more

Nice local pizza shop, definitely worth a visit and better than the national chains. Only complaint is the AC doesn't work so well so it can get pretty warm if eating inside. The apps and salads were pretty good too. I would come back read more

See all

The server gave great service and played a song for the birthday girl While she was getting some pizza after the bars!

They have great gf pizza! The crust tasted great and was cooked to perfection. The many varieties of specialty pizzas was a huge bonus and especially enjoyed the service. The people in our group who had regular pizzas really enjoyed it too! read more

Good food. Good service. Convenient. TV was off so she gave us the remote to watch our channels. Easy going

Food is always fantastic, the owner and his staff are overly helpful and personable, and the new interior is really sleek and comfortable! Love that they kept the booths! Try the American Classic Cheeseburger pizza, it's a hit in our house! read more

See all

I can always count on Jeff's pizza to be amazing! Tonight I ordered their smotherella sticks and a salad. Their smotherella sticks are cheesy and delicious and I've never been disappointed. I also have very high praise for their salads. I feel like you get a nice portion of quality ingredients for a low price. My food was delivered before my estimated delivery time and the food was fresh upon arrival. I will definitely be ordering Jeff's again. I think I might try one of their pasta's or Calzones ne read more

Jeff's Pizza Shop - Smotherella sticks - Pizza Near Me - Ames, Iowa

Cozy pizza joint close to Iowa State. They sell single pizza slices at nighttime on weekends, which is brilliant. Their 30" pizza is a monster. Split it with a crowd or take on their pizza challenge! If you and a friend can finish it within one hour, you receive the pizza for free & $100 cash. Michael, the GM, is a great employee. I enjoyed chatting with Michael about the food challenge. read more

Jeff's Pizza Shop - the entrance to the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Ames, Iowa

Horrible experience. We had two pizzas and ordered smotherella. It took nearly 2 hours and then they forgot the smotherella. It's been over an hour and we are still waiting. The pizza was cold and we didn't get our whole order. We have 5 adults and 3 kids and no one is happy. Not a satisfied customer. read more

Looked online for some pizza while visiting my daughter for Thanksgiving. Google said this place was decent Unfortunately it seems like the people writing the reviews haven't had good pizza. I called and asked for a well done double sliced large cheese pizza. The girl I spoke to seemed like she didn't know what a well done pizza was and actually said she didn't know what a double sliced pizza is , that should've been my cue to hang up. Went and picked up the pizza and the pizza dough was not fully cooked and hardly had any sauce. Looked well done but was soggy. Pizza dough tasted kinda sweet. All this for $28.00. One of the worst pizzas I've had in a while. Very hard review for me to write, I love pizza. read more

Phone order for pickup: ordered a four meat and a spinach/havarti/artichoke. Got home to find a four meat and some type of cowboy pizza. Phone to complain: "I wasn't the one who took your order. Do you want me to make you a new one? You will have to come pick it up because I don't know where our driver is." Result: no longer a customer. read more

This is the result of the last delivery. Pizza was dropped. Needles to say, I'm very unhappy with this. I called to complain and they are sending a fresh Pizza out. read more

Jeff's Pizza Shop - This is the result of my last delivery. Pizza was dropped. - Pizza Near Me - Ames, Iowa

Amazing food and service! by far the Bart pizza around. The recent remodel looks amazing and really updated to look. They sell daily by the slice at meal times and also serve coffee now. 10/10 would recommend! read more

you really can't beat $4 slices. The employees are nice and i always get everything super fast. I will say that I wish they sold sausage slices and seasoned their crust on weekends like they do on weekdays. other than that everything else rocks! read more

Great pizza, it always hits when you need it to. Great crust, and the smotherella sticks are delicious. read more

Jeff's Pizza Shop - 20' Hawaiian - Pizza Near Me - Ames, Iowa

Order was 20 minutes late (took around an hour and 15 minutes to arrive in total). Pizzas seem to be smaller than what I ordered. I don't think that I will be ordering from here again any time soon. read more

Anyone who has been a student of ISU considers Jeff's to be a staple. The single slice take away is great and so is the cheesy bread. The pizza itself is good.. a very distinct taste. Staff is not overly friendly but they get the job done. read more

This place has gone down. This used to be the best pizza in town if not the state, and it's not as good anymore. New ownership? New management? Fix it, pizza gods!!!! read more

Stopped in to grab pizza rolls after the football game. Placed our order online and it was almost ready when we got there. Staff was friendly, but not wearing masks. The place was not very clean and was definitely run by college kids who were joking around most of the time. Pizza rolls were hot and fresh, tasty and a great portion size. read more

Great local pizza. Choices of pizza are of good variety and value. Friendly staff, and the pizza itself is solidly above average in quality. If you are looking to venture outside of chain pizza in Ames, I'd suggest starting here. People who reviewed negatively are probably just humorless bungholes. read more

Jeff's Pizza is the best late night pizza in Ames. The delivery is always super quick and the pizza always tastes great!

Just not good. For the person on the phone, thin crust is NOT handtossed. A pepperoni, sausage jalapeño ended up being just sausage. Cmon Jeffs, do better. read more

Delivery service is rude & ridiculous! Have waited over 30 past the time our order was supposed to be delivered. Person I called dismissed how upset & disappointed we were. Acted as though it was no big deal. Gave them two more chances & finally had enough. We ordered from ANYWHERE else but Jeff's Pizza. Plus, for the prices they get, their food is sub par at best. read more

This is one of those 2 handed pizza places. See pics. It takes 2 hands to hold the piece, because of the size and weight of the slice! I got the mushroom sausage pizza and one slice is plenty to fill most people up! Full of sausage, mushrooms and cheese, this is probably the best pizza I've had since the last time I was here. It's just THAT good. Clean. Family friendly. Friendly staff. Street parking and located in campus town. Good prices. Marcydiner tantrum scale of 5/5-no screaming kids. read more

See all

Jeff's offers great pizzas at a very reasonable price. They offer daily specials, which are great deals. I think it's awesome that they offer some less traditional options such as the BBQ chicken and buffalo chicken pizza, as well as a Philly cheesesteak pizza. The crust is known to taste like a breadstick, and I certainly can't disagree. This pizza shop is a staple to campus life for all Isu students. It's the late night stop for nigh goers and also the primary choice for pizza hosted events, for the most part. They open late, so they are accessible at virtually anytime you hit a pizza craving. I would definitely recommend this pizza shop to anyone in the area. read more

Jeff's Pizza Shop - Steak and shrimp pizza with smotherella sticks with jalapeño on the side - Pizza Near Me - Ames, Iowa

Anyone remember Landsberg Pharmacy? Probably not unless you are at least forty years old and have lived in Ames all your life. It was the long time occupant of the site that now houses Jeff's Pizza. After some failures of businesses at the location, it's good to see a long-term success in Jeff's. Let's hope all the construction in the area and associated parking issues do not harm Jeff's business too much. Thankfully, Jeff's is in easy walking distance for many ISU students (dare we say the most conveniently located pizza joint for ISU?) and has a thriving delivery business. I really like Jeff's. It's not foodie pizza. It's pizza. There are some foodie alternatives on the menu, but I've always felt bad pizza joints are exposed when you challenge them with simplicity. Order a simple pepperoni pizza and Jeff's shines. One of just two locations, Jeff's has some unique combination pizzas on the menu. I have a preference for thin and crispy pizza crust that, while not Jeff's default dough, is done very well here. My only complaint about Jeff's is a little inconsistency, typical I suppose of pizza places that are dependent on a lot of part-time workers that turn over often. They've screwed up my crust preference more than once, eating at the restaurant and with carry out. They handled the errors nicely, however, so for me it's not even an issue. The fact that the thin crust comes out soggy on occasion is of greater concern. That said, we've never had an issue when we stuck to their default crust, so perhaps it's just a consequence of me asking them to be something they're not. Pay attention to the daily specials. The savings can be significant. Jeff's Pizza is a great choice for delivery, carry out and dining in. Consider giving them a try while the construction is making business a little difficult for them. read more

Great pizza will definitely order again. Taste is very fresh and natural. Lots of cheese on the supreme. Crust is thick but not deep dish, but very good price. Tomatoes and garlic stand out to blend with other ingredients. Top notch ahead of the pack like Bears' new star David Montgomery, RB ! read more

Jeff's Pizza Shop - Supreme plus buffalo meat excellent tomatoes and garlic, perfect crust - Pizza Near Me - Ames, Iowa

Whether it's drunk slices or the Monday Bogo special, it's very easy to choose to spend $20 on 2 pizzas and a $10 tip for the delivery driver when I could spend that much on an okay dinner and a drink at a nearby chain. Also received my most recent order 10 minutes earlier than estimated and it was cooked perfectly. read more

Picked up pepperoni rolls after the ball game. They were really good. They seemed to be missing the buttery Parmesan topping that I remembered. read more

Phenomenal pizza and arguably the best wings in town.

Absolutely delicious pizza. Some of the best pizza crust and dough I've ever had, and the sauce to cheese to topping ratio was good too. 10/10 recommend! read more

Oh my smotharella sticks. I'm a total pizza snob but I love Jeff's and it's my go-to pizza delivery choice. My favorite pizza is the 4 cheese tomato and spinach pizza but smotharella sticks are my weakness. They're garlicy, buttery, cheesy perfection. The bosco sticks are also fantastic and clones are also very good. I think what it comes down to is that Jeff's has good sauce. It's zesty and always tastes fresh. I love getting extra sauce with my orders and dunking my food into it. Mmmm. Jeff's is really reasonably priced and offers great delivery service which you can order online. They also have amazing daily specials in which they practically give their food away. What a deal! read more

Update: a different cashier, again, was unbelievably condescending and rude. She planted the receipt down on the table, said nothing, so I asked if it needed to be signed. She said "uh, yeah, right here, where it says SIGNATURE" supppperrrr over this service. Went in last night and the cashier was SUPER rude. I asked her if she was having a bad night, she said that she was. Slammed a utensil, rolled her eyes. Unfortunately, you don't get to show off your bad mood when in a customer service position. They need to have a chat with their employees about proper etiquette. read more

Awesome super doughy pizza on a budget. Monday's bogo! Must tries is spud supreme! Biggest pizza I've seen ordered 20 inch. Smotherrella sticks a must or try their Viacom sticks. Yummy pizza. read more

DO NOT ATTEMPT TO ORDER ONLINE. Use the app or call, but online ordering bombs out when you try and pay then it deletes your order when you try and refresh. It's absolutely aggravating. Almost ordered Dominos instead because it's so much easier to order from them. read more

I always dug the Vegan pizza here with no cheese, I also dug how you could get a bucket of beers. The layout is very similar to any college town pizzeria. They got sandwiches and cheese sticks and all that other stuff your parents don't wont you to live on while in college! But even this adult dug this place a few times! Most recently stopped in when I saw a friend through the window. Not much has change, but that's kinda feels good in a college town! read more

Ordered pizza for a Friday at Jack Trice tailgating before ISU game..pizza was thin crust and just the right amount of cheese and toppings. Good flavor. Delivery guy was cool..only thing keeping it from a 5 star was the $28 for 2 small one topping pizzas delivered plus tip. Ouch.. read more